PennyDreadful
PD mdog
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
mdog,theshadowmaker

== Game 1 (883039068) ==
[Time] 1719623157
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 33.10
[Gatherling] Round=4
[04:05:59] PDBot has started watching.
[04:05:59] theshadowmaker joined the game.
[04:05:59] mdog joined the game.
[04:06:02] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: hi!
[04:06:04] mdog chooses to play first.
[04:06:13] [CHAT] mdog: hi, have fun
[04:06:21] mdog mulligans to six cards.
[04:06:23] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:06:25] mdog mulligans to five cards.
[04:07:08] mdog puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[04:07:08] Turn 1: mdog
[04:07:09] mdog skips their draw step.
[04:07:14] mdog plays [Rivendell].
[04:07:17] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[04:07:22] theshadowmaker plays [Rugged Prairie].
[04:07:27] Turn 2: mdog
[04:07:29] mdog plays [Plains].
[04:07:33] mdog casts [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:07:38] theshadowmaker discards [Oliphaunt].
[04:07:38] theshadowmaker cycles [Oliphaunt].
[04:07:41] theshadowmaker reveals [Mountain].
[04:07:43] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[04:07:50] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[04:07:55] Turn 3: mdog
[04:07:58] mdog plays [Fortified Beachhead].
[04:08:02] mdog casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:08:13] mdog casts [Harbin, Vanguard Aviator].
[04:08:19] theshadowmaker discards [Timeless Dragon].
[04:08:19] theshadowmaker cycles [Timeless Dragon].
[04:08:23] theshadowmaker reveals [Plains].
[04:08:27] mdog puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:08:30] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:08:35] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]
[04:08:40] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[04:08:45] theshadowmaker plays [Plains].
[04:08:59] theshadowmaker exiles [Glimpse of Tomorrow] with 3 time counters.
[04:08:59] theshadowmaker puts three time counters on [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:09:00] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Glimpse of Tomorrow[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset
[04:09:07] Turn 4: mdog
[04:09:11] mdog plays [Mystic Gate].
[04:09:15] mdog casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:09:19] mdog puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:09:20] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:09:26] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Harbin, Vanguard Aviator], [Champion of the Parish], and [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]
[04:09:50] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[04:09:51] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Glimpse of Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 3{RR} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:09:55] theshadowmaker removes a time counter from [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:09:58] theshadowmaker plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[04:10:04] theshadowmaker exiles [Timeless Dragon] with [Timeless Dragon]'s ability.
[04:10:04] theshadowmaker activates an ability of [Timeless Dragon] (Eternalize {2WW}).
[04:10:06] theshadowmaker's [Timeless Dragon] creates a Timeless Dragon.
[04:10:12] mdog activates an ability of [Rivendell] ( Scry 2.).
[04:11:02] mdog scrys 2 (0 top, 2 bottom).
[04:11:07] Turn 5: mdog
[04:11:45] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon], [Harbin, Vanguard Aviator], [Champion of the Parish], and [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]
[04:11:51] [Timeless Dragon] blocks [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:12:05] mdog plays [Plains].
[04:12:11] Turn 5: theshadowmaker
[04:12:11] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Glimpse of Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 3{RR} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:12:14] theshadowmaker removes a time counter from [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:12:24] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[04:12:30] theshadowmaker casts [Geological Appraiser].
[04:12:32] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.).
[04:12:41] theshadowmaker reveals 6 cards with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability: mdog, [Siege-Gang Commander], [Twinshot Sniper], [Ghitu Encampment], [Mountain], and [Etali's Favor].
[04:12:45] theshadowmaker casts [Etali's Favor] targeting [Timeless Dragon].
[04:12:48] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[04:12:49] theshadowmaker reveals 4 cards with [Etali's Favor]'s ability: [Chancellor of the Forge], [Battlefield Forge], [Devouring Sugarmaw], and [Etali's Favor].
[04:12:49] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Chancellor of the Forge[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset
[04:12:52] theshadowmaker casts [Etali's Favor] targeting [Geological Appraiser].
[04:12:54] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[04:12:56] theshadowmaker reveals 8 cards with [Etali's Favor]'s ability: [Boonweaver Giant], [Battlefield Forge], [Kher Keep], [Twinshot Sniper], [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Boonweaver Giant], [Geological Appraiser], and [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:12:57] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Boonweaver Giant[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Boonweaver Giant puts auras into play even if it's not on the battlefield
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Boonweaver Giant` or `!notbugged Boonweaver Giant`
[04:12:59] theshadowmaker casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:13:04] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[04:13:18] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates four Phyrexian Goblin Tokens.
[04:13:25] theshadowmaker casts [Flame-Kin Zealot].
[04:13:26] mdog puts triggered ability from [Soldier of the Pantheon] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a multicolored spell, you gain 1 life.).
[04:13:34] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Flame-Kin Zealot] onto the stack (When Flame-Kin Zealot enters the battlefield, creatures you control get +1/+1 and gain haste until...).
[04:13:45] mdog has conceded from the game.
[04:13:45] theshadowmaker wins the game.
Winner: theshadowmaker
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (883039854) ==
[Time] 1719623686
[04:14:46] PDBot has started watching.
[04:14:50] mdog chooses to play first.
[04:14:58] mdog mulligans to six cards.
[04:15:00] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:15:17] mdog puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:15:17] Turn 1: mdog
[04:15:17] mdog skips their draw step.
[04:15:23] mdog plays [Plains].
[04:15:25] mdog casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:15:28] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[04:15:30] theshadowmaker plays [Battlefield Forge].
[04:15:35] theshadowmaker discards [Oliphaunt].
[04:15:35] theshadowmaker cycles [Oliphaunt].
[04:15:39] theshadowmaker reveals [Mountain].
[04:15:40] Turn 2: mdog
[04:15:44] mdog plays [Fortified Beachhead].
[04:15:49] mdog casts [Harbin, Vanguard Aviator].
[04:15:53] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon]
[04:15:59] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[04:16:08] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[04:16:11] theshadowmaker exiles [Glimpse of Tomorrow] with 3 time counters.
[04:16:12] theshadowmaker puts three time counters on [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:16:16] Turn 3: mdog
[04:16:20] mdog plays [Minas Tirith].
[04:16:24] mdog casts [Boromir, Warden of the Tower].
[04:16:29] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Harbin, Vanguard Aviator] and [Soldier of the Pantheon]
[04:16:40] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[04:16:41] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Glimpse of Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 3{RR} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:16:45] theshadowmaker removes a time counter from [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:16:58] theshadowmaker plays [Battlefield Forge].
[04:17:08] theshadowmaker discards [Twinshot Sniper].
[04:17:08] theshadowmaker activates an ability of [Twinshot Sniper] targeting [Harbin, Vanguard Aviator] ( Twinshot Sniper deals 2 damage to any target.).
[04:17:22] Turn 4: mdog
[04:17:26] mdog plays [Eiganjo Castle].
[04:17:31] mdog casts [Thalia's Lieutenant].
[04:17:34] mdog puts triggered ability from [Thalia's Lieutenant] onto the stack (When Thalia's Lieutenant enters the battlefield, put a +1/+1 counter on each other Human you contr...).
[04:17:37] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Soldier of the Pantheon] and [Boromir, Warden of the Tower].
[04:17:42] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Boromir, Warden of the Tower] and [Soldier of the Pantheon]
[04:17:54] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[04:17:54] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Glimpse of Tomorrow] onto the stack (Suspend 3{RR} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:17:57] theshadowmaker removes a time counter from [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[04:18:00] theshadowmaker plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[04:18:24] theshadowmaker has conceded from the game.
[04:18:24] mdog wins the game.
Winner: mdog
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (883040178) ==
[Time] 1719623936
[04:18:57] PDBot has started watching.
[04:19:01] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:19:04] mdog begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:19:05] theshadowmaker reveals [Chancellor of the Forge] from their opening hand.
[04:19:07] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[04:19:07] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (At the beginning of the first upkeep, create a 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature token with haste.).
[04:19:10] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates a Phyrexian Goblin Token.
[04:19:10] theshadowmaker skips their draw step.
[04:19:11] theshadowmaker plays [Plains].
[04:19:15] theshadowmaker discards [Oliphaunt].
[04:19:15] theshadowmaker cycles [Oliphaunt].
[04:19:17] theshadowmaker reveals [Mountain].
[04:19:20] mdog is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[04:19:22] Turn 1: mdog
[04:19:28] mdog plays [Plains].
[04:19:32] mdog casts [Icatian Javelineers].
[04:19:36] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[04:19:43] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[04:19:51] mdog is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[04:19:55] Turn 2: mdog
[04:19:59] mdog plays [Fortified Beachhead].
[04:20:07] mdog casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:21:08] mdog casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:21:11] mdog puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:21:17] theshadowmaker casts [Have for Dinner].
[04:21:20] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[04:21:20] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[04:21:21] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:21:32] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[04:21:36] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[04:21:44] Turn 3: mdog
[04:21:51] mdog plays [Island].
[04:21:53] mdog casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:21:56] mdog puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:21:59] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:22:03] mdog casts [Thalia's Lieutenant].
[04:22:07] mdog puts triggered ability from [Thalia's Lieutenant] onto the stack (When Thalia's Lieutenant enters the battlefield, put a +1/+1 counter on each other Human you contr...).
[04:22:07] mdog puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:22:07] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:22:12] mdog puts a +1/+1 counter on [Icatian Javelineers], [Champion of the Parish], [Soldier of the Pantheon], and [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:22:24] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon] and [Champion of the Parish]
[04:22:38] [Phyrexian Goblin Token] blocks [Champion of the Parish].
[04:22:40] [Human Token] blocks [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[04:22:56] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[04:22:59] theshadowmaker plays [Plains].
[04:23:02] theshadowmaker casts [Wrath of God].
[04:23:05] mdog removes a javelin counter from [Icatian Javelineers].
[04:23:05] mdog activates an ability of [Icatian Javelineers] targeting theshadowmaker ( Icatian Javelineers deals 1 damage to any target.).
[04:23:10] Turn 4: mdog
[04:23:12] mdog plays [Mystic Gate].
[04:23:19] mdog casts [Boromir, Warden of the Tower].
[04:23:23] Turn 5: theshadowmaker
[04:23:29] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[04:23:34] theshadowmaker casts [Day of Judgment].
[04:23:42] mdog activates an ability of [Boromir, Warden of the Tower] ( Creatures you control gain indestructible until end of turn. The Ring tempts you.).
[04:23:44] mdog is tempted by the Ring.
[04:23:52] Turn 5: mdog
[04:23:57] mdog casts [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben].
[04:24:06] mdog casts [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel].
[04:24:10] Turn 6: theshadowmaker
[04:24:16] theshadowmaker plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[04:24:22] theshadowmaker casts [Timeless Dragon].
[04:24:36] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: Boromir + Thalia is a nombo if both are out in the battlefield
[04:24:42] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: probably you know it already, but still :)
[04:24:50] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: just fyi
[04:24:52] [CHAT] mdog: yeah, it's still worth running both
[04:24:57] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: oh, ofc
[04:25:08] [CHAT] mdog: it is awkward, though
[04:25:10] Turn 6: mdog
[04:25:22] mdog plays [Plains].
[04:26:28] ThyShuffler has started watching.
[04:26:45] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]
[04:26:47] mdog activates an ability of [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel] targeting [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben] ( Another target creature you control gains protection from the card type of your choice until end ...).
[04:26:53] mdog chooses creature for Pippin, Guard of the Citadel.
[04:27:08] Turn 7: theshadowmaker
[04:27:15] theshadowmaker plays [Battlefield Forge].
[04:27:22] theshadowmaker casts [Chancellor of the Forge].
[04:27:25] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[04:27:26] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates two Phyrexian Goblin Tokens.
[04:27:30] mdog is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Phyrexian Goblin Token], and [Timeless Dragon]
[04:27:36] Turn 7: mdog
[04:27:48] mdog casts mdog.
[04:28:06] Turn 8: theshadowmaker
[04:28:10] theshadowmaker plays [Kher Keep].
[04:28:25] mdog is being attacked by [Chancellor of the Forge] and [Timeless Dragon]
[04:28:56] [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben] blocks [Chancellor of the Forge].
[04:28:58] mdog blocks [Chancellor of the Forge].
[04:29:28] Blockers for [Chancellor of the Forge] are ordered as follows: [Thalia, Guardian of Thraben], mdog
[04:29:34] mdog activates an ability of [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel] targeting mdog ( Another target creature you control gains protection from the card type of your choice until end ...).
[04:29:36] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: oh, that works
[04:29:41] mdog chooses creature for Pippin, Guard of the Citadel.
[04:29:47] [CHAT] mdog: thalia still dies
[04:30:03] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: indeed
[04:30:13] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: I swear every day I play worse this card game xD
[04:30:32] [CHAT] mdog: you got 5 damage through and killed thalia, still worth it
[04:30:35] Turn 8: mdog
[04:30:44] mdog casts [Flowering of the White Tree].
[04:31:12] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel]
[04:31:24] theshadowmaker casts [Have for Dinner].
[04:31:27] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[04:31:27] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[04:31:45] [Phyrexian Goblin Token] blocks [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel].
[04:31:47] [Phyrexian Goblin Token] blocks [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel].
[04:31:48] [Human Token] blocks [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel].
[04:31:56] Blockers for [Pippin, Guard of the Citadel] are ordered as follows: [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Human Token]
[04:32:04] theshadowmaker activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.).
[04:32:06] theshadowmaker's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep.
[04:32:19] Turn 9: theshadowmaker
[04:32:29] theshadowmaker casts [Chancellor of the Forge].
[04:32:34] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[04:32:40] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates three Phyrexian Goblin Tokens.
[04:32:51] mdog is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Phyrexian Goblin Token], and [Timeless Dragon]
[04:32:56] mdog blocks [Timeless Dragon].
[04:33:04] Turn 9: mdog
[04:33:18] [CHAT] mdog: I can't beat draws like that, ggs
[04:33:22] mdog has conceded from the game.
[04:33:22] theshadowmaker wins the game.
Winner: theshadowmaker
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: theshadowmaker: 2–1
[04:33:23] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: :)ggs
[04:33:27] theshadowmaker has left the game.