PennyDreadful
PD vs theshadowmaker
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
ThyShuffler,theshadowmaker

== Game 1 (868805582) ==
[Time] 1708138928
[14:02:09] PDBot has started watching.
[14:02:09] theshadowmaker joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 32.01
[Gatherling] Round=5
[14:02:12] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: hi!!
[14:02:15] theshadowmaker chooses to play first.
[14:02:24] theshadowmaker mulligans to six cards.
[14:02:29] [CHAT] ThyShuffler: Why hello there
[14:02:32] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:02:44] theshadowmaker puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[14:02:44] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[14:02:45] theshadowmaker skips their draw step.
[14:02:47] theshadowmaker plays [Shivan Reef].
[14:02:50] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[14:02:52] ThyShuffler plays [Needle Spires].
[14:02:59] theshadowmaker discards [Imposing Vantasaur].
[14:02:59] theshadowmaker cycles [Imposing Vantasaur].
[14:03:01] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[14:03:03] theshadowmaker plays [Cascade Bluffs].
[14:03:06] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[14:03:11] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:03:14] ThyShuffler casts [Merry, Esquire of Rohan].
[14:03:22] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:03:27] theshadowmaker casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[14:03:30] [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] blocks [Merry, Esquire of Rohan].
[14:03:33] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[14:03:42] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[14:03:45] ThyShuffler plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[14:03:53] ThyShuffler casts [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:04:00] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[14:04:05] theshadowmaker discards [Curator of Mysteries].
[14:04:05] theshadowmaker cycles [Curator of Mysteries].
[14:04:10] theshadowmaker plays [Island].
[14:04:13] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[14:04:15] ThyShuffler plays [Mountain].
[14:04:17] ThyShuffler casts [Fervent Champion].
[14:04:23] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Sword of Fire and Ice] targeting [Fervent Champion] (Equip {2}).
[14:04:28] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[14:04:28] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[14:04:32] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Sword of Fire and Ice] onto the stack targeting theshadowmaker (Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, Sword of Fire and Ice deals 2 damage t...).
[14:04:34] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Sword of Fire and Ice]'s ability.
[14:04:38] ThyShuffler casts [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:04:41] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Sword of Fire and Ice] targeting [Fervent Champion] (Equip {2}).
[14:04:44] Turn 5: theshadowmaker
[14:04:47] theshadowmaker has conceded from the game.
[14:04:47] ThyShuffler wins the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 1 Completed.
[14:04:51] theshadowmaker has left the game.

== Game 2 (868805882) ==
[Time] 1708139160
[14:06:00] PDBot has started watching.
[14:06:08] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:06:10] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:06:10] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[14:06:11] theshadowmaker skips their draw step.
[14:06:12] theshadowmaker plays [Sulfur Falls].
[14:06:16] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[14:06:18] ThyShuffler plays [Needle Spires].
[14:06:19] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[14:06:26] theshadowmaker plays [Cascade Bluffs].
[14:06:29] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[14:06:32] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:06:36] ThyShuffler casts [Merry, Esquire of Rohan].
[14:06:45] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:06:55] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[14:06:57] theshadowmaker plays [Shivan Reef].
[14:07:03] theshadowmaker casts [Pyroclasm].
[14:07:06] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[14:07:16] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:07:22] ThyShuffler casts [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:07:30] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[14:07:44] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[14:07:46] ThyShuffler plays [Mountain].
[14:07:49] ThyShuffler casts [Merry, Esquire of Rohan].
[14:08:04] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Sword of Fire and Ice] targeting [Merry, Esquire of Rohan] (Equip {2}).
[14:08:35] theshadowmaker casts [Abrade] targeting [Sword of Fire and Ice] (Destroy target artifact.).
[14:08:42] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:08:48] Turn 5: theshadowmaker
[14:09:28] theshadowmaker casts [Lamplight Phoenix].
[14:09:29] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[14:09:45] ThyShuffler casts [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:09:48] ThyShuffler casts [Eater of Virtue].
[14:09:53] Turn 6: theshadowmaker
[14:09:56] theshadowmaker plays [Cascade Bluffs].
[14:10:10] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[14:10:17] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Merry, Esquire of Rohan] (Equip {1}).
[14:10:30] ThyShuffler plays [Mountain].
[14:10:34] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Sword of Fire and Ice] targeting [Merry, Esquire of Rohan] (Equip {2}).
[14:11:00] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:11:22] theshadowmaker casts [Repeal] targeting [Sword of Fire and Ice]. (X is 3).
[14:11:23] theshadowmaker returns [Sword of Fire and Ice] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[14:11:23] theshadowmaker draws a card with [Repeal].
[14:11:29] [Lamplight Phoenix] blocks [Merry, Esquire of Rohan].
[14:11:32] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...).
[14:11:46] Turn 7: theshadowmaker
[14:11:50] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[14:12:18] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:12:19] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[14:12:21] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:12:25] ThyShuffler casts [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:12:51] theshadowmaker casts [Forbid] targeting [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:12:58] ThyShuffler casts [Akiri, Fearless Voyager].
[14:13:10] theshadowmaker casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Akiri, Fearless Voyager].
[14:13:13] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:13:14] Turn 8: theshadowmaker
[14:13:17] theshadowmaker plays [Sulfur Falls].
[14:13:38] theshadowmaker casts [Sphinx of Foresight].
[14:13:40] theshadowmaker casts [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel].
[14:13:46] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:13:49] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[14:13:53] ThyShuffler casts [Sword of Fire and Ice].
[14:13:57] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Sword of Fire and Ice] targeting [Merry, Esquire of Rohan] (Equip {2}).
[14:14:02] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:14:14] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Sword of Fire and Ice] onto the stack targeting [Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel] (Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, Sword of Fire and Ice deals 2 damage t...).
[14:14:15] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Sword of Fire and Ice]'s ability.
[14:14:20] Turn 9: theshadowmaker
[14:14:20] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Sphinx of Foresight] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, scry 1.).
[14:14:31] theshadowmaker scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[14:14:42] theshadowmaker discards [Imposing Vantasaur].
[14:14:42] theshadowmaker cycles [Imposing Vantasaur].
[14:14:56] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Sphinx of Foresight] and [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:15:03] Turn 9: ThyShuffler
[14:15:09] ThyShuffler casts [Akiri, Fearless Voyager].
[14:16:05] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:16:05] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Akiri, Fearless Voyager] onto the stack (Whenever you attack a player with one or more equipped creatures, draw a card.).
[14:16:17] theshadowmaker casts [Repeal] targeting [Sword of Fire and Ice]. (X is 3).
[14:16:19] theshadowmaker returns [Sword of Fire and Ice] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[14:16:19] theshadowmaker draws a card with [Repeal].
[14:16:23] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Akiri, Fearless Voyager]'s ability.
[14:16:40] ThyShuffler has conceded from the game.
[14:16:40] theshadowmaker wins the game.
Winner: theshadowmaker
Game 2 Completed.
[14:16:44] theshadowmaker has left the game.

== Game 3 (868806838) ==
[Time] 1708139880
[14:18:01] PDBot has started watching.
[14:18:04] ThyShuffler chooses to play first.
[14:18:07] ThyShuffler mulligans to six cards.
[14:18:12] theshadowmaker begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:18:15] ThyShuffler mulligans to five cards.
[14:18:32] ThyShuffler puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[14:18:32] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[14:18:33] ThyShuffler skips their draw step.
[14:18:34] ThyShuffler plays [Mountain].
[14:18:36] ThyShuffler casts [Fervent Champion].
[14:18:41] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[14:18:41] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[14:18:42] Turn 1: theshadowmaker
[14:18:44] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[14:18:49] theshadowmaker casts [Assault] targeting [Fervent Champion].
[14:18:53] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[14:18:56] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:18:57] ThyShuffler casts [Fervent Champion].
[14:19:00] ThyShuffler casts [Eater of Virtue].
[14:19:02] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Fervent Champion] (Equip {1}).
[14:19:06] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[14:19:07] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[14:19:08] Turn 2: theshadowmaker
[14:19:16] theshadowmaker discards [Imposing Vantasaur].
[14:19:16] theshadowmaker cycles [Imposing Vantasaur].
[14:19:22] theshadowmaker plays [Sulfur Falls].
[14:19:25] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[14:19:32] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[14:19:32] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[14:19:34] Turn 3: theshadowmaker
[14:19:40] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[14:19:44] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: what
[14:19:47] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: f6 myself
[14:19:50] [CHAT] theshadowmaker: oh well
[14:19:52] [CHAT] ThyShuffler: :(
[14:19:55] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[14:19:55] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[14:20:01] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:20:04] ThyShuffler casts [Inspiring Overseer].
[14:20:06] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Inspiring Overseer] onto the stack (When Inspiring Overseer enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life and draw a card.).
[14:20:10] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Inspiring Overseer]'s ability.
[14:20:17] Turn 4: theshadowmaker
[14:20:30] theshadowmaker plays [Cascade Bluffs].
[14:20:35] theshadowmaker casts [Lamplight Phoenix].
[14:20:42] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[14:21:04] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Inspiring Overseer] (Equip {1}).
[14:21:15] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Inspiring Overseer]
[14:21:26] [Lamplight Phoenix] blocks [Inspiring Overseer].
[14:21:33] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Eater of Virtue] onto the stack (Whenever equipped creature dies, exile it.).
[14:21:33] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...).
[14:21:50] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Fervent Champion] (Equip {1}).
[14:21:57] Turn 5: theshadowmaker
[14:22:12] theshadowmaker plays [Sulfur Falls].
[14:22:21] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[14:22:31] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Fervent Champion]
[14:22:31] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Fervent Champion] on the stack.
[14:22:48] theshadowmaker casts [Repeal] targeting [Eater of Virtue]. (X is 1).
[14:22:50] theshadowmaker returns [Eater of Virtue] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[14:22:50] theshadowmaker draws a card with [Repeal].
[14:22:57] [Lamplight Phoenix] blocks [Fervent Champion].
[14:23:10] ThyShuffler casts [Eater of Virtue].
[14:23:15] ThyShuffler casts [Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden].
[14:23:29] Turn 6: theshadowmaker
[14:23:33] theshadowmaker plays [Sulfur Falls].
[14:23:45] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[14:23:50] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden] (Equip {1}).
[14:24:02] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden]
[14:24:02] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden] onto the stack (Whenever Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden attacks, it gets +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the num...).
[14:24:07] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden]'s ability.
[14:24:13] [Lamplight Phoenix] blocks [Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden].
[14:24:20] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Eater of Virtue] onto the stack (Whenever equipped creature dies, exile it.).
[14:24:20] theshadowmaker puts triggered ability from [Lamplight Phoenix] onto the stack (When Lamplight Phoenix dies, you may exile it and collect evidence 4. If you do, return Lamplight ...).
[14:24:36] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:24:52] ThyShuffler casts [Mirran Crusader].
[14:25:02] theshadowmaker discards [Mountain].
[14:25:02] theshadowmaker discards [Shivan Reef].
[14:25:02] theshadowmaker casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Mirran Crusader].
[14:25:12] Turn 7: theshadowmaker
[14:25:20] theshadowmaker plays [Mountain].
[14:25:30] theshadowmaker casts [Lamplight Phoenix].
[14:25:38] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:25:43] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[14:25:45] ThyShuffler plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[14:25:48] ThyShuffler casts [Illuminator Virtuoso].
[14:26:01] theshadowmaker discards [Shivan Reef].
[14:26:01] theshadowmaker discards [Memory Lapse].
[14:26:01] theshadowmaker casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Illuminator Virtuoso].
[14:26:07] ThyShuffler casts [Swiftblade Vindicator].
[14:26:15] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Swiftblade Vindicator] (Equip {1}).
[14:26:29] Turn 8: theshadowmaker
[14:26:47] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:26:55] Turn 9: ThyShuffler
[14:27:13] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Swiftblade Vindicator]
[14:27:31] theshadowmaker casts [Abrade] targeting [Eater of Virtue] (Destroy target artifact.).
[14:27:43] [Lamplight Phoenix] blocks [Swiftblade Vindicator].
[14:27:52] Honorbound84 has started watching.
[14:27:55] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[14:28:00] Turn 9: theshadowmaker
[14:28:08] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Lamplight Phoenix] and [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:28:13] Turn 10: ThyShuffler
[14:28:27] ThyShuffler casts a card face down.
[14:28:43] theshadowmaker casts [Forbid] targeting face-down creature #1.
[14:28:48] ThyShuffler casts [Merry, Esquire of Rohan].
[14:29:00] theshadowmaker is being attacked by [Merry, Esquire of Rohan]
[14:29:02] Turn 10: theshadowmaker
[14:29:20] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Lamplight Phoenix]
[14:29:28] Turn 11: ThyShuffler
[14:29:33] ThyShuffler has conceded from the game.
[14:29:33] theshadowmaker wins the game.
Winner: theshadowmaker
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: theshadowmaker: 2–1
[14:29:39] theshadowmaker has left the game.
[14:29:40] ThyShuffler draws their next card.
[14:29:41] ThyShuffler draws their next card.
[14:29:43] ThyShuffler draws their next card.
[14:29:44] ThyShuffler draws their next card.