PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality HeWhoSpeaksToHimself,swamp_thing == Game 1 (871996194) == [Time] 1710707021 [07:23:42] PDBot has started watching. [07:23:44] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself chooses to play first. [League] Vadrok Foretold by hewhospeakstohimself (238186) vs Grugrugru by swamp_thing (238167) [07:23:45] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [07:23:46] [CHAT] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself: gl hf! [07:23:50] [CHAT] swamp_thing: u2 [07:23:53] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:23:57] swamp_thing begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:23:57] Turn 1: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:23:59] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself skips their draw step. [07:24:00] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Irrigated Farmland]. [07:24:07] Turn 1: swamp_thing [07:24:11] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:24:15] Turn 2: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:24:18] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Mystic Gate]. [07:24:26] Turn 2: swamp_thing [07:24:31] swamp_thing plays [Fire-Lit Thicket]. [07:24:36] Turn 3: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:24:40] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself exiles [Ancestral Vision] with 4 time counters. [07:24:41] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts four time counters on [Ancestral Vision]. [07:24:42] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Mystic Gate]. [07:24:50] Turn 3: swamp_thing [07:24:54] swamp_thing plays [Rootbound Crag]. [07:24:58] swamp_thing casts [Tireless Tracker]. [07:25:04] Turn 4: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:25:04] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Ancestral Vision] onto the stack (Suspend 4{U} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [07:25:11] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself removes a time counter from [Ancestral Vision]. [07:25:22] Turn 4: swamp_thing [07:25:25] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:25:25] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, investigate.). [07:25:29] swamp_thing investigates. [07:25:29] swamp_thing's [Tireless Tracker] creates a Clue Token. [07:25:37] swamp_thing casts [Bloodbraid Elf]. [07:25:37] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Bloodbraid Elf] onto the stack (Cascade). [07:25:41] swamp_thing reveals 2 cards with [Bloodbraid Elf]: [Rootbound Crag] and [Birds of Paradise]. [07:25:45] swamp_thing casts [Birds of Paradise]. [07:25:54] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself is being attacked by [Bloodbraid Elf] and [Tireless Tracker] [07:26:02] Turn 5: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:26:03] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Ancestral Vision] onto the stack (Suspend 4{U} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [07:26:05] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself removes a time counter from [Ancestral Vision]. [07:26:13] Turn 5: swamp_thing [07:26:18] swamp_thing plays [Rootbound Crag]. [07:26:18] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, investigate.). [07:26:20] swamp_thing investigates. [07:26:20] swamp_thing's [Tireless Tracker] creates a Clue Token. [07:26:25] swamp_thing casts [Geological Appraiser]. [07:26:27] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.). [07:26:31] swamp_thing reveals [Atarka's Command] with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability. [07:26:31] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Atarka's Command[sU] has a graphical bug. The "can't gain life" or "damage can't be prevented" effect doesn't appear in the Effect zone after the spell/ability resolves. Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Atarka's Command` or `!notbugged Atarka's Command` [07:26:38] swamp_thing casts [Atarka's Command]. [07:26:38] Chosen mode: Atarka's Command deals 3 damage to each opponent. [07:26:38] Chosen mode: Creatures you control get +1/+1 and gain reach until end of turn. [07:26:38] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself has conceded from the game. [07:26:38] swamp_thing wins the game. Winner: swamp_thing Game 1 Completed. [07:26:41] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself has left the game. == Game 2 (871996620) == [Time] 1710707228 [07:27:08] PDBot has started watching. [07:27:14] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself chooses to play first. [07:27:19] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:27:21] swamp_thing begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:27:21] Turn 1: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:27:22] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself skips their draw step. [07:27:24] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Island]. [07:27:29] Turn 1: swamp_thing [07:27:32] swamp_thing plays [Forest]. [07:27:33] swamp_thing casts [Birds of Paradise]. [07:27:38] Turn 2: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:27:41] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Battlefield Forge]. [07:27:47] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself discards [Glacial Fortress]. [07:27:47] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Thrill of Possibility]. [07:27:49] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself draws two cards with [Thrill of Possibility]. [07:27:56] Turn 2: swamp_thing [07:27:59] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:28:03] swamp_thing casts [Courser of Kruphix]. [07:28:12] Turn 3: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:28:54] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Glacial Fortress]. [07:28:58] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Geist of Saint Traft]. [07:29:10] Turn 3: swamp_thing [07:29:14] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:29:14] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:29:24] swamp_thing casts [Domri Rade]. [07:29:40] swamp_thing puts a loyalty counter on [Domri Rade]. [07:29:40] swamp_thing activates an ability of [Domri Rade] ( Look at the top card of your library. If it's a creature card, you may reveal it and put it into ...). [07:29:49] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself is being attacked by [Courser of Kruphix] [07:30:00] Turn 4: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:30:23] swamp_thing is being attacked by [Geist of Saint Traft] [07:30:23] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Geist of Saint Traft] onto the stack (Whenever Geist of Saint Traft attacks, create a 4/4 white Angel creature token with flying that's ...). [07:30:30] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself's [Geist of Saint Traft] creates an Angel Token. [07:30:32] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking [Domri Rade] [07:30:36] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Lightning Helix] targeting [Birds of Paradise]. [07:30:47] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself removes four loyalty counters from [Domri Rade]. [07:30:48] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Geist of Saint Traft] onto the stack (Exile Angel Token at end of combat.). [07:31:04] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Irrigated Farmland]. [07:31:08] Turn 4: swamp_thing [07:31:17] swamp_thing casts [Tireless Tracker]. [07:31:22] swamp_thing plays [Forest]. [07:31:24] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:31:24] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, investigate.). [07:31:27] swamp_thing investigates. [07:31:27] swamp_thing's [Tireless Tracker] creates a Clue Token. [07:31:34] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself is being attacked by [Courser of Kruphix] [07:31:40] Turn 5: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:31:47] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Shivan Reef]. [07:31:54] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] for its mutate cost targeting [Geist of Saint Traft]. [07:32:00] [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] merges with [Geist of Saint Traft] on the top of the mutated creature. (It is now a [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] with [Geist of Saint Traft] below it.) [07:32:03] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] onto the stack targeting [Lightning Helix] (Whenever this creature mutates, you may cast target noncreature card with mana value 3 or less fro...). [07:32:14] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Lightning Helix] from the graveyard targeting [Tireless Tracker]. [07:32:21] swamp_thing is being attacked by [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] [07:32:21] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] onto the stack (Whenever this creature attacks, create a 4/4 white Angel creature token with flying that's tapped ...). [07:32:24] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself's [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] creates an Angel Token. [07:32:24] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking swamp_thing [07:32:30] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] onto the stack (Exile Angel Token at end of combat.). [07:32:37] Turn 5: swamp_thing [07:32:41] swamp_thing plays [Fire-Lit Thicket]. [07:32:42] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:32:47] swamp_thing casts [Geological Appraiser]. [07:32:49] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.). [07:32:52] swamp_thing reveals 3 cards with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability: [Raging Ravine], [Rootbound Crag], and [Atarka's Command]. [07:33:00] swamp_thing casts [Atarka's Command]. [07:33:00] Chosen mode: Atarka's Command deals 3 damage to each opponent. [07:33:00] Chosen mode: Creatures you control get +1/+1 and gain reach until end of turn. [07:33:10] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself is being attacked by [Courser of Kruphix] [07:33:22] Turn 6: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:33:37] swamp_thing is being attacked by [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] [07:33:38] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] onto the stack (Whenever this creature attacks, create a 4/4 white Angel creature token with flying that's tapped ...). [07:33:41] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself's [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] creates an Angel Token. [07:33:41] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts [Angel Token] onto the battlefield attacking swamp_thing [07:33:54] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] onto the stack (Exile Angel Token at end of combat.). [07:34:01] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Geist of Saint Traft]. [07:34:08] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Frostburn Weird]. [07:34:12] Turn 6: swamp_thing [07:34:15] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:34:16] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:34:21] swamp_thing casts [Geological Appraiser]. [07:34:22] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.). [07:34:22] swamp_thing reveals [Kari Zev, Skyship Raider] with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability. [07:34:25] swamp_thing casts [Kari Zev, Skyship Raider]. [07:34:37] swamp_thing activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.). [07:34:38] swamp_thing draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability. [07:34:41] swamp_thing has conceded from the game. [07:34:41] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself wins the game. Winner: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (871997584) == [Time] 1710707768 [07:36:09] PDBot has started watching. [07:36:10] swamp_thing joined the game. [07:36:17] swamp_thing chooses to play first. [07:36:21] swamp_thing mulligans to six cards. [07:36:23] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:36:27] swamp_thing puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [07:36:27] Turn 1: swamp_thing [07:36:29] swamp_thing skips their draw step. [07:36:31] swamp_thing plays [Forest]. [07:36:33] Turn 1: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:36:36] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Sulfur Falls]. [07:36:42] Turn 2: swamp_thing [07:36:45] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:36:48] Turn 2: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:36:50] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Mystic Gate]. [07:37:01] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Frostburn Weird]. [07:37:06] Turn 3: swamp_thing [07:37:08] swamp_thing plays [Forest]. [07:37:11] swamp_thing casts [Courser of Kruphix]. [07:37:16] Turn 3: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:37:21] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Sulfur Falls]. [07:37:27] Turn 4: swamp_thing [07:37:32] swamp_thing plays [Rootbound Crag]. [07:37:32] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:37:40] swamp_thing casts [Bloodbraid Elf]. [07:37:40] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Bloodbraid Elf] onto the stack (Cascade). [07:37:43] swamp_thing reveals [Atarka's Command] with [Bloodbraid Elf]. [07:37:53] swamp_thing casts [Atarka's Command]. [07:37:53] Chosen mode: Atarka's Command deals 3 damage to each opponent. [07:37:53] Chosen mode: Creatures you control get +1/+1 and gain reach until end of turn. [07:38:03] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself is being attacked by [Bloodbraid Elf] and [Courser of Kruphix] [07:38:10] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself discards [Ancestral Vision]. [07:38:10] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Thrill of Possibility]. [07:38:11] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself draws two cards with [Thrill of Possibility]. [07:38:15] [Frostburn Weird] blocks [Bloodbraid Elf]. [07:38:21] Turn 4: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:38:25] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Island]. [07:38:32] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Madcap Experiment]. [07:38:34] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself reveals 13 cards with [Madcap Experiment]: [Shivan Reef], [Mystic Gate], [Glacial Fortress], [Geist of Saint Traft], [Mystic Gate], [Island], [As Foretold], [Geist of Saint Traft], [Cascade Bluffs], [Lightning Helix], [07:38:34] [Glacial Fortress], [Shivan Reef], and [Platinum Emperion]. [07:38:35] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]As Foretold[sU] has an advantageous bug. Disrupting Shoal counters spells of any mana value when cast from As Foretold Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged As Foretold` or `!notbugged As Foretold` [07:38:35] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Platinum Emperion[sU] has a disadvantageous bug. If you control Platinum Emperion you cannot even pay 0 life for costs. [07:38:43] Turn 5: swamp_thing [07:38:46] swamp_thing plays [Fire-Lit Thicket]. [07:38:46] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:39:11] Turn 5: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:39:22] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Madcap Experiment]. [07:39:24] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself reveals 20 cards with [Madcap Experiment]: [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder], [Thrill of Possibility], [Mystic Gate], [Inevitable Betrayal], [Inevitable Betrayal], [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder], [Lightning Helix], [Glacial Fortress], [Ancestral Vision], [Madcap Experiment], [07:39:24] [Geist of Saint Traft], [Lightning Helix], [Burst Lightning], [Lightning Helix], [Island], [Madcap Experiment], [Shivan Reef], [General Ferrous Rokiric], [As Foretold], and [Platinum Emperion]. [07:39:26] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays HeWhoSpeaksToHimself. [07:39:34] Turn 6: swamp_thing [07:39:38] swamp_thing plays [Mountain]. [07:39:38] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:39:44] swamp_thing casts [Geological Appraiser]. [07:39:45] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.). [07:39:49] swamp_thing reveals [Migloz, Maze Crusher] with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability. [07:39:51] swamp_thing casts [Migloz, Maze Crusher]. [07:39:57] swamp_thing casts [Birds of Paradise]. [07:40:06] Turn 6: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:40:27] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Cascade Bluffs]. [07:40:47] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] for its mutate cost targeting [Frostburn Weird]. [07:40:57] [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] merges with [Frostburn Weird] on the bottom of the mutated creature. (It is now a [Frostburn Weird] with [Vadrok, Apex of Thunder] below it.) [07:41:01] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [Frostburn Weird] onto the stack targeting [Ancestral Vision] (Whenever this creature mutates, you may cast target noncreature card with mana value 3 or less fro...). [07:41:08] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Ancestral Vision] from the graveyard targeting HeWhoSpeaksToHimself. [07:41:09] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself draws three cards with [Ancestral Vision]. [07:41:25] Turn 7: swamp_thing [07:41:29] swamp_thing plays [Raging Ravine]. [07:41:29] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:41:39] swamp_thing removes three oil counters from [Migloz, Maze Crusher]. [07:41:40] swamp_thing activates an ability of [Migloz, Maze Crusher] targeting [Platinum Emperion] ( Destroy target artifact or enchantment.). [07:41:54] swamp_thing casts [Geological Appraiser]. [07:41:56] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.). [07:41:58] swamp_thing reveals 2 cards with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability: [Raging Ravine] and [Birds of Paradise]. [07:42:01] swamp_thing casts [Birds of Paradise]. [07:42:18] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself discards [Cascade Bluffs]. [07:42:18] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Thrill of Possibility]. [07:42:21] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself draws two cards with [Thrill of Possibility]. [07:42:22] Turn 7: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:42:44] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [General Ferrous Rokiric]. [07:42:48] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Mountain]. [07:42:53] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Frostburn Weird]. [07:42:53] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself puts triggered ability from [General Ferrous Rokiric] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a multicolored spell, create a 4/4 red and white Golem artifact creature token.). [07:42:58] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself's [General Ferrous Rokiric] creates a Golem Token. [07:43:06] swamp_thing is being attacked by [Frostburn Weird] [07:43:18] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself activates an ability of [Frostburn Weird] ( Frostburn Weird gets +1/-1 until end of turn.). [07:43:27] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself activates an ability of [Frostburn Weird] ( Frostburn Weird gets +1/-1 until end of turn.). [07:43:35] Turn 8: swamp_thing [07:43:41] swamp_thing casts [Bloodbraid Elf]. [07:43:41] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Bloodbraid Elf] onto the stack (Cascade). [07:43:42] swamp_thing reveals 2 cards with [Bloodbraid Elf]: [Bloodbraid Elf] and [Gruul Spellbreaker]. [07:43:45] swamp_thing casts [Gruul Spellbreaker]. [07:43:47] swamp_thing chooses to add a counter for [Gruul Spellbreaker] [07:43:52] swamp_thing plays [Raging Ravine]. [07:43:52] swamp_thing puts triggered ability from [Courser of Kruphix] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.). [07:44:01] swamp_thing discards [Sheltered Thicket]. [07:44:01] swamp_thing cycles [Sheltered Thicket]. [07:44:07] swamp_thing casts [Kari Zev, Skyship Raider]. [07:44:15] Turn 8: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself [07:44:23] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [As Foretold]. [07:44:36] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Ancestral Vision] using an alternate cost targeting HeWhoSpeaksToHimself. [07:44:48] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself draws three cards with [Ancestral Vision]. [07:44:53] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [As Foretold]. [07:44:59] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself casts [Inevitable Betrayal] using an alternate cost targeting swamp_thing. [07:45:07] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself plays [Island]. [07:45:10] swamp_thing has conceded from the game. [07:45:10] HeWhoSpeaksToHimself wins the game. Winner: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: HeWhoSpeaksToHimself: 2–1