PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Dawnsday,supergirl-type00 == Game 1 (876026784) == [Time] 1714134468 [22:27:48] PDBot has started watching. [League] Memoirs of a Physician by supergirl-type00 (240454) vs Someone Fix This Manabase by dawnsday (240463) [22:27:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [22:27:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Due to a Magic Online bug, PDBot is unable to tell which player is which. Please report this league match manually. [22:28:21] [CHAT] supergirl-type00: Hello and good luck to you [22:28:23] supergirl-type00 chooses to play first. [22:28:26] supergirl-type00 mulligans to six cards. [22:28:28] [CHAT] Dawnsday: Best of luck :) [22:28:32] Dawnsday begins the game with seven cards in hand. [22:28:36] supergirl-type00 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [22:28:36] Turn 1: supergirl-type00 [22:28:37] supergirl-type00 skips their draw step. [22:28:38] supergirl-type00 plays [Plains]. [22:28:41] supergirl-type00 casts [Cathedral Sanctifier]. [22:28:41] supergirl-type00 puts triggered ability from [Cathedral Sanctifier] onto the stack (When Cathedral Sanctifier enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life.). [22:28:44] Turn 1: Dawnsday [22:28:51] Dawnsday plays [Island]. [22:28:55] Turn 2: supergirl-type00 [22:28:58] supergirl-type00 plays [Restless Fortress]. [22:29:02] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:29:05] Turn 2: Dawnsday [22:29:13] Dawnsday plays [Hinterland Harbor]. [22:29:17] Turn 3: supergirl-type00 [22:29:20] supergirl-type00 plays [Plains]. [22:29:25] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:29:31] supergirl-type00 casts [Deep-Cavern Bat]. [22:29:31] supergirl-type00 puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting Dawnsday (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...). [22:29:42] Turn 3: Dawnsday [22:29:50] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Nursery]. [22:29:53] Turn 4: supergirl-type00 [22:29:57] supergirl-type00 plays [Plains]. [22:30:02] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:30:05] Turn 4: Dawnsday [22:30:13] Dawnsday plays [Captivating Cave]. [22:30:17] Turn 5: supergirl-type00 [22:30:21] supergirl-type00 plays [Isolated Chapel]. [22:30:23] supergirl-type00 casts [Ritual of Rejuvenation]. [22:30:23] supergirl-type00 draws a card with [Ritual of Rejuvenation]. [22:30:29] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:30:32] Turn 5: Dawnsday [22:30:38] Dawnsday plays [Hanweir Battlements]. [22:30:45] Turn 6: supergirl-type00 [22:30:49] supergirl-type00 plays [Caves of Koilos]. [22:30:58] supergirl-type00 casts [Divinity of Pride]. [22:31:04] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:31:08] Turn 6: Dawnsday [22:31:19] Dawnsday plays [Promising Vein]. [22:31:26] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Hidden Nursery] ( Discover 4.). [22:31:27] Dawnsday reveals 12 cards with [Hidden Nursery]'s ability: [Bad River], [Restless Vinestalk], [Hidden Nursery], [Hidden Nursery], [Forgotten Monument], [Hidden Volcano], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Pit of Offerings], [Promising Vein], [Hinterland Harbor], [22:31:27] [Grasslands], and [Shardless Agent]. [22:31:30] Dawnsday casts [Shardless Agent]. [22:31:31] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [22:31:33] Dawnsday reveals 14 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Cavernous Maw], [Hidden Volcano], [Sheltered Thicket], [Captivating Cave], [Cavernous Maw], [Promising Vein], [Bad River], [Hinterland Harbor], [Hanweir Battlements], [Shardless Agent], [22:31:33] [Hidden Cataract], [Grasslands], [Kessig Wolf Run], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [22:31:34] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Tibalt's Trickery[sU] has an advantageous bug. Tibalt's Trickery allows the person casting a spell using it to cast a spell that was milled and then exiled by an effect like Dryad MIlitant Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Tibalt's Trickery` or `!notbugged Tibalt's Trickery` [22:31:37] Dawnsday casts supergirl-type00 targeting [Shardless Agent]. [22:31:38] Dawnsday mills [Grasslands] and [Pit of Offerings]. [22:31:42] Dawnsday casts [Primal Surge]. [22:31:44] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:31:45] Dawnsday puts [Island] onto the battlefield. [22:31:46] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:31:47] Dawnsday puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [22:31:48] Dawnsday puts [Hinterland Harbor] onto the battlefield. [22:31:49] Dawnsday puts [Restless Vinestalk] onto the battlefield. [22:31:50] Dawnsday puts [Sheltered Thicket] onto the battlefield. [22:31:51] Dawnsday puts [Shardless Agent] onto the battlefield. [22:31:52] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:31:53] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:31:54] Dawnsday puts [Grasslands] onto the battlefield. [22:31:56] Dawnsday puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [22:31:57] Dawnsday puts [Pit of Offerings] onto the battlefield. [22:31:58] Dawnsday puts [Promising Vein] onto the battlefield. [22:32:00] Dawnsday puts [Restless Vinestalk] onto the battlefield. [22:32:01] Dawnsday puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [22:32:02] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Nursery] onto the battlefield. [22:32:03] Dawnsday puts [Hinterland Harbor] onto the battlefield. [22:32:04] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Nursery] onto the battlefield. [22:32:05] Dawnsday puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [22:32:07] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Volcano] onto the battlefield. [22:32:08] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Volcano] onto the battlefield. [22:32:09] Dawnsday puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [22:32:10] Dawnsday puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [22:32:11] Dawnsday puts [Hanweir Battlements] onto the battlefield. [22:32:13] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:32:14] Dawnsday puts [Promising Vein] onto the battlefield. [22:32:15] Dawnsday puts [Shardless Agent] onto the battlefield. [22:32:16] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:32:17] Dawnsday puts [Sheltered Thicket] onto the battlefield. [22:32:18] Dawnsday puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [22:32:19] Dawnsday puts [Grasslands] onto the battlefield. [22:32:20] Dawnsday puts [Hinterland Harbor] onto the battlefield. [22:32:21] Dawnsday puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [22:32:25] Dawnsday puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [22:32:26] Dawnsday puts [Forest] onto the battlefield. [22:32:33] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Pit of Offerings] onto the stack targeting [Ritual of Rejuvenation] (When Pit of Offerings enters the battlefield, exile up to three target cards from graveyards.). [22:33:00] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:33:08] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Hanweir Battlements] targeting [Cavernous Maw] ( Target creature gains haste until end of turn.). [22:33:50] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Cavernous Maw]. (X is 9) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [22:33:57] supergirl-type00 is being attacked by [Cavernous Maw] [22:34:04] Turn 7: supergirl-type00 [22:34:09] supergirl-type00 plays [Caves of Koilos]. [22:34:13] supergirl-type00 casts [Ritual of Rejuvenation]. [22:34:15] supergirl-type00 draws a card with [Ritual of Rejuvenation]. [22:34:26] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Divinity of Pride], [Deep-Cavern Bat], and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:34:30] [Shardless Agent] blocks [Cathedral Sanctifier]. [22:34:43] Turn 7: Dawnsday [22:35:10] Dawnsday plays [Cinder Glade]. [22:35:31] supergirl-type00 is being attacked by [Shardless Agent] and [Shardless Agent] [22:36:37] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Shardless Agent]. (X is 30) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [22:36:40] Dawnsday wins the game. Winner: Dawnsday Game 1 Completed. [22:36:44] Dawnsday has left the game. == Game 2 (876027210) == [Time] 1714135036 [22:37:16] PDBot has started watching. [22:37:21] supergirl-type00 mulligans to six cards. [22:37:26] Dawnsday mulligans to six cards. [22:37:29] supergirl-type00 mulligans to five cards. [22:37:31] Dawnsday mulligans to five cards. [22:37:38] supergirl-type00 puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [22:37:40] Dawnsday mulligans to four cards. [22:37:42] Dawnsday mulligans to three cards. [22:37:44] Dawnsday mulligans to two cards. [22:37:47] Dawnsday mulligans to one card. [22:37:56] Dawnsday puts six cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with one card in hand. [22:37:56] Turn 1: supergirl-type00 [22:37:58] supergirl-type00 skips their draw step. [22:38:00] supergirl-type00 plays [Plains]. [22:38:02] supergirl-type00 casts [Cathedral Sanctifier]. [22:38:02] supergirl-type00 puts triggered ability from [Cathedral Sanctifier] onto the stack (When Cathedral Sanctifier enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life.). [22:38:06] Turn 1: Dawnsday [22:38:10] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Volcano]. [22:38:13] Turn 2: supergirl-type00 [22:38:17] supergirl-type00 plays [Plains]. [22:38:22] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:38:28] Turn 2: Dawnsday [22:38:32] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Volcano]. [22:38:34] Turn 3: supergirl-type00 [22:38:38] supergirl-type00 plays [Swamp]. [22:38:44] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:38:47] Turn 3: Dawnsday [22:38:52] Dawnsday plays [Hidden Nursery]. [22:38:55] Turn 4: supergirl-type00 [22:38:58] supergirl-type00 plays [Caves of Koilos]. [22:39:01] supergirl-type00 casts [Cathedral Sanctifier]. [22:39:02] supergirl-type00 puts triggered ability from [Cathedral Sanctifier] onto the stack (When Cathedral Sanctifier enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life.). [22:39:07] supergirl-type00 casts [Deep-Cavern Bat]. [22:39:07] supergirl-type00 puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting Dawnsday (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...). [22:39:20] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:39:28] Turn 4: Dawnsday [22:39:32] Dawnsday plays [Grasslands]. [22:39:36] Turn 5: supergirl-type00 [22:39:46] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Cathedral Sanctifier], and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:39:55] supergirl-type00 casts [Tempt with Treats]. [22:39:55] supergirl-type00's [Tempt with Treats] creates a Food Token. [22:40:02] supergirl-type00 casts [Gumdrop Poisoner]. [22:40:09] supergirl-type00 puts triggered ability from [Gumdrop Poisoner] onto the stack (When Gumdrop Poisoner enters the battlefield, up to one target creature gets -X/-X until end of tu...). [22:40:13] Turn 5: Dawnsday [22:40:18] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Grasslands] ( Search your library for a Forest or Plains card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.). [22:40:33] Dawnsday plays [Bad River]. [22:40:37] Turn 6: supergirl-type00 [22:40:42] supergirl-type00 casts [Serra Ascendant]. [22:40:50] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Gumdrop Poisoner], [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Cathedral Sanctifier], and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:41:01] supergirl-type00 activates an ability of [Food Token] ( Gain 3 life.). [22:41:04] Turn 6: Dawnsday [22:41:10] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.). [22:41:13] Dawnsday plays [Island]. [22:41:19] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Hidden Nursery] ( Discover 4.). [22:41:20] Dawnsday reveals 33 cards with [Hidden Nursery]'s ability: [Forgotten Monument], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Grasslands], [Hidden Nursery], [Primal Surge], [Hanweir Battlements], [Hinterland Harbor], [Bad River], [Hinterland Harbor], [Sheltered Thicket], [22:41:20] [Promising Vein], [Island], [Grasslands], [Captivating Cave], [Pit of Offerings], [Hinterland Harbor], [Hidden Cataract], [Cavernous Maw], [Hidden Nursery], [Forest], [22:41:20] [Promising Vein], [Hinterland Harbor], [Pit of Offerings], [Forgotten Monument], [Restless Vinestalk], [Cavernous Maw], [Hidden Cataract], [Forgotten Monument], [Cavernous Maw], [Sheltered Thicket], [22:41:20] [Hanweir Battlements], [Cinder Glade], and [Shardless Agent]. [22:41:24] Dawnsday casts [Shardless Agent]. [22:41:25] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [22:41:27] Dawnsday reveals 6 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Promising Vein], [Grasslands], [Shardless Agent], [Cinder Glade], [Bad River], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [22:41:29] Dawnsday casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Shardless Agent]. [22:41:30] Dawnsday mills [Promising Vein], [Forest], and [Shardless Agent]. [22:41:33] Dawnsday casts [Primal Surge]. [22:41:42] Dawnsday puts [Promising Vein] onto the battlefield. [22:41:43] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:41:44] Dawnsday puts [Pit of Offerings] onto the battlefield. [22:41:45] Dawnsday puts [Hinterland Harbor] onto the battlefield. [22:41:46] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:41:47] Dawnsday puts [Hinterland Harbor] onto the battlefield. [22:41:47] Dawnsday puts [Island] onto the battlefield. [22:41:49] Dawnsday puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [22:41:50] Dawnsday puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [22:41:51] Dawnsday puts [Pit of Offerings] onto the battlefield. [22:41:52] Dawnsday puts [Hanweir Battlements] onto the battlefield. [22:41:54] Dawnsday puts [Restless Vinestalk] onto the battlefield. [22:41:55] Dawnsday puts [Promising Vein] onto the battlefield. [22:41:56] Dawnsday puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [22:41:58] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Nursery] onto the battlefield. [22:41:59] Dawnsday puts [Sheltered Thicket] onto the battlefield. [22:42:00] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:42:01] Dawnsday puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [22:42:02] Dawnsday puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [22:42:03] Dawnsday puts [Sheltered Thicket] onto the battlefield. [22:42:04] Dawnsday puts [Hinterland Harbor] onto the battlefield. [22:42:06] Dawnsday puts [Forest] onto the battlefield. [22:42:07] Dawnsday puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [22:42:08] Dawnsday puts [Cinder Glade] onto the battlefield. [22:42:10] Dawnsday puts [Shardless Agent] onto the battlefield. [22:42:11] Dawnsday puts [Grasslands] onto the battlefield. [22:42:12] Dawnsday puts supergirl-type00 onto the battlefield. [22:42:13] Dawnsday puts [Promising Vein] onto the battlefield. [22:42:14] Dawnsday puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [22:42:15] Dawnsday puts [Hanweir Battlements] onto the battlefield. [22:42:16] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Nursery] onto the battlefield. [22:42:18] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:42:19] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:42:20] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:42:21] Dawnsday puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [22:42:22] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Nursery] onto the battlefield. [22:42:24] Dawnsday puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [22:42:27] Dawnsday puts [Grasslands] onto the battlefield. [22:42:28] Dawnsday puts [Grasslands] onto the battlefield. [22:42:29] Dawnsday puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [22:42:31] Dawnsday puts [Captivating Cave] onto the battlefield. [22:42:37] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Pit of Offerings] onto the stack (When Pit of Offerings enters the battlefield, exile up to three target cards from graveyards.). [22:42:40] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Pit of Offerings] onto the stack (When Pit of Offerings enters the battlefield, exile up to three target cards from graveyards.). [22:42:59] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Hanweir Battlements] targeting [Shardless Agent] ( Target creature gains haste until end of turn.). [22:43:01] Placebo has started watching. [22:43:58] supergirl-type00 is being attacked by [Shardless Agent] [22:44:34] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Shardless Agent]. (X is 10) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [22:44:40] [Serra Ascendant] blocks [Shardless Agent]. [22:44:51] Turn 7: supergirl-type00 [22:44:58] supergirl-type00 casts [Serra Ascendant]. [22:45:16] Dawnsday is being attacked by [Gumdrop Poisoner], [Deep-Cavern Bat], [Cathedral Sanctifier], and [Cathedral Sanctifier] [22:45:23] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:45:34] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:45:44] [Cavernous Maw] blocks [Gumdrop Poisoner]. [22:45:46] [Cavernous Maw] blocks [Cathedral Sanctifier]. [22:45:55] Turn 7: Dawnsday [22:46:02] Dawnsday plays [Hinterland Harbor]. [22:46:33] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Restless Vinestalk] ( Until end of turn, Restless Vinestalk becomes a 5/5 green and blue Plant creature with trample. I...). [22:46:46] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:46:59] supergirl-type00 is being attacked by [Restless Vinestalk] and [Cavernous Maw] [22:47:07] Dawnsday puts triggered ability from [Restless Vinestalk] onto the stack targeting [Cavernous Maw] (Whenever Restless Vinestalk attacks, up to one other target creature has base power and toughness ...). [22:47:16] [Serra Ascendant] blocks [Restless Vinestalk]. [22:48:51] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Restless Vinestalk]. (X is 27) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [22:49:02] Turn 8: supergirl-type00 [22:49:19] Turn 8: Dawnsday [22:49:23] Dawnsday plays [Cavernous Maw]. [22:49:24] Placebo has stopped watching. [22:49:34] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:49:50] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:50:03] supergirl-type00 is being attacked by [Cavernous Maw] [22:50:49] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Cavernous Maw]. (X is 22) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [22:50:53] supergirl-type00 casts [Path to Exile] targeting [Cavernous Maw]. [22:51:00] Dawnsday's Kessig Wolf Run is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [22:51:12] Turn 9: supergirl-type00 [22:51:14] supergirl-type00 plays [Swamp]. [22:51:24] supergirl-type00 casts [Divinity of Pride]. [22:51:36] Turn 9: Dawnsday [22:51:41] Dawnsday plays [Restless Vinestalk]. [22:51:51] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Cavernous Maw] ( Cavernous Maw becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature until end of turn. It's still a Cave land.). [22:52:33] Dawnsday activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Cavernous Maw]. (X is 32) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [22:52:38] supergirl-type00 is being attacked by [Cavernous Maw] [22:52:42] [Cathedral Sanctifier] blocks [Cavernous Maw]. [22:52:43] [Divinity of Pride] blocks [Cavernous Maw]. [22:52:47] Blockers for [Cavernous Maw] are ordered as follows: [Cathedral Sanctifier], [Divinity of Pride] [22:52:51] Dawnsday wins the game. [22:52:51] supergirl-type00 loses the game. Winner: Dawnsday Game 2 Completed. Match Winner: Dawnsday: 2–0 [22:52:51] [CHAT] supergirl-type00: good game [22:52:56] supergirl-type00 has left the game.