PennyDreadful
PD 500 R1 vs WaffleRoffler
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
tutuu97,WaffleRoffler

== Game 1 (887158886) ==
[Time] 1722706975
[03:42:56] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=The Penny Dreadful 500 (Season 33)
[Gatherling] Round=1
[03:43:06] tutuu97 chooses to play first.
[03:43:08] [CHAT] tutuu97: glhf
[03:43:25] tutuu97 mulligans to six cards.
[03:43:33] Sacritor has started watching.
[03:43:34] MTGfan1996 has started watching.
[03:43:35] WaffleRoffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:43:37] tutuu97 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[03:43:37] Turn 1: tutuu97
[03:43:38] tutuu97 skips their draw step.
[03:43:39] tutuu97 plays [Isolated Chapel].
[03:43:57] Turn 1: WaffleRoffler
[03:43:58] WaffleRoffler plays [Plains].
[03:44:01] Turn 2: tutuu97
[03:44:06] tutuu97 plays [Isolated Chapel].
[03:44:14] Turn 2: WaffleRoffler
[03:44:18] WaffleRoffler plays [Swamp].
[03:44:30] WaffleRoffler casts [Tithing Blade].
[03:44:31] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Tithing Blade] onto the stack (When Tithing Blade enters, each opponent sacrifices a creature.).
[03:44:45] Turn 3: tutuu97
[03:44:47] tutuu97 plays [Swamp].
[03:44:51] tutuu97 casts [Deep-Cavern Bat].
[03:45:06] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting WaffleRoffler (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonland card from it ...).
[03:45:18] MTGfan1996 has stopped watching.
[03:45:32] Turn 3: WaffleRoffler
[03:45:38] WaffleRoffler plays [Swamp].
[03:45:44] WaffleRoffler casts [Guardian of Ghirapur].
[03:45:55] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Guardian of Ghirapur] onto the stack targeting [Tithing Blade] (When Guardian of Ghirapur enters, exile up to one other target creature or artifact you control. R...).
[03:46:06] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Guardian of Ghirapur] onto the stack (Return Tithing Blade to the battlefield under Tithing Blade owner's control at the beginning of th...).
[03:46:19] Coupoutous has started watching.
[03:46:26] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Tithing Blade] onto the stack (When Tithing Blade enters, each opponent sacrifices a creature.).
[03:46:26] theshadowmaker has started watching.
[03:46:31] Turn 4: tutuu97
[03:46:45] tutuu97 casts [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:46:56] theshadowmaker has stopped watching.
[03:47:00] glendaloc has started watching.
[03:47:01] Coupoutous has stopped watching.
[03:47:14] tutuu97 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[03:47:29] Turn 4: WaffleRoffler
[03:47:35] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[03:47:39] tutuu97 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:47:45] WaffleRoffler plays [Swamp].
[03:48:03] WaffleRoffler casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[03:48:15] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] targeting [Guardian of Ghirapur] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[03:48:46] Turn 5: tutuu97
[03:49:14] tutuu97 casts [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:49:30] WaffleRoffler's [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] is being attacked by [Benevolent Bodyguard]
[03:49:37] tutuu97 removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[03:49:40] Turn 5: WaffleRoffler
[03:49:40] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Guardian of Ghirapur to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your ...).
[03:49:40] Akamatsu has started watching.
[03:49:49] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Guardian of Ghirapur] onto the stack targeting [Tithing Blade] (When Guardian of Ghirapur enters, exile up to one other target creature or artifact you control. R...).
[03:50:14] WaffleRoffler plays [Plains].
[03:50:21] WaffleRoffler casts [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord].
[03:50:28] WaffleRoffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[03:50:29] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[03:50:40] WaffleRoffler puts two loyalty counters on [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord].
[03:50:40] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord] targeting tutuu97 ( Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[03:50:51] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[03:50:53] tutuu97 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:50:59] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[03:51:01] tutuu97 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:51:11] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Guardian of Ghirapur] onto the stack (Return Tithing Blade to the battlefield under Tithing Blade owner's control at the beginning of th...).
[03:51:16] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Tithing Blade] onto the stack (When Tithing Blade enters, each opponent sacrifices a creature.).
[03:51:20] Turn 6: tutuu97
[03:51:33] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[03:51:34] tutuu97 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:51:38] tutuu97 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[03:51:53] Turn 6: WaffleRoffler
[03:52:13] WaffleRoffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:53:07] tutuu97 is being attacked by [Guardian of Ghirapur]
[03:53:26] WaffleRoffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[03:53:26] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[03:53:34] WaffleRoffler puts two loyalty counters on [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord].
[03:53:34] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord] targeting tutuu97 ( Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[03:53:45] Turn 7: tutuu97
[03:53:53] tutuu97 casts [Greasefang, Okiba Boss].
[03:54:03] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] on the stack.
[03:54:11] WaffleRoffler's [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] is being attacked by [Benevolent Bodyguard]
[03:54:30] tutuu97 removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[03:54:38] Turn 7: WaffleRoffler
[03:55:07] WaffleRoffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Swamp].
[03:55:08] glendaloc has stopped watching.
[03:55:29] WaffleRoffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[03:55:29] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[03:55:42] WaffleRoffler puts two loyalty counters on [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord].
[03:55:43] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord] targeting tutuu97 ( Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[03:56:03] WaffleRoffler casts [Novice Inspector].
[03:56:05] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Novice Inspector] onto the stack (When Novice Inspector enters, investigate.).
[03:56:11] WaffleRoffler investigates.
[03:56:11] WaffleRoffler's [Novice Inspector] creates a Clue Token.
[03:56:30] tutuu97 is being attacked by [Guardian of Ghirapur]
[03:57:02] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[03:57:04] tutuu97 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[03:57:12] Turn 8: tutuu97
[03:57:18] [CHAT] WaffleRoffler: lol dude i accidentLLY GOT RID OF ONE OF MY MANA ON ACCIDENT 
[03:57:23] tutuu97 casts [Lively Dirge].
[03:57:23] Chosen mode: {1}  Search your library for a card, put it into your graveyard, then shuffle.
[03:57:24] [CHAT] WaffleRoffler: fml 
[03:57:37] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] onto the stack targeting [Parhelion II] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, return target Vehicle card from your graveyard to the bat...).
[03:57:49] [CHAT] tutuu97: haha oops, sorry xd
[03:58:00] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Parhelion II] (Crew 4).
[03:58:14] WaffleRoffler's [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord] is being attacked by [Parhelion II]
[03:58:15] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Parhelion II] onto the stack (Whenever Parhelion II attacks, create two 4/4 white Angel creature tokens with flying and vigilanc...).
[03:58:22] tutuu97's [Parhelion II] creates two Angel Tokens.
[03:58:29] tutuu97 puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord]
[03:58:36] tutuu97 puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord]
[03:58:48] tutuu97 removes five loyalty counters from [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord].
[03:58:58] tutuu97 removes five loyalty counters from [Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord].
[03:59:02] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] onto the stack (Return Parhelion II to Parhelion II owner's hand at the beginning of your next end step.).
[03:59:14] tutuu97 returns [Parhelion II] to its owner's hand with [Greasefang, Okiba Boss]'s ability.
[03:59:18] Turn 8: WaffleRoffler
[03:59:27] WaffleRoffler casts [Elite Spellbinder].
[03:59:35] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Elite Spellbinder] onto the stack targeting tutuu97 (When Elite Spellbinder enters, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonland card from i...).
[04:00:29] WaffleRoffler casts [Novice Inspector].
[04:00:32] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Novice Inspector] onto the stack (When Novice Inspector enters, investigate.).
[04:00:39] WaffleRoffler investigates.
[04:00:39] WaffleRoffler's [Novice Inspector] creates a Clue Token.
[04:01:06] Turn 9: tutuu97
[04:01:16] tutuu97 casts [Deep-Cavern Bat].
[04:01:18] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting WaffleRoffler (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonland card from it ...).
[04:01:30] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] on the stack.
[04:01:50] WaffleRoffler is being attacked by [Angel Token], [Angel Token], and [Greasefang, Okiba Boss]
[04:01:59] [Novice Inspector] blocks [Greasefang, Okiba Boss].
[04:02:15] Turn 9: WaffleRoffler
[04:02:28] WaffleRoffler casts [Nurturing Pixie].
[04:02:56] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Nurturing Pixie] onto the stack targeting [Guardian of Ghirapur] (When Nurturing Pixie enters, return up to one target non-Faerie, nonland permanent you control to ...).
[04:03:07] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Destroy each nonland permanent with mana value equal to the number of charge counters on Ratchet ...).
[04:03:14] WaffleRoffler's Triggered ability from Nurturing Pixie is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[04:03:38] Turn 10: tutuu97
[04:03:43] tutuu97 plays [Plains].
[04:03:50] tutuu97 casts [Greasefang, Okiba Boss].
[04:03:55] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] on the stack.
[04:04:09] WaffleRoffler is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Angel Token], and [Angel Token]
[04:04:16] [Nurturing Pixie] blocks [Deep-Cavern Bat].
[04:04:20] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Benevolent Bodyguard] targeting [Deep-Cavern Bat] ( Target creature you control gains protection from the color of your choice until end of turn.).
[04:04:36] Turn 10: WaffleRoffler
[04:04:50] WaffleRoffler casts [Tenacious Underdog].
[04:04:55] DGF has started watching.
[04:05:17] Turn 11: tutuu97
[04:05:29] tutuu97 casts [Deep-Cavern Bat].
[04:05:36] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting WaffleRoffler (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonland card from it ...).
[04:05:40] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] on the stack.
[04:05:48] DGF has stopped watching.
[04:05:55] WaffleRoffler is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Angel Token], and [Angel Token]
[04:06:09] Turn 11: WaffleRoffler
[04:06:14] WaffleRoffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:06:53] WaffleRoffler exiles [Tithing Blade] with [Tithing Blade]'s ability.
[04:06:53] WaffleRoffler exiles [Nurturing Pixie] with with [Tithing Blade]'s ability.
[04:06:53] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Tithing Blade] (Craft with creature {4B}).
[04:06:57] [Tithing Blade] transforms into [Consuming Sepulcher].
[04:07:06] Turn 12: tutuu97
[04:07:10] tutuu97 plays [Caves of Koilos].
[04:07:13] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] on the stack.
[04:07:25] Akamatsu has stopped watching.
[04:07:31] WaffleRoffler is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Angel Token], and [Angel Token]
[04:07:34] [CHAT] WaffleRoffler: gg lol
[04:07:46] [CHAT] tutuu97: gg, maybe u win g2 and 3 :P
[04:07:52] tutuu97 wins the game.
Winner: tutuu97
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (887161292) ==
[Time] 1722708646
[04:10:46] PDBot has started watching.
[04:10:49] WaffleRoffler chooses to play first.
[04:10:54] DL23 has started watching.
[04:11:10] WaffleRoffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:11:19] tutuu97 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:11:19] Turn 1: WaffleRoffler
[04:11:19] WaffleRoffler skips their draw step.
[04:11:22] WaffleRoffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:11:28] DL23 has stopped watching.
[04:11:35] Turn 1: tutuu97
[04:11:38] tutuu97 plays [Plains].
[04:11:44] Turn 2: WaffleRoffler
[04:11:52] WaffleRoffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:11:56] Turn 2: tutuu97
[04:12:09] tutuu97 plays [Caves of Koilos].
[04:12:13] SeismicSandwich has started watching.
[04:12:28] Turn 3: WaffleRoffler
[04:12:34] WaffleRoffler plays [Plains].
[04:12:58] WaffleRoffler casts [Novice Inspector].
[04:13:01] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Novice Inspector] onto the stack (When Novice Inspector enters, investigate.).
[04:13:08] WaffleRoffler investigates.
[04:13:08] WaffleRoffler's [Novice Inspector] creates a Clue Token.
[04:13:20] WaffleRoffler casts [Fanatical Offering].
[04:13:20] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Fanatical Offering[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Exploring with empty library does not put a +1/+1 counter on a creature
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Fanatical Offering` or `!notbugged Fanatical Offering`
[04:13:27] Coupoutous has stopped watching.
[04:13:27] WaffleRoffler draws two cards with [Fanatical Offering].
[04:13:28] WaffleRoffler's [Fanatical Offering] creates a Map Token.
[04:13:46] Turn 3: tutuu97
[04:13:52] tutuu97 plays [Plains].
[04:14:08] tutuu97 casts [Lively Dirge].
[04:14:08] Chosen mode: {1}  Search your library for a card, put it into your graveyard, then shuffle.
[04:14:25] Turn 4: WaffleRoffler
[04:14:31] WaffleRoffler plays [Swamp].
[04:14:45] WaffleRoffler casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:14:50] WaffleRoffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:14:51] WaffleRoffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[04:15:02] Turn 4: tutuu97
[04:15:06] tutuu97 plays [Swamp].
[04:15:14] tutuu97 casts [Greasefang, Okiba Boss].
[04:15:26] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] onto the stack targeting [Parhelion II] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, return target Vehicle card from your graveyard to the bat...).
[04:15:35] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Parhelion II] (Crew 4).
[04:15:48] WaffleRoffler is being attacked by [Parhelion II]
[04:15:49] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Parhelion II] onto the stack (Whenever Parhelion II attacks, create two 4/4 white Angel creature tokens with flying and vigilanc...).
[04:15:57] tutuu97's [Parhelion II] creates two Angel Tokens.
[04:15:59] tutuu97 puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]
[04:16:04] tutuu97 puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking WaffleRoffler
[04:16:15] tutuu97 removes four loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:16:16] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] onto the stack (Return Parhelion II to Parhelion II owner's hand at the beginning of your next end step.).
[04:16:22] tutuu97 returns [Parhelion II] to its owner's hand with [Greasefang, Okiba Boss]'s ability.
[04:16:26] Turn 5: WaffleRoffler
[04:16:30] WaffleRoffler plays [Plains].
[04:16:59] WaffleRoffler casts [Tithing Blade].
[04:17:02] WaffleRoffler puts triggered ability from [Tithing Blade] onto the stack (When Tithing Blade enters, each opponent sacrifices a creature.).
[04:17:18] WaffleRoffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Shambling Vent].
[04:17:22] FredHawk has started watching.
[04:17:26] [CHAT] tutuu97: you did it again lol
[04:17:32] [CHAT] WaffleRoffler: dammit
[04:17:43] [CHAT] SeismicSandwich: lmao
[04:17:45] [CHAT] SeismicSandwich: lol
[04:17:56] Akamatsu has started watching.
[04:17:57] souzaleo_90 has started watching.
[04:18:03] [CHAT] WaffleRoffler: lol honestly i probably deserve it at this point
[04:18:15] Turn 5: tutuu97
[04:18:21] tutuu97 plays [Swamp].
[04:18:44] SeismicSandwich has stopped watching.
[04:18:50] tutuu97 discards [Parhelion II].
[04:18:50] tutuu97 casts [Bitter Triumph] targeting [Angel Token].
[04:18:55] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Greasefang, Okiba Boss] onto the stack targeting [Parhelion II] (At the beginning of combat on your turn, return target Vehicle card from your graveyard to the bat...).
[04:18:56] wizzerinus has started watching.
[04:19:03] tutuu97 activates an ability of [Parhelion II] (Crew 4).
[04:19:10] WaffleRoffler is being attacked by [Parhelion II]
[04:19:10] tutuu97 puts triggered ability from [Parhelion II] onto the stack (Whenever Parhelion II attacks, create two 4/4 white Angel creature tokens with flying and vigilanc...).
[04:19:15] [CHAT] tutuu97: gg!
[04:19:18] [CHAT] WaffleRoffler: gg my friend
[04:19:21] tutuu97's [Parhelion II] creates two Angel Tokens.
[04:19:21] tutuu97 puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking WaffleRoffler
[04:19:21] tutuu97 puts tutuu97 onto the battlefield attacking WaffleRoffler
[04:19:29] tutuu97 wins the game.
Winner: tutuu97
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: tutuu97: 2–0