PennyDreadful
pd vs. EternalParadox38 
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
EternalParadox38,BirdsAndBees

== Game 1 (892716328) ==
[Time] 1726873430
[02:03:51] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 34.07
[Gatherling] Round=1
[02:03:55] BirdsAndBees chooses to play first.
[02:04:01] BirdsAndBees begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:04:03] EternalParadox38 mulligans to six cards.
[02:04:14] EternalParadox38 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[02:04:14] Turn 1: BirdsAndBees
[02:04:17] BirdsAndBees skips their draw step.
[02:04:18] BirdsAndBees plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[02:04:20] Turn 1: EternalParadox38
[02:04:22] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:04:24] EternalParadox38 casts [Forsaken Miner].
[02:04:27] Turn 2: BirdsAndBees
[02:04:29] BirdsAndBees plays [Sunken Ruins].
[02:04:34] Turn 2: EternalParadox38
[02:04:46] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[02:04:50] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Forsaken Miner]
[02:04:58] EternalParadox38 casts [Vraan, Executioner Thane].
[02:05:10] BirdsAndBees casts [Tainted Indulgence].
[02:05:11] BirdsAndBees draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence].
[02:05:15] BirdsAndBees discards [Torrential Gearhulk].
[02:05:19] Turn 3: BirdsAndBees
[02:05:24] BirdsAndBees plays [Swamp].
[02:05:26] BirdsAndBees casts [Duress] targeting EternalParadox38.
[02:05:29] EternalParadox38 reveals 4 cards with [Duress]: [Swamp], [Judith, the Scourge Diva], [Swamp], and [Sulfurous Springs].
[02:05:36] Turn 3: EternalParadox38
[02:05:41] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:05:44] EternalParadox38 casts [Judith, the Scourge Diva].
[02:05:48] BirdsAndBees casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Judith, the Scourge Diva].
[02:05:54] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Vraan, Executioner Thane] and [Forsaken Miner]
[02:05:56] Turn 4: BirdsAndBees
[02:05:59] BirdsAndBees plays [Temple of Deceit].
[02:06:00] BirdsAndBees puts triggered ability from [Temple of Deceit] onto the stack (When Temple of Deceit enters, scry 1.).
[02:06:02] BirdsAndBees scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[02:06:06] Turn 4: EternalParadox38
[02:06:15] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Vraan, Executioner Thane] and [Forsaken Miner]
[02:06:19] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:06:26] Turn 5: BirdsAndBees
[02:06:29] BirdsAndBees plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[02:06:36] Turn 5: EternalParadox38
[02:06:39] EternalParadox38 plays [Sulfurous Springs].
[02:06:42] EternalParadox38 casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[02:06:52] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Vraan, Executioner Thane] and [Forsaken Miner]
[02:07:08] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting BirdsAndBees ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[02:07:09] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[02:07:09] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Vraan, Executioner Thane] onto the stack (Whenever one or more other creatures you control die, each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 li...).
[02:07:32] BirdsAndBees casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting [Forsaken Miner], and [Judith, the Scourge Diva]. (X is 1).
[02:07:33] Chosen mode: Exile up to twice X target cards from graveyards.
[02:07:41] BirdsAndBees has conceded from the game.
[02:07:41] EternalParadox38 wins the game.
Winner: EternalParadox38
Game 1 Completed.
[02:07:46] BirdsAndBees has left the game.

== Game 2 (892716756) ==
[Time] 1726873787
[02:09:47] PDBot has started watching.
[02:10:05] BirdsAndBees chooses to play first.
[02:10:09] BirdsAndBees begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:10:12] EternalParadox38 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:10:12] Turn 1: BirdsAndBees
[02:10:12] BirdsAndBees skips their draw step.
[02:10:12] BirdsAndBees plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[02:10:12] Turn 1: EternalParadox38
[02:10:12] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:10:13] EternalParadox38 casts [Forsaken Miner].
[02:10:15] Turn 2: BirdsAndBees
[02:10:18] BirdsAndBees plays [Swamp].
[02:10:21] Turn 2: EternalParadox38
[02:10:27] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Forsaken Miner]
[02:10:31] BirdsAndBees casts [Lagoon Breach] targeting [Forsaken Miner].
[02:10:36] EternalParadox38 puts [Forsaken Miner] on top of their library with [Lagoon Breach].
[02:10:41] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[02:10:43] EternalParadox38 casts [Bitterblossom].
[02:10:48] Turn 3: BirdsAndBees
[02:10:53] BirdsAndBees plays [Sunken Ruins].
[02:10:56] Turn 3: EternalParadox38
[02:10:56] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:10:58] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:11:05] EternalParadox38 plays [Graven Cairns].
[02:11:09] EternalParadox38 casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:11:15] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[02:11:36] BirdsAndBees casts [Disfigure] targeting [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:11:37] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack targeting BirdsAndBees (When Dreadhorde Butcher dies, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[02:11:37] EternalParadox38 casts [Forsaken Miner].
[02:11:38] Turn 4: BirdsAndBees
[02:11:39] BirdsAndBees plays [Island].
[02:11:42] Turn 4: EternalParadox38
[02:11:42] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:11:44] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:11:53] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Forsaken Miner] and [Faerie Rogue Token]
[02:12:02] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:12:06] Turn 5: BirdsAndBees
[02:12:09] BirdsAndBees plays [Island].
[02:12:15] Turn 5: EternalParadox38
[02:12:15] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:12:17] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:12:24] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Faerie Rogue Token], [Forsaken Miner], and [Faerie Rogue Token]
[02:12:31] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[02:12:42] BirdsAndBees casts [Consume the Meek].
[02:12:46] Turn 6: BirdsAndBees
[02:12:52] BirdsAndBees casts [Duress] targeting EternalParadox38.
[02:12:52] EternalParadox38 reveals 3 cards with [Duress]: [Bloodsoaked Champion], [Dragonskull Summit], and [Chain Lightning].
[02:12:54] EternalParadox38 discards [Chain Lightning].
[02:13:12] BirdsAndBees casts [Tasigur, the Golden Fang].
[02:13:15] Turn 6: EternalParadox38
[02:13:15] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:13:18] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:13:22] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[02:13:24] EternalParadox38 casts [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[02:13:27] EternalParadox38 casts [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[02:13:35] Turn 7: BirdsAndBees
[02:13:38] BirdsAndBees plays [Island].
[02:13:46] BirdsAndBees casts [Horned Loch-Whale].
[02:14:01] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Tasigur, the Golden Fang]
[02:14:25] Turn 7: EternalParadox38
[02:14:25] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:14:27] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:14:44] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Bloodsoaked Champion] and [Bloodsoaked Champion]
[02:14:48] [Horned Loch-Whale] blocks [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[02:14:55] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Bloodsoaked Champion] ( Return Bloodsoaked Champion from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[02:14:58] EternalParadox38 plays [Graven Cairns].
[02:15:04] Turn 8: BirdsAndBees
[02:15:08] BirdsAndBees plays [River of Tears].
[02:15:26] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale] and [Tasigur, the Golden Fang]
[02:15:30] [Faerie Rogue Token] blocks [Horned Loch-Whale].
[02:15:42] Turn 8: EternalParadox38
[02:15:42] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:15:44] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:15:59] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Bloodsoaked Champion] and [Bloodsoaked Champion]
[02:16:14] BirdsAndBees activates an ability of [Tasigur, the Golden Fang] ( Mill two cards, then return a nonland card of an opponent's choice from your graveyard to your ha...).
[02:16:16] BirdsAndBees mills [Concealing Curtains] and BirdsAndBees.
[02:16:25] EternalParadox38 chooses BirdsAndBees.
[02:16:25] BirdsAndBees is returned to BirdsAndBees's hand from the graveyard.
[02:16:37] EternalParadox38 casts [Chain Lightning] targeting BirdsAndBees.
[02:16:37] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[02:16:50] BirdsAndBees casts [Forbid] targeting [Chain Lightning].
[02:16:56] Turn 9: BirdsAndBees
[02:17:03] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale] and [Tasigur, the Golden Fang]
[02:17:06] [Faerie Rogue Token] blocks [Horned Loch-Whale].
[02:17:18] Turn 9: EternalParadox38
[02:17:18] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bitterblossom] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 black Faerie Rogue creature toke...).
[02:17:20] EternalParadox38's [Bitterblossom] creates a Faerie Rogue Token.
[02:17:26] EternalParadox38 casts [Specter's Shriek] targeting BirdsAndBees.
[02:17:38] BirdsAndBees casts [Shoot the Sheriff] targeting [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[02:17:52] BirdsAndBees casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting [Bloodsoaked Champion] (-X/-X). (X is 4).
[02:17:52] Chosen mode: Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. You gain X life.
[02:17:57] BirdsAndBees reveals their hand to [Specter's Shriek], containing EternalParadox38.
[02:18:05] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Forsaken Miner] and [Faerie Rogue Token]
[02:18:12] Turn 10: BirdsAndBees
[02:18:18] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale] and [Tasigur, the Golden Fang]
[02:18:20] [Faerie Rogue Token] blocks [Horned Loch-Whale].
[02:18:22] BirdsAndBees wins the game.
[02:18:22] EternalParadox38 loses the game.
Winner: BirdsAndBees
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (892717466) ==
[Time] 1726874365
[02:19:25] PDBot has started watching.
[02:19:26] EternalParadox38 chooses to play first.
[02:19:32] EternalParadox38 mulligans to six cards.
[02:19:44] BirdsAndBees begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:19:54] EternalParadox38 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[02:19:54] Turn 1: EternalParadox38
[02:19:54] EternalParadox38 skips their draw step.
[02:19:56] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[02:19:58] Turn 1: BirdsAndBees
[02:20:02] BirdsAndBees plays [River of Tears].
[02:20:04] BirdsAndBees casts [Duress] targeting EternalParadox38.
[02:20:05] EternalParadox38 reveals 5 cards with [Duress]: [Thran Portal], [Bitterblossom], [Dreadhorde Butcher], [Sulfurous Springs], and [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:20:06] EternalParadox38 discards [Bitterblossom].
[02:20:08] Turn 2: EternalParadox38
[02:20:13] EternalParadox38 plays [Sulfurous Springs].
[02:20:19] EternalParadox38 casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:20:24] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[02:20:26] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack (Whenever Dreadhorde Butcher deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, put a +1/+1 counter o...).
[02:20:27] EternalParadox38 puts a +1/+1 counter on [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:20:29] Turn 2: BirdsAndBees
[02:20:32] BirdsAndBees plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[02:20:35] Turn 3: EternalParadox38
[02:20:40] EternalParadox38 plays [Thran Portal].
[02:20:43] EternalParadox38 chooses Swamp for [Thran Portal].
[02:21:01] EternalParadox38 casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:21:07] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher] and [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[02:21:10] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack (Whenever Dreadhorde Butcher deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, put a +1/+1 counter o...).
[02:21:10] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack (Whenever Dreadhorde Butcher deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, put a +1/+1 counter o...).
[02:21:12] EternalParadox38 puts a +1/+1 counter on [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:21:14] EternalParadox38 puts a +1/+1 counter on [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:21:16] Turn 3: BirdsAndBees
[02:21:27] BirdsAndBees plays [Sunken Ruins].
[02:21:31] Turn 4: EternalParadox38
[02:21:38] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher] and [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[02:21:44] BirdsAndBees casts [Lagoon Breach] targeting [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:21:49] EternalParadox38 puts [Dreadhorde Butcher] on top of their library with [Lagoon Breach].
[02:21:53] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack (Whenever Dreadhorde Butcher deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, put a +1/+1 counter o...).
[02:21:55] EternalParadox38 puts a +1/+1 counter on [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:21:57] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:22:01] EternalParadox38 casts [Tymaret, Chosen from Death].
[02:22:13] Turn 4: BirdsAndBees
[02:22:17] BirdsAndBees plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[02:22:25] Turn 5: EternalParadox38
[02:22:29] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[02:22:32] EternalParadox38 casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:22:39] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher], [Tymaret, Chosen from Death], and [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[02:22:44] BirdsAndBees casts [Disfigure] targeting [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:22:49] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack targeting BirdsAndBees (When Dreadhorde Butcher dies, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[02:22:55] BirdsAndBees casts [Shoot the Sheriff] targeting [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[02:22:59] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack targeting BirdsAndBees (When Dreadhorde Butcher dies, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[02:23:19] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Tymaret, Chosen from Death] targeting [Shoot the Sheriff], and [Disfigure] ( Exile up to two target cards from graveyards. You gain 1 life for each creature card exiled this ...).
[02:23:26] Turn 5: BirdsAndBees
[02:23:30] BirdsAndBees plays [Island].
[02:23:35] Turn 6: EternalParadox38
[02:23:43] BirdsAndBees is being attacked by [Tymaret, Chosen from Death]
[02:24:01] BirdsAndBees casts [Consume the Meek].
[02:24:11] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Tymaret, Chosen from Death] targeting [Duress] ( Exile up to two target cards from graveyards. You gain 1 life for each creature card exiled this ...).
[02:24:17] Turn 6: BirdsAndBees
[02:24:24] Turn 7: EternalParadox38
[02:24:29] EternalParadox38 plays [Graven Cairns].
[02:24:33] Turn 7: BirdsAndBees
[02:24:37] BirdsAndBees plays [Swamp].
[02:24:41] Turn 8: EternalParadox38
[02:24:55] BirdsAndBees casts [Horned Loch-Whale].
[02:24:56] Turn 8: BirdsAndBees
[02:25:02] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale]
[02:25:05] Turn 9: EternalParadox38
[02:25:17] EternalParadox38 casts EternalParadox38.
[02:25:21] BirdsAndBees casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[02:25:22] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sauron's Ransom[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Sauron's Ransom shows whether face down cards are white-bordered and whether they have "save-targets" enabled
[02:25:40] BirdsAndBees is tempted by the Ring. [Horned Loch-Whale] becomes their Ring-bearer.
[02:26:04] BirdsAndBees casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting EternalParadox38 (-X/-X). (X is 2).
[02:26:04] Chosen mode: Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. You gain X life.
[02:26:08] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from EternalParadox38 onto the stack targeting BirdsAndBees (Whenever a nontoken creature you control dies, Judith, the Scourge Diva deals 1 damage to any targ...).
[02:26:11] Turn 9: BirdsAndBees
[02:26:14] BirdsAndBees plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[02:26:17] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Horned Loch-Whale]
[02:26:21] Turn 10: EternalParadox38
[02:26:29] EternalParadox38 plays [Graven Cairns].
[02:26:37] EternalParadox38 casts [Gatekeeper of Malakir] (with kicker).
[02:26:45] BirdsAndBees discards [Lost Legacy].
[02:26:45] BirdsAndBees discards [Sunken Ruins].
[02:26:45] BirdsAndBees casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Gatekeeper of Malakir].
[02:26:50] EternalParadox38 has conceded from the game.
[02:26:50] BirdsAndBees wins the game.
Winner: BirdsAndBees
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: BirdsAndBees: 2–1
[02:26:56] BirdsAndBees has left the game.