PennyDreadful
pd league
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
MTGfan1996,thijmen

== Game 1 (866304912) ==
[Time] 1705924627
[22:57:07] PDBot has started watching.
[22:57:07] MTGfan1996 joined the game.
[League] Stolen Trickery Fun by thijmen (233837) vs Trick or Treat by mtgfan1996 (233838)
[22:57:10] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[22:57:15] MTGfan1996 chooses to play first.
[22:57:22] MTGfan1996 mulligans to six cards.
[22:57:25] [CHAT] thijmen: gl  hf
[22:57:29] thijmen mulligans to six cards.
[22:57:52] MTGfan1996 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[22:57:54] thijmen mulligans to five cards.
[22:57:57] thijmen mulligans to four cards.
[22:58:08] thijmen mulligans to three cards.
[22:58:13] thijmen mulligans to two cards.
[22:58:23] thijmen puts five cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with two cards in hand.
[22:58:23] Turn 1: MTGfan1996
[22:58:24] MTGfan1996 skips their draw step.
[22:58:27] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: aggresive mulling
[22:58:32] MTGfan1996 plays [Rocky Tar Pit].
[22:58:33] Turn 1: thijmen
[22:58:42] thijmen plays [Fetid Pools].
[22:58:45] Turn 2: MTGfan1996
[22:58:51] [CHAT] thijmen: Yes
[22:59:05] MTGfan1996 plays [Fetid Pools].
[22:59:11] Turn 2: thijmen
[22:59:14] thijmen plays [Fetid Pools].
[22:59:18] Turn 3: MTGfan1996
[22:59:24] MTGfan1996 plays [Swamp].
[22:59:28] Turn 3: thijmen
[22:59:32] thijmen plays [Rocky Tar Pit].
[22:59:35] Turn 4: MTGfan1996
[22:59:39] MTGfan1996 plays [Swamp].
[22:59:41] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[22:59:51] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[22:59:51] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:59:51] MTGfan1996 reveals 2 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Bad River] and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[22:59:52] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Tibalt's Trickery[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Tibalt's Trickery allows the person casting a spell using it to cast a spell that was milled and then exiled by an effect like Dryad MIlitant
[22:59:55] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[22:59:56] MTGfan1996 mills [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Hit the Mother Lode], and [Island].
[23:00:00] MTGfan1996 casts MTGfan1996.
[23:00:00] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from MTGfan1996 onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:00:00] MTGfan1996 reveals [Tibalt's Trickery] with MTGfan1996.
[23:00:06] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting MTGfan1996.
[23:00:06] MTGfan1996 mills [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:00:15] MTGfan1996 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Fetid Pools].
[23:00:15] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:00:16] MTGfan1996 reveals 6 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Lake of the Dead], [Fetid Pools], [Enigma Sphinx], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enigma Sphinx], and [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:16] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Lake of the Dead[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled
[23:00:20] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:20] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:00:21] MTGfan1996 reveals 5 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Deny Reality], [Enigma Sphinx], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Lake of the Dead], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:00:24] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:24] MTGfan1996 mills [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[23:00:29] MTGfan1996 casts [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:00:29] MTGfan1996 reveals [Enlisted Wurm] with [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:00:34] MTGfan1996 casts [Enlisted Wurm].
[23:00:34] MTGfan1996's [Hit the Mother Lode] creates four Treasure Tokens.
[23:00:34] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Enlisted Wurm] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:00:35] MTGfan1996 reveals [Deny Reality] with [Enlisted Wurm].
[23:00:42] MTGfan1996 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Rocky Tar Pit].
[23:00:42] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:00:43] MTGfan1996 reveals 13 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Bad River], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Cataract], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Hidden Cataract], [Sunlit Marsh], [Haunted Mire], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Bad River], 
[23:00:43] [Enlisted Wurm], [Ethersworn Sphinx], and [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:50] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:50] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:00:50] MTGfan1996 reveals [Tibalt's Trickery] with [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:54] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[23:00:54] MTGfan1996 mills [Lake of the Dead], [Bad River], and [Fetid Pools].
[23:00:59] MTGfan1996 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Fetid Pools].
[23:00:59] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:01:00] MTGfan1996 reveals 8 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Rocky Tar Pit], [Sunlit Marsh], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Fetid Pools], [Hidden Cataract], [Lake of the Dead], [Bad River], and [Kathari Remnant].
[23:01:04] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:01:04] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:01:06] MTGfan1996 reveals 29 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Swamp], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enigma Sphinx], [Lake of the Dead], [Fetid Pools], [Enigma Sphinx], [Deny Reality], [Enigma Sphinx], [Lake of the Dead], [Rocky Tar Pit], 
[23:01:06] [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Sunlit Marsh], [Bad River], [Hidden Cataract], [Enlisted Wurm], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Haunted Mire], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Bad River], 
[23:01:06] [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Cataract], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Sunlit Marsh], [Lake of the Dead], [Bad River], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Hidden Cataract], and [Fetid Pools].
[23:01:07] MTGfan1996 returns [Fetid Pools] to its owner's hand with [Deny Reality].
[23:01:07] MTGfan1996 returns [Rocky Tar Pit] to its owner's hand with [Deny Reality].
[23:01:07] MTGfan1996's [Deny Reality] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[23:01:08] Turn 4: thijmen
[23:01:15] thijmen plays [Fetid Pools].
[23:01:18] Turn 5: MTGfan1996
[23:01:35] thijmen is being attacked by [Enlisted Wurm]
[23:02:10] MTGfan1996 plays [Lake of the Dead].
[23:02:12] MTGfan1996 sacrifices [Swamp].
[23:03:22] MTGfan1996 casts [Enigma Sphinx].
[23:03:22] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Enigma Sphinx] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:03:25] MTGfan1996 reveals 2 cards with [Enigma Sphinx]: [Hit the Mother Lode] and [Deny Reality].
[23:03:31] MTGfan1996 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Fetid Pools].
[23:03:31] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:03:35] MTGfan1996 reveals 27 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Enigma Sphinx], [Sunlit Marsh], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Hidden Cataract], [Lake of the Dead], [Sunlit Marsh], [Lake of the Dead], [Bad River], [Fetid Pools], [Bad River], 
[23:03:35] [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Enigma Sphinx], [Bad River], [Enlisted Wurm], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Haunted Mire], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Hidden Cataract], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Swamp], 
[23:03:35] [Enigma Sphinx], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Cataract], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Fetid Pools], and [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:03:38] thijmen has conceded from the game.
[23:03:38] MTGfan1996 wins the game.
Winner: MTGfan1996
Game 1 Completed.
[23:03:42] thijmen has left the game.

== Game 2 (866305302) ==
[Time] 1705925065
[23:04:25] PDBot has started watching.
[23:04:27] thijmen chooses to play first.
[23:04:31] thijmen mulligans to six cards.
[23:04:37] MTGfan1996 mulligans to six cards.
[23:04:39] thijmen mulligans to five cards.
[23:04:41] MTGfan1996 mulligans to five cards.
[23:04:48] thijmen puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[23:04:58] MTGfan1996 puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[23:04:58] Turn 1: thijmen
[23:05:06] thijmen skips their draw step.
[23:05:07] thijmen plays [Fetid Pools].
[23:05:09] Turn 1: MTGfan1996
[23:05:23] MTGfan1996 plays [Rocky Tar Pit].
[23:05:24] Turn 2: thijmen
[23:05:29] thijmen plays [Rocky Tar Pit].
[23:05:31] Turn 2: MTGfan1996
[23:05:51] MTGfan1996 plays [Bad River].
[23:05:56] Turn 3: thijmen
[23:05:59] thijmen plays [Hidden Cataract].
[23:06:07] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[23:06:12] Turn 3: MTGfan1996
[23:06:17] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[23:06:33] MTGfan1996 plays [Hidden Cataract].
[23:06:41] thijmen activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[23:06:51] Turn 4: thijmen
[23:06:59] thijmen plays [Lake of the Dead].
[23:07:00] thijmen sacrifices [Fetid Pools].
[23:07:08] thijmen activates an ability of [Hidden Cataract] ( Discover 4.).
[23:07:10] thijmen reveals 4 cards with [Hidden Cataract]'s ability: [Bad River], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Swamp], and [Kathari Remnant].
[23:07:13] thijmen casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:07:13] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:07:18] thijmen reveals 20 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Hidden Cataract], [Swamp], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Fetid Pools], [Enlisted Wurm], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Bad River], [Enigma Sphinx], [Deny Reality], [Kathari Remnant], 
[23:07:18] [Swamp], [Haunted Mire], [Enlisted Wurm], [Enigma Sphinx], [Sunlit Marsh], [Enigma Sphinx], [Fetid Pools], [Deny Reality], [Island], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:07:20] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[23:07:23] thijmen mills [Deny Reality], [Lake of the Dead], and [Bad River].
[23:07:25] thijmen casts [Enlisted Wurm].
[23:07:25] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Enlisted Wurm] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:07:29] thijmen reveals 4 cards with [Enlisted Wurm]: [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Lake of the Dead], [Rocky Tar Pit], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:07:32] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Enlisted Wurm].
[23:07:35] thijmen mills [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Kathari Remnant], and [Brilliant Ultimatum].
[23:07:38] thijmen casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:07:38] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:07:42] thijmen reveals 10 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Hit the Mother Lode], [Hidden Cataract], [Bad River], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Hidden Cataract], [Sunlit Marsh], [Deny Reality], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:07:44] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[23:07:47] thijmen mills [Enigma Sphinx], [Brilliant Ultimatum], and [Swamp].
[23:07:49] thijmen casts [Brilliant Ultimatum].
[23:08:28] [CHAT] thijmen: oops
[23:08:33] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: heheh
[23:08:38] [CHAT] thijmen: thought I just got the lands
[23:08:40] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: das nie handig
[23:08:56] Turn 4: MTGfan1996
[23:09:09] MTGfan1996 plays [Lake of the Dead].
[23:09:11] MTGfan1996 sacrifices [Swamp].
[23:09:26] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Hidden Cataract] ( Discover 4.).
[23:09:26] MTGfan1996 reveals 12 cards with [Hidden Cataract]'s ability: [Rocky Tar Pit], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Bad River], [Fetid Pools], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Enlisted Wurm], [Enigma Sphinx], [Deny Reality], [Bad River], [Enlisted Wurm], 
[23:09:26] [Lake of the Dead], and [Kathari Remnant].
[23:09:31] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:09:31] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:09:32] MTGfan1996 reveals 11 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Swamp], [Hidden Cataract], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Enigma Sphinx], [Deny Reality], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Lake of the Dead], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Sunlit Marsh], [Enlisted Wurm], and 
[23:09:32] [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:09:37] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[23:09:37] MTGfan1996 mills [Bad River], [Enlisted Wurm], and [Hidden Cataract].
[23:09:43] MTGfan1996 casts [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:09:43] MTGfan1996 reveals [Enigma Sphinx] with [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:09:50] MTGfan1996 casts [Enigma Sphinx].
[23:09:50] MTGfan1996's [Hit the Mother Lode] creates three Treasure Tokens.
[23:09:50] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Enigma Sphinx] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:09:50] MTGfan1996 reveals [Kathari Remnant] with [Enigma Sphinx].
[23:09:55] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:09:55] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:09:56] MTGfan1996 reveals 12 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Kathari Remnant], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Sunlit Marsh], [Haunted Mire], [Swamp], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Lake of the Dead], 
[23:09:56] [Hit the Mother Lode], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:10:01] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[23:10:02] MTGfan1996 mills [Deny Reality], [Kathari Remnant], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:10:06] MTGfan1996 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Lake of the Dead].
[23:10:06] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:10:07] MTGfan1996 reveals 3 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Hidden Cataract], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[23:10:14] MTGfan1996 casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Deny Reality].
[23:10:14] MTGfan1996 mills [Enlisted Wurm].
[23:10:19] MTGfan1996 casts [Enlisted Wurm].
[23:10:19] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Enlisted Wurm] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:10:19] MTGfan1996 reveals 4 cards with [Enlisted Wurm]: [Bad River], [Fetid Pools], [Brilliant Ultimatum], and [Deny Reality].
[23:10:24] MTGfan1996 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Lake of the Dead].
[23:10:24] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:10:26] MTGfan1996 reveals 24 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enigma Sphinx], [Lake of the Dead], [Bad River], [Sunlit Marsh], [Hidden Cataract], [Deny Reality], [Lake of the Dead], [Brilliant Ultimatum], 
[23:10:26] [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enigma Sphinx], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Enlisted Wurm], [Swamp], [Island], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Lake of the Dead], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Haunted Mire], 
[23:10:26] [Swamp], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Ethersworn Sphinx], and [Kathari Remnant].
[23:10:32] MTGfan1996 casts [Kathari Remnant].
[23:10:32] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[23:10:34] MTGfan1996 reveals 31 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Sunlit Marsh], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Hidden Cataract], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Fetid Pools], [Bad River], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Island], [Rocky Tar Pit], 
[23:10:34] [Lake of the Dead], [Lake of the Dead], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Haunted Mire], [Hit the Mother Lode], [Deny Reality], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Swamp], [Enigma Sphinx], [Lake of the Dead], 
[23:10:34] [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Swamp], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Hidden Cataract], [Bad River], [Enigma Sphinx], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Sunlit Marsh], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enlisted Wurm], and 
[23:10:34] [Hit the Mother Lode].
[23:10:39] MTGfan1996 returns [Lake of the Dead] to its owner's hand with [Deny Reality].
[23:10:42] thijmen has conceded from the game.
[23:10:42] MTGfan1996 wins the game.
Winner: MTGfan1996
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: MTGfan1996: 2–0
[23:10:47] thijmen has left the game.