PennyDreadful
PD Kickoff Finals vs theshadowmaker
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
EternalParadox38,theshadowmaker

== Game 1 (876844682) ==
[Time] 1714865793
[09:36:34] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Season 33 Kick Off
[Gatherling] Round=9
[09:36:37] EternalParadox38 chooses to play first.
[09:36:39] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: hi!! good luck :)
[09:36:46] [CHAT] EternalParadox38: same to you
[09:36:57] EternalParadox38 mulligans to six cards.
[09:37:07] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[09:37:09] EternalParadox38 mulligans to five cards.
[09:37:32] EternalParadox38 puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[09:37:34] theshadowmaker reveals [Chancellor of the Forge] from their opening hand.
[09:37:35] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Chancellor of the Forge[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset
[09:37:50] Turn 1: EternalParadox38
[09:37:50] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (At the beginning of the first upkeep, create a 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature token with haste.).
[09:37:52] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates a Phyrexian Goblin Token.
[09:37:52] EternalParadox38 skips their draw step.
[09:37:54] EternalParadox38 plays [Foreboding Ruins].
[09:37:57] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[09:38:06] theshadowmaker plays [Ghitu Encampment].
[09:38:11] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[09:38:12] Turn 2: EternalParadox38
[09:38:14] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[09:38:17] EternalParadox38 casts [Dark Confidant].
[09:38:19] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[09:38:35] theshadowmaker plays [Battlefield Forge].
[09:38:45] Turn 3: EternalParadox38
[09:38:45] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dark Confidant] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your h...).
[09:38:50] EternalParadox38 reveals [Swamp] with [Dark Confidant]'s ability.
[09:38:53] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[09:38:59] EternalParadox38 casts [Deep-Cavern Bat].
[09:39:00] CHAOSBLACKDOOM has started watching.
[09:39:12] theshadowmaker casts [Have for Dinner].
[09:39:14] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[09:39:14] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[09:39:17] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting theshadowmaker (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...).
[09:39:37] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[09:39:46] theshadowmaker plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[09:40:03] Turn 4: EternalParadox38
[09:40:03] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dark Confidant] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your h...).
[09:40:08] EternalParadox38 reveals [Swamp] with [Dark Confidant]'s ability.
[09:40:13] EternalParadox38 plays [Swamp].
[09:40:17] EternalParadox38 casts [Judith, the Scourge Diva].
[09:40:30] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat]
[09:40:45] theshadowmaker discards [Oliphaunt].
[09:40:45] theshadowmaker cycles [Oliphaunt].
[09:40:48] theshadowmaker reveals [Mountain].
[09:40:56] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[09:40:59] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[09:41:03] theshadowmaker casts [Geological Appraiser].
[09:41:10] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.).
[09:41:11] theshadowmaker reveals 13 cards with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability: [Mountain], [Mountain], [Boonweaver Giant], [Oliphaunt], [Chancellor of the Forge], [Boonweaver Giant], [Clifftop Retreat], [Mountain], [Mountain], [Mountain], 
[09:41:11] [Geological Appraiser], EternalParadox38, and theshadowmaker.
[09:41:12] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Boonweaver Giant[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Boonweaver Giant puts auras into play even if it's not on the battlefield
[09:41:14] theshadowmaker casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[09:41:15] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Glimpse of Tomorrow[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset
[09:41:31] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Flame-Kin Zealot] onto the stack (When Flame-Kin Zealot enters the battlefield, creatures you control get +1/+1 and gain haste until...).
[09:41:33] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[09:41:35] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[09:41:38] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Twinshot Sniper] onto the stack targeting [Deep-Cavern Bat] (When Twinshot Sniper enters the battlefield, it deals 2 damage to any target.).
[09:41:56] EternalParadox38 has conceded from the game.
[09:41:56] theshadowmaker wins the game.
Winner: theshadowmaker
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (876845184) ==
[Time] 1714866230
[09:43:50] PDBot has started watching.
[09:44:00] EternalParadox38 mulligans to six cards.
[09:44:05] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[09:44:14] EternalParadox38 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[09:44:16] theshadowmaker reveals [Chancellor of the Forge] from their opening hand.
[09:44:18] theshadowmaker reveals [Chancellor of the Forge] from their opening hand.
[09:44:21] Turn 1: EternalParadox38
[09:44:21] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (At the beginning of the first upkeep, create a 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature token with haste.).
[09:44:21] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (At the beginning of the first upkeep, create a 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature token with haste.).
[09:44:23] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates a Phyrexian Goblin Token.
[09:44:24] theshadowmaker's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates a Phyrexian Goblin Token.
[09:44:24] EternalParadox38 skips their draw step.
[09:44:27] EternalParadox38 plays [Dragonskull Summit].
[09:44:30] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[09:44:37] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[09:44:42] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token] and [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[09:44:43] Turn 2: EternalParadox38
[09:44:50] EternalParadox38 plays [Graven Cairns].
[09:45:02] EternalParadox38 casts [Specter's Shriek] targeting theshadowmaker.
[09:45:10] theshadowmaker discards [Oliphaunt].
[09:45:10] theshadowmaker cycles [Oliphaunt].
[09:45:13] theshadowmaker reveals [Mountain].
[09:45:15] theshadowmaker reveals their hand to [Specter's Shriek], containing [Mountain], [Oliphaunt], [Rugged Prairie], [Timeless Dragon], [Geological Appraiser], [Chancellor of the Forge], and [Chancellor of the Forge].
[09:45:33] EternalParadox38 casts [Forsaken Miner].
[09:45:36] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[09:45:46] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[09:45:54] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token] and [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[09:46:04] Turn 3: EternalParadox38
[09:46:18] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Forsaken Miner]
[09:46:27] EternalParadox38 casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[09:46:35] theshadowmaker discards [Timeless Dragon].
[09:46:35] theshadowmaker cycles [Timeless Dragon].
[09:46:38] theshadowmaker reveals [Plains].
[09:46:40] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[09:46:50] theshadowmaker plays [Plains].
[09:46:58] theshadowmaker casts [Spitebellows] for its evoke cost.
[09:47:00] supergirl-type00 has started watching.
[09:47:04] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Spitebellows] onto the stack (Evoke (When this permanent enters the battlefield, if its evoke cost was paid, its controller sa...).
[09:47:10] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Spitebellows] onto the stack targeting [Forsaken Miner] (When Spitebellows leaves the battlefield, it deals 6 damage to target creature.).
[09:47:14] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Phyrexian Goblin Token] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[09:47:15] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:47:21] theshadowmaker's Triggered ability from Spitebellows is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[09:47:25] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[09:47:29] Turn 4: EternalParadox38
[09:47:38] EternalParadox38 casts [Dark Confidant].
[09:47:42] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[09:47:47] theshadowmaker plays [Rugged Prairie].
[09:47:51] theshadowmaker casts [Geological Appraiser].
[09:47:54] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.).
[09:47:56] theshadowmaker reveals [Glimpse of Tomorrow] with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability.
[09:47:58] theshadowmaker casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[09:48:20] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Twinshot Sniper] onto the stack targeting [Dark Confidant] (When Twinshot Sniper enters the battlefield, it deals 2 damage to any target.).
[09:48:37] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting theshadowmaker ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[09:48:37] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:48:39] Pigmax has started watching.
[09:48:41] theshadowmaker discards [Oliphaunt].
[09:48:41] theshadowmaker cycles [Oliphaunt].
[09:48:44] theshadowmaker reveals [Mountain].
[09:48:46] Pigmax has stopped watching.
[09:48:48] theshadowmaker's Triggered ability from Twinshot Sniper is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[09:48:52] Turn 5: EternalParadox38
[09:49:20] supergirl-type00 has stopped watching.
[09:49:29] Turn 5: theshadowmaker
[09:49:38] theshadowmaker plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[09:49:53] EternalParadox38 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Oliphaunt].
[09:49:53] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:50:12] EternalParadox38 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Oliphaunt].
[09:50:12] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:50:24] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Twinshot Sniper]
[09:50:36] EternalParadox38 exiles [Timeless Dragon] with [Timeless Dragon]'s ability.
[09:50:36] theshadowmaker activates an ability of [Timeless Dragon] (Eternalize {2WW}).
[09:50:36] theshadowmaker's [Timeless Dragon] creates a Timeless Dragon.
[09:50:37] Turn 6: EternalParadox38
[09:51:05] EternalParadox38 casts [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[09:51:10] Turn 6: theshadowmaker
[09:51:19] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[09:51:26] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Timeless Dragon] and [Twinshot Sniper]
[09:51:37] Turn 7: EternalParadox38
[09:51:55] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Dreadhorde Butcher]
[09:52:03] theshadowmaker casts [Have for Dinner].
[09:52:05] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[09:52:05] theshadowmaker's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[09:52:17] [Human Token] blocks [Dreadhorde Butcher].
[09:52:37] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dreadhorde Butcher] onto the stack targeting [Twinshot Sniper] (When Dreadhorde Butcher dies, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[09:52:37] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:52:49] theshadowmaker activates an ability of [Food Token] ( Gain 3 life.).
[09:53:05] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Twinshot Sniper] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[09:53:06] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:53:16] EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Twinshot Sniper] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[09:53:16] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Forsaken Miner] onto the stack (Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Forsaken Miner from your graveyard...).
[09:53:25] Turn 7: theshadowmaker
[09:53:30] theshadowmaker plays [Battlefield Forge].
[09:53:33] theshadowmaker exiles [Glimpse of Tomorrow] with 3 time counters.
[09:53:33] theshadowmaker puts three time counters on [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[09:53:40] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Timeless Dragon]
[09:53:42] Turn 8: EternalParadox38
[09:53:50] EternalParadox38 has conceded from the game.
[09:53:50] theshadowmaker wins the game.
Winner: theshadowmaker
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: theshadowmaker: 2–0
[09:53:55] theshadowmaker has left the game.