PennyDreadful
PD v DFG
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
GoldfishMan2136,DGF

== Game 1 (890229036) ==
[Time] 1725065908
[10:58:29] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 34.04
[Gatherling] Round=4
[10:58:31] DGF joined the game.
[10:58:33] GoldfishMan2136 chooses to play first.
[10:58:40] [CHAT] GoldfishMan2136: glhf
[10:58:47] GoldfishMan2136 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[10:59:01] DGF begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[10:59:01] Turn 1: GoldfishMan2136
[10:59:04] GoldfishMan2136 skips their draw step.
[10:59:04] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[10:59:07] Turn 1: DGF
[10:59:14] DGF plays [Swamp].
[10:59:17] DGF casts [Dread Wanderer].
[10:59:22] Turn 2: GoldfishMan2136
[10:59:27] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[10:59:37] Turn 2: DGF
[10:59:46] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Dread Wanderer]
[10:59:53] DGF plays [Mountain].
[10:59:58] DGF casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[11:00:02] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Goblin Bombardment].
[11:00:11] Turn 3: GoldfishMan2136
[11:00:16] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:00:24] Turn 3: DGF
[11:00:27] [CHAT] DGF: you too!
[11:00:34] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:00:41] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Dread Wanderer]
[11:00:50] DGF casts [Unlucky Witness].
[11:01:01] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Sauron's Ransom].
[11:01:01] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sauron's Ransom[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Sauron's Ransom shows whether face down cards are white-bordered and whether they have "save-targets" enabled
[11:01:38] GoldfishMan2136 is tempted by the Ring.
[11:01:44] Turn 4: GoldfishMan2136
[11:01:50] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[11:01:53] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Academy Loremaster].
[11:02:04] Turn 4: DGF
[11:02:06] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Academy Loremaster] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:02:20] DGF plays [Graven Cairns].
[11:02:27] DGF casts [Chain Lightning] targeting [Academy Loremaster].
[11:02:39] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Unlucky Witness] and [Dread Wanderer]
[11:02:52] DGF casts [Vraan, Executioner Thane].
[11:03:16] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Disfigure] targeting [Vraan, Executioner Thane].
[11:03:21] Turn 5: GoldfishMan2136
[11:03:27] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[11:03:30] GoldfishMan2136 casts ability from [Lurrus of the Dream-Den] ( Put Lurrus of the Dream-Den into your hand.).
[11:03:40] Turn 5: DGF
[11:03:44] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:03:48] DGF casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[11:03:50] DGF puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting GoldfishMan2136 (When Mesmeric Fiend enters, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a nonland card from ...).
[11:04:21] GoldfishMan2136 reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Island], [Volatile Stormdrake], [Island], [Volatile Stormdrake], and [Underground River].
[11:04:27] DGF casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:04:35] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher], [Unlucky Witness], and [Dread Wanderer]
[11:04:41] DGF puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack (Whenever Dreadhorde Butcher deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, put a +1/+1 counter o...).
[11:04:43] DGF puts a +1/+1 counter on [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:04:48] Turn 6: GoldfishMan2136
[11:04:52] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[11:05:06] GoldfishMan2136 has conceded from the game.
[11:05:06] DGF wins the game.
Winner: DGF
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (890229864) ==
[Time] 1725066396
[11:06:36] PDBot has started watching.
[11:06:45] GoldfishMan2136 chooses to play first.
[11:06:52] GoldfishMan2136 mulligans to six cards.
[11:07:06] DGF mulligans to six cards.
[11:07:08] GoldfishMan2136 mulligans to five cards.
[11:07:15] DGF puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[11:07:17] GoldfishMan2136 mulligans to four cards.
[11:07:23] GoldfishMan2136 puts three cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with four cards in hand.
[11:07:23] Turn 1: GoldfishMan2136
[11:07:26] GoldfishMan2136 skips their draw step.
[11:07:27] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[11:07:30] Turn 1: DGF
[11:07:34] DGF plays [Sulfurous Springs].
[11:07:41] Turn 2: GoldfishMan2136
[11:07:43] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:07:47] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Academy Loremaster].
[11:07:59] Turn 2: DGF
[11:08:02] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Academy Loremaster] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:08:12] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:08:16] DGF casts [Duress] targeting GoldfishMan2136.
[11:08:18] GoldfishMan2136 reveals 2 cards with [Duress]: [River of Tears] and [Disfigure].
[11:08:21] GoldfishMan2136 discards [Disfigure].
[11:08:27] DGF casts [Chain Lightning] targeting [Academy Loremaster].
[11:08:38] Turn 3: GoldfishMan2136
[11:08:42] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[11:08:46] GoldfishMan2136 casts ability from [Lurrus of the Dream-Den] ( Put Lurrus of the Dream-Den into your hand.).
[11:08:49] Turn 3: DGF
[11:08:54] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:09:01] DGF casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[11:09:06] Turn 4: GoldfishMan2136
[11:09:12] GoldfishMan2136 plays [River of Tears].
[11:09:22] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Lurrus of the Dream-Den].
[11:09:33] Turn 4: DGF
[11:09:42] DGF plays [Sulfurous Springs].
[11:09:47] Turn 5: GoldfishMan2136
[11:09:54] GoldfishMan2136 casts GoldfishMan2136 from the graveyard.
[11:10:03] DGF is being attacked by [Lurrus of the Dream-Den]
[11:10:14] Turn 5: DGF
[11:10:16] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from GoldfishMan2136 onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:10:27] DGF plays [Graven Cairns].
[11:10:40] DGF casts [Chain Lightning] targeting [Lurrus of the Dream-Den].
[11:10:54] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[11:10:56] Turn 6: GoldfishMan2136
[11:10:59] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from GoldfishMan2136 onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:11:01] GoldfishMan2136 draws a card with GoldfishMan2136's ability.
[11:11:05] DGF is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] and GoldfishMan2136
[11:11:07] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] onto the stack (Whenever Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel deals combat damage to a player, put a chorus counter on it. ...).
[11:11:08] GoldfishMan2136 puts a chorus counter on [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[11:11:08] GoldfishMan2136 draws a card with [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]'s ability.
[11:11:10] GoldfishMan2136 discards [Volatile Stormdrake].
[11:11:11] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Underground River].
[11:11:13] Turn 6: DGF
[11:11:32] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from GoldfishMan2136 onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:11:40] DGF draws a card with GoldfishMan2136's ability.
[11:11:46] DGF plays [Graven Cairns].
[11:12:00] DGF casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:12:16] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[11:12:22] DGF puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack (Whenever Dreadhorde Butcher deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, put a +1/+1 counter o...).
[11:12:26] DGF puts a +1/+1 counter on [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:12:37] DGF activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting GoldfishMan2136 ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[11:12:40] DGF puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack targeting GoldfishMan2136 (When Dreadhorde Butcher dies, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[11:12:51] Turn 7: GoldfishMan2136
[11:12:58] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Academy Loremaster].
[11:13:02] DGF is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]
[11:13:05] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] onto the stack (Whenever Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel deals combat damage to a player, put a chorus counter on it. ...).
[11:13:06] GoldfishMan2136 puts a chorus counter on [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[11:13:06] GoldfishMan2136 draws a card with [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]'s ability.
[11:13:10] GoldfishMan2136 discards [Unsummon].
[11:13:11] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Creeping Tar Pit].
[11:13:13] Turn 7: DGF
[11:13:16] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Academy Loremaster] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:13:22] DGF draws a card with [Academy Loremaster]'s ability.
[11:13:26] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:13:37] DGF casts [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[11:13:54] DGF casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:13:58] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:14:10] DGF activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[11:14:24] Turn 8: GoldfishMan2136
[11:14:26] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Academy Loremaster] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:14:31] GoldfishMan2136 draws a card with [Academy Loremaster]'s ability.
[11:14:32] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[11:14:36] GoldfishMan2136 activates an ability of [Creeping Tar Pit] ( Creeping Tar Pit becomes a 3/2 blue and black Elemental creature until end of turn and can't be b...).
[11:14:44] DGF is being attacked by [Creeping Tar Pit] and [Academy Loremaster]
[11:14:53] Turn 8: DGF
[11:14:55] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Academy Loremaster] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:15:02] DGF draws a card with [Academy Loremaster]'s ability.
[11:15:05] DGF plays [Mountain].
[11:15:13] DGF has conceded from the game.
[11:15:13] GoldfishMan2136 wins the game.
Winner: GoldfishMan2136
Game 2 Completed.
[11:15:17] GoldfishMan2136 has left the game.

== Game 3 (890230786) ==
[Time] 1725066976
[11:16:17] PDBot has started watching.
[11:16:20] DGF chooses to play first.
[11:16:32] DGF begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:16:34] GoldfishMan2136 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:16:34] Turn 1: DGF
[11:16:39] DGF skips their draw step.
[11:16:41] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:16:44] DGF casts [Duress] targeting GoldfishMan2136.
[11:16:44] GoldfishMan2136 reveals 7 cards with [Duress]: [Creeping Tar Pit], [Mana Leak], [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel], [Aether Spike], [Mana Leak], [Academy Loremaster], and [Island].
[11:17:00] GoldfishMan2136 discards [Mana Leak].
[11:17:06] Turn 1: GoldfishMan2136
[11:17:09] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Creeping Tar Pit].
[11:17:18] Turn 2: DGF
[11:17:23] DGF plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[11:17:28] Turn 2: GoldfishMan2136
[11:17:31] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[11:17:34] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Academy Loremaster].
[11:17:43] DGF casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Academy Loremaster].
[11:17:55] Turn 3: DGF
[11:17:58] [CHAT] DGF: oh no
[11:17:59] [CHAT] DGF: 2 3
[11:18:03] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Academy Loremaster] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's draw step, that player may draw an additional card. If they do, ...).
[11:18:18] [CHAT] GoldfishMan2136: it is an important distinction
[11:18:22] DGF draws a card with [Academy Loremaster]'s ability.
[11:18:25] DGF plays [Mountain].
[11:18:35] DGF casts [Chain Lightning] targeting [Academy Loremaster].
[11:18:39] [CHAT] DGF: agreed
[11:18:47] Turn 3: GoldfishMan2136
[11:18:52] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Island].
[11:19:02] Turn 4: DGF
[11:19:06] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:19:09] DGF casts [Dread Wanderer].
[11:19:14] DGF casts [Dread Wanderer].
[11:19:24] Turn 4: GoldfishMan2136
[11:19:28] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:19:31] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Life of Toshiro Umezawa].
[11:19:38] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] onto the stack targeting [Dread Wanderer] (Target creature gets -1/-1 until end of turn.).
[11:19:52] Turn 5: DGF
[11:19:57] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:20:02] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Dread Wanderer]
[11:20:03] Phyrexiann has started watching.
[11:20:14] Turn 5: GoldfishMan2136
[11:20:16] GoldfishMan2136 puts a lore counter on [Life of Toshiro Umezawa].
[11:20:18] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] onto the stack targeting [Dread Wanderer] (Target creature gets -1/-1 until end of turn.).
[11:20:31] Turn 6: DGF
[11:20:37] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:20:43] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[11:20:46] Turn 6: GoldfishMan2136
[11:20:46] datrobino has started watching.
[11:20:47] GoldfishMan2136 puts a lore counter on [Life of Toshiro Umezawa].
[11:20:48] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] onto the stack (Exile this Saga, then return it to the battlefield transformed under your control.).
[11:20:51] GoldfishMan2136 exiles [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] with its own ability.
[11:20:51] [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] transforms into [Memory of Toshiro].
[11:20:59] DGF is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]
[11:21:07] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] onto the stack (Whenever Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel deals combat damage to a player, put a chorus counter on it. ...).
[11:21:16] GoldfishMan2136 puts a chorus counter on [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[11:21:16] GoldfishMan2136 draws a card with [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]'s ability.
[11:21:20] GoldfishMan2136 discards [Mana Leak].
[11:21:21] GoldfishMan2136 plays [River of Tears].
[11:21:24] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Pithing Needle].
[11:21:24] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Pithing Needle[sU] has an unclassified bug.
Avatars are incorrectly on the list of cards you can name with cards such as Pithing Needle.
[11:21:39] GoldfishMan2136 names Goblin Bombardment for [Pithing Needle].
[11:21:48] Turn 7: DGF
[11:21:53] DGF plays [Sulfurous Springs].
[11:21:57] DGF casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:22:06] DGF activates an ability of [Dread Wanderer] ( Return Dread Wanderer from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[11:22:11] Phyrexiann has stopped watching.
[11:22:22] Turn 7: GoldfishMan2136
[11:22:33] DGF is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]
[11:22:39] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] onto the stack (Whenever Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel deals combat damage to a player, put a chorus counter on it. ...).
[11:22:43] GoldfishMan2136 puts a chorus counter on [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[11:22:43] GoldfishMan2136 draws a card with [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]'s ability.
[11:22:57] Phyrexiann has started watching.
[11:22:57] GoldfishMan2136 discards [Academy Loremaster].
[11:23:04] Turn 8: DGF
[11:23:11] DGF casts [Forsaken Miner].
[11:23:24] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Dread Wanderer] and [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[11:23:27] [Memory of Toshiro] blocks [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[11:23:35] DGF puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack targeting [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] (When Dreadhorde Butcher dies, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[11:23:47] DGF casts [Chain Lightning] targeting [Memory of Toshiro].
[11:24:02] DGF activates an ability of [Dread Wanderer] ( Return Dread Wanderer from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[11:24:10] Turn 8: GoldfishMan2136
[11:24:15] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Creeping Tar Pit].
[11:24:19] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Flaying Tendrils].
[11:24:31] Turn 9: DGF
[11:24:37] DGF casts [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[11:24:43] Turn 9: GoldfishMan2136
[11:24:52] GoldfishMan2136 activates an ability of [Creeping Tar Pit] ( Creeping Tar Pit becomes a 3/2 blue and black Elemental creature until end of turn and can't be b...).
[11:24:55] DGF is being attacked by [Creeping Tar Pit]
[11:24:59] Turn 10: DGF
[11:25:04] DGF plays [Swamp].
[11:25:10] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Bloodsoaked Champion]
[11:25:17] Turn 10: GoldfishMan2136
[11:25:19] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[11:25:26] GoldfishMan2136 activates an ability of [Creeping Tar Pit] ( Creeping Tar Pit becomes a 3/2 blue and black Elemental creature until end of turn and can't be b...).
[11:25:34] DGF is being attacked by [Creeping Tar Pit]
[11:25:41] GoldfishMan2136 casts ability from [Lurrus of the Dream-Den] ( Put Lurrus of the Dream-Den into your hand.).
[11:25:44] Turn 11: DGF
[11:25:51] DGF casts [Bloodsoaked Champion].
[11:26:04] Turn 11: GoldfishMan2136
[11:26:14] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Volatile Stormdrake].
[11:26:19] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Volatile Stormdrake] onto the stack targeting [Bloodsoaked Champion] (When Volatile Stormdrake enters, exchange control of Volatile Stormdrake and target creature an op...).
[11:26:22] GoldfishMan2136 puts four energy counters on GoldfishMan2136.
[11:26:25] GoldfishMan2136 removes an energy counter from GoldfishMan2136.
[11:26:28] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Unsummon] targeting [Volatile Stormdrake].
[11:26:33] GoldfishMan2136 returns [Volatile Stormdrake] to its owner's hand with [Unsummon].
[11:26:41] GoldfishMan2136 activates an ability of [Creeping Tar Pit] ( Creeping Tar Pit becomes a 3/2 blue and black Elemental creature until end of turn and can't be b...).
[11:26:50] DGF is being attacked by [Creeping Tar Pit]
[11:27:00] Turn 12: DGF
[11:27:08] DGF casts [Judith, the Scourge Diva].
[11:27:17] GoldfishMan2136 is being attacked by [Bloodsoaked Champion]
[11:27:27] Turn 12: GoldfishMan2136
[11:27:31] GoldfishMan2136 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[11:27:39] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Flaying Tendrils].
[11:27:48] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Lurrus of the Dream-Den].
[11:27:55] GoldfishMan2136 casts [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] from the graveyard.
[11:28:00] GoldfishMan2136 puts triggered ability from [Life of Toshiro Umezawa] onto the stack (You gain 2 life.).
[11:28:16] Turn 13: DGF
[11:28:43] DGF casts [Price of Progress].
[11:28:53] [CHAT] DGF: the life gain mattered haha
[11:28:54] [CHAT] DGF: ggs
[11:28:59] DGF has conceded from the game.
[11:28:59] GoldfishMan2136 wins the game.
Winner: GoldfishMan2136
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: GoldfishMan2136: 2–1
[11:29:05] GoldfishMan2136 has left the game.