Penny Dreadful: "PD Birthday Time"
Game 587874748
PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 7.05
[Gatherling] Round=3
[League] Host doesn't have active run
thundershot899 chooses to play first.
thundershot899 keeps this hand.
[CHAT] thundershot899: glhf
[CHAT] thundershot899: first time I have been looking foward to a gift :(
[CHAT] thundershot899: *not been
[CHAT] Merawder: lol had me wondering for a sec
Merawder keeps this hand.
Turn 1: thundershot899
thundershot899 skips their draw step.
thundershot899 plays [Dimir Guildgate].
Turn 1: Merawder
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
Turn 2: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
thundershot899 casts [Merfolk Looter].
Turn 2: Merawder
[CHAT] Merawder: was the saddest thing I've heard all day for a minute
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Dimir Signet].
Turn 3: thundershot899
thundershot899 activates an ability of [Merfolk Looter] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
thundershot899 draws a card with [Merfolk Looter]'s ability.
[CHAT] Merawder: merfolk looter, that's pretty neat
thundershot899 discards [Kederekt Leviathan].
thundershot899 plays [Dimir Guildgate].
Turn 3: Merawder
[CHAT] Merawder: oh god this is combo
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder casts [Smokestack].
[CHAT] thundershot899: it would have been a wincon in fate :P
[CHAT] thundershot899: oh *** this is stax
Turn 4: thundershot899
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
thundershot899 activates an ability of [Merfolk Looter] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
thundershot899 draws a card with [Merfolk Looter]'s ability.
[CHAT] thundershot899: :P
thundershot899 discards [Kederekt Leviathan].
thundershot899 casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Kederekt Leviathan].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...).
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Kederekt Leviathan] onto the stack (When Kederekt Leviathan enters the battlefield, return all other nonland permanents to their owner...).
[Animate Dead] is returned to thundershot899's hand from the battlefield.
[Smokestack] is returned to Merawder's hand from the battlefield.
[Dimir Signet] is returned to Merawder's hand from the battlefield.
[Merfolk Looter] is returned to thundershot899's hand from the battlefield.
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.).
[CHAT] Merawder: ahhh
[CHAT] Merawder: lol
Turn 4: Merawder
[CHAT] Merawder: so wait
[CHAT] thundershot899: didnt know that worked...
[CHAT] Merawder: you can just keep doing that
[CHAT] thundershot899: yeah...
[CHAT] Merawder: HAX
[CHAT] thundershot899: HAX!!
Merawder casts [Dimir Signet].
[CHAT] thundershot899: LOL
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
Merawder plays [Selesnya Sanctuary].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Selesnya Sanctuary] onto the stack (When Selesnya Sanctuary enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
Merawder returns [Island] to its owner's hand with [Selesnya Sanctuary]'s ability.
Turn 5: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Piranha Marsh].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Piranha Marsh] onto the stack targeting Merawder (When Piranha Marsh enters the battlefield, target player loses 1 life.).
Turn 5: Merawder
[CHAT] Merawder: oh god what do I do
[CHAT] thundershot899: swing for 1 :P
Merawder plays [Tranquil Garden].
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Palace Familiar].
PennyDreadful
PD Birthday Time
Tourney, BuggedCardObserver, LeagueObserver, PennyDreadfulLegality
thundershot899,Merawder
Game 587877004
PDBot has started watching.
Merawder chooses to play first.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 7.05
[Gatherling] Round=3
[League] Host doesn't have active run
Merawder keeps this hand.
thundershot899 mulligans to 6 cards.
thundershot899 keeps this hand.
Turn 1: Merawder
thundershot899 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Merawder skips their draw step.
Merawder plays [Seaside Citadel].
Turn 1: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
Turn 2: Merawder
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
Turn 2: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Nephalia Drownyard].
Turn 3: Merawder
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder plays [Lonely Sandbar].
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Palace Familiar].
Turn 3: thundershot899
Turn 4: Merawder
Merawder casts [Gift of Immortality] targeting [Alchemist's Apprentice].
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice] and [Palace Familiar].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 4: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Island].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 5: Merawder
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice] and [Palace Familiar].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Sailor of Means].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Sailor of Means] onto the stack (When Sailor of Means enters the battlefield, create a colorless Treasure artifact token with '{T},...).
Merawder's [Sailor of Means] creates a Treasure token.
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
thundershot899 casts [Tragic Lesson].
thundershot899 draws two cards with [Tragic Lesson].
thundershot899 discards [Worldgorger Dragon].
[CHAT] Merawder: oh god if you untap and win
[CHAT] Merawder: nooo
[CHAT] thundershot899: gg
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 5: thundershot899
[CHAT] Merawder: I'm going to lose with 2 unsubstantiate and a consign to dream in hadn
[CHAT] Merawder: why did I play so greedy
[CHAT] thundershot899: simple
[CHAT] thundershot899: because I dont have it :P
[CHAT] Merawder: ah haha
thundershot899 discards [Dimir Infiltrator].
thundershot899 transmutes [Dimir Infiltrator].
[CHAT] Merawder: well now you know my hand
[CHAT] Merawder: LOL
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
thundershot899 reveals [Animate Dead].
thundershot899 plays [Piranha Marsh].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Piranha Marsh] onto the stack targeting Merawder (When Piranha Marsh enters the battlefield, target player loses 1 life.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 6: Merawder
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice], [Palace Familiar], [Sailor of Means], and [Palace Familiar].
[CHAT] thundershot899: so can you tap out again :P
[CHAT] Merawder: mmmmmmmmm
Merawder plays [Tranquil Garden].
[CHAT] Merawder: :thinking:
Merawder casts [Filigree Familiar].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 6: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Island].
[CHAT] thundershot899: I think you just win here
thundershot899 casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Worldgorger Dragon].
[CHAT] thundershot899: unsubstate kills me
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...).
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Worldgorger Dragon] onto the stack (When Worldgorger Dragon enters the battlefield, exile all other permanents you control.).
Merawder casts [Unsubstantiate] targeting [Worldgorger Dragon].
thundershot899 casts [Perplex] targeting [Unsubstantiate].
[CHAT] Merawder: lol!
[CHAT] thundershot899: gg
[CHAT] Merawder: do I wish to discard my hand?
[CHAT] Merawder: I mean, not really modo
Merawder discards [Consign to Dream].
Merawder discards [Tranquil Garden].
Merawder discards [Tranquil Garden].
Merawder discards [Unsubstantiate].
Merawder discards [Consign to Dream].
Merawder discards [Sailor of Means].
Merawder returns [Worldgorger Dragon] to its owner's hand with [Unsubstantiate].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Worldgorger Dragon] onto the stack (When Worldgorger Dragon leaves the battlefield, return the exiled cards to the battlefield under t...).
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.).
thundershot899 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Merawder
Game 1 Completed.
Game 587879248
PDBot has started watching.
thundershot899 mulligans to 6 cards.
Merawder keeps this hand.
thundershot899 keeps this hand.
Turn 1: thundershot899
thundershot899 put a card on the bottom of the library.
thundershot899 skips their draw step.
thundershot899 plays [Piranha Marsh].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Piranha Marsh] onto the stack targeting Merawder (When Piranha Marsh enters the battlefield, target player loses 1 life.).
Turn 1: Merawder
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
Turn 2: thundershot899
thundershot899 discards [Scarab Feast].
thundershot899 cycles [Scarab Feast].
thundershot899 plays [Dimir Guildgate].
Turn 2: Merawder
Merawder plays [Lonely Sandbar].
Turn 3: thundershot899
thundershot899 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Merawder.
Merawder discards [Ongoing Investigation].
Merawder reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Filigree Familiar], [Palace Familiar], [Eldrazi Skyspawner], [Sailor of Means], [Surveilling Sprite], and [Surveilling Sprite].
Turn 3: Merawder
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder casts [Eldrazi Skyspawner].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Eldrazi Skyspawner] onto the stack (When Eldrazi Skyspawner enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature toke...).
Merawder's [Eldrazi Skyspawner] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
Turn 4: thundershot899
thundershot899 casts [Dimir Infiltrator].
Turn 4: Merawder
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Eldrazi Skyspawner].
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Sailor of Means].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Sailor of Means] onto the stack (When Sailor of Means enters the battlefield, create a colorless Treasure artifact token with '{T},...).
Merawder's [Sailor of Means] creates a Treasure token.
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
Turn 5: thundershot899
Turn 5: Merawder
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Palace Familiar] and [Eldrazi Skyspawner].
Merawder casts [Surveilling Sprite].
Merawder casts [Surveilling Sprite].
Turn 6: thundershot899
Turn 6: Merawder
Merawder casts [Eldrazi Skyspawner].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Eldrazi Skyspawner] onto the stack (When Eldrazi Skyspawner enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature toke...).
Merawder's [Eldrazi Skyspawner] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
Merawder casts [Surveilling Sprite].
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Surveilling Sprite], [Surveilling Sprite], [Palace Familiar], and [Eldrazi Skyspawner].
Turn 7: thundershot899
thundershot899 plays [Island].
[CHAT] Merawder: lol it's ok if I brick on combo pieces as long as you brick on everything else
thundershot899 casts [Oath of Jace].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Oath of Jace] onto the stack (When Oath of Jace enters the battlefield, draw three cards, then discard two cards.).
thundershot899 draws three cards with [Oath of Jace]'s ability.
thundershot899 discards [Worldgorger Dragon].
thundershot899 discards [Perplex].
[CHAT] Merawder: I meant interaction, not combo pieces
Turn 7: Merawder
[CHAT] Merawder: nice
[CHAT] thundershot899: oh no
thundershot899 is being attacked by [Surveilling Sprite], [Eldrazi Skyspawner], [Surveilling Sprite], [Surveilling Sprite], [Palace Familiar], and [Eldrazi Skyspawner].
Turn 8: thundershot899
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Oath of Jace] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, scry X, where X is the number of planeswalkers you control.).
[CHAT] Merawder: I do lose to leviathan no matter what I think though
thundershot899 casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Worldgorger Dragon].
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...).
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Worldgorger Dragon] onto the stack (When Worldgorger Dragon enters the battlefield, exile all other permanents you control.).
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.).
[CHAT] Merawder: nooooo lol I was bluffing
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Worldgorger Dragon] onto the stack (When Worldgorger Dragon leaves the battlefield, return the exiled cards to the battlefield under t...).
[CHAT] thundershot899: I have turn aside anyway :P
[CHAT] thundershot899: ggs
[CHAT] Merawder: gg
thundershot899 puts triggered ability from [Piranha Marsh] onto the stack targeting Merawder (When Piranha Marsh enters the battlefield, target player loses 1 life.).
Merawder has conceded from the game.
Winner: thundershot899
Game 2 Completed.
Merawder has left the game.