PennyDreadful
pd vs cheiffireball
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Cheiffireball,Chandogg

== Game 1 (871131450) ==
[Time] 1709944534
[11:35:35] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 32.04
[Gatherling] Round=2
[11:35:39] Chandogg chooses to play first.
[11:35:44] [CHAT] Cheiffireball: gl hf
[11:35:45] Chandogg begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:35:57] Cheiffireball begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:35:57] Turn 1: Chandogg
[11:35:59] Chandogg skips their draw step.
[11:36:00] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:36:07] Chandogg casts [Bone Saw].
[11:36:13] Chandogg casts [Wayward Guide-Beast].
[11:36:19] Turn 1: Cheiffireball
[11:36:24] Cheiffireball plays [Ghitu Encampment].
[11:36:28] Turn 2: Chandogg
[11:36:32] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:36:36] Chandogg casts [Bone Saw].
[11:36:41] Chandogg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast] (Equip {1}).
[11:36:49] Chandogg casts [Reckless Charge] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast].
[11:36:55] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:37:00] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:37:04] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:37:11] Turn 2: Cheiffireball
[11:37:17] Cheiffireball plays [Mountain].
[11:37:21] Turn 3: Chandogg
[11:37:24] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:37:28] Chandogg casts [Vexing Devil].
[11:37:30] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Vexing Devil] onto the stack (When Vexing Devil enters the battlefield, any opponent may have it deal 4 damage to them. If a pla...).
[11:37:46] Chandogg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast] (Equip {1}).
[11:37:53] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:37:57] Cheiffireball discards [Timeless Dragon].
[11:37:58] Cheiffireball cycles [Timeless Dragon].
[11:38:01] Cheiffireball reveals [Plains].
[11:38:05] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:38:09] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:38:17] Turn 3: Cheiffireball
[11:38:22] Cheiffireball plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[11:38:31] Turn 4: Chandogg
[11:38:35] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:38:43] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:38:47] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:38:51] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:39:05] Cheiffireball casts [Have for Dinner].
[11:39:06] Cheiffireball's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[11:39:06] Cheiffireball's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[11:39:12] Turn 4: Cheiffireball
[11:39:27] Cheiffireball plays [Plains].
[11:39:32] Cheiffireball casts [Etali's Favor] targeting [Human Token].
[11:39:38] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[11:39:41] Cheiffireball reveals 5 cards with [Etali's Favor]'s ability: [Chancellor of the Forge], [Chancellor of the Forge], [Mountain], [Mountain], and [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:39:42] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Chancellor of the Forge[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If multiple Chancellor of the Forge triggers would create many (200+) tokens, the game may reset
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Chancellor of the Forge` or `!notbugged Chancellor of the Forge`
[11:39:45] Cheiffireball casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:39:45] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Glimpse of Tomorrow[sU] has a graphical bug.
Glimpse of tomorrow doesn't reveal nonpermanent cards.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Glimpse of Tomorrow` or `!notbugged Glimpse of Tomorrow`
[11:39:51] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Ogre Battledriver] onto the stack (Whenever another creature enters the battlefield under your control, that creature gets +2/+0 and ...).
[11:40:25] Cheiffireball casts [Have for Dinner].
[11:40:28] Cheiffireball's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[11:40:28] Cheiffireball's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[11:40:29] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Ogre Battledriver] onto the stack (Whenever another creature enters the battlefield under your control, that creature gets +2/+0 and ...).
[11:40:54] Chandogg is being attacked by [Human Token] and [Devouring Sugarmaw]
[11:41:03] Turn 5: Chandogg
[11:41:13] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:41:34] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:41:34] Cheiffireball has conceded from the game.
[11:41:34] Chandogg wins the game.
Winner: Chandogg
Game 1 Completed.
[11:41:38] Cheiffireball has left the game.

== Game 2 (871132058) ==
[Time] 1709944963
[11:42:43] PDBot has started watching.
[11:42:48] Cheiffireball mulligans to six cards.
[11:42:50] Chandogg mulligans to six cards.
[11:42:59] Cheiffireball puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[11:43:14] Chandogg puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[11:43:17] Cheiffireball reveals [Chancellor of the Forge] from their opening hand.
[11:43:18] Turn 1: Cheiffireball
[11:43:18] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (At the beginning of the first upkeep, create a 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature token with haste.).
[11:43:21] Cheiffireball's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates a Phyrexian Goblin Token.
[11:43:23] Cheiffireball skips their draw step.
[11:43:25] Cheiffireball plays [Ghitu Encampment].
[11:43:28] Chandogg is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[11:43:32] Turn 1: Chandogg
[11:43:36] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:43:38] Chandogg casts [Fervent Champion].
[11:43:41] Chandogg casts [Bone Saw].
[11:43:45] Chandogg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Fervent Champion] (Equip {1}).
[11:43:51] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[11:43:51] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[11:43:57] Turn 2: Cheiffireball
[11:44:02] Cheiffireball plays [Kher Keep].
[11:44:07] Chandogg is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[11:44:11] Turn 2: Chandogg
[11:44:15] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:44:17] Chandogg casts [Bone Saw].
[11:44:21] Chandogg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Fervent Champion] (Equip {1}).
[11:44:26] Chandogg casts [Wayward Guide-Beast].
[11:44:30] Chandogg casts [Vexing Devil].
[11:44:33] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Vexing Devil] onto the stack (When Vexing Devil enters the battlefield, any opponent may have it deal 4 damage to them. If a pla...).
[11:44:50] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast] and [Fervent Champion]
[11:44:50] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[11:44:54] Cheiffireball discards [Twinshot Sniper].
[11:44:54] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Twinshot Sniper] targeting [Fervent Champion] ( Twinshot Sniper deals 2 damage to any target.).
[11:45:10] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:45:13] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:45:20] Turn 3: Cheiffireball
[11:45:26] Cheiffireball plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[11:45:31] Chandogg is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[11:45:35] Turn 3: Chandogg
[11:45:41] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:45:47] Chandogg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast] (Equip {1}).
[11:45:52] Chandogg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast] (Equip {1}).
[11:45:58] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:46:03] Cheiffireball discards [Twinshot Sniper].
[11:46:03] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Twinshot Sniper] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast] ( Twinshot Sniper deals 2 damage to any target.).
[11:46:09] Turn 4: Cheiffireball
[11:46:18] Chandogg is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[11:46:26] Turn 4: Chandogg
[11:46:30] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:46:43] Cheiffireball casts [Have for Dinner].
[11:46:45] Cheiffireball's [Have for Dinner] creates a Human Token.
[11:46:45] Cheiffireball's [Have for Dinner] creates a Food Token.
[11:46:47] Turn 5: Cheiffireball
[11:46:53] Cheiffireball plays [Mountain].
[11:47:09] Cheiffireball casts [Geological Appraiser].
[11:47:15] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.).
[11:47:23] Chandogg casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Geological Appraiser].
[11:47:29] Cheiffireball reveals [Glimpse of Tomorrow] with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability.
[11:47:30] Cheiffireball casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:47:38] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Twinshot Sniper] onto the stack targeting Chandogg (When Twinshot Sniper enters the battlefield, it deals 2 damage to any target.).
[11:47:38] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[11:47:40] Cheiffireball's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates two Phyrexian Goblin Tokens.
[11:47:48] Cheiffireball casts [Felidar Retreat].
[11:47:55] Chandogg is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token] and [Phyrexian Goblin Token]
[11:48:03] Turn 5: Chandogg
[11:48:08] Chandogg casts [Vexing Devil].
[11:48:10] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Vexing Devil] onto the stack (When Vexing Devil enters the battlefield, any opponent may have it deal 4 damage to them. If a pla...).
[11:48:24] Turn 6: Cheiffireball
[11:48:29] Cheiffireball plays [Ghitu Encampment].
[11:48:32] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control. Those creatures gain vigilance until end of turn...).
[11:48:34] Cheiffireball puts a +1/+1 counter on [Chancellor of the Forge], [Twinshot Sniper], [Phyrexian Goblin Token], and [Phyrexian Goblin Token].
[11:48:42] Chandogg is being attacked by [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Phyrexian Goblin Token], [Twinshot Sniper], and [Chancellor of the Forge]
[11:48:46] Cheiffireball wins the game.
Winner: Cheiffireball
Game 2 Completed.
[11:48:50] Cheiffireball has left the game.

== Game 3 (871132536) ==
[Time] 1709945353
[11:49:14] PDBot has started watching.
[11:49:20] Chandogg begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:49:36] Cheiffireball mulligans to six cards.
[11:49:48] Cheiffireball puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[11:49:48] Turn 1: Chandogg
[11:49:50] Chandogg skips their draw step.
[11:49:56] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:50:01] Chandogg casts [Wayward Guide-Beast].
[11:50:08] Chandogg exiles [Volcanic Salvo] with with [Blazing Shoal]'s ability.
[11:50:08] Chandogg casts [Blazing Shoal] targeting [Wayward Guide-Beast]. (X is 12).
[11:50:13] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:50:15] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:50:18] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:50:22] Turn 1: Cheiffireball
[11:50:26] Cheiffireball plays [Ghitu Encampment].
[11:50:31] Turn 2: Chandogg
[11:50:34] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:50:41] Chandogg casts [Fervent Champion].
[11:50:49] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Fervent Champion] and [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:50:49] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[11:50:54] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:50:58] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:51:04] Turn 2: Cheiffireball
[11:51:08] Cheiffireball plays [Mountain].
[11:51:13] Turn 3: Chandogg
[11:51:17] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:51:22] Chandogg casts [Reckless Charge] targeting [Fervent Champion].
[11:51:30] Cheiffireball discards [Twinshot Sniper].
[11:51:30] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Twinshot Sniper] targeting [Fervent Champion] ( Twinshot Sniper deals 2 damage to any target.).
[11:51:36] Chandogg's [Reckless Charge] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[11:51:46] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:51:48] Chandogg puts triggered ability from [Wayward Guide-Beast] onto the stack (Whenever Wayward Guide-Beast deals combat damage to a player, return a land you control to its own...).
[11:51:52] Chandogg returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Wayward Guide-Beast]'s ability.
[11:51:55] Turn 3: Cheiffireball
[11:51:59] Cheiffireball plays [Mountain].
[11:52:03] Turn 4: Chandogg
[11:52:08] Chandogg plays [Mountain].
[11:52:11] Chandogg casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[11:52:18] Cheiffireball is being attacked by [Wayward Guide-Beast]
[11:52:22] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Ghitu Encampment] ( Ghitu Encampment becomes a 2/1 red Warrior creature with first strike until end of turn. It's sti...).
[11:52:28] [Ghitu Encampment] blocks [Wayward Guide-Beast].
[11:52:39] Turn 4: Cheiffireball
[11:52:45] Cheiffireball plays [Mountain].
[11:53:05] Cheiffireball casts [Geological Appraiser].
[11:53:09] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Geological Appraiser] onto the stack (When Geological Appraiser enters the battlefield, if you cast it, discover 3.).
[11:53:12] Cheiffireball reveals 21 cards with [Geological Appraiser]'s ability: [Geological Appraiser], [Plains], [Devouring Sugarmaw], [Clifftop Retreat], [Felidar Retreat], [Felidar Retreat], [Felidar Retreat], [Geological Appraiser], [Twinshot Sniper], [Timeless Dragon], 
[11:53:12] [Battlefield Forge], [Kher Keep], [Chancellor of the Forge], [Mountain], [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Geological Appraiser], [Devouring Sugarmaw], [Clifftop Retreat], [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Clifftop Retreat], and 
[11:53:12] [Etali's Favor].
[11:53:15] Cheiffireball casts [Etali's Favor] targeting [Geological Appraiser].
[11:53:18] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[11:53:21] Cheiffireball reveals 9 cards with [Etali's Favor]'s ability: [Battlefield Forge], [Siege-Gang Commander], [Siege-Gang Commander], [Timeless Dragon], [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Mountain], [Twinshot Sniper], [Ghitu Encampment], and [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:53:22] Cheiffireball casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:53:40] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[11:53:44] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[11:53:46] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:53:47] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:53:49] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:53:52] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:53:56] Cheiffireball's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates four Phyrexian Goblin Tokens.
[11:53:59] roboton has started watching.
[11:54:01] Cheiffireball reveals 17 cards with [Etali's Favor]'s ability: [Chancellor of the Forge], [Mountain], [Mountain], [Siege-Gang Commander], [Felidar Retreat], [Geological Appraiser], [Battlefield Forge], [Battlefield Forge], [Battlefield Forge], [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], 
[11:54:01] [Chancellor of the Forge], [Timeless Dragon], [Geological Appraiser], [Mountain], [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Felidar Retreat], and [Etali's Favor].
[11:54:03] Cheiffireball casts [Etali's Favor] targeting [Chancellor of the Forge].
[11:54:06] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[11:54:08] Cheiffireball reveals 6 cards with [Etali's Favor]'s ability: [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Plains], [Battlefield Forge], [Twinshot Sniper], [Mountain], and [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:54:10] Cheiffireball casts [Glimpse of Tomorrow].
[11:54:27] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Etali's Favor] onto the stack (When Etali's Favor enters the battlefield, discover 3.).
[11:54:36] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Twinshot Sniper] onto the stack targeting Chandogg (When Twinshot Sniper enters the battlefield, it deals 2 damage to any target.).
[11:54:38] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Chancellor of the Forge] onto the stack (When Chancellor of the Forge enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red Phyrexian Goblin creature to...).
[11:54:40] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Siege-Gang Commander] onto the stack (When Siege-Gang Commander enters the battlefield, create three 1/1 red Goblin creature tokens.).
[11:54:41] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Siege-Gang Commander] onto the stack (When Siege-Gang Commander enters the battlefield, create three 1/1 red Goblin creature tokens.).
[11:54:45] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:47] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:48] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:50] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:52] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:54] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:55] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:54:59] Cheiffireball puts triggered ability from [Felidar Retreat] onto the stack (Create a 2/2 white Cat Beast creature token.).
[11:55:04] Cheiffireball activates an ability of [Kher Keep] ( Create a 0/1 red Kobold creature token named Kobolds of Kher Keep.).
[11:55:08] Cheiffireball's [Kher Keep] creates a Kobolds of Kher Keep.
[11:55:10] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:14] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:16] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:17] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:19] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:20] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:22] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:23] Cheiffireball's [Felidar Retreat] creates a Cat Beast Token.
[11:55:27] Cheiffireball's [Siege-Gang Commander] creates three Goblin Tokens.
[11:55:30] Cheiffireball's [Siege-Gang Commander] creates three Goblin Tokens.
[11:55:34] Cheiffireball's [Chancellor of the Forge] creates twenty-one Phyrexian Goblin Tokens.
[11:55:46] Chandogg has conceded from the game.
[11:55:46] Cheiffireball wins the game.
Winner: Cheiffireball
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Cheiffireball: 2–1
[11:55:52] Chandogg has left the game.