PennyDreadful
PD Sunday vs Garcia_Edu
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Garcia_Edu,Cat_Weasle

== Game 1 (892905026) ==
[Time] 1727026575
[20:36:16] PDBot has started watching.
[20:36:16] Cat_Weasle joined the game.
[20:36:16] Garcia_Edu joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 34.07
[Gatherling] Round=1
[20:36:19] Cat_Weasle chooses to play first.
[20:36:21] [CHAT] Cat_Weasle: gl hf
[20:36:38] Cat_Weasle begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:36:57] Garcia_Edu mulligans to six cards.
[20:37:01] Garcia_Edu puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[20:37:01] Turn 1: Cat_Weasle
[20:37:02] Cat_Weasle skips their draw step.
[20:37:06] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[20:37:10] Turn 1: Garcia_Edu
[20:37:12] Garcia_Edu plays [Swamp].
[20:37:17] Turn 2: Cat_Weasle
[20:37:21] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[20:37:47] Turn 2: Garcia_Edu
[20:37:53] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains].
[20:37:57] Garcia_Edu casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Cat_Weasle.
[20:38:00] Cat_Weasle casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Agonizing Remorse].
[20:38:07] Turn 3: Cat_Weasle
[20:38:11] Cat_Weasle plays [Temple of Deceit].
[20:38:11] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Temple of Deceit] onto the stack (When Temple of Deceit enters, scry 1.).
[20:38:16] Cat_Weasle scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[20:38:19] Turn 3: Garcia_Edu
[20:38:21] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos].
[20:38:27] Turn 4: Cat_Weasle
[20:38:29] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[20:38:35] Turn 4: Garcia_Edu
[20:38:37] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains].
[20:38:44] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[20:38:44] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sauron's Ransom[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Sauron's Ransom shows whether face down cards are white-bordered and whether they have "save-targets" enabled
[20:39:03] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring.
[20:39:06] Turn 5: Cat_Weasle
[20:39:11] Cat_Weasle plays [Temple of Deceit].
[20:39:11] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Temple of Deceit] onto the stack (When Temple of Deceit enters, scry 1.).
[20:39:18] Cat_Weasle scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[20:39:25] Turn 5: Garcia_Edu
[20:39:28] Garcia_Edu plays [Shambling Vent].
[20:39:34] Turn 6: Cat_Weasle
[20:39:36] Cat_Weasle plays [Sunken Ruins].
[20:39:43] Turn 6: Garcia_Edu
[20:39:44] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos].
[20:39:52] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[20:40:19] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring for the second time.
[20:40:40] Turn 7: Cat_Weasle
[20:40:42] Cat_Weasle plays [Sunken Hollow].
[20:40:58] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya's Guile].
[20:40:58] Chosen mode: Each opponent sacrifices a creature.
[20:40:58] Chosen mode: Exile all opponents' graveyards.
[20:40:58] Chosen mode: Create a 1/1 white and black Spirit creature token with flying.
[20:40:58] Chosen mode: You gain 4 life. 
[20:41:00] Cat_Weasle casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Kaya's Guile].
[20:41:07] Turn 7: Garcia_Edu
[20:41:10] Garcia_Edu plays [Fetid Heath].
[20:41:31] Cat_Weasle casts [Dig Through Time].
[20:41:49] Turn 8: Cat_Weasle
[20:41:51] Cat_Weasle plays [Swamp].
[20:41:58] Turn 8: Garcia_Edu
[20:42:04] Garcia_Edu casts [The Birth of Meletis].
[20:42:05] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [The Birth of Meletis] onto the stack (Search your library for a basic Plains card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle.).
[20:42:11] Garcia_Edu reveals [Plains].
[20:42:13] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains].
[20:42:24] Cat_Weasle casts [Horned Loch-Whale].
[20:42:29] Turn 9: Cat_Weasle
[20:42:34] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[20:42:49] Garcia_Edu casts [Abstruse Appropriation] targeting [Horned Loch-Whale].
[20:42:49] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Horned Loch-Whale] onto the stack (Ward {2} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[20:42:59] Cat_Weasle casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Abstruse Appropriation].
[20:43:42] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring for the third time. [Horned Loch-Whale] becomes their Ring-bearer.
[20:43:51] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale]
[20:43:51] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer attacks, draw a card. Then discard a card.).
[20:43:53] Cat_Weasle draws a card with The Ring's Emblem's ability.
[20:43:59] Cat_Weasle discards [Shoot the Sheriff].
[20:44:12] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[20:44:16] Turn 9: Garcia_Edu
[20:44:17] Garcia_Edu puts a lore counter on [The Birth of Meletis].
[20:44:17] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [The Birth of Meletis] onto the stack (Create a 0/4 colorless Wall artifact creature token with defender.).
[20:44:22] Garcia_Edu's [The Birth of Meletis] creates a Wall Token.
[20:44:27] Garcia_Edu casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Cat_Weasle.
[20:44:38] Cat_Weasle reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Memory], [Commit], [Commit/Memory], [Syncopate], [Lagoon Breach], [Horned Loch-Whale], [Sauron's Ransom], [Tainted Indulgence], and [Torrential Gearhulk].
[20:45:12] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:45:17] Cat_Weasle casts [Commit] targeting [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:45:20] Garcia_Edu puts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] beneath the top 1 cards of their library.
[20:45:27] Turn 10: Cat_Weasle
[20:45:33] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale]
[20:45:33] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer attacks, draw a card. Then discard a card.).
[20:45:36] Cat_Weasle draws a card with The Ring's Emblem's ability.
[20:45:38] Cat_Weasle discards [Island].
[20:45:44] [Wall Token] blocks [Horned Loch-Whale].
[20:45:45] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer becomes blocked by a creature, that creature's controller sacrifices it ...).
[20:45:49] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Wall Token's controller sacrifices it at end of combat.).
[20:45:53] Cat_Weasle plays [Swamp].
[20:45:58] Turn 10: Garcia_Edu
[20:45:59] Garcia_Edu puts a lore counter on [The Birth of Meletis].
[20:45:59] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [The Birth of Meletis] onto the stack (You gain 2 life.).
[20:46:03] Garcia_Edu plays [Swamp].
[20:46:11] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:46:19] Cat_Weasle casts [Torrential Gearhulk].
[20:46:34] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Torrential Gearhulk] onto the stack targeting [Commit/Memory] (When Torrential Gearhulk enters, you may cast target instant card from your graveyard without payi...).
[20:46:41] Cat_Weasle casts [Commit] from the graveyard targeting [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:46:44] Garcia_Edu puts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] beneath the top 1 cards of their library.
[20:46:51] Garcia_Edu casts [Abstruse Appropriation] targeting [Torrential Gearhulk].
[20:46:59] Cat_Weasle casts [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:47:01] Cat_Weasle draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:47:15] Turn 11: Cat_Weasle
[20:47:19] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[20:47:31] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring for the 4th time. [Horned Loch-Whale] becomes their Ring-bearer.
[20:47:34] Cat_Weasle casts [Search for Azcanta].
[20:47:38] Cat_Weasle plays [Swamp].
[20:47:44] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale]
[20:47:44] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer attacks, draw a card. Then discard a card.).
[20:47:46] Cat_Weasle draws a card with The Ring's Emblem's ability.
[20:47:48] Cat_Weasle discards [Island].
[20:47:53] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer deals combat damage to a player, each opponent loses 3 life.).
[20:48:00] Turn 11: Garcia_Edu
[20:48:14] Turn 12: Cat_Weasle
[20:48:15] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Search for Azcanta] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, surveil 1. Then if you have seven or more cards in your graveyard...).
[20:48:33] Garcia_Edu casts [Torrential Gearhulk].
[20:48:37] Cat_Weasle casts [Ertai Resurrected].
[20:48:43] Garcia_Edu has conceded from the game.
[20:48:43] Cat_Weasle wins the game.
Winner: Cat_Weasle
Game 1 Completed.
[20:48:47] Cat_Weasle has left the game.

== Game 2 (892906350) ==
[Time] 1727027386
[20:49:46] PDBot has started watching.
[20:49:51] Garcia_Edu begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:49:55] Cat_Weasle begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:49:55] Turn 1: Garcia_Edu
[20:49:56] Garcia_Edu skips their draw step.
[20:49:58] Garcia_Edu plays [Shambling Vent].
[20:50:02] Turn 1: Cat_Weasle
[20:50:07] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[20:50:09] Turn 2: Garcia_Edu
[20:50:11] Garcia_Edu plays [Fetid Heath].
[20:50:17] Garcia_Edu casts [Duress] targeting Cat_Weasle.
[20:50:20] Cat_Weasle reveals 7 cards with [Duress]: [Swamp], [The End], [An Offer You Can't Refuse], [Horned Loch-Whale], [Sunken Ruins], [Ertai Resurrected], and [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:50:35] Cat_Weasle discards [An Offer You Can't Refuse].
[20:50:40] Garcia_Edu casts [Duress] targeting Cat_Weasle.
[20:50:41] Cat_Weasle reveals 6 cards with [Duress]: [Swamp], [The End], [Horned Loch-Whale], [Sunken Ruins], [Ertai Resurrected], and [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:50:45] Cat_Weasle discards [The End].
[20:50:56] Turn 2: Cat_Weasle
[20:50:59] Cat_Weasle plays [Swamp].
[20:51:03] Turn 3: Garcia_Edu
[20:51:05] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains].
[20:51:08] Garcia_Edu casts ability from [Kaheera, the Orphanguard] ( Put Kaheera, the Orphanguard into your hand.).
[20:51:11] Cat_Weasle casts [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:51:13] Cat_Weasle draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:51:25] Cat_Weasle discards [Intimidation Campaign].
[20:51:32] Turn 3: Cat_Weasle
[20:51:33] Cat_Weasle plays [Sunken Ruins].
[20:51:40] Turn 4: Garcia_Edu
[20:51:43] Garcia_Edu plays [Fetid Heath].
[20:51:49] Garcia_Edu casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Cat_Weasle.
[20:52:04] Cat_Weasle reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Syncopate], [Forbid], [Sauron's Ransom], [Lagoon Breach], [Horned Loch-Whale], and [Ertai Resurrected].
[20:52:43] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[20:52:55] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring.
[20:52:57] Turn 4: Cat_Weasle
[20:53:00] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[20:53:08] Turn 5: Garcia_Edu
[20:53:10] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains].
[20:53:18] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaheera, the Orphanguard].
[20:53:29] Cat_Weasle casts [Ertai Resurrected].
[20:53:33] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Ertai Resurrected] onto the stack targeting [Kaheera, the Orphanguard] (Destroy another target creature or planeswalker. Its controller draws a card.).
[20:53:45] Garcia_Edu casts [Shoot the Sheriff] targeting [Ertai Resurrected].
[20:53:47] Garcia_Edu draws a card with [Ertai Resurrected]'s ability.
[20:53:48] Turn 5: Cat_Weasle
[20:53:50] Cat_Weasle plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[20:53:59] Turn 6: Garcia_Edu
[20:54:01] Garcia_Edu plays [Fetid Heath].
[20:54:09] Cat_Weasle casts [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:54:11] Cat_Weasle draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence].
[20:54:13] Turn 6: Cat_Weasle
[20:54:17] Cat_Weasle plays [Nephalia Drownyard].
[20:54:23] Turn 7: Garcia_Edu
[20:54:39] Cat_Weasle activates an ability of [Nephalia Drownyard] targeting Garcia_Edu ( Target player mills three cards.).
[20:54:40] Garcia_Edu mills [Plains], [Abstruse Appropriation], and [Vindicate].
[20:54:41] Turn 7: Cat_Weasle
[20:54:44] Cat_Weasle plays [Temple of Deceit].
[20:54:44] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Temple of Deceit] onto the stack (When Temple of Deceit enters, scry 1.).
[20:54:48] Cat_Weasle scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[20:54:54] Turn 8: Garcia_Edu
[20:55:04] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:55:09] Cat_Weasle casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:55:22] Cat_Weasle activates an ability of [Nephalia Drownyard] targeting Garcia_Edu ( Target player mills three cards.).
[20:55:23] Garcia_Edu mills [Condemn], [Swamp], and [Swamp].
[20:55:24] Turn 8: Cat_Weasle
[20:55:26] Cat_Weasle plays [Swamp].
[20:55:32] Turn 9: Garcia_Edu
[20:55:40] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:55:48] Cat_Weasle discards [Sunken Ruins].
[20:55:48] Cat_Weasle discards [Syncopate].
[20:55:48] Cat_Weasle casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[20:55:59] Cat_Weasle activates an ability of [Nephalia Drownyard] targeting Garcia_Edu ( Target player mills three cards.).
[20:56:01] Garcia_Edu mills [Shambling Vent], [Ob Nixilis Reignited], and [Vindicate].
[20:56:03] Turn 9: Cat_Weasle
[20:56:11] Turn 10: Garcia_Edu
[20:56:20] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Shambling Vent] ( Shambling Vent becomes a 2/3 white and black Elemental creature with lifelink until end of turn. ...).
[20:56:27] Cat_Weasle is being attacked by [Shambling Vent]
[20:56:31] Cat_Weasle casts [Lagoon Breach] targeting [Shambling Vent].
[20:56:39] Garcia_Edu puts [Shambling Vent] on top of their library with [Lagoon Breach].
[20:56:41] Turn 10: Cat_Weasle
[20:56:49] Turn 11: Garcia_Edu
[20:56:51] Garcia_Edu plays [Shambling Vent].
[20:57:11] Cat_Weasle casts [Horned Loch-Whale].
[20:57:20] Garcia_Edu casts [Shoot the Sheriff] targeting [Horned Loch-Whale].
[20:57:20] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Horned Loch-Whale] onto the stack (Ward {2} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[20:57:31] Cat_Weasle casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Shoot the Sheriff].
[20:57:37] Turn 11: Cat_Weasle
[20:57:42] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale]
[20:57:51] Turn 12: Garcia_Edu
[20:57:53] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos].
[20:58:08] Cat_Weasle activates an ability of [Nephalia Drownyard] targeting Garcia_Edu ( Target player mills three cards.).
[20:58:15] Garcia_Edu casts [Shoot the Sheriff] targeting [Horned Loch-Whale].
[20:58:16] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Horned Loch-Whale] onto the stack (Ward {2} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[20:58:34] Garcia_Edu mills [Vindicate], [Swamp], and [Caves of Koilos].
[20:58:37] Turn 12: Cat_Weasle
[20:58:43] Turn 13: Garcia_Edu
[20:58:55] Cat_Weasle activates an ability of [Nephalia Drownyard] targeting Garcia_Edu ( Target player mills three cards.).
[20:58:57] Garcia_Edu mills [Duress], [Condemn], and [Kaya's Guile].
[20:58:59] Turn 13: Cat_Weasle
[20:59:02] Cat_Weasle plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[20:59:17] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya's Guile].
[20:59:17] Chosen mode: Each opponent sacrifices a creature.
[20:59:17] Chosen mode: Exile all opponents' graveyards.
[20:59:17] Chosen mode: Create a 1/1 white and black Spirit creature token with flying.
[20:59:17] Chosen mode: You gain 4 life. 
[20:59:22] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[20:59:35] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring for the second time.
[20:59:44] Cat_Weasle discards [Swamp].
[20:59:44] Cat_Weasle discards [Swamp].
[20:59:44] Cat_Weasle casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Kaya's Guile].
[20:59:49] Turn 14: Garcia_Edu
[21:00:11] Turn 14: Cat_Weasle
[21:00:13] Cat_Weasle plays [Island].
[21:00:25] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya's Guile].
[21:00:25] Chosen mode: Each opponent sacrifices a creature.
[21:00:25] Chosen mode: Exile all opponents' graveyards.
[21:00:25] Chosen mode: Create a 1/1 white and black Spirit creature token with flying.
[21:00:25] Chosen mode: You gain 4 life. 
[21:00:39] Cat_Weasle casts [Commit] targeting [Kaya's Guile].
[21:00:40] Garcia_Edu puts [Kaya's Guile] beneath the top 1 cards of their library.
[21:00:43] Turn 15: Garcia_Edu
[21:00:44] MTGfan1996 has started watching.
[21:00:51] yellowvanblake has started watching.
[21:00:52] Garcia_Edu plays [Swamp].
[21:00:59] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: !record
[21:00:59] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  Cat_Weasle 1-0 Garcia_Edu
[21:01:02] Garcia_Edu casts [Ob Nixilis Reignited].
[21:01:12] Cat_Weasle casts [Torrential Gearhulk].
[21:01:19] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from [Torrential Gearhulk] onto the stack targeting [Forbid] (When Torrential Gearhulk enters, you may cast target instant card from your graveyard without payi...).
[21:01:25] Cat_Weasle casts [Forbid] from the graveyard targeting [Ob Nixilis Reignited].
[21:01:31] Turn 15: Cat_Weasle
[21:01:39] Cat_Weasle casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[21:01:46] Cat_Weasle is tempted by the Ring for the third time. [Torrential Gearhulk] becomes their Ring-bearer.
[21:01:52] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Torrential Gearhulk]
[21:01:52] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer attacks, draw a card. Then discard a card.).
[21:01:55] Garcia_Edu casts [Condemn] targeting [Torrential Gearhulk].
[21:02:04] Cat_Weasle discards [Sunken Ruins].
[21:02:04] Cat_Weasle discards [Sunken Ruins].
[21:02:04] Cat_Weasle casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Condemn].
[21:02:06] Cat_Weasle draws a card with The Ring's Emblem's ability.
[21:02:07] Cat_Weasle discards [Temple of Deceit].
[21:02:16] Turn 16: Garcia_Edu
[21:02:33] Turn 16: Cat_Weasle
[21:02:47] Cat_Weasle casts [Dig Through Time].
[21:03:06] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya's Guile].
[21:03:06] Chosen mode: Each opponent sacrifices a creature.
[21:03:06] Chosen mode: Exile all opponents' graveyards.
[21:03:06] Chosen mode: Create a 1/1 white and black Spirit creature token with flying.
[21:03:06] Chosen mode: You gain 4 life. 
[21:03:13] Cat_Weasle discards [Island].
[21:03:13] Cat_Weasle discards [The Celestus].
[21:03:13] Cat_Weasle casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Kaya's Guile].
[21:03:40] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Torrential Gearhulk]
[21:03:40] Cat_Weasle puts triggered ability from The Ring's Emblem onto the stack (Whenever your Ring-bearer attacks, draw a card. Then discard a card.).
[21:03:41] Cat_Weasle draws a card with The Ring's Emblem's ability.
[21:03:46] Cat_Weasle discards [Sauron's Ransom].
[21:03:53] Turn 17: Garcia_Edu
[21:04:05] Garcia_Edu casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Cat_Weasle.
[21:04:12] Cat_Weasle reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Dig Through Time], [Outrageous Robbery], and [Forbid].
[21:04:24] Garcia_Edu casts [The Eternal Wanderer].
[21:04:39] Cat_Weasle casts [Dig Through Time].
[21:04:54] Cat_Weasle casts [Mana Leak] targeting [The Eternal Wanderer].
[21:04:58] Garcia_Edu has conceded from the game.
[21:04:58] Cat_Weasle wins the game.
Winner: Cat_Weasle
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: Cat_Weasle: 2–0
[21:05:02] Garcia_Edu has left the game.