PennyDreadful PD vs tidalslimshady BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney tidalslimshady,Cheiffireball == Game 1 (888112474) == [Time] 1723506440 [09:47:21] PDBot has started watching. [Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 34.01 [Gatherling] Round=2 [09:47:29] Cheiffireball chooses to play first. [09:47:31] Cheiffireball begins the game with seven cards in hand. [09:47:33] tidalslimshady mulligans to six cards. [09:47:40] tidalslimshady puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [09:47:40] Turn 1: Cheiffireball [09:48:22] Cheiffireball skips their draw step. [09:48:23] Cheiffireball plays [Sunken Hollow]. [09:48:29] Turn 1: tidalslimshady [09:48:36] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:48:39] tidalslimshady exiles [Search for Tomorrow] with 2 time counters. [09:48:39] tidalslimshady puts two time counters on [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:48:47] Turn 2: Cheiffireball [09:48:50] Cheiffireball plays [Island]. [09:48:50] Turn 2: tidalslimshady [09:48:50] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [09:48:51] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:48:53] tidalslimshady casts [Traverse the Ulvenwald]. [09:48:54] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest]. [09:48:54] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:48:55] tidalslimshady casts [Caravan Vigil]. [09:48:55] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest]. [09:48:58] Cheiffireball casts [Tainted Indulgence]. [09:48:58] Cheiffireball draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence]. [09:49:01] Cheiffireball discards [Unburial Rites]. [09:49:03] Turn 3: Cheiffireball [09:49:10] Cheiffireball plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [09:49:16] Turn 3: tidalslimshady [09:49:16] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [09:49:18] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:49:18] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, you may cast it w...). [09:49:21] tidalslimshady casts [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:49:28] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:49:31] tidalslimshady casts [Nature's Lore]. [09:49:41] tidalslimshady casts [Nature's Lore]. [09:49:55] tidalslimshady casts [Analyze the Pollen]. [09:50:03] Cheiffireball casts [Frantic Search]. [09:50:05] Cheiffireball draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [09:50:08] Cheiffireball discards [Shoot the Sheriff]. [09:50:08] Cheiffireball discards [Caves of Koilos]. [09:50:17] Cheiffireball casts [Phantom Interference] targeting [Analyze the Pollen]. [09:50:17] Chosen mode: {1} Counter target spell unless its controller pays {2}. [09:50:24] Turn 4: Cheiffireball [09:50:29] Cheiffireball plays [Swamp]. [09:50:31] Turn 4: tidalslimshady [09:50:41] tidalslimshady casts [Thragtusk]. [09:50:42] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Thragtusk] onto the stack (When Thragtusk enters, you gain 5 life.). [09:50:51] Cheiffireball casts [Gifts Ungiven] targeting tidalslimshady. [09:50:58] Cheiffireball reveals [Iona, Shield of Emeria]. [09:50:58] Cheiffireball reveals [Void Winnower]. [09:51:04] tidalslimshady chooses Iona, Shield of Emeria and Void Winnower. [09:51:05] Turn 5: Cheiffireball [09:51:27] Cheiffireball casts [Dig Through Time]. [09:51:42] Cheiffireball plays [Sunken Hollow]. [09:51:46] Turn 5: tidalslimshady [09:52:00] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Thragtusk] [09:52:03] tidalslimshady casts [Goblin Charbelcher]. [09:52:10] Cheiffireball casts [Forbid] targeting [Goblin Charbelcher]. [09:52:16] Turn 6: Cheiffireball [09:52:25] Cheiffireball casts [Unburial Rites] targeting [Void Winnower]. [09:52:27] Cheiffireball plays [Caves of Koilos]. [09:52:28] Turn 6: tidalslimshady [09:52:33] tidalslimshady casts [Recross the Paths]. [09:52:34] tidalslimshady reveals 29 cards with [Recross the Paths]: [Caravan Vigil], [Cleanup Crew], [Chancellor of the Tangle], [Dig Up], [Thragtusk], [Kogla, the Titan Ape], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Thragtusk], [Rampant Growth], [Caravan Vigil], [09:52:35] [Recross the Paths], [Nature's Lore], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Search for Tomorrow], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Analyze the Pollen], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Chancellor of the Tangle], [Rampant Growth], [Recross the Paths], [09:52:35] [Sylvan Library], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Chancellor of the Tangle], [Dig Up], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Thragtusk], [Recross the Paths], and [Forest]. [09:52:36] tidalslimshady reveals [Fanatic of Rhonas]. [09:52:36] Cheiffireball reveals [Shoot the Sheriff]. [09:52:36] No one wins the clash. [09:52:41] tidalslimshady has conceded from the game. [09:52:41] Cheiffireball wins the game. Winner: Cheiffireball Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (888113066) == [Time] 1723506806 [09:53:27] PDBot has started watching. [09:53:27] tidalslimshady chooses to play first. [09:53:33] tidalslimshady begins the game with seven cards in hand. [09:53:45] Cheiffireball mulligans to six cards. [09:53:53] Cheiffireball puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [09:53:54] Turn 1: tidalslimshady [09:53:54] tidalslimshady skips their draw step. [09:53:55] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:53:57] tidalslimshady exiles [Search for Tomorrow] with 2 time counters. [09:53:57] tidalslimshady puts two time counters on [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:53:59] Turn 1: Cheiffireball [09:54:04] Cheiffireball plays [Sunken Hollow]. [09:54:05] Turn 2: tidalslimshady [09:54:05] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [09:54:07] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:54:09] tidalslimshady casts [Analyze the Pollen]. [09:54:11] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest] with [Analyze the Pollen]. [09:54:12] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:54:13] tidalslimshady casts [Caravan Vigil]. [09:54:16] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest]. [09:54:19] Turn 2: Cheiffireball [09:54:22] Cheiffireball plays [Island]. [09:54:26] Turn 3: tidalslimshady [09:54:26] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [09:54:29] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:54:29] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, you may cast it w...). [09:54:31] tidalslimshady casts [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:54:33] Cheiffireball casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:54:40] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:54:42] tidalslimshady casts [Ground Seal]. [09:54:44] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Ground Seal] onto the stack (When Ground Seal enters, draw a card.). [09:54:46] tidalslimshady draws a card with [Ground Seal]'s ability. [09:54:48] tidalslimshady casts [Analyze the Pollen]. [09:54:52] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest] with [Analyze the Pollen]. [09:54:56] Turn 3: Cheiffireball [09:55:00] Cheiffireball casts [Duress] targeting tidalslimshady. [09:55:01] tidalslimshady reveals 5 cards with [Duress]: [Forest], [Nature's Lore], [Rampant Growth], [Sylvan Caryatid], and [Goblin Charbelcher]. [09:55:08] tidalslimshady discards [Goblin Charbelcher]. [09:55:11] Cheiffireball plays [Island]. [09:55:12] Turn 4: tidalslimshady [09:55:14] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [09:55:16] tidalslimshady casts [Nature's Lore]. [09:55:30] tidalslimshady exiles [Search for Tomorrow] with 2 time counters. [09:55:30] tidalslimshady puts two time counters on [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:55:32] tidalslimshady casts [Rampant Growth]. [09:55:41] Turn 4: Cheiffireball [09:55:52] Cheiffireball plays [Swamp]. [09:55:54] Turn 5: tidalslimshady [09:55:54] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [09:55:56] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:56:00] tidalslimshady casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [09:56:08] Cheiffireball casts [Tainted Indulgence]. [09:56:09] Cheiffireball draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence]. [09:56:10] Cheiffireball discards [Island]. [09:56:14] Turn 5: Cheiffireball [09:56:18] Cheiffireball plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [09:56:21] Cheiffireball casts [Liliana, Death's Majesty]. [09:56:25] Cheiffireball puts a loyalty counter on [Liliana, Death's Majesty]. [09:56:25] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Liliana, Death's Majesty] ( Create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token. Mill two cards.). [09:56:26] Cheiffireball's [Liliana, Death's Majesty] creates a Zombie Token. [09:56:26] Cheiffireball mills [Frantic Search] and [Mana Leak]. [09:56:30] Turn 6: tidalslimshady [09:56:31] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [09:56:33] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:56:33] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, you may cast it w...). [09:56:36] tidalslimshady casts [Search for Tomorrow]. [09:56:57] tidalslimshady casts [Recross the Paths]. [09:57:01] tidalslimshady reveals 41 cards with [Recross the Paths]: [Thragtusk], [Thragtusk], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Nature's Lore], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Search for Tomorrow], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Recross the Paths], [09:57:02] [Chancellor of the Tangle], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Caravan Vigil], [Rampant Growth], [Dig Up], [Caravan Vigil], [Rampant Growth], [Nature's Lore], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Nature's Lore], [09:57:02] [Sylvan Caryatid], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Thragtusk], [Recross the Paths], [Ground Seal], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Rampant Growth], [Cleanup Crew], [Cleanup Crew], [Analyze the Pollen], [09:57:03] [Dig Up], [Recross the Paths], [Thragtusk], [Search for Tomorrow], [Dig Up], [Chancellor of the Tangle], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Analyze the Pollen], [Chancellor of the Tangle], and [09:57:03] [Chancellor of the Tangle]. [09:57:50] tidalslimshady reveals [Chancellor of the Tangle]. [09:57:51] Cheiffireball reveals [Island]. [09:57:51] tidalslimshady wins the clash. [09:57:53] tidalslimshady puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [09:58:08] Cheiffireball puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [09:58:10] tidalslimshady casts [Ground Seal]. [09:58:12] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Ground Seal] onto the stack (When Ground Seal enters, draw a card.). [09:58:14] tidalslimshady draws a card with [Ground Seal]'s ability. [09:58:15] tidalslimshady casts [Ground Seal]. [09:58:17] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Ground Seal] onto the stack (When Ground Seal enters, draw a card.). [09:58:18] tidalslimshady draws a card with [Ground Seal]'s ability. [09:58:21] Turn 6: Cheiffireball [09:58:27] Cheiffireball plays [Thran Portal]. [09:58:29] Cheiffireball chooses Plains for [Thran Portal]. [09:58:31] Cheiffireball puts a loyalty counter on [Liliana, Death's Majesty]. [09:58:32] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Liliana, Death's Majesty] ( Create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token. Mill two cards.). [09:58:32] Cheiffireball's [Liliana, Death's Majesty] creates a Zombie Token. [09:58:32] Cheiffireball mills [Glacial Fortress] and [Drowned Catacomb]. [09:58:35] Turn 7: tidalslimshady [09:58:39] tidalslimshady casts [Goblin Charbelcher]. [09:58:44] Cheiffireball casts [Sauron's Ransom]. [09:58:45] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sauron's Ransom[sU] has an advantageous bug. Sauron's Ransom shows whether face down cards are white-bordered Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Sauron's Ransom` or `!notbugged Sauron's Ransom` [09:59:25] Cheiffireball is tempted by the Ring. [Zombie Token] becomes their Ring-bearer. [09:59:27] Cheiffireball has conceded from the game. [09:59:28] tidalslimshady wins the game. Winner: tidalslimshady Game 2 Completed. [09:59:31] Cheiffireball has left the game. == Game 3 (888113696) == [Time] 1723507238 [10:00:39] PDBot has started watching. [10:00:44] Cheiffireball chooses to play first. [10:00:52] Cheiffireball begins the game with seven cards in hand. [10:00:54] tidalslimshady begins the game with seven cards in hand. [10:00:54] Turn 1: Cheiffireball [10:01:04] Cheiffireball skips their draw step. [10:01:24] Cheiffireball plays [Island]. [10:01:26] Turn 1: tidalslimshady [10:01:29] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [10:01:30] tidalslimshady casts [Traverse the Ulvenwald]. [10:01:33] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest]. [10:01:36] Turn 2: Cheiffireball [10:01:41] Cheiffireball plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [10:01:42] Turn 2: tidalslimshady [10:01:47] tidalslimshady plays [Forest]. [10:01:48] tidalslimshady casts [Nature's Lore]. [10:01:55] Cheiffireball casts [Phantom Interference] targeting [Nature's Lore]. [10:01:55] Chosen mode: {1} Counter target spell unless its controller pays {2}. [10:02:01] Turn 3: Cheiffireball [10:02:06] Cheiffireball plays [Swamp]. [10:02:08] Turn 3: tidalslimshady [10:02:20] tidalslimshady casts [Nature's Lore]. [10:02:21] tidalslimshady exiles [Search for Tomorrow] with 2 time counters. [10:02:21] tidalslimshady puts two time counters on [Search for Tomorrow]. [10:02:23] Cheiffireball casts [Tainted Indulgence]. [10:02:24] Cheiffireball draws two cards with [Tainted Indulgence]. [10:02:25] Cheiffireball discards [Repeal]. [10:02:26] Turn 4: Cheiffireball [10:02:34] Cheiffireball plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [10:02:36] Turn 4: tidalslimshady [10:02:36] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [10:02:39] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [10:02:52] tidalslimshady casts [Rampant Growth]. [10:03:07] Turn 5: Cheiffireball [10:03:11] Cheiffireball plays [Caves of Koilos]. [10:03:15] Turn 5: tidalslimshady [10:03:15] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [10:03:19] tidalslimshady removes a time counter from [Search for Tomorrow]. [10:03:19] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Search for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 2{G} (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, you may cast it w...). [10:03:53] tidalslimshady casts [Search for Tomorrow]. [10:04:02] tidalslimshady casts [Recross the Paths]. [10:04:05] tidalslimshady reveals [Forest] with [Recross the Paths]. [10:04:05] tidalslimshady reveals [Ground Seal]. [10:04:05] Cheiffireball reveals [Sunken Hollow]. [10:04:05] tidalslimshady wins the clash. [10:04:12] tidalslimshady puts 1 card on top of their library. [10:04:15] Cheiffireball puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [10:04:17] tidalslimshady casts [Ground Seal]. [10:04:20] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Ground Seal] onto the stack (When Ground Seal enters, draw a card.). [10:04:22] tidalslimshady draws a card with [Ground Seal]'s ability. [10:04:30] Cheiffireball casts [Dig Through Time]. [10:04:37] Turn 6: Cheiffireball [10:04:44] Cheiffireball plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [10:04:52] Turn 6: tidalslimshady [10:04:55] tidalslimshady casts [Recross the Paths]. [10:05:05] tidalslimshady reveals 38 cards with [Recross the Paths]: [Search for Tomorrow], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Dig Up], [Analyze the Pollen], [Recross the Paths], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Dig Up], [Sylvan Caryatid], [10:05:06] [Thragtusk], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Rampant Growth], [Analyze the Pollen], [Cleanup Crew], [Caravan Vigil], [Thragtusk], [Search for Tomorrow], [Chancellor of the Tangle], [Caravan Vigil], [10:05:06] [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Dig Up], [Traverse the Ulvenwald], [Caravan Vigil], [Cleanup Crew], [Nature's Lore], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Fanatic of Rhonas], [Rampant Growth], [Analyze the Pollen], [10:05:07] [Search for Tomorrow], [Recross the Paths], [Nature's Lore], [Ground Seal], [Analyze the Pollen], [Thragtusk], [Chancellor of the Tangle], and [Forest]. [10:05:31] tidalslimshady reveals [Chancellor of the Tangle]. [10:05:31] Cheiffireball reveals [Sauron's Ransom]. [10:05:32] tidalslimshady wins the clash. [10:05:41] tidalslimshady puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [10:05:58] Cheiffireball puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [10:06:03] tidalslimshady casts [Ground Seal]. [10:06:04] tidalslimshady puts triggered ability from [Ground Seal] onto the stack (When Ground Seal enters, draw a card.). [10:06:06] tidalslimshady draws a card with [Ground Seal]'s ability. [10:06:08] tidalslimshady casts [Fanatic of Rhonas]. [10:06:19] Cheiffireball casts [Sauron's Ransom]. [10:06:22] Cheiffireball is tempted by the Ring. [10:06:27] Cheiffireball casts [Sauron's Ransom]. [10:06:41] Cheiffireball is tempted by the Ring for the second time. [10:06:45] Turn 7: Cheiffireball [10:06:51] Cheiffireball casts [Duress] targeting tidalslimshady. [10:06:52] tidalslimshady reveals 6 cards with [Duress]: [Rampant Growth], [Recross the Paths], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Recross the Paths], and [Thragtusk]. [10:06:54] tidalslimshady discards [Goblin Charbelcher]. [10:07:02] Cheiffireball plays [Sunken Hollow]. [10:07:05] Cheiffireball casts [Duress] targeting tidalslimshady. [10:07:11] tidalslimshady reveals 5 cards with [Duress]: [Rampant Growth], [Recross the Paths], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Recross the Paths], and [Thragtusk]. [10:07:19] tidalslimshady discards [Recross the Paths]. [10:07:26] Cheiffireball casts [Duress] targeting tidalslimshady. [10:07:27] tidalslimshady reveals 4 cards with [Duress]: [Rampant Growth], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Recross the Paths], and [Thragtusk]. [10:07:31] tidalslimshady discards [Recross the Paths]. [10:07:48] Cheiffireball discards [Thran Portal]. [10:07:49] Turn 7: tidalslimshady [10:07:58] tidalslimshady casts [Thragtusk]. [10:08:12] Cheiffireball discards [Repeal]. [10:08:12] Cheiffireball discards [Island]. [10:08:13] Cheiffireball casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Thragtusk]. [10:08:17] tidalslimshady casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [10:08:22] Turn 8: Cheiffireball [10:08:36] Cheiffireball plays [Glacial Fortress]. [10:08:40] Cheiffireball casts [Duress] targeting tidalslimshady. [10:08:40] tidalslimshady reveals 2 cards with [Duress]: [Chancellor of the Tangle] and [Rampant Growth]. [10:08:42] tidalslimshady discards [Rampant Growth]. [10:08:45] Turn 8: tidalslimshady [10:08:59] tidalslimshady casts [Chancellor of the Tangle]. [10:09:03] Cheiffireball casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Chancellor of the Tangle]. [10:09:15] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Fanatic of Rhonas] [10:09:24] Cheiffireball casts [Gifts Ungiven] targeting tidalslimshady. [10:09:35] Cheiffireball reveals [Swamp]. [10:09:35] Cheiffireball reveals [Island]. [10:09:35] Cheiffireball reveals [Sunken Hollow]. [10:09:35] Cheiffireball reveals [Glacial Fortress]. [10:09:40] tidalslimshady chooses Island and Glacial Fortress. [10:09:42] Turn 9: Cheiffireball [10:09:46] Cheiffireball plays [Sunken Hollow]. [10:09:50] Cheiffireball casts [Void Winnower]. [10:09:58] Turn 9: tidalslimshady [10:10:20] Turn 10: Cheiffireball [10:10:26] tidalslimshady is being attacked by [Void Winnower] [10:10:29] Turn 10: tidalslimshady [10:10:33] tidalslimshady has conceded from the game. [10:10:33] Cheiffireball wins the game. Winner: Cheiffireball Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Cheiffireball: 2–1