PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Dawnsday,Schuwwey == Game 1 (876056306) == [Time] 1714159182 [05:19:43] PDBot has started watching. [League] Ooey Gooey by schuwwey (240527) vs Deserted Island by dawnsday (240523) [05:19:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [05:19:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Due to a Magic Online bug, PDBot is unable to tell which player is which. Please report this league match manually. [05:19:46] Schuwwey chooses to play first. [05:19:53] Schuwwey begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:19:55] Dawnsday begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:19:55] Turn 1: Schuwwey [05:19:55] Schuwwey skips their draw step. [05:19:57] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:20:05] Turn 1: Dawnsday [05:20:09] Dawnsday plays [Lush Oasis]. [05:20:09] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Lush Oasis] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Lush Oasis enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:20:18] Turn 2: Schuwwey [05:20:22] Schuwwey plays [Hinterland Harbor]. [05:20:26] Turn 2: Dawnsday [05:20:31] Dawnsday plays [Eroded Canyon]. [05:20:32] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Eroded Canyon] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Eroded Canyon enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:20:41] Turn 3: Schuwwey [05:20:44] Schuwwey plays [Hinterland Harbor]. [05:20:49] Schuwwey casts [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:20:52] Schuwwey's [Slime Against Humanity] creates an Ooze Token. [05:20:52] Schuwwey puts two +1/+1 counters on [Ooze Token]. [05:20:58] Turn 3: Dawnsday [05:21:01] Dawnsday plays [Island]. [05:21:05] Dawnsday casts [Shardless Agent]. [05:21:05] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [05:21:09] Dawnsday reveals 29 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Academy Ruins], [Bristling Backwoods], [Field of the Dead], [Shardless Agent], [Kher Keep], [Lonely Arroyo], [Hidden Nursery], [Lonely Arroyo], [Soured Springs], [Island], [05:21:09] [Creosote Heath], [Hidden Cataract], [Forest], [Island], [Quicksand], [Creosote Heath], [Forest], [Bristling Backwoods], [Lush Oasis], [Festering Gulch], [05:21:09] [Quicksand], [Primal Surge], [Island], [Field of the Dead], [Shardless Agent], [Quicksand], [Field of the Dead], [Hidden Cataract], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [05:21:09] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Tibalt's Trickery[sU] has an advantageous bug. Tibalt's Trickery allows the person casting a spell using it to cast a spell that was milled and then exiled by an effect like Dryad MIlitant Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Tibalt's Trickery` or `!notbugged Tibalt's Trickery` [05:21:13] Dawnsday casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Shardless Agent]. [05:21:17] Dawnsday mills [Field of the Dead], [Hidden Nursery], and [Lush Oasis]. [05:21:23] Dawnsday casts [Primal Surge]. [05:21:29] Dawnsday puts [Field of the Dead] onto the battlefield. [05:21:30] Dawnsday puts [Lush Oasis] onto the battlefield. [05:21:31] Dawnsday puts [Creosote Heath] onto the battlefield. [05:21:32] Dawnsday puts [Creosote Heath] onto the battlefield. [05:21:33] Dawnsday puts [Quicksand] onto the battlefield. [05:21:35] Dawnsday puts [Lonely Arroyo] onto the battlefield. [05:21:36] Dawnsday puts [Soured Springs] onto the battlefield. [05:21:37] Dawnsday puts [Island] onto the battlefield. [05:21:37] [CHAT] Schuwwey: WOAH [05:21:38] Dawnsday puts [Bristling Backwoods] onto the battlefield. [05:21:39] Dawnsday puts [Quicksand] onto the battlefield. [05:21:40] [CHAT] Schuwwey: dang [05:21:41] Dawnsday puts [Field of the Dead] onto the battlefield. [05:21:42] Dawnsday puts [Lush Oasis] onto the battlefield. [05:21:43] Dawnsday puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [05:21:44] Schuwwey has conceded from the game. [05:21:44] Dawnsday wins the game. Winner: Dawnsday Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (876056578) == [Time] 1714159374 [05:22:54] PDBot has started watching. [05:22:59] Schuwwey chooses to play first. [05:23:07] Schuwwey begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:23:11] Dawnsday mulligans to six cards. [05:23:13] Dawnsday mulligans to five cards. [05:23:22] Dawnsday puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [05:23:22] Turn 1: Schuwwey [05:23:22] Schuwwey skips their draw step. [05:23:27] [CHAT] Schuwwey: so you just really aggro mulligan til you get the cascade? [05:23:31] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:23:35] Turn 1: Dawnsday [05:23:40] Dawnsday plays [Lush Oasis]. [05:23:41] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Lush Oasis] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Lush Oasis enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:23:46] [CHAT] Dawnsday: Yeah it's very fragile [05:23:54] Turn 2: Schuwwey [05:24:01] [CHAT] Schuwwey: thats sick tho [05:24:05] Schuwwey plays [Hinterland Harbor]. [05:24:14] Schuwwey casts [Mulch]. [05:24:14] Schuwwey reveals 4 cards with [Mulch]: [Druid's Deliverance], [Slime Against Humanity], [Birds of Paradise], and [Forest]. [05:24:16] Schuwwey puts [Forest] into their hand with with [Mulch]. [05:24:16] Schuwwey puts [Birds of Paradise], [Druid's Deliverance], and [Slime Against Humanity] into their graveyard. [05:24:16] [CHAT] Dawnsday: yeah I'm having a lotta fun with it but yeah any counters or discard and it's a lot rougher [05:24:21] Turn 2: Dawnsday [05:24:25] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Cataract]. [05:24:33] Turn 3: Schuwwey [05:24:36] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:24:44] Turn 3: Dawnsday [05:24:50] [CHAT] Schuwwey: makes sense makes sense [05:24:52] Dawnsday plays [Academy Ruins]. [05:24:58] Dawnsday casts [Shardless Agent]. [05:24:58] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [05:25:17] [CHAT] Dawnsday: Slime against humanity looks fun I didn't even know that was legal here [05:25:24] [CHAT] Schuwwey: wait the cascade still goes tho [05:25:25] [CHAT] Schuwwey: tough [05:25:37] Dawnsday reveals 27 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Creosote Heath], [Field of the Dead], [Hidden Nursery], [Lonely Arroyo], [Soured Springs], [Hidden Nursery], [Island], [Kher Keep], [Shardless Agent], [Eroded Canyon], [05:25:37] [Hidden Cataract], [Forest], [Bristling Backwoods], [Hidden Cataract], [Creosote Heath], [Forest], [Bristling Backwoods], [Hidden Nursery], [Lonely Arroyo], [Shardless Agent], [05:25:37] [Lush Oasis], [Hidden Nursery], [Lonely Arroyo], [Lush Oasis], [Bristling Backwoods], [Hidden Cataract], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [05:25:44] Dawnsday casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Shardless Agent]. [05:25:53] Schuwwey casts [Confounding Riddle] targeting [Tibalt's Trickery]. [05:25:53] Chosen mode: Counter target spell unless its controller pays {4}. [05:25:57] [CHAT] Schuwwey: there we go lol [05:26:00] [CHAT] Schuwwey: almost threw that [05:26:00] [CHAT] Dawnsday: yeah you just counter the surge or the trickery lol [05:26:14] Turn 4: Schuwwey [05:26:20] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:26:28] Schuwwey casts [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:26:29] Schuwwey's [Slime Against Humanity] creates an Ooze Token. [05:26:29] Schuwwey puts three +1/+1 counters on [Ooze Token]. [05:26:33] Turn 4: Dawnsday [05:26:39] [CHAT] Schuwwey: thats cool tho i like it [05:26:41] Dawnsday plays [Field of the Dead]. [05:26:45] [CHAT] Schuwwey: yea slime just got added [05:26:52] Turn 5: Schuwwey [05:26:57] Schuwwey plays [Island]. [05:27:01] Schuwwey casts [Strategic Planning]. [05:27:02] [CHAT] Dawnsday: Yeah I might steal your list when I see your league finish haha it seems sweet [05:27:23] Schuwwey casts [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:27:26] Schuwwey's [Slime Against Humanity] creates an Ooze Token. [05:27:26] Schuwwey puts four +1/+1 counters on [Ooze Token]. [05:27:34] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Ooze Token] [05:27:47] Turn 5: Dawnsday [05:27:53] [CHAT] Schuwwey: thanks thanks its still in the works [05:28:02] Dawnsday plays [Forest]. [05:28:09] [CHAT] Schuwwey: keeping card advantage is tough when you want stuff in your graveyard and exile [05:28:17] Turn 6: Schuwwey [05:28:31] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Ooze Token] and [Ooze Token] [05:28:54] [CHAT] Dawnsday: yeah i see the idea tho [05:28:55] Turn 6: Dawnsday [05:29:02] Dawnsday plays [Westvale Abbey]. [05:29:17] Schuwwey is being attacked by [Shardless Agent] [05:29:35] Schuwwey casts [Confounding Riddle]. [05:29:35] Chosen mode: Look at the top 4 cards of your library. Put 1 of them into your hand and the rest into your graveyard. [05:29:47] Turn 7: Schuwwey [05:29:59] Schuwwey casts [Tamiyo, Collector of Tales]. [05:30:09] Schuwwey puts a loyalty counter on [Tamiyo, Collector of Tales]. [05:30:09] Schuwwey activates an ability of [Tamiyo, Collector of Tales] ( Choose a nonland card name, then reveal the top four cards of your library. Put all cards with th...). [05:30:18] Schuwwey names Wood Sage for Tamiyo, Collector of Tales. [05:30:29] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Ooze Token] and [Ooze Token] [05:30:36] Turn 7: Dawnsday [05:30:40] Dawnsday plays [Quicksand]. [05:30:40] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Field of the Dead] onto the stack (Whenever Field of the Dead or another land enters the battlefield under your control, if you contr...). [05:30:48] Dawnsday's [Field of the Dead] creates a Zombie Token. [05:30:59] Turn 8: Schuwwey [05:31:03] Schuwwey plays [Yavimaya Coast]. [05:31:05] Schuwwey puts a loyalty counter on [Tamiyo, Collector of Tales]. [05:31:05] Schuwwey activates an ability of [Tamiyo, Collector of Tales] ( Choose a nonland card name, then reveal the top four cards of your library. Put all cards with th...). [05:31:12] Schuwwey names Wood Sage for Tamiyo, Collector of Tales. [05:31:30] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Ooze Token] and [Ooze Token] [05:31:35] [Shardless Agent] blocks [Ooze Token]. [05:31:37] [Zombie Token] blocks [Ooze Token]. [05:31:46] Blockers for [Ooze Token] are ordered as follows: [Shardless Agent], [Zombie Token] [05:31:52] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Quicksand] targeting [Ooze Token] ( Target attacking creature without flying gets -1/-2 until end of turn.). [05:32:26] Schuwwey casts [Strategic Planning]. [05:32:43] Schuwwey casts [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:32:44] Schuwwey's [Slime Against Humanity] creates an Ooze Token. [05:32:44] Schuwwey puts seven +1/+1 counters on [Ooze Token]. [05:32:47] Turn 8: Dawnsday [05:32:49] Dawnsday has conceded from the game. [05:32:49] Schuwwey wins the game. Winner: Schuwwey Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (876057450) == [Time] 1714160004 [05:33:25] PDBot has started watching. [05:33:29] Dawnsday chooses to play first. [05:33:35] Dawnsday begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:33:40] Schuwwey mulligans to six cards. [05:33:53] Schuwwey puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [05:33:53] Turn 1: Dawnsday [05:33:53] Dawnsday skips their draw step. [05:34:00] Dawnsday plays [Bristling Backwoods]. [05:34:00] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Bristling Backwoods] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Bristling Backwoods enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:34:11] Turn 1: Schuwwey [05:34:13] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:34:15] Schuwwey casts [Birds of Paradise]. [05:34:19] Turn 2: Dawnsday [05:34:27] Dawnsday plays [Lush Oasis]. [05:34:27] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Lush Oasis] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Lush Oasis enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:34:38] Turn 2: Schuwwey [05:34:41] Schuwwey plays [Island]. [05:34:50] Turn 3: Dawnsday [05:34:53] Dawnsday plays [Kher Keep]. [05:35:00] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.). [05:35:03] Dawnsday's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep. [05:35:09] Turn 3: Schuwwey [05:35:22] Turn 4: Dawnsday [05:35:29] Dawnsday plays [Creosote Heath]. [05:35:29] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Creosote Heath] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Creosote Heath enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:35:36] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.). [05:35:37] Dawnsday's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep. [05:35:46] Turn 4: Schuwwey [05:35:51] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:36:02] Turn 5: Dawnsday [05:36:07] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Nursery]. [05:36:12] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.). [05:36:14] Dawnsday's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep. [05:36:22] Turn 5: Schuwwey [05:36:58] Turn 6: Dawnsday [05:37:08] Dawnsday plays [Lonely Arroyo]. [05:37:08] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Lonely Arroyo] onto the stack targeting Schuwwey (When Lonely Arroyo enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent.). [05:37:15] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.). [05:37:17] Dawnsday's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep. [05:37:24] Turn 6: Schuwwey [05:37:35] Schuwwey casts [Mulch]. [05:37:36] Schuwwey reveals 4 cards with [Mulch]: [Slime Against Humanity], [Slime Against Humanity], [Island], and [Yavimaya Coast]. [05:37:47] Schuwwey puts [Island] and [Yavimaya Coast] into their hand with with [Mulch]. [05:37:47] Schuwwey puts [Slime Against Humanity] and [Slime Against Humanity] into their graveyard. [05:37:53] [CHAT] Schuwwey: im so dumb [05:37:57] [CHAT] Schuwwey: birds makes any color lmao [05:37:59] [CHAT] Schuwwey: lol [05:38:09] Schuwwey plays [Island]. [05:38:12] [CHAT] Dawnsday: The ol manadork classic [05:38:28] Schuwwey discards [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:38:28] Turn 7: Dawnsday [05:38:38] Dawnsday plays [Island]. [05:38:55] Dawnsday casts [Shardless Agent]. [05:38:55] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [05:39:01] Dawnsday reveals 46 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Hidden Cataract], [Lonely Arroyo], [Forest], [Field of the Dead], [Field of the Dead], [Westvale Abbey], [Forest], [Festering Gulch], [Primal Surge], [Hidden Nursery], [05:39:01] [Creosote Heath], [Quicksand], [Soured Springs], [Island], [Shardless Agent], [Forest], [Lush Oasis], [Island], [Shardless Agent], [Hidden Nursery], [05:39:01] [Creosote Heath], [Bristling Backwoods], [Island], [Forest], Schuwwey, Dawnsday, [Forest], [Field of the Dead], [Bristling Backwoods], [Festering Gulch], [05:39:01] [Eroded Canyon], [Soured Springs], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Bristling Backwoods], [Island], [Hidden Nursery], [Lonely Arroyo], [Lush Oasis], [Quicksand], [Eroded Canyon], [05:39:01] [Quicksand], [Lush Oasis], [Festering Gulch], [Shardless Agent], [Quicksand], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [05:39:08] Dawnsday casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Shardless Agent]. [05:39:14] Schuwwey casts [Flashfreeze] targeting [Tibalt's Trickery]. [05:39:31] Turn 7: Schuwwey [05:39:39] Schuwwey plays [Forest]. [05:39:55] Schuwwey casts [Strategic Planning]. [05:40:16] Schuwwey casts [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:40:17] Schuwwey's [Slime Against Humanity] creates an Ooze Token. [05:40:17] Schuwwey puts five +1/+1 counters on [Ooze Token]. [05:40:28] Turn 8: Dawnsday [05:40:33] Dawnsday plays [Academy Ruins]. [05:40:46] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Hidden Nursery] ( Discover 4.). [05:40:50] Dawnsday reveals 3 cards with [Hidden Nursery]'s ability: [Quicksand], [Island], and [Shardless Agent]. [05:40:52] Dawnsday casts [Shardless Agent]. [05:40:52] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [05:41:00] Dawnsday reveals 44 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Forest], [Forest], [Festering Gulch], [Lush Oasis], [Quicksand], [Forest], [Field of the Dead], [Hidden Nursery], [Creosote Heath], [Lonely Arroyo], [05:41:00] [Bristling Backwoods], [Quicksand], [Primal Surge], [Lush Oasis], [Bristling Backwoods], [Field of the Dead], [Field of the Dead], [Lonely Arroyo], [Field of the Dead], [Creosote Heath], [05:41:00] [Westvale Abbey], [Forest], [Festering Gulch], [Soured Springs], [Hidden Nursery], [Shardless Agent], [Forest], [Island], [Bristling Backwoods], [Hidden Cataract], [05:41:00] [Kessig Wolf Run], [Island], [Quicksand], [Island], [Shardless Agent], [Soured Springs], [Festering Gulch], [Eroded Canyon], [Eroded Canyon], [Lush Oasis], [05:41:00] [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Nursery], [Island], and [Quicksand]. [05:41:15] Turn 8: Schuwwey [05:41:20] Schuwwey plays [Hinterland Harbor]. [05:41:38] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Ooze Token] [05:41:59] Schuwwey casts [Wood Sage]. [05:42:07] Schuwwey casts [Wood Sage]. [05:42:17] Turn 9: Dawnsday [05:42:20] Dawnsday plays [Field of the Dead]. [05:42:21] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Field of the Dead] onto the stack (Whenever Field of the Dead or another land enters the battlefield under your control, if you contr...). [05:42:24] Dawnsday's [Field of the Dead] creates a Zombie Token. [05:42:36] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.). [05:42:40] Dawnsday's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep. [05:42:54] Schuwwey is being attacked by [Shardless Agent] and [Shardless Agent] [05:43:00] [Birds of Paradise] blocks [Shardless Agent]. [05:43:11] Turn 9: Schuwwey [05:43:16] Schuwwey plays [Yavimaya Coast]. [05:43:22] Schuwwey activates an ability of [Wood Sage] ( Choose a creature card name. Reveal the top four cards of your library and put all of them with t...). [05:43:30] Schuwwey names Wood Sage for Wood Sage. [05:43:32] Schuwwey activates an ability of [Wood Sage] ( Choose a creature card name. Reveal the top four cards of your library and put all of them with t...). [05:43:37] Schuwwey names Wood Sage for Wood Sage. [05:43:52] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Ooze Token] [05:44:13] Schuwwey casts [Slime Against Humanity]. [05:44:14] Schuwwey's [Slime Against Humanity] creates an Ooze Token. [05:44:14] Schuwwey puts eight +1/+1 counters on [Ooze Token]. [05:44:21] Turn 10: Dawnsday [05:44:25] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Cataract]. [05:44:26] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Field of the Dead] onto the stack (Whenever Field of the Dead or another land enters the battlefield under your control, if you contr...). [05:44:31] Dawnsday's [Field of the Dead] creates a Zombie Token. [05:44:38] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.). [05:44:42] Dawnsday's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep. [05:44:50] Dawnsday has conceded from the game. [05:44:50] Schuwwey wins the game. Winner: Schuwwey Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Schuwwey: 2–1 [05:44:55] Dawnsday has left the game.