PennyDreadful
PD LEAGUE
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Carmandor,thijmen

== Game 1 (866302726) ==
[Time] 1705922529
[22:22:10] PDBot has started watching.
[22:22:10] Carmandor joined the game.
[22:22:10] thijmen joined the game.
[League] Datrobino's Season Past by carmandor (233832) vs Stolen Trickery Fun by thijmen (233834)
[22:22:13] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[22:22:19] thijmen chooses to play first.
[22:22:22] [CHAT] thijmen: gl hf
[22:22:33] [CHAT] Carmandor: GL
[22:22:46] thijmen begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:22:48] Carmandor begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:22:48] Turn 1: thijmen
[22:22:51] thijmen skips their draw step.
[22:22:51] thijmen plays [Hidden Cataract].
[22:22:56] Turn 1: Carmandor
[22:23:05] Carmandor plays [Isolated Chapel].
[22:23:10] Turn 2: thijmen
[22:23:15] thijmen plays [Fetid Pools].
[22:23:19] Turn 2: Carmandor
[22:23:23] Carmandor plays [Caves of Koilos].
[22:23:26] Carmandor casts [Tithing Blade].
[22:23:27] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tithing Blade] onto the stack (When Tithing Blade enters the battlefield, each opponent sacrifices a creature.).
[22:23:32] Turn 3: thijmen
[22:23:39] thijmen plays [Lake of the Dead].
[22:23:39] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Lake of the Dead[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled
[22:23:45] thijmen sacrifices [Fetid Pools].
[22:23:55] Turn 3: Carmandor
[22:24:02] Carmandor plays [Shambling Vent].
[22:24:08] Turn 4: thijmen
[22:24:19] thijmen plays [Island].
[22:24:23] Turn 4: Carmandor
[22:24:30] Carmandor casts [Vindicate] targeting [Lake of the Dead].
[22:24:32] Carmandor plays [Shambling Vent].
[22:24:37] Turn 5: thijmen
[22:24:50] Turn 5: Carmandor
[22:24:58] Carmandor casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:25:01] Carmandor removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:25:01] Carmandor activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[22:25:07] thijmen chooses a card from their hand.
[22:25:07] thijmen discards [Hit the Mother Lode].
[22:25:07] Carmandor draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[22:25:09] Carmandor plays [Sunpetal Grove].
[22:25:22] Turn 6: thijmen
[22:25:30] Turn 6: Carmandor
[22:25:36] Carmandor removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:25:36] Carmandor activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[22:25:41] thijmen chooses a card from their hand.
[22:25:41] thijmen discards [Hit the Mother Lode].
[22:25:41] Carmandor draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[22:25:52] Carmandor casts [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:25:52] thijmen is protecting Carmandor's [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:25:53] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Invasion of Ixalan] onto the stack (When Invasion of Ixalan enters the battlefield, look at the top five cards of your library. You ma...).
[22:26:02] Carmandor reveals [Forest] with [Invasion of Ixalan]'s ability.
[22:26:04] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[22:26:20] Carmandor casts [Vindicate] targeting [Hidden Cataract].
[22:26:26] Turn 7: thijmen
[22:26:39] Turn 7: Carmandor
[22:26:44] Carmandor activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[22:26:57] Carmandor casts [Dig Up] for its cleave cost using an alternate cost.
[22:27:18] Carmandor plays [Sunlit Marsh].
[22:27:25] Turn 8: thijmen
[22:27:56] thijmen discards [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[22:27:57] Turn 8: Carmandor
[22:27:57] Carmandor puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Kaya, Ghost Assassin to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your ...).
[22:28:05] Carmandor removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:28:05] Carmandor activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[22:28:10] thijmen chooses a card from their hand.
[22:28:10] thijmen discards [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[22:28:10] Carmandor draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[22:28:15] Carmandor casts [Tireless Tracker].
[22:28:17] Carmandor plays [Plains].
[22:28:18] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, investigate.).
[22:28:19] Carmandor investigates.
[22:28:19] Carmandor's [Tireless Tracker] creates a Clue Token.
[22:28:29] Carmandor casts [Dark Petition].
[22:28:35] MTGfan1996 has started watching.
[22:28:40] Carmandor activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.).
[22:28:40] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever you sacrifice a Clue, put a +1/+1 counter on Tireless Tracker.).
[22:28:42] Carmandor puts a +1/+1 counter on [Tireless Tracker].
[22:28:43] Carmandor draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability.
[22:28:49] Turn 9: thijmen
[22:28:52] thijmen plays [Fetid Pools].
[22:28:56] Turn 9: Carmandor
[22:29:10] Carmandor plays thijmen.
[22:29:10] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, investigate.).
[22:29:12] Carmandor investigates.
[22:29:12] Carmandor's [Tireless Tracker] creates a Clue Token.
[22:29:17] Carmandor removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:29:17] Carmandor activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[22:29:22] thijmen chooses a card from their hand.
[22:29:22] thijmen discards [Brilliant Ultimatum].
[22:29:22] Carmandor draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[22:29:34] Carmandor casts [Seasons Past].
[22:29:35] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Seasons Past[sU] has an unclassified bug.
There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves.
[22:29:40] Carmandor chooses [Dig Up], [Vindicate], and [Dark Petition] for [Seasons Past].
[22:29:41] Carmandor puts [Seasons Past] on bottom of their library with [Seasons Past].
[22:29:48] Carmandor casts [Vindicate] targeting [Fetid Pools].
[22:29:53] Carmandor's [Invasion of Ixalan] is being attacked by [Tireless Tracker]
[22:29:55] Carmandor removes four defense counters from [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:29:55] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Invasion of Ixalan] onto the stack (When the last defense counter is removed from this permanent, exile it, then you may cast it trans...).
[22:29:57] Carmandor exiles [Invasion of Ixalan] with its own ability.
[22:30:01] Carmandor casts [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:30:11] Carmandor discards [Tithing Blade].
[22:30:11] Turn 10: thijmen
[22:30:14] thijmen plays [Swamp].
[22:30:21] Turn 10: Carmandor
[22:30:24] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[22:30:25] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, investigate.).
[22:30:27] Carmandor investigates.
[22:30:27] Carmandor's [Tireless Tracker] creates a Clue Token.
[22:30:32] thijmen is being attacked by [Belligerent Regisaur] and [Tireless Tracker]
[22:30:48] Carmandor casts [Dig Up] for its cleave cost using an alternate cost.
[22:30:48] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Belligerent Regisaur] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell, Belligerent Regisaur gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[22:31:12] Carmandor casts [Vindicate] targeting [Swamp].
[22:31:12] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Belligerent Regisaur] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell, Belligerent Regisaur gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[22:31:19] Carmandor removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[22:31:19] Carmandor activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[22:31:22] Turn 11: thijmen
[22:31:26] thijmen plays [Sunlit Marsh].
[22:31:32] Carmandor activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.).
[22:31:33] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever you sacrifice a Clue, put a +1/+1 counter on Tireless Tracker.).
[22:31:34] Carmandor puts a +1/+1 counter on [Tireless Tracker].
[22:31:35] Carmandor draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability.
[22:31:37] Turn 11: Carmandor
[22:31:43] Carmandor activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.).
[22:31:44] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Tireless Tracker] onto the stack (Whenever you sacrifice a Clue, put a +1/+1 counter on Tireless Tracker.).
[22:31:45] Carmandor puts a +1/+1 counter on [Tireless Tracker].
[22:31:46] Carmandor draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability.
[22:31:47] Placebo has started watching.
[22:31:51] thijmen is being attacked by [Belligerent Regisaur] and [Tireless Tracker]
[22:31:57] Carmandor wins the game.
Winner: Carmandor
Game 1 Completed.
[22:32:02] thijmen has left the game.
[22:32:04] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: !record

== Game 2 (866303432) ==
[Time] 1705923203
[22:33:23] PDBot has started watching.
[22:33:26] thijmen chooses to play first.
[22:33:39] thijmen begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:34:15] Carmandor mulligans to six cards.
[22:34:26] Carmandor puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[22:34:26] Turn 1: thijmen
[22:34:29] thijmen skips their draw step.
[22:34:30] thijmen plays [Bad River].
[22:34:39] Turn 1: Carmandor
[22:34:43] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: !record
[22:34:43] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  Carmandor 1-0 thijmen
[22:34:45] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[22:34:49] Carmandor casts [Dig Up].
[22:34:52] Carmandor reveals [Swamp].
[22:34:56] Turn 2: thijmen
[22:34:59] thijmen plays [Bad River].
[22:35:08] Turn 2: Carmandor
[22:35:12] Carmandor plays [Shambling Vent].
[22:35:17] Turn 3: thijmen
[22:35:22] thijmen plays [Rocky Tar Pit].
[22:35:32] Turn 3: Carmandor
[22:35:36] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[22:35:46] chickeninthebrain has started watching.
[22:35:47] Carmandor casts [Lost Legacy] targeting thijmen.
[22:35:58] Carmandor names Hit the Mother Lode for [Lost Legacy].
[22:36:17] Carmandor exiled 4 copies of Hit the Mother Lode (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 4 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[22:36:25] thijmen activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[22:36:32] thijmen activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[22:36:37] Turn 4: thijmen
[22:36:41] thijmen activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[22:36:45] thijmen plays [Swamp].
[22:36:49] thijmen casts [Kathari Remnant].
[22:36:49] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:36:53] [CHAT] Carmandor: I called the wrong card
[22:36:54] overbe1ng has started watching.
[22:36:55] thijmen reveals 3 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Rocky Tar Pit], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[22:36:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Tibalt's Trickery[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Tibalt's Trickery allows the person casting a spell using it to cast a spell that was milled and then exiled by an effect like Dryad MIlitant
[22:37:00] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[22:37:01] thijmen mills [Enigma Sphinx].
[22:37:03] thijmen casts [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[22:37:03] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Ethersworn Sphinx] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:37:06] thijmen reveals [Enlisted Wurm] with [Ethersworn Sphinx].
[22:37:08] thijmen casts [Enlisted Wurm].
[22:37:08] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Enlisted Wurm] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:37:11] thijmen reveals [Kathari Remnant] with [Enlisted Wurm].
[22:37:13] thijmen casts [Kathari Remnant].
[22:37:13] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:37:16] thijmen reveals 2 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Lake of the Dead] and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[22:37:18] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[22:37:20] thijmen mills [Fetid Pools], [Ethersworn Sphinx], and [Sunlit Marsh].
[22:37:24] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Tibalt's Trickery].
[22:37:25] thijmen's [Tibalt's Trickery] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[22:37:35] [CHAT] thijmen: oops, I messed up as well
[22:37:40] Turn 4: Carmandor
[22:37:52] Carmandor plays [Caves of Koilos].
[22:38:02] Carmandor casts [Firja's Retribution].
[22:38:02] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Firja's Retribution] onto the stack (Create a 4/4 white Angel Warrior creature token with flying and vigilance.).
[22:38:03] Carmandor's [Firja's Retribution] creates an Angel Warrior Token.
[22:38:09] Turn 5: thijmen
[22:38:12] thijmen plays [Island].
[22:38:16] thijmen casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Angel Warrior Token].
[22:38:16] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:38:20] thijmen reveals 3 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Enigma Sphinx], and [Kathari Remnant].
[22:38:22] thijmen casts [Kathari Remnant].
[22:38:22] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:38:26] thijmen reveals 4 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Kathari Remnant], [Enlisted Wurm], [Lake of the Dead], and [Tibalt's Trickery].
[22:38:30] thijmen casts [Tibalt's Trickery] targeting [Kathari Remnant].
[22:38:31] thijmen mills [Brilliant Ultimatum].
[22:38:34] thijmen casts [Brilliant Ultimatum].
[22:38:54] thijmen casts [Enlisted Wurm].
[22:38:54] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Enlisted Wurm] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:38:58] thijmen reveals 7 cards with [Enlisted Wurm]: [Enlisted Wurm], [Enigma Sphinx], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Bad River], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enigma Sphinx], and [Deny Reality].
[22:39:03] thijmen casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Angel Warrior Token].
[22:39:03] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:39:07] thijmen reveals 14 cards with [Deny Reality]: [Deny Reality], [Hidden Cataract], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Ethersworn Sphinx], [Lake of the Dead], [Hidden Cataract], [Sunlit Marsh], [Swamp], [Hidden Cataract], [Haunted Mire], 
[22:39:07] [Enigma Sphinx], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Lake of the Dead], and [Kathari Remnant].
[22:39:10] thijmen casts [Kathari Remnant].
[22:39:10] thijmen puts triggered ability from [Kathari Remnant] onto the stack (Cascade).
[22:39:14] thijmen reveals 21 cards with [Kathari Remnant]: [Enlisted Wurm], [Bad River], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Enlisted Wurm], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Bad River], [Enigma Sphinx], [Enigma Sphinx], [Enigma Sphinx], [Ethersworn Sphinx], 
[22:39:14] [Deny Reality], [Haunted Mire], [Hidden Cataract], [Hidden Cataract], [Brilliant Ultimatum], [Sunlit Marsh], [Lake of the Dead], [Rocky Tar Pit], [Lake of the Dead], [Hidden Cataract], and 
[22:39:14] [Swamp].
[22:39:22] thijmen returns [Angel Warrior Token] to its owner's hand with [Deny Reality].
[22:39:26] thijmen's [Deny Reality] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[22:39:31] Carmandor is being attacked by [Enlisted Wurm] and [Ethersworn Sphinx]
[22:39:36] Turn 5: Carmandor
[22:39:38] Carmandor puts a lore counter on [Firja's Retribution].
[22:39:39] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Firja's Retribution] onto the stack (Until end of turn, Angels you control gain '{T}: Destroy target creature with power less than this...).
[22:39:42] Carmandor plays [Sunpetal Grove].
[22:40:06] Carmandor casts [Guardian of Ghirapur].
[22:40:11] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Guardian of Ghirapur] onto the stack (When Guardian of Ghirapur enters the battlefield, exile up to one other target creature or artifac...).
[22:40:15] Carmandor has conceded from the game.
[22:40:15] thijmen wins the game.
Winner: thijmen
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (866303980) ==
[Time] 1705923633
[22:40:34] PDBot has started watching.
[22:40:35] Carmandor chooses to play first.
[22:40:44] Carmandor mulligans to six cards.
[22:40:46] thijmen mulligans to six cards.
[22:40:49] Carmandor mulligans to five cards.
[22:40:52] thijmen mulligans to five cards.
[22:40:53] Carmandor mulligans to four cards.
[22:41:07] thijmen puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[22:41:09] Carmandor mulligans to three cards.
[22:41:21] Carmandor puts four cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with three cards in hand.
[22:41:21] Turn 1: Carmandor
[22:41:22] Carmandor skips their draw step.
[22:41:24] Carmandor plays [Scattered Groves].
[22:41:29] Turn 1: thijmen
[22:41:31] thijmen plays [Bad River].
[22:41:35] Turn 2: Carmandor
[22:41:38] Carmandor plays [Isolated Chapel].
[22:41:41] Carmandor casts [Spirited Companion].
[22:41:42] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Spirited Companion] onto the stack (When Spirited Companion enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[22:41:43] Carmandor draws a card with [Spirited Companion]'s ability.
[22:41:48] Turn 2: thijmen
[22:41:51] thijmen plays [Hidden Cataract].
[22:41:56] Turn 3: Carmandor
[22:42:03] Carmandor casts [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:42:03] thijmen is protecting Carmandor's [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:42:04] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Invasion of Ixalan] onto the stack (When Invasion of Ixalan enters the battlefield, look at the top five cards of your library. You ma...).
[22:42:08] Carmandor reveals [Llanowar Wastes] with [Invasion of Ixalan]'s ability.
[22:42:11] Carmandor plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[22:42:15] Carmandor's [Invasion of Ixalan] is being attacked by [Spirited Companion]
[22:42:17] Carmandor removes a defense counter from [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:42:22] thijmen activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[22:42:28] Turn 3: thijmen
[22:42:30] thijmen plays [Rocky Tar Pit].
[22:42:35] Turn 4: Carmandor
[22:42:43] Carmandor casts [Lost Legacy] targeting thijmen.
[22:42:50] Carmandor names Tibalt's Trickery for [Lost Legacy].
[22:43:03] Carmandor exiled 4 copies of Tibalt's Trickery (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 4 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[22:43:05] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[22:43:09] Carmandor's [Invasion of Ixalan] is being attacked by [Spirited Companion]
[22:43:11] Carmandor removes a defense counter from [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:43:22] Turn 4: thijmen
[22:43:30] Turn 5: Carmandor
[22:43:34] Carmandor plays [Plains].
[22:43:39] Carmandor's [Invasion of Ixalan] is being attacked by [Spirited Companion]
[22:43:41] Carmandor removes a defense counter from [Invasion of Ixalan].
[22:43:47] Carmandor casts [Thragtusk].
[22:43:48] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Thragtusk] onto the stack (When Thragtusk enters the battlefield, you gain 5 life.).
[22:43:52] thijmen activates an ability of [Rocky Tar Pit] ( Search your library for a Swamp or Mountain card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[22:44:01] Turn 5: thijmen
[22:44:05] thijmen has conceded from the game.
[22:44:05] Carmandor wins the game.
Winner: Carmandor
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Carmandor: 2–1
[22:44:08] Carmandor draws their next card.
[22:44:09] Carmandor draws their next card.
[22:44:10] thijmen has left the game.