PennyDreadful Penny Dreadful League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality 8BitAvenger,brett990 == Game 1 (868157334) == [Time] 1707539266 [15:27:47] PDBot has started watching. [League] Rhino Midrange by brett990 (234681) vs Oops All Lakes by 8bitavenger (234677) [15:27:49] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [15:27:49] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Due to a Magic Online bug, PDBot is unable to tell which player is which. Please report this league match manually. [15:27:58] 8BitAvenger chooses to play first. [15:28:04] [CHAT] 8BitAvenger: hihi hf gg [15:28:08] 8BitAvenger mulligans to six cards. [15:28:12] brett990 mulligans to six cards. [15:28:14] 8BitAvenger mulligans to five cards. [15:28:19] brett990 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [15:28:21] 8BitAvenger mulligans to four cards. [15:28:48] 8BitAvenger puts three cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with four cards in hand. [15:28:48] Turn 1: 8BitAvenger [15:28:49] 8BitAvenger skips their draw step. [15:28:50] 8BitAvenger plays [Rocky Tar Pit]. [15:28:52] Turn 1: brett990 [15:28:56] brett990 plays [Forest]. [15:28:58] brett990 casts [Birds of Paradise]. [15:29:00] Turn 2: 8BitAvenger [15:29:06] 8BitAvenger activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.). [15:29:12] 8BitAvenger plays [Hidden Cataract]. [15:29:13] Turn 2: brett990 [15:29:21] brett990 plays [Plains]. [15:29:24] brett990 casts [Elvish Visionary]. [15:29:24] brett990 puts triggered ability from [Elvish Visionary] onto the stack (When Elvish Visionary enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [15:29:29] brett990 draws a card with [Elvish Visionary]'s ability. [15:29:38] Turn 3: 8BitAvenger [15:29:48] 8BitAvenger plays [Forgotten Monument]. [15:29:55] Turn 3: brett990 [15:29:59] brett990 plays [Isolated Chapel]. [15:30:14] 8BitAvenger is being attacked by [Elvish Visionary] [15:30:19] Turn 4: 8BitAvenger [15:30:33] 8BitAvenger plays [Crystal Grotto]. [15:30:34] 8BitAvenger puts triggered ability from [Crystal Grotto] onto the stack (When Crystal Grotto enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [15:30:40] 8BitAvenger scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom). [15:30:53] 8BitAvenger casts [Kathari Remnant]. [15:30:53] 8BitAvenger puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade). [15:30:56] 8BitAvenger reveals 46 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Bad River], [Fetid Pools], brett990, 8BitAvenger, [Swamp], [Lake of the Dead], [Swamp], [Hidden Cataract], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Hidden Volcano], [15:30:56] [Island], [Kathari Remnant], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Crystal Grotto], [Bad River], [Smoldering Marsh], [Cavernous Maw], [Hidden Cataract], [Kathari Remnant], [Hidden Necropolis], [15:30:56] [Fetid Pools], [Cavernous Maw], [Crystal Grotto], [Hidden Volcano], [Cavernous Maw], [Kathari Remnant], [Lake of the Dead], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Contaminated Aquifer], [Hidden Cataract], [15:30:56] [Primal Surge], [Smoldering Marsh], [Swamp], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Lavaclaw Reaches], [Bad River], [Lake of the Dead], [Hidden Necropolis], [Crystal Grotto], [Island], [15:30:56] [Hidden Necropolis], [Hidden Necropolis], [Hanweir Battlements], [Contaminated Aquifer], [Contaminated Aquifer], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [15:30:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Lake of the Dead[sU] has an advantageous bug. Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Lake of the Dead` or `!notbugged Lake of the Dead` [15:30:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Tibalt's Trickery[sU] has an advantageous bug. Tibalt's Trickery allows the person casting a spell using it to cast a spell that was milled and then exiled by an effect like Dryad MIlitant Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Tibalt's Trickery` or `!notbugged Tibalt's Trickery` [15:31:20] 8BitAvenger casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant]. [15:31:20] 8BitAvenger mills [Lake of the Dead], [Fetid Pools], and [Westvale Abbey]. [15:31:30] 8BitAvenger casts [Primal Surge]. [15:31:40] 8BitAvenger puts [Crystal Grotto] onto the battlefield. [15:31:42] 8BitAvenger puts [Hanweir Battlements] onto the battlefield. [15:31:43] 8BitAvenger puts [Contaminated Aquifer] onto the battlefield. [15:31:44] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Volcano] onto the battlefield. [15:31:47] 8BitAvenger puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [15:31:48] 8BitAvenger puts [Lake of the Dead] onto the battlefield. [15:31:52] 8BitAvenger sacrifices [Contaminated Aquifer]. [15:31:55] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Necropolis] onto the battlefield. [15:31:56] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Volcano] onto the battlefield. [15:31:57] 8BitAvenger puts [Kathari Remnant] onto the battlefield. [15:31:58] 8BitAvenger puts [Fetid Pools] onto the battlefield. [15:31:59] 8BitAvenger puts [Smoldering Marsh] onto the battlefield. [15:32:00] 8BitAvenger puts [Kathari Remnant] onto the battlefield. [15:32:00] 8BitAvenger puts [Island] onto the battlefield. [15:32:01] 8BitAvenger puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [15:32:02] 8BitAvenger puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [15:32:03] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [15:32:04] 8BitAvenger puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [15:32:05] 8BitAvenger puts [Island] onto the battlefield. [15:32:06] 8BitAvenger puts [Contaminated Aquifer] onto the battlefield. [15:32:07] 8BitAvenger puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [15:32:08] 8BitAvenger puts [Smoldering Marsh] onto the battlefield. [15:32:09] 8BitAvenger puts [Crystal Grotto] onto the battlefield. [15:32:10] 8BitAvenger puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [15:32:11] 8BitAvenger puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [15:32:12] 8BitAvenger puts [Crystal Grotto] onto the battlefield. [15:32:13] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:32:14] 8BitAvenger puts [Lake of the Dead] onto the battlefield. [15:32:19] 8BitAvenger sacrifices [Contaminated Aquifer]. [15:32:20] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [15:32:21] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:32:23] 8BitAvenger puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [15:32:24] 8BitAvenger puts [Rocky Tar Pit] onto the battlefield. [15:32:25] 8BitAvenger puts [Hanweir Battlements] onto the battlefield. [15:32:26] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Necropolis] onto the battlefield. [15:32:27] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [15:32:28] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Necropolis] onto the battlefield. [15:32:29] 8BitAvenger puts [Fetid Pools] onto the battlefield. [15:32:30] 8BitAvenger puts [Rocky Tar Pit] onto the battlefield. [15:32:31] 8BitAvenger puts [Lavaclaw Reaches] onto the battlefield. [15:32:32] 8BitAvenger puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [15:32:33] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Necropolis] onto the battlefield. [15:32:34] 8BitAvenger puts [Rocky Tar Pit] onto the battlefield. [15:32:35] 8BitAvenger puts [Contaminated Aquifer] onto the battlefield. [15:32:36] 8BitAvenger puts brett990 onto the battlefield. [15:32:37] 8BitAvenger puts [Kathari Remnant] onto the battlefield. [15:32:39] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:32:41] 8BitAvenger puts triggered ability from [Crystal Grotto] onto the stack (When Crystal Grotto enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [15:32:41] 8BitAvenger puts triggered ability from [Crystal Grotto] onto the stack (When Crystal Grotto enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [15:32:41] 8BitAvenger puts triggered ability from [Crystal Grotto] onto the stack (When Crystal Grotto enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [15:32:52] 8BitAvenger scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom). [15:32:54] 8BitAvenger scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom). [15:32:57] 8BitAvenger scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom). [15:33:25] 8BitAvenger activates an ability of [Hanweir Battlements] targeting [Kathari Remnant] ( Target creature gains haste until end of turn.). [15:34:30] 8BitAvenger activates an ability of [Kessig Wolf Run] targeting [Kathari Remnant]. (X is 20) ( Target creature gets +X/+0 and gains trample until end of turn.). [15:34:34] brett990 casts [Cut Down] targeting [Kathari Remnant]. [15:34:37] 8BitAvenger's Kessig Wolf Run is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [15:34:39] Turn 4: brett990 [15:34:43] brett990 plays [Forest]. [15:34:47] brett990 casts [Siege Rhino]. [15:34:48] brett990 puts triggered ability from [Siege Rhino] onto the stack (When Siege Rhino enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 3 life and you gain 3 life.). [15:34:54] Turn 5: 8BitAvenger [15:35:18] 8BitAvenger plays [Lake of the Dead]. [15:35:20] 8BitAvenger sacrifices [Smoldering Marsh]. [15:35:47] brett990 has conceded from the game. [15:35:47] 8BitAvenger wins the game. Winner: 8BitAvenger Game 1 Completed. [15:35:51] brett990 has left the game. == Game 2 (868157934) == [Time] 1707539824 [15:37:04] PDBot has started watching. [15:37:10] brett990 chooses to play first. [15:37:25] brett990 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [15:37:35] 8BitAvenger mulligans to six cards. [15:37:39] 8BitAvenger mulligans to five cards. [15:37:43] datrobino has started watching. [15:37:50] 8BitAvenger mulligans to four cards. [15:37:56] 8BitAvenger mulligans to three cards. [15:38:41] 8BitAvenger puts four cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with three cards in hand. [15:38:41] Turn 1: brett990 [15:38:42] brett990 skips their draw step. [15:38:44] brett990 plays [Stirring Wildwood]. [15:38:47] Turn 1: 8BitAvenger [15:38:54] 8BitAvenger plays [Rocky Tar Pit]. [15:38:58] Turn 2: brett990 [15:39:01] brett990 plays [Plains]. [15:39:05] Turn 2: 8BitAvenger [15:39:38] 8BitAvenger activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.). [15:40:16] 8BitAvenger plays [Contaminated Aquifer]. [15:40:18] Turn 3: brett990 [15:40:24] brett990 plays [Sunpetal Grove]. [15:40:29] Turn 3: 8BitAvenger [15:40:42] 8BitAvenger plays [Lake of the Dead]. [15:40:44] 8BitAvenger sacrifices [Contaminated Aquifer]. [15:40:53] 8BitAvenger casts [Kathari Remnant]. [15:40:53] 8BitAvenger puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade). [15:40:56] 8BitAvenger reveals 48 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Hidden Cataract], [Swamp], [Hanweir Battlements], [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Necropolis], [Lake of the Dead], [Fetid Pools], [Kathari Remnant], [Hidden Cataract], [Contaminated Aquifer], [15:40:56] brett990, 8BitAvenger, [Swamp], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Bad River], [Island], [Fetid Pools], [Bad River], [15:40:56] [Cavernous Maw], [Cavernous Maw], [Island], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Primal Surge], [Crystal Grotto], [Hidden Necropolis], [Kathari Remnant], [15:40:56] [Hidden Cataract], [Crystal Grotto], [Kathari Remnant], [Forgotten Monument], [Lake of the Dead], [Hidden Volcano], [Kessig Wolf Run], [Cavernous Maw], [Fetid Pools], [Bad River], [15:40:56] [Fetid Pools], [Crystal Grotto], [Forgotten Monument], [Smoldering Marsh], [Westvale Abbey], [Lake of the Dead], [Bad River], and [Tibalt's Trickery]. [15:41:01] 8BitAvenger casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant]. [15:41:02] 8BitAvenger mills [Hidden Necropolis], [Cavernous Maw], and [Smoldering Marsh]. [15:41:06] 8BitAvenger casts [Primal Surge]. [15:41:11] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Cataract] onto the battlefield. [15:41:13] 8BitAvenger puts [Island] onto the battlefield. [15:41:14] 8BitAvenger puts [Lake of the Dead] onto the battlefield. [15:41:15] 8BitAvenger puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [15:41:16] 8BitAvenger puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [15:41:17] 8BitAvenger puts [Westvale Abbey] onto the battlefield. [15:41:18] 8BitAvenger puts [Crystal Grotto] onto the battlefield. [15:41:19] 8BitAvenger puts [Crystal Grotto] onto the battlefield. [15:41:20] 8BitAvenger puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [15:41:21] 8BitAvenger puts [Bad River] onto the battlefield. [15:41:22] 8BitAvenger puts [Kessig Wolf Run] onto the battlefield. [15:41:22] 8BitAvenger puts [Kathari Remnant] onto the battlefield. [15:41:23] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:41:24] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:41:24] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:41:25] 8BitAvenger puts [Rocky Tar Pit] onto the battlefield. [15:41:26] 8BitAvenger puts [Forgotten Monument] onto the battlefield. [15:41:26] 8BitAvenger puts [Fetid Pools] onto the battlefield. [15:41:28] 8BitAvenger puts [Hidden Volcano] onto the battlefield. [15:41:28] 8BitAvenger puts [Cavernous Maw] onto the battlefield. [15:41:29] 8BitAvenger puts [Rocky Tar Pit] onto the battlefield. [15:41:30] 8BitAvenger puts [Crystal Grotto] onto the battlefield. [15:41:30] 8BitAvenger puts [Swamp] onto the battlefield. [15:41:31] brett990 has conceded from the game. [15:41:31] 8BitAvenger wins the game. Winner: 8BitAvenger Game 2 Completed. Match Winner: 8BitAvenger: 2–0 [15:41:34] brett990 has left the game.