PennyDreadful PD Sunday R4 vs TheWatchWander BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney forgetti,TheWatchWander == Game 1 (874315460) == [Time] 1712521084 [06:18:05] PDBot has started watching. [Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 32.08 [Gatherling] Round=4 [06:18:23] forgetti chooses to play first. [06:18:26] [CHAT] forgetti: gl hf [06:18:29] forgetti begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:18:32] TheWatchWander mulligans to six cards. [06:18:43] [CHAT] TheWatchWander: gl [06:18:47] TheWatchWander puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [06:18:47] Turn 1: forgetti [06:18:48] forgetti skips their draw step. [06:18:50] forgetti plays [Swamp]. [06:18:53] Turn 1: TheWatchWander [06:18:55] TheWatchWander plays [Shivan Reef]. [06:19:01] Turn 2: forgetti [06:19:05] forgetti plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [06:19:08] forgetti casts [Pack Rat]. [06:19:12] TheWatchWander discards [Imposing Vantasaur]. [06:19:12] TheWatchWander cycles [Imposing Vantasaur]. [06:19:15] Turn 2: TheWatchWander [06:19:20] TheWatchWander discards [Hieroglyphic Illumination]. [06:19:20] TheWatchWander cycles [Hieroglyphic Illumination]. [06:19:23] TheWatchWander plays [Island]. [06:19:26] Turn 3: forgetti [06:19:29] forgetti plays [Swamp]. [06:19:33] TheWatchWander is being attacked by [Pack Rat] [06:19:40] Turn 3: TheWatchWander [06:19:47] TheWatchWander discards [Curator of Mysteries]. [06:19:47] TheWatchWander cycles [Curator of Mysteries]. [06:19:50] TheWatchWander plays [Island]. [06:20:07] forgetti discards [Pack Rat]. [06:20:07] forgetti activates an ability of [Pack Rat] ( Create a token that's a copy of Pack Rat.). [06:20:09] TheWatchWander casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:20:12] forgetti's [Pack Rat] creates a Pack Rat. [06:20:13] Turn 4: forgetti [06:20:20] forgetti plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [06:20:25] forgetti casts [Deep-Cavern Bat]. [06:20:25] forgetti puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting TheWatchWander (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...). [06:20:37] TheWatchWander is being attacked by [Pack Rat] and [Pack Rat] [06:20:39] [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] blocks [Pack Rat]. [06:20:47] Turn 4: TheWatchWander [06:20:50] TheWatchWander casts [Assault] targeting [Pack Rat]. [06:20:56] forgetti casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Assault]. [06:21:08] TheWatchWander casts [Discovery]. [06:21:12] TheWatchWander puts [Assault/Battery] and [Forbid] into their graveyard. [06:21:12] TheWatchWander draws a card with [Discovery]. [06:21:17] Turn 5: forgetti [06:21:22] TheWatchWander is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] and [Pack Rat] [06:21:25] Turn 5: TheWatchWander [06:21:36] forgetti casts [Sauron's Ransom]. [06:21:36] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sauron's Ransom[sU] has an advantageous bug. Sauron's Ransom shows whether face down cards are white-bordered [06:21:45] TheWatchWander discards [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:21:45] TheWatchWander discards [Bridge from Below]. [06:21:45] TheWatchWander casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Sauron's Ransom]. [06:21:51] Turn 6: forgetti [06:21:57] TheWatchWander is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] and [Pack Rat] [06:22:02] forgetti plays [Island]. [06:22:04] Turn 6: TheWatchWander [06:22:13] TheWatchWander casts [Discovery]. [06:22:20] forgetti casts [Unwind] targeting [Discovery]. [06:22:23] TheWatchWander has conceded from the game. [06:22:23] forgetti wins the game. Winner: forgetti Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (874316296) == [Time] 1712521446 [06:24:06] PDBot has started watching. [06:24:08] TheWatchWander chooses to play first. [06:24:11] TheWatchWander begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:24:15] forgetti begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:24:15] Turn 1: TheWatchWander [06:24:15] TheWatchWander skips their draw step. [06:24:18] TheWatchWander plays [Island]. [06:24:23] Turn 1: forgetti [06:24:27] forgetti plays [Fetid Pools]. [06:24:35] TheWatchWander discards [Hieroglyphic Illumination]. [06:24:35] TheWatchWander cycles [Hieroglyphic Illumination]. [06:24:36] Turn 2: TheWatchWander [06:24:38] TheWatchWander plays [Sulfur Falls]. [06:24:40] Turn 2: forgetti [06:24:44] forgetti plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [06:24:48] forgetti casts [Deep-Cavern Bat]. [06:24:56] TheWatchWander casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:24:59] forgetti puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting TheWatchWander (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...). [06:25:16] Turn 3: TheWatchWander [06:25:18] TheWatchWander plays [Island]. [06:25:19] TheWatchWander casts [Altar of Dementia]. [06:25:26] Turn 3: forgetti [06:25:32] forgetti plays [Island]. [06:25:34] forgetti casts [Mistcaller]. [06:25:39] forgetti casts [The Reality Chip]. [06:25:44] Turn 4: TheWatchWander [06:25:46] TheWatchWander plays [Island]. [06:25:55] forgetti is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] [06:25:59] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] onto the stack (Whenever Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel deals combat damage to a player, put a chorus counter on it. ...). [06:26:00] TheWatchWander puts a chorus counter on [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:26:00] TheWatchWander draws a card with [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]'s ability. [06:26:02] TheWatchWander discards [Bridge from Below]. [06:26:04] TheWatchWander casts [Sphinx of Foresight]. [06:26:11] Turn 4: forgetti [06:26:23] forgetti activates an ability of [The Reality Chip] targeting [Deep-Cavern Bat] (Reconfigure {2U} - Attach). [06:26:26] forgetti plays [Swamp]. [06:26:31] Turn 5: TheWatchWander [06:26:31] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Sphinx of Foresight] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, scry 1.). [06:26:34] TheWatchWander scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom). [06:26:39] forgetti is being attacked by [Sphinx of Foresight] and [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] [06:26:43] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] onto the stack (Whenever Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel deals combat damage to a player, put a chorus counter on it. ...). [06:26:44] TheWatchWander puts a chorus counter on [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:26:44] TheWatchWander draws a card with [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]'s ability. [06:26:46] TheWatchWander discards [Island]. [06:26:50] Turn 5: forgetti [06:26:56] forgetti casts [Long Goodbye] targeting [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:27:05] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:27:05] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:27:11] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:27:16] TheWatchWander mills [Sphinx of Foresight] and [Cascade Bluffs]. [06:27:19] forgetti's [Long Goodbye] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [06:27:24] forgetti plays [Swamp]. [06:27:29] TheWatchWander is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] [06:27:34] TheWatchWander discards [Curator of Mysteries]. [06:27:34] TheWatchWander cycles [Curator of Mysteries]. [06:27:52] TheWatchWander discards [Curator of Mysteries]. [06:27:52] TheWatchWander cycles [Curator of Mysteries]. [06:28:00] TheWatchWander casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:28:08] forgetti casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:28:11] Turn 6: TheWatchWander [06:28:11] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Sphinx of Foresight] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, scry 1.). [06:28:14] TheWatchWander scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom). [06:28:16] TheWatchWander casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:28:21] forgetti is being attacked by [Zombie Token] and [Sphinx of Foresight] [06:28:38] Turn 6: forgetti [06:28:53] forgetti casts [Long Goodbye] targeting [Zombie Token]. [06:28:58] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:29:00] TheWatchWander mills [Lamplight Phoenix] and forgetti. [06:29:02] forgetti's [Long Goodbye] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [06:29:04] forgetti plays [Island]. [06:29:29] Turn 7: TheWatchWander [06:29:29] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Sphinx of Foresight] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, scry 1.). [06:29:33] TheWatchWander scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom). [06:29:38] forgetti is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] and [Sphinx of Foresight] [06:29:56] [Deep-Cavern Bat] blocks [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:30:03] forgetti activates an ability of [Mistcaller] ( Until end of turn, if a nontoken creature would enter the battlefield and it wasn't cast, exile i...). [06:30:03] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (When a creature is put into an opponent's graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below is ...). [06:30:08] TheWatchWander exiles [Bridge from Below] with its own ability. [06:30:19] TheWatchWander plays [Mountain]. [06:30:28] forgetti casts [Sauron's Ransom]. [06:31:03] forgetti is tempted by the Ring. [The Reality Chip] becomes their Ring-bearer. [06:31:10] Turn 7: forgetti [06:31:14] forgetti casts [Duress] targeting TheWatchWander. [06:31:49] forgetti has conceded from the game. [06:31:50] TheWatchWander wins the game. Winner: TheWatchWander Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (874317352) == [Time] 1712521946 [06:32:27] PDBot has started watching. [06:32:34] TheWatchWander begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:32:36] TheWatchWander reveals [Sphinx of Foresight] from their opening hand. [06:32:37] Turn 1: forgetti [06:32:39] forgetti skips their draw step. [06:32:41] forgetti plays [Island]. [06:32:44] Turn 1: TheWatchWander [06:32:44] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Sphinx of Foresight] onto the stack (Scry 3 at the beginning of your first upkeep.). [06:32:52] TheWatchWander scrys 3 (1 top, 2 bottom). [06:32:53] TheWatchWander plays [Island]. [06:32:56] Turn 2: forgetti [06:33:01] forgetti plays [Swamp]. [06:33:04] forgetti casts [Deep-Cavern Bat]. [06:33:11] forgetti puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting TheWatchWander (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...). [06:33:31] TheWatchWander discards [Imposing Vantasaur]. [06:33:32] TheWatchWander cycles [Imposing Vantasaur]. [06:33:35] Turn 2: TheWatchWander [06:33:36] TheWatchWander plays [Sulfur Falls]. [06:33:43] Turn 3: forgetti [06:33:53] TheWatchWander is being attacked by [Deep-Cavern Bat] [06:34:01] TheWatchWander casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:34:05] Turn 3: TheWatchWander [06:34:12] forgetti is being attacked by [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] [06:34:15] forgetti casts [Long Goodbye] targeting [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel]. [06:34:17] TheWatchWander plays [Mountain]. [06:34:19] TheWatchWander casts [Lamplight Phoenix]. [06:34:21] Turn 4: forgetti [06:34:33] forgetti plays [Drowned Catacomb]. [06:34:37] forgetti casts [Deep-Cavern Bat]. [06:34:40] forgetti puts triggered ability from [Deep-Cavern Bat] onto the stack targeting TheWatchWander (When Deep-Cavern Bat enters the battlefield, look at target opponent's hand. You may exile a nonla...). [06:34:56] Turn 4: TheWatchWander [06:35:13] TheWatchWander casts [Altar of Dementia]. [06:35:17] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:35:18] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:35:27] TheWatchWander mills [Abrade], [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel], and [Shivan Reef]. [06:35:30] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:35:30] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:35:39] TheWatchWander mills [Mountain], [Bridge from Below], and [Cascade Bluffs]. [06:35:45] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:35:46] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:35:46] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:35:48] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:35:52] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:35:53] TheWatchWander mills [Spell Pierce] and [Altar of Dementia]. [06:36:01] TheWatchWander mills [Abrade], [Imposing Vantasaur], and [Memory Lapse]. [06:36:04] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:36:06] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:36:06] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:36:07] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:36:14] TheWatchWander mills [Sulfur Falls], [Memory Lapse], and [Mountain]. [06:36:17] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:36:19] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:36:19] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:36:19] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:36:29] TheWatchWander mills [Sulfur Falls], [Sphinx of Foresight], and [Bridge from Below]. [06:36:32] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:36:33] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:36:33] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:36:33] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:36:34] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:36:35] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:36:41] TheWatchWander mills [Shivan Reef], [Hieroglyphic Illumination], and [Island]. [06:36:44] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:36:45] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:36:46] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:36:46] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:36:46] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:36:47] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:36:55] TheWatchWander mills [Cascade Bluffs], [Lamplight Phoenix], and [Repeal]. [06:36:58] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:36:59] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:37:00] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:00] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:00] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:01] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:08] TheWatchWander mills [Bridge from Below], [Sulfur Falls], and [Dig Through Time]. [06:37:11] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:37:12] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:37:12] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:12] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:13] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:13] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:14] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:14] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:20] TheWatchWander mills [Curator of Mysteries], [Shivan Reef], and [Discovery/Dispersal]. [06:37:23] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting TheWatchWander ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:37:24] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:37:25] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:25] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:25] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:25] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:26] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:26] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:33] TheWatchWander mills [Assault/Battery], [Cascade Bluffs], and [Memory Lapse]. [06:37:36] TheWatchWander activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting forgetti ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.). [06:37:38] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...). [06:37:38] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:38] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:38] TheWatchWander puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...). [06:37:39] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:39] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:40] TheWatchWander's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token. [06:37:49] forgetti mills [Swamp], [Hostage Taker], and [Memory Lapse]. [06:37:51] forgetti has conceded from the game. [06:37:51] TheWatchWander wins the game. Winner: TheWatchWander Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: TheWatchWander: 2–1 [06:37:59] TheWatchWander has left the game. [06:38:06] forgetti draws their next card. [06:38:06] forgetti draws their next card. [06:38:07] forgetti draws their next card.