PennyDreadful
PD AEther_vile
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
FinalDefiance,AEther_vile

== Game 1 (901788528) ==
[Time] 1734896497
[21:41:38] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 36.05
[Gatherling] Round=3
[21:41:43] [CHAT] AEther_vile: gl hf
[21:41:45] AEther_vile chooses to play first.
[21:41:48] [CHAT] FinalDefiance: thanks you too
[21:41:54] AEther_vile begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:41:56] FinalDefiance begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:41:56] Turn 1: AEther_vile
[21:41:56] AEther_vile skips their draw step.
[21:41:57] AEther_vile plays [Shambling Vent].
[21:41:59] Turn 1: FinalDefiance
[21:42:02] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:42:05] Turn 2: AEther_vile
[21:42:07] AEther_vile plays [Swamp].
[21:42:11] AEther_vile casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:42:13] FinalDefiance discards [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[21:42:13] FinalDefiance discards [Peer Through Depths].
[21:42:18] Turn 2: FinalDefiance
[21:42:21] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:42:24] FinalDefiance casts [Strategic Planning].
[21:42:52] Turn 3: AEther_vile
[21:42:53] AEther_vile plays [Plains].
[21:42:56] AEther_vile casts [Phyrexian Arena].
[21:43:01] Turn 3: FinalDefiance
[21:44:24] FinalDefiance casts [Sapphire Medallion].
[21:44:26] Turn 4: AEther_vile
[21:44:26] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[21:44:28] AEther_vile draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[21:44:32] AEther_vile plays [Fetid Heath].
[21:44:38] AEther_vile casts [Abstruse Appropriation] targeting [Sapphire Medallion].
[21:44:41] Turn 4: FinalDefiance
[21:44:58] FinalDefiance casts [High Tide].
[21:45:02] FinalDefiance casts [Hidden Strings] targeting [Island], and [Island].
[21:45:14] FinalDefiance casts [High Tide].
[21:45:26] FinalDefiance casts [Dig Through Time].
[21:45:48] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:45:54] FinalDefiance reveals [Strategic Planning] with [Peer Through Depths].
[21:45:58] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:46:11] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:46:19] FinalDefiance reveals [Turnabout] with [Peer Through Depths].
[21:46:28] Turn 5: AEther_vile
[21:46:28] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[21:46:30] AEther_vile draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[21:46:36] AEther_vile plays [Plains].
[21:46:40] AEther_vile casts [Obzedat, Ghost Council].
[21:46:40] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack targeting FinalDefiance (When Obzedat, Ghost Council enters, target opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[21:46:44] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile Obzedat, Ghost Council. If you do, return it to t...).
[21:46:46] AEther_vile exiles [Obzedat, Ghost Council] with its own ability.
[21:46:47] Turn 5: FinalDefiance
[21:46:53] FinalDefiance casts [Strategic Planning].
[21:47:09] FinalDefiance plays [Lonely Sandbar].
[21:47:27] Turn 6: AEther_vile
[21:47:30] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack (Return Obzedat, Ghost Council to the battlefield under Obzedat, Ghost Council owner's control at t...).
[21:47:30] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[21:47:30] AEther_vile draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[21:47:33] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack targeting FinalDefiance (When Obzedat, Ghost Council enters, target opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[21:47:40] FinalDefiance is being attacked by [Obzedat, Ghost Council]
[21:47:50] AEther_vile plays [Swamp].
[21:47:54] AEther_vile casts [Elspeth, Sun's Champion].
[21:47:56] AEther_vile puts a loyalty counter on [Elspeth, Sun's Champion].
[21:47:56] AEther_vile activates an ability of [Elspeth, Sun's Champion] ( Create three 1/1 white Soldier creature tokens.).
[21:47:57] AEther_vile's [Elspeth, Sun's Champion] creates three Soldier Tokens.
[21:47:58] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile Obzedat, Ghost Council. If you do, return it to t...).
[21:48:00] AEther_vile exiles [Obzedat, Ghost Council] with its own ability.
[21:48:01] Turn 6: FinalDefiance
[21:48:24] FinalDefiance casts [Strategic Planning].
[21:48:36] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:48:41] Turn 7: AEther_vile
[21:48:45] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[21:48:45] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack (Return Obzedat, Ghost Council to the battlefield under Obzedat, Ghost Council owner's control at t...).
[21:48:46] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack targeting FinalDefiance (When Obzedat, Ghost Council enters, target opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[21:48:48] AEther_vile draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[21:48:57] AEther_vile activates an ability of [Shambling Vent] ( Shambling Vent becomes a 2/3 white and black Elemental creature with lifelink until end of turn. ...).
[21:49:00] FinalDefiance has conceded from the game.
[21:49:00] AEther_vile wins the game.
Winner: AEther_vile
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (901789804) ==
[Time] 1734897030
[21:50:30] PDBot has started watching.
[21:50:32] FinalDefiance chooses to play first.
[21:50:34] FinalDefiance begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:50:37] AEther_vile begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:50:37] Turn 1: FinalDefiance
[21:50:38] FinalDefiance skips their draw step.
[21:50:39] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:50:42] Turn 1: AEther_vile
[21:50:46] AEther_vile plays [Godless Shrine].
[21:50:49] Turn 2: FinalDefiance
[21:50:52] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:50:54] FinalDefiance casts [Sapphire Medallion].
[21:50:58] Turn 2: AEther_vile
[21:51:01] AEther_vile plays [Swamp].
[21:51:13] AEther_vile casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:51:13] FinalDefiance discards [Dig Through Time].
[21:51:13] FinalDefiance discards [Strategic Planning].
[21:51:16] Turn 3: FinalDefiance
[21:51:19] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:51:23] Turn 3: AEther_vile
[21:51:27] AEther_vile plays [Isolated Chapel].
[21:51:30] AEther_vile casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:51:35] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:51:51] FinalDefiance reveals [Pieces of the Puzzle] with [Peer Through Depths].
[21:51:57] FinalDefiance casts [An Offer You Can't Refuse] targeting [Agonizing Remorse].
[21:52:00] AEther_vile's [An Offer You Can't Refuse] creates two Treasure Tokens under AEther_vile's control.
[21:52:04] Turn 4: FinalDefiance
[21:52:09] FinalDefiance casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[21:52:10] FinalDefiance reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Turnabout], [An Offer You Can't Refuse], [Peer Through Depths], [Fae of Wishes], and [Mind's Desire].
[21:52:58] FinalDefiance chooses Peer Through Depths and Turnabout.
[21:53:00] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:53:02] FinalDefiance casts [Strategic Planning].
[21:53:10] Turn 4: AEther_vile
[21:53:40] AEther_vile plays [Fetid Heath].
[21:53:44] AEther_vile casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[21:53:49] AEther_vile removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[21:53:49] AEther_vile activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[21:53:53] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:54:28] FinalDefiance reveals [High Tide] with [Peer Through Depths].
[21:54:34] FinalDefiance chooses a card from their hand.
[21:54:34] FinalDefiance discards [Turnabout].
[21:54:34] AEther_vile draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[21:54:41] AEther_vile casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:54:41] FinalDefiance reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [High Tide] and [Dig Through Time].
[21:54:49] Turn 5: FinalDefiance
[21:55:04] FinalDefiance casts [High Tide].
[21:55:06] FinalDefiance casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[21:55:06] FinalDefiance reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Lonely Sandbar], [Turnabout], [Island], [Island], and [Mind's Desire].
[21:55:09] FinalDefiance chooses Turnabout and Mind's Desire.
[21:55:14] FinalDefiance casts [Turnabout] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:55:15] FinalDefiance chooses land for [Turnabout].
[21:55:17] FinalDefiance casts [Mind's Desire].
[21:55:17] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Mind's Desire] onto the stack (Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell that was cast before it this turn. You m...).
[21:55:26] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:55:29] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:55:32] FinalDefiance reveals [Mind's Desire] with [Peer Through Depths].
[21:55:36] FinalDefiance casts [Hidden Strings] targeting [Island], and [Island].
[21:56:06] FinalDefiance casts [Mind's Desire].
[21:56:06] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Mind's Desire] onto the stack (Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell that was cast before it this turn. You m...).
[21:56:18] FinalDefiance casts [High Tide].
[21:56:21] FinalDefiance casts [Hidden Strings] targeting [Island], and [Island].
[21:56:26] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:56:41] FinalDefiance reveals [Turnabout] with [Peer Through Depths].
[21:56:48] FinalDefiance casts [Turnabout] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:56:49] FinalDefiance chooses land for [Turnabout].
[21:56:52] FinalDefiance casts [Commit] targeting [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[21:56:52] AEther_vile puts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] beneath the top 1 cards of their library.
[21:56:56] FinalDefiance casts [Memory] from the graveyard.
[21:56:57] FinalDefiance draws seven cards with [Memory].
[21:56:57] AEther_vile draws seven cards with [Memory].
[21:57:03] FinalDefiance casts [Sapphire Medallion].
[21:57:08] FinalDefiance casts [Mind's Desire].
[21:57:08] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Mind's Desire] onto the stack (Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell that was cast before it this turn. You m...).
[21:57:28] FinalDefiance casts [Aetherflux Reservoir].
[21:57:31] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[21:57:31] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Aetherflux Reservoir] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell, you gain 1 life for each spell you've cast this turn.).
[21:57:35] AEther_vile has conceded from the game.
[21:57:35] FinalDefiance wins the game.
Winner: FinalDefiance
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (901790986) ==
[Time] 1734897490
[21:58:11] PDBot has started watching.
[21:58:11] FinalDefiance joined the game.
[21:58:17] AEther_vile chooses to play first.
[21:58:24] AEther_vile mulligans to six cards.
[21:58:38] FinalDefiance mulligans to six cards.
[21:58:43] AEther_vile puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[21:58:46] FinalDefiance puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[21:58:46] Turn 1: AEther_vile
[21:58:47] AEther_vile skips their draw step.
[21:58:48] AEther_vile plays [Fetid Heath].
[21:58:50] Turn 1: FinalDefiance
[21:58:53] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:58:58] Turn 2: AEther_vile
[21:58:59] AEther_vile plays [Fetid Heath].
[21:59:04] Turn 2: FinalDefiance
[21:59:06] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:59:13] Turn 3: AEther_vile
[21:59:14] AEther_vile plays [Plains].
[21:59:32] AEther_vile casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting FinalDefiance.
[21:59:35] FinalDefiance reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Turnabout], [Island], [Island], [Mind's Desire], [Dig Through Time], and [High Tide].
[21:59:52] Turn 3: FinalDefiance
[21:59:56] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[21:59:59] FinalDefiance discards [Lonely Sandbar].
[21:59:59] FinalDefiance cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
[22:00:09] Turn 4: AEther_vile
[22:00:11] AEther_vile plays [Plains].
[22:00:27] AEther_vile casts [Lost Legacy] targeting FinalDefiance.
[22:00:37] AEther_vile names High Tide for [Lost Legacy].
[22:01:16] AEther_vile exiled 3 copies of High Tide (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 3 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[22:01:31] Turn 4: FinalDefiance
[22:01:34] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[22:01:45] Turn 5: AEther_vile
[22:01:56] AEther_vile casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:02:00] AEther_vile removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:02:00] AEther_vile activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[22:02:03] FinalDefiance chooses a card from their hand.
[22:02:03] FinalDefiance discards [Island].
[22:02:03] AEther_vile draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[22:02:10] Turn 5: FinalDefiance
[22:02:16] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[22:02:26] Turn 6: AEther_vile
[22:02:32] AEther_vile removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:02:32] AEther_vile activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[22:02:37] FinalDefiance chooses a card from their hand.
[22:02:38] FinalDefiance discards [An Offer You Can't Refuse].
[22:02:38] AEther_vile draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[22:02:44] AEther_vile plays [Isolated Chapel].
[22:02:52] AEther_vile casts [Obzedat, Ghost Council].
[22:02:55] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack targeting FinalDefiance (When Obzedat, Ghost Council enters, target opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[22:02:58] AEther_vile puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile Obzedat, Ghost Council. If you do, return it to t...).
[22:03:09] FinalDefiance casts [Dig Through Time].
[22:03:26] AEther_vile exiles [Obzedat, Ghost Council] with its own ability.
[22:03:28] Turn 6: FinalDefiance
[22:03:34] FinalDefiance plays [Island].
[22:03:46] FinalDefiance casts [Sapphire Medallion].
[22:03:59] FinalDefiance casts [Turnabout] targeting FinalDefiance.
[22:04:00] FinalDefiance chooses land for [Turnabout].
[22:04:05] FinalDefiance casts [Turnabout] targeting FinalDefiance.
[22:04:07] FinalDefiance chooses land for [Turnabout].
[22:04:09] FinalDefiance casts [Mind's Desire].
[22:04:09] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Mind's Desire] onto the stack (Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell that was cast before it this turn. You m...).
[22:04:18] FinalDefiance casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[22:04:18] FinalDefiance reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Commit/Memory], [Island], [Island], [Peer Through Depths], and [Peer Through Depths].
[22:04:36] FinalDefiance chooses Peer Through Depths and Peer Through Depths.
[22:04:39] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[22:05:47] FinalDefiance reveals [Mind's Desire] with [Peer Through Depths].
[22:05:55] FinalDefiance casts [Hidden Strings] targeting [Island], and [Island].
[22:06:05] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[22:06:30] FinalDefiance reveals [Pieces of the Puzzle] with [Peer Through Depths].
[22:06:35] FinalDefiance casts [Mind's Desire].
[22:06:35] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Mind's Desire] onto the stack (Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell that was cast before it this turn. You m...).
[22:06:52] FinalDefiance casts [Peer Through Depths].
[22:06:59] FinalDefiance reveals [Hidden Strings] with [Peer Through Depths].
[22:07:04] FinalDefiance casts [Turnabout] targeting FinalDefiance.
[22:07:05] FinalDefiance chooses land for [Turnabout].
[22:07:11] FinalDefiance casts [Hidden Strings] targeting [Island], and [Island].
[22:07:42] FinalDefiance casts [Granted].
[22:07:47] FinalDefiance chooses Aetherflux Reservoir.
[22:07:53] FinalDefiance casts [Aetherflux Reservoir].
[22:08:03] FinalDefiance casts [Fae of Wishes].
[22:08:03] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Aetherflux Reservoir] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell, you gain 1 life for each spell you've cast this turn.).
[22:08:13] FinalDefiance casts [Strategic Planning].
[22:08:14] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Aetherflux Reservoir] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell, you gain 1 life for each spell you've cast this turn.).
[22:08:16] FinalDefiance casts [An Offer You Can't Refuse] targeting [Strategic Planning].
[22:08:16] FinalDefiance puts triggered ability from [Aetherflux Reservoir] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell, you gain 1 life for each spell you've cast this turn.).
[22:08:17] AEther_vile has conceded from the game.
[22:08:17] FinalDefiance wins the game.
Winner: FinalDefiance
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: FinalDefiance: 2–1
[22:08:26] AEther_vile has left the game.