Freeform premodern Challenge CAUSTEK BuggedCardObserver,Tourney Caustek,derflotteschotte87 == Game 1 (886436234) == [Time] 1722102188 [03:43:09] PDBot has started watching. [Gatherling] Event=July 2024 Premodern Monthly Challenge [Gatherling] Round=5 [03:43:15] Caustek chooses to play first. [03:43:20] Caustek mulligans to six cards. [03:43:23] [CHAT] derflotteschotte87: glhf [03:43:27] derflotteschotte87 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [03:43:29] [CHAT] Caustek: hey there! you too thank you! [03:43:38] Caustek puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [03:43:38] Turn 1: Caustek [03:43:43] Caustek skips their draw step. [03:43:44] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [03:43:45] Caustek casts [Festering Goblin]. [03:43:47] Turn 1: derflotteschotte87 [03:43:52] derflotteschotte87 plays [Plains]. [03:43:59] Turn 2: Caustek [03:44:09] derflotteschotte87 is being attacked by [Festering Goblin] [03:44:16] Caustek plays [Mishra's Factory]. [03:44:17] Caustek casts [Jet Medallion]. [03:44:32] derflotteschotte87 casts [Swords to Plowshares] targeting [Festering Goblin]. [03:44:34] Turn 2: derflotteschotte87 [03:44:37] derflotteschotte87 plays [Flooded Strand]. [03:44:40] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Flooded Strand] ( Search your library for a Plains or Island card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.). [03:44:51] derflotteschotte87 casts [Meddling Mage]. [03:44:58] derflotteschotte87 names Smother for [Meddling Mage]. [03:45:00] Turn 3: Caustek [03:45:07] Caustek plays [Mishra's Factory]. [03:45:10] Caustek casts [Cabal Therapy] targeting derflotteschotte87. [03:45:16] Caustek names Disenchant for [Cabal Therapy]. [03:45:16] derflotteschotte87 reveals their hand to [Cabal Therapy], containing [Gemstone Mine], [Swords to Plowshares], [Ice], [Fire], [Fire/Ice], [Lightning Bolt], and [Plains]. [03:45:32] Turn 3: derflotteschotte87 [03:45:43] derflotteschotte87 plays [Gemstone Mine]. [03:45:49] Turn 4: Caustek [03:45:54] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [03:47:13] Turn 4: derflotteschotte87 [03:47:17] derflotteschotte87 plays [Plains]. [03:47:26] Caustek is being attacked by [Meddling Mage] [03:47:35] Turn 5: Caustek [03:47:48] Caustek casts [Priest of Gix]. [03:47:51] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [03:48:06] Caustek casts [Cabal Therapy] from the graveyard targeting derflotteschotte87. [03:48:20] Caustek names Swords to Plowshares for [Cabal Therapy]. [03:48:20] derflotteschotte87 reveals their hand to [Cabal Therapy], containing [Enlightened Tutor], [Swords to Plowshares], [Ice], [Fire], [Fire/Ice], [Lightning Bolt], and [Plains]. [03:48:37] derflotteschotte87 discards [Swords to Plowshares]. [03:48:43] Caustek casts [Bone Shredder]. [03:48:46] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Bone Shredder] onto the stack targeting [Meddling Mage] (When Bone Shredder enters, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature.). [03:48:58] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:49:07] derflotteschotte87 removes a mining counter from [Gemstone Mine]. [03:49:19] derflotteschotte87 casts [Fire] targeting [Bone Shredder] for 1, and Caustek for 1. [03:49:28] Turn 5: derflotteschotte87 [03:49:31] derflotteschotte87 plays [Plains]. [03:49:34] derflotteschotte87 casts [Silver Knight]. [03:49:38] Turn 6: Caustek [03:49:47] Caustek activates an ability of [Mishra's Factory] ( Mishra's Factory becomes a 2/2 Assembly-Worker artifact creature until end of turn. It's still a ...). [03:49:58] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Bone Shredder] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:50:04] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Bone Shredder] onto the stack targeting [Silver Knight] (When Bone Shredder enters, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature.). [03:50:10] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [03:50:14] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:50:24] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Priest of Gix] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:50:27] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [03:50:55] derflotteschotte87 casts [Enlightened Tutor]. [03:51:00] derflotteschotte87 reveals [Cursed Scroll]. [03:51:02] Turn 6: derflotteschotte87 [03:51:05] derflotteschotte87 casts [Cursed Scroll]. [03:51:13] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Cursed Scroll] targeting [Priest of Gix] ( Choose a card name, then reveal a card at random from your hand. If that card has the chosen name...). [03:51:31] derflotteschotte87 names Lightning Bolt for Cursed Scroll. [03:51:31] derflotteschotte87 reveals [Lightning Bolt] at random. [03:51:35] Turn 7: Caustek [03:51:47] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:51:50] Turn 7: derflotteschotte87 [03:51:54] derflotteschotte87 casts [Savannah Lions]. [03:51:58] Turn 8: Caustek [03:52:10] Caustek casts [Rotlung Reanimator]. [03:52:31] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Priest of Gix] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:52:31] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Rotlung Reanimator] onto the stack (Whenever Rotlung Reanimator or another Cleric dies, create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.). [03:52:42] Caustek's [Rotlung Reanimator] creates a Zombie Token. [03:52:47] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [03:53:03] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Cursed Scroll] targeting [Priest of Gix] ( Choose a card name, then reveal a card at random from your hand. If that card has the chosen name...). [03:53:17] derflotteschotte87 names Lightning Bolt for Cursed Scroll. [03:53:17] derflotteschotte87 reveals [Lightning Bolt] at random. [03:53:29] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:53:33] derflotteschotte87 removes a mining counter from [Gemstone Mine]. [03:53:35] derflotteschotte87 casts [Lightning Bolt] targeting [Zombie Token]. [03:53:43] Caustek activates an ability of [Mishra's Factory] ( Mishra's Factory becomes a 2/2 Assembly-Worker artifact creature until end of turn. It's still a ...). [03:53:59] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Priest of Gix] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:54:00] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [03:54:05] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:54:11] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Bone Shredder] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:54:11] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Bone Shredder] onto the stack targeting [Savannah Lions] (When Bone Shredder enters, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature.). [03:54:14] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:54:20] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Priest of Gix] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:54:20] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [03:54:25] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:54:29] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Rotlung Reanimator] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:54:32] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:54:35] Caustek activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Priest of Gix] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [03:54:35] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Rotlung Reanimator] onto the stack (Whenever Rotlung Reanimator or another Cleric dies, create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.). [03:54:38] Caustek's [Rotlung Reanimator] creates a Zombie Token. [03:54:40] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [03:54:43] Caustek casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [03:54:46] derflotteschotte87 has conceded from the game. [03:54:46] Caustek wins the game. Winner: Caustek Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (886437338) == [Time] 1722102979 [03:56:19] PDBot has started watching. [03:56:21] derflotteschotte87 chooses to play first. [03:56:26] derflotteschotte87 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [03:56:28] Caustek begins the game with seven cards in hand. [03:56:28] Turn 1: derflotteschotte87 [03:56:29] derflotteschotte87 skips their draw step. [03:56:30] derflotteschotte87 plays [Plains]. [03:56:32] Turn 1: Caustek [03:56:37] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [03:56:39] Caustek casts [Carrion Feeder]. [03:56:41] Turn 2: derflotteschotte87 [03:57:03] derflotteschotte87 casts [Mox Diamond]. [03:57:05] derflotteschotte87 discards [City of Brass]. [03:57:05] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]City of Brass[sU] has an unclassified bug. Drain Power does not function correctly when the targeted player controls City of Brass. Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged City of Brass` or `!notbugged City of Brass` [03:57:08] derflotteschotte87 plays [Flooded Strand]. [03:57:11] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Flooded Strand] ( Search your library for a Plains or Island card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.). [03:57:19] derflotteschotte87 casts [Engineered Plague]. [03:57:24] derflotteschotte87 chooses Zombie for [Engineered Plague]. [03:57:27] Turn 2: Caustek [03:57:38] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [03:57:39] Turn 3: derflotteschotte87 [03:57:52] derflotteschotte87 casts [Winter Orb]. [03:57:56] Turn 3: Caustek [03:58:11] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [03:58:21] Caustek casts [Cabal Therapy] targeting derflotteschotte87. [03:58:30] Caustek names Disenchant for [Cabal Therapy]. [03:58:30] derflotteschotte87 reveals their hand to [Cabal Therapy], containing [Mox Diamond], [Swords to Plowshares], and [Wasteland]. [03:58:39] Turn 4: derflotteschotte87 [03:58:44] derflotteschotte87 casts [Mox Diamond]. [03:58:46] derflotteschotte87 discards [Plains]. [03:58:49] Turn 4: Caustek [03:59:39] Caustek casts [Mesmeric Fiend]. [03:59:46] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting derflotteschotte87 (When Mesmeric Fiend enters, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a nonland card from ...). [03:59:52] derflotteschotte87 casts [Swords to Plowshares] targeting [Mesmeric Fiend]. [03:59:53] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack (When Mesmeric Fiend leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.). [03:59:59] derflotteschotte87 reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Wasteland]. [04:00:03] Turn 5: derflotteschotte87 [04:00:07] derflotteschotte87 casts [Savannah Lions]. [04:00:11] Turn 5: Caustek [04:00:19] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:00:34] Caustek casts [Priest of Gix]. [04:00:34] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [04:00:40] Caustek casts [Rotlung Reanimator]. [04:00:44] Turn 6: derflotteschotte87 [04:00:49] derflotteschotte87 plays [Wasteland]. [04:00:55] derflotteschotte87 casts [Meddling Mage]. [04:01:13] derflotteschotte87 names Recurring Nightmare for [Meddling Mage]. [04:01:18] Turn 6: Caustek [04:01:34] Turn 7: derflotteschotte87 [04:01:38] derflotteschotte87 plays [Plains]. [04:01:41] Turn 7: Caustek [04:02:00] Turn 8: derflotteschotte87 [04:02:13] Turn 8: Caustek [04:02:59] Turn 9: derflotteschotte87 [04:03:04] derflotteschotte87 plays [Island]. [04:03:25] Turn 9: Caustek [04:04:46] Caustek casts [Diabolic Intent]. [04:04:46] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Rotlung Reanimator] onto the stack (Whenever Rotlung Reanimator or another Cleric dies, create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.). [04:04:48] Caustek's [Rotlung Reanimator] creates a Zombie Token. [04:04:55] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:04:57] Caustek casts [Jet Medallion]. [04:05:02] Turn 10: derflotteschotte87 [04:05:07] derflotteschotte87 casts [Silver Knight]. [04:05:15] Turn 10: Caustek [04:05:27] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:05:38] Caustek casts [Phyrexian Rager]. [04:05:40] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Rager] onto the stack (When Phyrexian Rager enters, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.). [04:05:43] Caustek draws a card with [Phyrexian Rager]'s ability. [04:05:56] Turn 11: derflotteschotte87 [04:06:08] derflotteschotte87 casts [Seal of Cleansing]. [04:06:11] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Seal of Cleansing] targeting [Jet Medallion] ( Destroy target artifact or enchantment.). [04:06:15] Caustek is being attacked by [Silver Knight] [04:06:24] Turn 11: Caustek [04:06:32] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:06:38] Turn 12: derflotteschotte87 [04:07:02] derflotteschotte87 casts [Meddling Mage]. [04:07:10] derflotteschotte87 names Rotlung Reanimator for [Meddling Mage]. [04:07:14] Caustek is being attacked by [Silver Knight] [04:07:17] Turn 12: Caustek [04:07:27] Caustek plays derflotteschotte87. [04:07:38] Turn 13: derflotteschotte87 [04:07:47] derflotteschotte87 casts [Soltari Priest]. [04:07:51] Caustek is being attacked by [Silver Knight] [04:08:01] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Wasteland] targeting derflotteschotte87 ( Destroy target nonbasic land.). [04:08:04] Turn 13: Caustek [04:08:17] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:08:31] Turn 14: derflotteschotte87 [04:08:38] Caustek is being attacked by [Soltari Priest] and [Silver Knight] [04:08:47] derflotteschotte87 casts [Savannah Lions]. [04:08:49] Turn 14: Caustek [04:08:57] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:09:04] Caustek casts [Highway Robber]. [04:09:05] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Highway Robber] onto the stack targeting derflotteschotte87 (When Highway Robber enters, target opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.). [04:09:09] Turn 15: derflotteschotte87 [04:09:18] Caustek is being attacked by [Soltari Priest] and [Silver Knight] [04:09:22] [Phyrexian Rager] blocks [Silver Knight]. [04:09:23] [Zombie Token] blocks [Silver Knight]. [04:09:35] Blockers for [Silver Knight] are ordered as follows: [Zombie Token], [Phyrexian Rager] [04:09:59] Turn 15: Caustek [04:10:07] Turn 16: derflotteschotte87 [04:10:25] Caustek is being attacked by [Savannah Lions], [Soltari Priest], and [Savannah Lions] [04:10:31] derflotteschotte87 casts [Swords to Plowshares] targeting [Rotlung Reanimator]. [04:10:44] Turn 16: Caustek [04:10:55] Caustek has conceded from the game. [04:10:55] derflotteschotte87 wins the game. Winner: derflotteschotte87 Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (886438578) == [Time] 1722103892 [04:11:32] PDBot has started watching. [04:11:35] Caustek chooses to play first. [04:11:38] Caustek mulligans to six cards. [04:11:43] derflotteschotte87 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [04:11:47] Caustek mulligans to five cards. [04:11:56] Caustek puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [04:11:56] Turn 1: Caustek [04:11:58] Caustek skips their draw step. [04:11:59] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:12:00] Caustek casts [Festering Goblin]. [04:12:06] Turn 1: derflotteschotte87 [04:12:09] derflotteschotte87 plays [Plains]. [04:12:11] derflotteschotte87 casts [Savannah Lions]. [04:12:29] Turn 2: Caustek [04:13:05] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:13:08] Caustek casts [Carrion Feeder]. [04:13:14] Turn 2: derflotteschotte87 [04:13:20] derflotteschotte87 plays [City of Brass]. [04:13:26] Caustek is being attacked by [Savannah Lions] [04:13:30] Caustek activates an ability of [Carrion Feeder] ( Put a +1/+1 counter on Carrion Feeder.). [04:13:32] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Festering Goblin] onto the stack targeting [Savannah Lions] (When Festering Goblin dies, target creature gets -1/-1 until end of turn.). [04:13:38] Caustek puts a +1/+1 counter on [Carrion Feeder]. [04:13:44] derflotteschotte87 casts [Mox Diamond]. [04:13:46] derflotteschotte87 discards [City of Brass]. [04:13:53] derflotteschotte87 casts [Engineered Plague]. [04:13:53] derflotteschotte87 puts triggered ability from [City of Brass] onto the stack (Whenever City of Brass becomes tapped, it deals 1 damage to you.). [04:14:02] derflotteschotte87 chooses Zombie for [Engineered Plague]. [04:14:06] derflotteschotte87 casts [Tormod's Crypt]. [04:14:11] Turn 3: Caustek [04:14:17] derflotteschotte87 is being attacked by [Carrion Feeder] [04:14:20] Turn 3: derflotteschotte87 [04:14:23] derflotteschotte87 plays [City of Brass]. [04:14:29] derflotteschotte87 puts triggered ability from [City of Brass] onto the stack (Whenever City of Brass becomes tapped, it deals 1 damage to you.). [04:14:34] derflotteschotte87 casts [Engineered Plague]. [04:14:41] derflotteschotte87 chooses Zombie for [Engineered Plague]. [04:14:46] Turn 4: Caustek [04:14:52] Turn 4: derflotteschotte87 [04:14:55] derflotteschotte87 plays [Undiscovered Paradise]. [04:15:03] derflotteschotte87 casts a card face down. [04:15:10] Caustek casts [Smother] targeting face-down creature #1. [04:15:10] derflotteschotte87 reveals face-down creature #1 as Exalted Angel. [04:15:11] Turn 5: Caustek [04:15:15] Caustek casts [Jet Medallion]. [04:15:17] Turn 5: derflotteschotte87 [04:15:17] [Undiscovered Paradise] is returned to derflotteschotte87's hand from the battlefield. [04:15:21] derflotteschotte87 plays [Undiscovered Paradise]. [04:15:29] derflotteschotte87 casts [Meddling Mage]. [04:15:51] derflotteschotte87 names Phyrexian Rager for [Meddling Mage]. [04:15:53] Turn 6: Caustek [04:15:59] Caustek casts [Priest of Gix]. [04:15:59] Caustek puts triggered ability from [Priest of Gix] onto the stack (When Priest of Gix enters, add {BBB}.). [04:16:03] Caustek casts [Jet Medallion]. [04:16:07] Turn 6: derflotteschotte87 [04:16:11] derflotteschotte87 plays [Gemstone Mine]. [04:16:15] Turn 7: Caustek [04:16:22] derflotteschotte87 is being attacked by [Priest of Gix] [04:16:29] Turn 7: derflotteschotte87 [04:16:36] derflotteschotte87 casts derflotteschotte87. [04:16:39] Caustek is being attacked by [Meddling Mage] [04:16:43] Turn 8: Caustek [04:16:48] derflotteschotte87 is being attacked by [Priest of Gix] [04:16:54] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:16:56] Turn 8: derflotteschotte87 [04:17:02] Caustek is being attacked by derflotteschotte87 and [Meddling Mage] [04:17:03] Turn 9: Caustek [04:17:12] Caustek plays [Swamp]. [04:17:15] Turn 9: derflotteschotte87 [04:17:25] Caustek is being attacked by derflotteschotte87 [04:17:33] derflotteschotte87 plays [Wasteland]. [04:17:36] Turn 10: Caustek [04:17:44] Turn 10: derflotteschotte87 [04:17:52] Caustek is being attacked by derflotteschotte87 and [Meddling Mage] [04:17:56] derflotteschotte87 casts [Lightning Bolt] targeting [Priest of Gix]. [04:17:58] Turn 11: Caustek [04:18:02] Caustek plays [Mishra's Factory]. [04:18:05] Turn 11: derflotteschotte87 [04:18:18] derflotteschotte87 activates an ability of [Wasteland] targeting [Mishra's Factory] ( Destroy target nonbasic land.). [04:18:23] Caustek is being attacked by derflotteschotte87 and [Meddling Mage] [04:18:40] derflotteschotte87 removes a mining counter from [Gemstone Mine]. [04:18:42] derflotteschotte87 casts [Tsabo's Web]. [04:18:43] derflotteschotte87 puts triggered ability from [Tsabo's Web] onto the stack (When Tsabo's Web enters, draw a card.). [04:18:45] derflotteschotte87 draws a card with [Tsabo's Web]'s ability. [04:18:50] derflotteschotte87 casts [Savannah Lions]. [04:18:53] Turn 12: Caustek [04:19:01] Caustek has conceded from the game. [04:19:01] derflotteschotte87 wins the game. Winner: derflotteschotte87 Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: derflotteschotte87: 2–1 [04:19:05] Caustek has left the game.