PennyDreadful
pd league
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
CivMaster,Jiipel

== Game 1 (876358020) ==
[Time] 1714421348
[06:09:09] PDBot has started watching.
[06:09:09] CivMaster joined the game.
[League] Didn't Do the Math TBH by jiipel (240982) vs Golgari Friends by civmaster (240983)
[06:09:12] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[06:09:13] Jiipel chooses to play first.
[06:09:16] [CHAT] Jiipel: glhf
[06:09:21] Jiipel begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:09:25] CivMaster mulligans to six cards.
[06:09:31] [CHAT] CivMaster: gl hf
[06:09:35] CivMaster mulligans to five cards.
[06:09:47] CivMaster puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[06:09:47] Turn 1: Jiipel
[06:09:47] Jiipel skips their draw step.
[06:09:49] Jiipel plays [Vivid Marsh].
[06:09:57] Turn 1: CivMaster
[06:10:00] CivMaster plays [Necroblossom Snarl].
[06:10:04] CivMaster casts [Birds of Paradise].
[06:10:11] Turn 2: Jiipel
[06:10:13] Jiipel plays [Pillar of the Paruns].
[06:10:13] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Pillar of the Paruns[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Pillar of the Paruns cannot pay for split costs
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Pillar of the Paruns` or `!notbugged Pillar of the Paruns`
[06:10:15] Turn 2: CivMaster
[06:10:18] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:10:32] CivMaster casts [Sylvan Caryatid].
[06:10:41] Turn 3: Jiipel
[06:10:44] Jiipel plays [Tendo Ice Bridge].
[06:10:55] Jiipel removes a charge counter from [Vivid Marsh].
[06:10:58] Jiipel casts [Shardless Agent].
[06:10:58] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:11:03] CivMaster has conceded from the game.
[06:11:03] Jiipel wins the game.
Winner: Jiipel
Game 1 Completed.
[06:11:08] CivMaster has left the game.

== Game 2 (876358286) ==
[Time] 1714421518
[06:11:58] PDBot has started watching.
[06:11:59] CivMaster chooses to play first.
[06:12:04] CivMaster begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:12:06] Jiipel begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:12:06] Turn 1: CivMaster
[06:12:06] CivMaster skips their draw step.
[06:12:10] CivMaster plays [Necroblossom Snarl].
[06:12:18] Turn 1: Jiipel
[06:12:21] Jiipel plays [Vivid Marsh].
[06:12:31] Turn 2: CivMaster
[06:12:34] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:12:37] CivMaster casts [Sylvan Caryatid].
[06:12:46] Turn 2: Jiipel
[06:12:52] Jiipel plays [Hidden Nursery].
[06:12:59] Turn 3: CivMaster
[06:13:03] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:13:16] CivMaster casts [Lost Legacy] targeting Jiipel.
[06:13:33] CivMaster names Primal Surge for [Lost Legacy].
[06:13:44] [CHAT] Jiipel: lol
[06:14:24] CivMaster exiled 0 copies of Primal Surge (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 0 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[06:14:36] Turn 3: Jiipel
[06:14:38] Jiipel plays [Forest].
[06:14:43] Jiipel removes a charge counter from [Vivid Marsh].
[06:14:49] Jiipel removes a charge counter from [Vivid Marsh].
[06:14:52] Jiipel casts [Shardless Agent].
[06:14:52] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:14:56] Jiipel reveals [Tibalt's Trickery] with [Shardless Agent].
[06:14:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Tibalt's Trickery[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Tibalt's Trickery allows the person casting a spell using it to cast a spell that was milled and then exiled by an effect like Dryad MIlitant
[06:14:59] Jiipel casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Shardless Agent].
[06:15:01] Jiipel mills [The First Sliver] and [Demonic Dread].
[06:15:06] Jiipel casts [Geological Appraiser].
[06:15:08] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.).
[06:15:11] Jiipel reveals 4 cards with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability: [Pillar of the Paruns], [The First Sliver], [Enigma Sphinx], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[06:16:18] [CHAT] Jiipel: hm im not being shown the discovered card
[06:16:37] [CHAT] CivMaster: tibalt's trickery as far as i could tell
[06:17:12] [CHAT] Jiipel: ah right i understand
[06:17:27] Turn 4: CivMaster
[06:17:30] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:17:44] CivMaster casts [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:17:49] CivMaster removes a loyalty counter from [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:17:49] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[06:17:50] CivMaster's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[06:17:58] Turn 4: Jiipel
[06:18:00] Jiipel plays [Mountain].
[06:18:15] Jiipel removes a charge counter from [Vivid Marsh].
[06:18:15] Jiipel casts [Shardless Agent].
[06:18:15] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:18:20] Jiipel reveals 16 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Tendo Ice Bridge], [The First Sliver], [Enigma Sphinx], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Tendo Ice Bridge], [Shardless Agent], [Hidden Nursery], [Bituminous Blast], [Demonic Dread], 
[06:18:20] [Hidden Cataract], [Vivid Marsh], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Tendrils of Agony], [Enigma Sphinx], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[06:18:25] Jiipel casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Shardless Agent].
[06:18:28] Jiipel mills [Hidden Volcano], [Tendo Ice Bridge], and [Geological Appraiser].
[06:18:32] Jiipel casts [Enlisted Wurm].
[06:18:32] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Enlisted Wurm] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:18:49] Jiipel reveals [Deny Reality] with [Enlisted Wurm].
[06:18:54] Jiipel casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:18:55] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:18:59] Jiipel reveals 8 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Vivid Marsh], [Hidden Cataract], [Island], [Tendo Ice Bridge], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Pillar of the Paruns], [The First Sliver], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[06:19:13] Jiipel casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Enlisted Wurm].
[06:19:13] Jiipel mills [Enlisted Wurm], [Geological Appraiser], and [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[06:19:17] Jiipel casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting CivMaster.
[06:19:17] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell that was cast before it this turn. You m...).
[06:19:32] Jiipel returns [Garruk Wildspeaker] to its owner's hand with [Deny Reality].
[06:19:43] Turn 5: CivMaster
[06:19:58] CivMaster casts [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:20:03] CivMaster removes a loyalty counter from [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:20:03] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[06:20:05] CivMaster's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[06:20:06] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:20:08] CivMaster casts [Birds of Paradise].
[06:20:16] Jiipel is being attacked by [Beast Token]
[06:20:21] [Geological Appraiser] blocks [Beast Token].
[06:20:30] Turn 5: Jiipel
[06:20:48] Turn 6: CivMaster
[06:20:51] CivMaster plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[06:20:54] CivMaster removes a loyalty counter from [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:20:54] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[06:20:56] CivMaster's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[06:21:02] Jiipel is being attacked by [Beast Token]
[06:21:19] CivMaster casts [Garruk Relentless].
[06:21:24] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Relentless] ( Create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token.).
[06:21:25] CivMaster's [Garruk Relentless] creates a Wolf Token.
[06:21:28] Turn 6: Jiipel
[06:21:47] Jiipel discards [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[06:21:47] Turn 7: CivMaster
[06:21:55] CivMaster removes a loyalty counter from [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:21:55] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[06:21:58] CivMaster's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[06:22:05] CivMaster casts [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:22:12] CivMaster puts a loyalty counter on [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:22:12] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] targeting [Forest], and [Forest] ( Untap two target lands.).
[06:22:16] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Relentless] ( Create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token.).
[06:22:17] CivMaster's [Garruk Relentless] creates a Wolf Token.
[06:22:23] Jiipel is being attacked by [Wolf Token], [Beast Token], and [Beast Token]
[06:22:32] Turn 7: Jiipel
[06:22:43] Jiipel discards [Deny Reality].
[06:22:43] Turn 8: CivMaster
[06:22:48] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Relentless] ( Create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token.).
[06:22:51] CivMaster's [Garruk Relentless] creates a Wolf Token.
[06:23:02] CivMaster removes four loyalty counters from [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[06:23:02] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Creatures you control get +3/+3 and gain trample until end of turn.).
[06:23:10] Jiipel has conceded from the game.
[06:23:10] CivMaster wins the game.
Winner: CivMaster
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (876359454) ==
[Time] 1714422218
[06:23:39] PDBot has started watching.
[06:23:42] Jiipel mulligans to six cards.
[06:23:47] CivMaster begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:23:50] Jiipel mulligans to five cards.
[06:23:57] Jiipel mulligans to four cards.
[06:24:08] Jiipel puts three cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with four cards in hand.
[06:24:08] Turn 1: Jiipel
[06:24:08] Jiipel skips their draw step.
[06:24:09] Jiipel plays [Hidden Cataract].
[06:24:17] Turn 1: CivMaster
[06:24:22] CivMaster plays [Necroblossom Snarl].
[06:24:27] CivMaster casts [Birds of Paradise].
[06:24:37] Turn 2: Jiipel
[06:24:39] Jiipel plays [Vivid Marsh].
[06:24:46] Turn 2: CivMaster
[06:24:48] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:24:54] CivMaster casts [Lost Legacy] targeting Jiipel.
[06:25:06] CivMaster names Tibalt's Trickery for [Lost Legacy].
[06:25:38] CivMaster exiled 4 copies of Tibalt's Trickery (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 4 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[06:25:53] Turn 3: Jiipel
[06:25:56] Jiipel plays [Tendo Ice Bridge].
[06:26:03] Turn 3: CivMaster
[06:26:07] CivMaster plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[06:26:31] CivMaster casts [Carth the Lion].
[06:26:33] CivMaster puts triggered ability from [Carth the Lion] onto the stack (Whenever Carth the Lion enters the battlefield or a planeswalker you control dies, look at the top...).
[06:26:56] CivMaster reveals [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman] with [Carth the Lion]'s ability.
[06:27:06] Turn 4: Jiipel
[06:27:26] Turn 4: CivMaster
[06:27:30] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:27:41] Jiipel is being attacked by [Carth the Lion]
[06:27:53] CivMaster casts [Garruk Relentless].
[06:27:57] CivMaster puts a loyalty counter on [Garruk Relentless].
[06:27:57] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Relentless] ( Create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token.).
[06:27:58] CivMaster's [Garruk Relentless] creates a Wolf Token.
[06:28:01] Turn 5: Jiipel
[06:28:04] Jiipel plays [Tendo Ice Bridge].
[06:28:12] Jiipel removes a charge counter from [Vivid Marsh].
[06:28:14] Jiipel casts [Shardless Agent].
[06:28:14] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:28:20] Jiipel reveals 48 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Hidden Cataract], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Enigma Sphinx], [Enlisted Wurm], [Forest], [Geological Appraiser], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Shardless Agent], [Bituminous Blast], [Tendo Ice Bridge], 
[06:28:21] [The First Sliver], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [The First Sliver], [Geological Appraiser], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Enlisted Wurm], [Vivid Marsh], [Deny Reality], [Ethersworn Sphinx], Jiipel, 
[06:28:21] CivMaster, [Shardless Agent], [Island], [Bituminous Blast], [Hidden Volcano], [The First Sliver], [Tendrils of Agony], [Geological Appraiser], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Hidden Nursery], 
[06:28:21] [Geological Appraiser], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Enigma Sphinx], [Mountain], [Hidden Nursery], [Enigma Sphinx], [Tendo Ice Bridge], [Hidden Volcano], [Vivid Marsh], [Tendrils of Agony], 
[06:28:21] [Enlisted Wurm], [Enigma Sphinx], [Demonic Dread], [Deny Reality], [Deny Reality], [Pillar of the Paruns], [The First Sliver], and [Enlisted Wurm].
[06:28:32] Turn 5: CivMaster
[06:28:40] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:28:52] CivMaster casts [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman].
[06:28:58] CivMaster puts a loyalty counter on [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman].
[06:28:58] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman] ( Create two 2/2 black and green Wolf creature tokens with 'When this creature dies, put a loyalty ...).
[06:29:00] CivMaster's [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman] creates two Wolf Tokens.
[06:29:04] CivMaster puts a loyalty counter on [Garruk Relentless].
[06:29:05] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Relentless] ( Create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token.).
[06:29:06] CivMaster's [Garruk Relentless] creates a Wolf Token.
[06:29:14] Jiipel is being attacked by [Carth the Lion]
[06:29:23] Turn 6: Jiipel
[06:29:39] Jiipel removes a charge counter from [Vivid Marsh].
[06:29:39] Jiipel casts [Shardless Agent].
[06:29:39] Jiipel puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade).
[06:29:47] Jiipel reveals 47 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Vivid Marsh], [Enlisted Wurm], [Hidden Nursery], [Enlisted Wurm], [Pillar of the Paruns], [The First Sliver], [Shardless Agent], [Forest], [Geological Appraiser], [Enlisted Wurm], 
[06:29:47] [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Mountain], [Deny Reality], [Island], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Tendrils of Agony], [Deny Reality], [Bituminous Blast], [Tendo Ice Bridge], [Vivid Marsh], 
[06:29:47] [Pillar of the Paruns], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Geological Appraiser], [Hidden Nursery], [Shardless Agent], [The First Sliver], [The First Sliver], [Hidden Volcano], [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Volcano], 
[06:29:47] [Enlisted Wurm], [Enigma Sphinx], [Enigma Sphinx], [Geological Appraiser], [Pillar of the Paruns], [Enigma Sphinx], [Bituminous Blast], [The First Sliver], [Geological Appraiser], [Tendrils of Agony], 
[06:29:47] [Enigma Sphinx], [Bituminous Blast], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Deny Reality], [Vivid Marsh], and [Tendo Ice Bridge].
[06:30:01] Turn 6: CivMaster
[06:30:04] CivMaster plays [Forest].
[06:30:08] CivMaster removes five loyalty counters from [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman].
[06:30:08] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman] ( You get an emblem with 'Creatures you control get +3/+3 and have trample.').
[06:30:09] CivMaster's [Garruk, Cursed Huntsman] creates an emblem. ("Creatures you control get +3/+3 and have trample.")
[06:30:13] CivMaster puts a loyalty counter on [Garruk Relentless].
[06:30:13] CivMaster activates an ability of [Garruk Relentless] targeting [Shardless Agent] ( Garruk Relentless deals 3 damage to target creature. That creature deals damage equal to its powe...).
[06:30:17] [CHAT] Jiipel: gg
[06:30:21] Jiipel has conceded from the game.
[06:30:21] CivMaster wins the game.
Winner: CivMaster
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: CivMaster: 2–1
[06:30:26] Jiipel has left the game.