PennyDreadful
PD vs NotAFriendlySkeleton
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
ThyShuffler,NotAFriendlySkeleton

== Game 1 (894843470) ==
[Time] 1728697102
[04:38:23] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 35.02
[Gatherling] Round=4
[04:38:30] NotAFriendlySkeleton chooses to play first.
[04:38:54] NotAFriendlySkeleton mulligans to six cards.
[04:39:01] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:39:13] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:39:13] Turn 1: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:39:13] NotAFriendlySkeleton skips their draw step.
[04:39:14] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:39:15] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Veteran Survivor].
[04:39:22] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:39:25] ThyShuffler plays [Temple of Silence].
[04:39:25] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters, scry 1.).
[04:39:29] ThyShuffler scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[04:39:30] Turn 2: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:39:33] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Minas Tirith].
[04:39:35] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Veteran Survivor]
[04:39:39] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Veteran Survivor] onto the stack (At the beginning of your second main phase, if Veteran Survivor is tapped, exile up to one target ...).
[04:39:40] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:39:49] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:39:56] ThyShuffler casts [Nowhere to Run].
[04:39:57] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Nowhere to Run] onto the stack targeting [Veteran Survivor] (When Nowhere to Run enters, target creature an opponent controls gets -3/-3 until end of turn.).
[04:39:58] Turn 3: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:40:01] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:40:05] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar].
[04:40:07] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:40:11] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:40:17] ThyShuffler casts [Choking Sands] targeting [Minas Tirith].
[04:40:18] Turn 4: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:40:22] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:40:24] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Luminarch Aspirant] onto the stack targeting [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.).
[04:40:25] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a +1/+1 counter on [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar].
[04:40:26] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar]
[04:40:26] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar] onto the stack (Whenever you attack, for each opponent, create a 1/1 white Human creature token that's tapped and ...).
[04:40:26] NotAFriendlySkeleton's [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar] creates a Human Token.
[04:40:27] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts [Human Token] onto the battlefield attacking ThyShuffler
[04:40:31] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[04:40:39] ThyShuffler casts [Bandit's Talent].
[04:40:39] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Bandit's Talent] onto the stack (When Bandit's Talent enters, each opponent discards two cards unless they discard a nonland card.).
[04:40:47] NotAFriendlySkeleton discards [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:40:48] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[04:40:52] ThyShuffler casts [Bandit's Talent].
[04:40:52] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Bandit's Talent] onto the stack (When Bandit's Talent enters, each opponent discards two cards unless they discard a nonland card.).
[04:41:08] NotAFriendlySkeleton discards [Thalia's Lieutenant].
[04:41:10] Turn 5: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:41:13] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Flowering of the White Tree].
[04:41:14] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:41:17] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Luminarch Aspirant] onto the stack targeting [Human Token] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.).
[04:41:18] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a +1/+1 counter on [Human Token].
[04:41:19] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Human Token], [Luminarch Aspirant], and [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar]
[04:41:19] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar] onto the stack (Whenever you attack, for each opponent, create a 1/1 white Human creature token that's tapped and ...).
[04:41:20] NotAFriendlySkeleton's [Adeline, Resplendent Cathar] creates a Human Token.
[04:41:20] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts [Human Token] onto the battlefield attacking ThyShuffler
[04:41:20] NotAFriendlySkeleton wins the game.
Winner: NotAFriendlySkeleton
Game 1 Completed.
[04:41:25] NotAFriendlySkeleton has left the game.
[04:41:30] ThyShuffler draws their next card.
[04:41:31] ThyShuffler draws their next card.

== Game 2 (894843828) ==
[Time] 1728697362
[04:42:43] PDBot has started watching.
[04:42:47] ThyShuffler chooses to play first.
[04:42:55] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:42:57] NotAFriendlySkeleton mulligans to six cards.
[04:43:09] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:43:09] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:43:10] ThyShuffler skips their draw step.
[04:43:12] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:43:15] Turn 1: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:43:16] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:43:18] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Kytheon, Hero of Akros].
[04:43:20] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:43:31] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:43:41] Turn 2: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:43:43] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Minas Tirith].
[04:43:49] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Kytheon, Hero of Akros]
[04:43:53] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:43:54] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:43:59] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:44:10] ThyShuffler casts [Deathmark] targeting [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:44:13] Turn 3: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:44:15] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:44:16] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Flowering of the White Tree].
[04:44:20] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Kytheon, Hero of Akros]
[04:44:22] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[04:44:33] ThyShuffler casts [Damn] targeting [Kytheon, Hero of Akros].
[04:44:34] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Kytheon, Hero of Akros] onto the stack (Ward {1} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[04:44:44] ThyShuffler plays [Temple of Silence].
[04:44:44] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters, scry 1.).
[04:44:51] ThyShuffler scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom).
[04:44:52] Turn 4: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:44:53] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:44:55] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Elspeth, Knight-Errant].
[04:44:57] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a loyalty counter on [Elspeth, Knight-Errant].
[04:44:57] NotAFriendlySkeleton activates an ability of [Elspeth, Knight-Errant] ( Create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token.).
[04:44:58] NotAFriendlySkeleton's [Elspeth, Knight-Errant] creates a Soldier Token.
[04:44:59] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[04:45:14] ThyShuffler casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:45:18] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] targeting [Soldier Token] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[04:45:23] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:45:26] Turn 5: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:45:28] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Veteran Survivor].
[04:45:32] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a loyalty counter on [Elspeth, Knight-Errant].
[04:45:32] NotAFriendlySkeleton activates an ability of [Elspeth, Knight-Errant] ( Create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token.).
[04:45:32] NotAFriendlySkeleton's [Elspeth, Knight-Errant] creates a Soldier Token.
[04:45:34] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:45:36] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[04:45:36] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Soldier Token to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your next up...).
[04:46:02] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Elspeth, Knight-Errant].
[04:46:06] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[04:46:11] ThyShuffler casts ThyShuffler.
[04:46:12] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from ThyShuffler onto the stack (When Bandit's Talent enters, each opponent discards two cards unless they discard a nonland card.).
[04:46:16] NotAFriendlySkeleton discards [Plains].
[04:46:23] ThyShuffler activates an ability of ThyShuffler ( Level 2.).
[04:46:23] ThyShuffler's ThyShuffler becomes level 2.
[04:46:29] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] targeting [Soldier Token] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[04:46:33] Turn 6: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:46:33] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from ThyShuffler onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[04:46:38] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:46:46] ThyShuffler's [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] is being attacked by [Veteran Survivor]
[04:46:49] NotAFriendlySkeleton removes three loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:46:54] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Veteran Survivor] onto the stack targeting [Damn] (At the beginning of your second main phase, if Veteran Survivor is tapped, exile up to one target ...).
[04:46:55] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[04:46:55] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Soldier Token to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your next up...).
[04:47:06] ThyShuffler plays [Caves of Koilos].
[04:47:14] ThyShuffler casts [Damn] for its overload cost using an alternate cost.
[04:47:24] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[04:47:31] Turn 7: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:47:31] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from ThyShuffler onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[04:47:36] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:47:38] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[04:47:39] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Kaya, Ghost Assassin to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your ...).
[04:47:56] ThyShuffler removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:47:56] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[04:47:56] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[04:48:17] ThyShuffler casts [Damn] targeting [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:48:18] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben] onto the stack (Ward {1} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[04:48:26] NotAFriendlySkeleton has conceded from the game.
[04:48:26] ThyShuffler wins the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 2 Completed.
[04:48:29] NotAFriendlySkeleton has left the game.

== Game 3 (894844260) ==
[Time] 1728697733
[04:48:53] PDBot has started watching.
[04:48:56] ThyShuffler joined the game.
[04:48:56] NotAFriendlySkeleton chooses to play first.
[04:49:24] NotAFriendlySkeleton mulligans to six cards.
[04:49:31] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:49:42] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:49:42] Turn 1: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:49:42] NotAFriendlySkeleton skips their draw step.
[04:49:43] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:49:44] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:49:46] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:49:48] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:49:51] ThyShuffler casts [Deathmark] targeting [Champion of the Parish].
[04:49:52] Turn 2: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:49:54] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:49:55] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:50:01] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:50:04] Turn 3: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:50:05] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:50:07] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:50:11] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Luminarch Aspirant] onto the stack targeting [Soldier of the Pantheon] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.).
[04:50:11] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a +1/+1 counter on [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:50:12] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon]
[04:50:15] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:50:18] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:50:23] ThyShuffler casts [Choking Sands] targeting [Plains].
[04:50:24] Turn 4: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:50:27] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:50:33] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Luminarch Aspirant] onto the stack targeting [Soldier of the Pantheon] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.).
[04:50:34] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a +1/+1 counter on [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:50:35] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Luminarch Aspirant] and [Soldier of the Pantheon]
[04:50:38] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[04:50:41] ThyShuffler plays [Caves of Koilos].
[04:50:49] ThyShuffler casts [Damn] for its overload cost using an alternate cost.
[04:50:51] Turn 5: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:50:52] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:50:55] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:50:57] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[04:51:18] ThyShuffler casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben] (-X/-X). (X is 2).
[04:51:18] Chosen mode: Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. You gain X life.
[04:51:19] Turn 6: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:51:22] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:51:22] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Luminarch Aspirant] onto the stack targeting [Luminarch Aspirant] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.).
[04:51:23] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a +1/+1 counter on [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:51:24] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[04:51:27] ThyShuffler plays [Temple of Silence].
[04:51:27] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters, scry 1.).
[04:51:32] ThyShuffler scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom).
[04:51:38] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Plains].
[04:51:42] Turn 7: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:51:44] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:51:49] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts triggered ability from [Luminarch Aspirant] onto the stack targeting [Luminarch Aspirant] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.).
[04:51:49] NotAFriendlySkeleton puts a +1/+1 counter on [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:51:50] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Luminarch Aspirant]
[04:51:53] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[04:52:03] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Luminarch Aspirant].
[04:52:08] ThyShuffler casts [Bandit's Talent].
[04:52:08] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Bandit's Talent] onto the stack (When Bandit's Talent enters, each opponent discards two cards unless they discard a nonland card.).
[04:52:17] NotAFriendlySkeleton discards [Flowering of the White Tree].
[04:52:19] Turn 8: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:52:22] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Champion of the Parish]
[04:52:24] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[04:52:33] ThyShuffler casts [Dark Ritual].
[04:52:37] ThyShuffler casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:52:41] ThyShuffler removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:52:41] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[04:52:44] NotAFriendlySkeleton chooses a card from their hand.
[04:52:44] NotAFriendlySkeleton discards [Thalia's Lieutenant].
[04:52:44] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[04:52:46] ThyShuffler plays [Temple of Silence].
[04:52:47] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters, scry 1.).
[04:52:54] ThyShuffler scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[04:53:04] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Plains].
[04:53:08] Turn 9: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:53:12] ThyShuffler's [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] is being attacked by [Champion of the Parish]
[04:53:13] NotAFriendlySkeleton removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:53:14] Turn 9: ThyShuffler
[04:53:33] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[04:53:39] ThyShuffler casts [Abstruse Appropriation] targeting [Champion of the Parish].
[04:53:42] ThyShuffler casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:53:46] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Bandit's Talent] ( Level 2.).
[04:53:46] ThyShuffler's [Bandit's Talent] becomes level 2.
[04:53:47] Turn 10: NotAFriendlySkeleton
[04:53:49] NotAFriendlySkeleton plays [Plains].
[04:53:51] NotAFriendlySkeleton casts [Veteran Survivor].
[04:53:52] Turn 10: ThyShuffler
[04:53:52] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Kaya, Ghost Assassin to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your ...).
[04:54:02] ThyShuffler casts [Kaya, Orzhov Usurper].
[04:54:06] NotAFriendlySkeleton has conceded from the game.
[04:54:06] ThyShuffler wins the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: ThyShuffler: 2–1
[04:54:09] NotAFriendlySkeleton has left the game.