Game 656265168

[Time] 1545696453
[11:07:34] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 10.12
[Gatherling] Round=1
[11:07:44] Kaitoukid111 chooses to play first.
[11:07:49] Kaitoukid111 mulligans to 6 cards.
[11:07:51] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:07:53] Kaitoukid111 keeps this hand.
[11:07:55] Kaitoukid111 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[11:07:55] Turn 1: Kaitoukid111
[11:07:55] Kaitoukid111 skips their draw step.
[11:07:57] Kaitoukid111 plays [Nomad Outpost].
[11:08:00] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:08:01] nanaiper plays [Jwar Isle Refuge].
[11:08:01] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Jwar Isle Refuge] onto the stack (When Jwar Isle Refuge enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[11:08:03] Turn 2: Kaitoukid111
[11:08:04] Kaitoukid111 plays [Swamp].
[11:08:07] Kaitoukid111 casts [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:08:09] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:08:10] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:08:13] nanaiper casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:08:15] nanaiper casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[11:08:17] Turn 3: Kaitoukid111
[11:08:20] Kaitoukid111 plays [Plains].
[11:08:24] Kaitoukid111 casts [Mangara of Corondor].
[11:08:26] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:08:29] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:08:31] nanaiper casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting Kaitoukid111.
[11:08:33] Kaitoukid111 sacrifices [Mangara of Corondor].
[11:08:35] Turn 4: Kaitoukid111
[11:08:36] Kaitoukid111 plays [Swamp].
[11:08:40] Kaitoukid111 casts [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:08:46] Kaitoukid111 casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:08:48] Kaitoukid111 puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting nanaiper (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...).
[11:09:00] nanaiper reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Trail of Evidence], [Sultai Charm], and [Power Sink].
[11:09:00] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:09:04] nanaiper casts [Trail of Evidence].
[11:09:05] Turn 5: Kaitoukid111
[11:09:10] Kaitoukid111 casts [Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle].
[11:09:14] nanaiper is being attacked by [Mesmeric Fiend] and [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:09:16] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:09:21] Turn 6: Kaitoukid111
[11:09:23] Kaitoukid111 plays [Vivid Marsh].
[11:09:30] nanaiper is being attacked by [Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle], [Mesmeric Fiend], and [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:09:37] nanaiper activates an ability of [Elixir of Immortality] ( You gain 5 life. Shuffle Elixir of Immortality and your graveyard into their owner's library.).
[11:09:41] Turn 6: nanaiper
[11:09:46] Turn 7: Kaitoukid111
[11:09:48] Kaitoukid111 plays [Plains].
[11:09:54] Kaitoukid111 casts [Arvad the Cursed].
[11:09:56] Kaitoukid111 puts triggered ability from [Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle] onto the stack targeting [Mangara of Corondor] (Whenever you cast a historic spell, return target creature card with converted mana cost 3 or less...).
[11:10:01] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [Arvad the Cursed]. (X is 2).
[11:10:02] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:10:04] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:10:14] nanaiper is being attacked by [Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle], [Mesmeric Fiend], and [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:10:16] Turn 7: nanaiper
[11:10:19] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:10:19] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:10:21] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:10:22] Turn 8: Kaitoukid111
[11:10:34] Kaitoukid111 activates an ability of [Mangara of Corondor] targeting [Opulent Palace] ( Exile Mangara of Corondor and target permanent.).
[11:10:56] nanaiper is being attacked by [Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle], [Mesmeric Fiend], and [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:11:04] Kaitoukid111 casts [Crovax, Ascendant Hero].
[11:11:04] Kaitoukid111 puts triggered ability from [Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle] onto the stack targeting [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim] (Whenever you cast a historic spell, return target creature card with converted mana cost 3 or less...).
[11:11:12] Kaitoukid111 puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack (When Mesmeric Fiend leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[11:11:16] Turn 8: nanaiper
[11:11:20] Turn 9: Kaitoukid111
[11:11:24] nanaiper has conceded from the game.
Winner: Kaitoukid111
Game 1 Completed.

Game 656265708

[Time] 1545696741
[11:12:21] PDBot has started watching.
[11:12:24] nanaiper chooses to play first.
[11:12:28] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:12:32] Kaitoukid111 keeps this hand.
[11:12:32] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:12:34] nanaiper skips their draw step.
[11:12:35] nanaiper plays [Island].
[11:12:39] Turn 1: Kaitoukid111
[11:12:41] Kaitoukid111 plays [Nomad Outpost].
[11:12:43] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:12:44] nanaiper plays [Forest].
[11:12:46] Turn 2: Kaitoukid111
[11:12:47] Kaitoukid111 plays [Swamp].
[11:12:50] Kaitoukid111 casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:12:53] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [Mesmeric Fiend]. (X is 1).
[11:12:57] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:13:00] nanaiper plays [Island].
[11:13:02] nanaiper casts [Trail of Evidence].
[11:13:03] Turn 3: Kaitoukid111
[11:13:05] Kaitoukid111 plays [Swamp].
[11:13:17] Kaitoukid111 casts [Painful Truths] (with 2 colors).
[11:13:19] Kaitoukid111 draws two cards with [Painful Truths].
[11:13:19] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:13:24] nanaiper casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nanaiper.
[11:13:24] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:13:24] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Compulsive Research` or `!notbugged Compulsive Research`
[11:13:25] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:13:26] nanaiper draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[11:13:31] nanaiper discards [Bile Blight].
[11:13:31] nanaiper discards [Moment of Craving].
[11:13:32] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:13:34] Turn 4: Kaitoukid111
[11:13:36] Kaitoukid111 plays [Plains].
[11:13:42] Kaitoukid111 casts [Baird, Steward of Argive].
[11:13:45] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:13:49] nanaiper casts [Scrabbling Claws].
[11:13:52] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:13:55] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Painful Truths].
[11:13:58] Turn 5: Kaitoukid111
[11:14:03] Kaitoukid111 casts [Sin Collector].
[11:14:08] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [Sin Collector]. (X is 2).
[11:14:08] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:14:11] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:14:17] nanaiper is being attacked by [Baird, Steward of Argive].
[11:14:21] Turn 6: nanaiper
[11:14:25] nanaiper casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Baird, Steward of Argive].
[11:14:25] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:14:27] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:14:30] nanaiper casts [Scrabbling Claws].
[11:14:33] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:14:36] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Baird, Steward of Argive].
[11:14:38] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:14:40] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Sin Collector].
[11:14:42] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:14:42] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:14:43] Turn 6: Kaitoukid111
[11:14:49] Kaitoukid111 casts [Danitha Capashen, Paragon].
[11:14:52] Turn 7: nanaiper
[11:14:54] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:14:57] nanaiper casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[11:15:02] nanaiper casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Danitha Capashen, Paragon].
[11:15:02] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:15:03] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:15:06] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:15:07] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Danitha Capashen, Paragon].
[11:15:09] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:15:10] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:15:13] Turn 7: Kaitoukid111
[11:15:15] Kaitoukid111 plays [Vivid Marsh].
[11:15:19] Kaitoukid111 casts [Mangara of Corondor].
[11:15:26] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:15:26] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:15:27] Turn 8: nanaiper
[11:15:29] nanaiper plays [Choked Estuary].
[11:15:33] nanaiper casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting Kaitoukid111.
[11:15:34] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:15:35] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:15:36] Kaitoukid111 sacrifices [Mangara of Corondor].
[11:15:40] Turn 8: Kaitoukid111
[11:15:42] Kaitoukid111 plays [Plains].
[11:15:49] Kaitoukid111 casts [Arvad the Cursed].
[11:16:01] nanaiper activates an ability of [Elixir of Immortality] ( You gain 5 life. Shuffle Elixir of Immortality and your graveyard into their owner's library.).
[11:16:07] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:16:08] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Mangara of Corondor].
[11:16:09] Turn 9: nanaiper
[11:16:13] nanaiper casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Arvad the Cursed].
[11:16:13] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:16:14] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:16:16] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:16:18] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:16:19] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Arvad the Cursed].
[11:16:22] Turn 9: Kaitoukid111
[11:16:35] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:16:35] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:16:37] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:16:37] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:16:38] Turn 10: nanaiper
[11:16:39] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:16:42] Turn 10: Kaitoukid111
[11:16:46] Kaitoukid111 casts [Danitha Capashen, Paragon].
[11:16:53] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:16:53] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:16:55] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:16:55] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:16:58] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Danitha Capashen, Paragon].
[11:16:58] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:16:59] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:17:03] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:17:03] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:17:04] Turn 11: nanaiper
[11:17:06] nanaiper plays [Jwar Isle Refuge].
[11:17:06] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Jwar Isle Refuge] onto the stack (When Jwar Isle Refuge enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[11:17:09] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:17:11] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Danitha Capashen, Paragon].
[11:17:14] Turn 11: Kaitoukid111
[11:17:18] Kaitoukid111 casts [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:17:22] Kaitoukid111 casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:17:26] Kaitoukid111 puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting nanaiper (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...).
[11:17:31] Kaitoukid111 activates an ability of [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim] ( You gain life equal to the sacrificed creature's toughness.).
[11:17:31] Kaitoukid111 puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack (When Mesmeric Fiend leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[11:17:38] nanaiper casts [Sultai Charm] (Draw two cards, then discard a card.).
[11:17:38] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:17:41] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:17:42] nanaiper draws two cards with [Sultai Charm].
[11:17:44] nanaiper discards [Jwar Isle Refuge].
[11:17:54] nanaiper reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Power Sink], [Moment of Craving], and [Encroaching Wastes].
[11:17:58] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:18:00] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:18:02] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:18:02] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:18:05] Turn 12: nanaiper
[11:18:08] nanaiper plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[11:18:11] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:18:11] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:18:14] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:18:18] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:18:18] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:18:18] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[11:18:22] Turn 12: Kaitoukid111
[11:18:32] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:18:33] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:18:36] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:18:36] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:18:41] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim] ( Exile target card from a graveyard. Draw a card.).
[11:18:41] nanaiper draws a card with [Scrabbling Claws]'s ability.
[11:18:42] Turn 13: nanaiper
[11:18:44] nanaiper plays [Island].
[11:18:48] nanaiper casts [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[11:18:51] Turn 13: Kaitoukid111
[11:18:55] Kaitoukid111 casts [Declaration in Stone] targeting [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[11:19:01] Kaitoukid111's [Declaration in Stone] creates a Clue token under nanaiper's control.
[11:19:09] nanaiper activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[11:19:09] nanaiper draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[11:19:10] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Kaitoukid111 ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[11:19:12] Kaitoukid111 exiles [Declaration in Stone].
[11:19:13] Turn 14: nanaiper
[11:19:15] nanaiper plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[11:19:37] Turn 14: Kaitoukid111
[11:19:38] Kaitoukid111 casts [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:19:38] Kaitoukid111 casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:19:38] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [Mesmeric Fiend]. (X is 3).
[11:19:38] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[11:19:38] Kaitoukid111 has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 2 Completed.

Game 213278408