Commander No cEDH combos/cEDH wincons. No timing out/scooping until it's 1v1. BuggedCardObserver Magical_Hacker,Silvergriffyn,Arose090,Inferno18 == Game 1 (858017222) == [Time] 1700632056 [07:47:36] PDBot has started watching. [07:47:38] Magical_Hacker chooses to play first. [07:47:38] Magical_Hacker chooses [Anara, Wolvid Familiar] and [Bruse Tarl, Boorish Herder] as their commanders. [07:47:38] Arose090 chooses [Ojer Taq, Deepest Foundation] as their commander. [07:47:38] Inferno18 chooses [Sekki, Seasons' Guide] as their commander. [07:47:38] Silvergriffyn chooses [Arcum Dagsson] as their commander. [07:47:40] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sekki, Seasons' Guide[sU] has an unclassified bug. Spirit tokens created by Sekki, Seasons' Guide are not considered to have the same name. [07:47:43] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Hi all [07:47:44] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: good luck and have fun [07:47:54] Magical_Hacker begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:47:55] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: glhf [07:48:00] Arose090 mulligans to seven cards. [07:48:05] Inferno18 mulligans to seven cards. [07:48:09] Silvergriffyn begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:48:23] Arose090 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:48:25] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: I'm using wifi on a cruise, so if I disconnect, just wait for me to reconnect [07:48:29] Inferno18 mulligans to six cards. [07:48:36] Inferno18 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [07:48:36] Turn 1: Magical_Hacker [07:48:42] Magical_Hacker plays [Spinerock Knoll]. [07:48:43] Magical_Hacker puts triggered ability from [Spinerock Knoll] onto the stack (Hideaway 4 (When this permanent enters the battlefield, look at the top 4 cards of your library....). [07:49:05] Turn 1: Arose090 [07:49:11] Arose090 plays [Plains]. [07:49:29] Turn 1: Inferno18 [07:49:41] Inferno18 plays [Mosswort Bridge]. [07:49:42] Inferno18 puts triggered ability from [Mosswort Bridge] onto the stack (Hideaway 4 (When this permanent enters the battlefield, look at the top 4 cards of your library....). [07:49:54] Turn 1: Silvergriffyn [07:50:00] Silvergriffyn plays Silvergriffyn. [07:50:13] Turn 2: Magical_Hacker [07:50:23] Magical_Hacker plays [Jetmir's Garden]. [07:50:33] Turn 2: Arose090 [07:50:40] Arose090 plays [Plains]. [07:50:42] Arose090 casts [Skrelv's Hive]. [07:50:53] Turn 2: Inferno18 [07:50:58] Inferno18 plays [Forest]. [07:51:02] Inferno18 casts [Rampant Growth]. [07:51:13] Turn 2: Silvergriffyn [07:51:20] Silvergriffyn plays [Snow-Covered Island]. [07:51:24] Silvergriffyn casts [Silver Myr]. [07:51:30] Turn 3: Magical_Hacker [07:51:41] Magical_Hacker plays [Krosan Verge]. [07:52:03] Magical_Hacker discards [Scattered Groves]. [07:52:03] Magical_Hacker cycles [Scattered Groves]. [07:52:11] Turn 3: Arose090 [07:52:11] Arose090 puts triggered ability from [Skrelv's Hive] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 colorless Phyrexian Mite artifac...). [07:52:17] Arose090's [Skrelv's Hive] creates a Phyrexian Mite Token. [07:52:21] Bafflement has started watching. [07:52:24] Arose090 plays [Plains]. [07:52:48] Arose090 casts [Jeweled Lotus]. [07:53:03] Arose090 casts [Ojer Taq, Deepest Foundation]. [07:53:15] Turn 3: Inferno18 [07:53:23] Inferno18 plays [Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx]. [07:53:30] Inferno18 casts [Sylvan Library]. [07:53:44] Turn 3: Silvergriffyn [07:53:50] Silvergriffyn plays [Snow-Covered Island]. [07:53:56] Silvergriffyn casts [Arcum Dagsson]. [07:54:04] Turn 4: Magical_Hacker [07:54:19] Magical_Hacker plays [Command Tower]. [07:54:31] Magical_Hacker casts [Anara, Wolvid Familiar]. [07:54:43] Turn 4: Arose090 [07:54:44] Arose090 puts triggered ability from [Skrelv's Hive] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life and create a 1/1 colorless Phyrexian Mite artifac...). [07:54:48] Arose090's [Skrelv's Hive] creates three Phyrexian Mite Tokens. [07:55:21] Arose090 casts [Ashnod's Altar]. [07:55:35] Silvergriffyn is being attacked by [Ojer Taq, Deepest Foundation] [07:55:44] Silvergriffyn has been dealt 6 total damage by Arose090's commander, [Ojer Taq, Deepest Foundation]. [07:55:52] Turn 4: Inferno18 [07:55:54] Inferno18 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Library] onto the stack (At the beginning of your draw step, you may draw two additional cards. If you do, choose two cards...). [07:56:05] Inferno18 draws two cards with [Sylvan Library]'s ability. [07:56:11] Inferno18 put a card on top of Inferno18's library. [07:56:13] Inferno18 kept a card. [07:56:16] Inferno18 plays [Forest]. [07:56:21] Inferno18 casts [Tempting Licid]. [07:56:45] Turn 4: Silvergriffyn [07:56:52] Silvergriffyn plays [Snow-Covered Island]. [07:56:58] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Arcum Dagsson] targeting [Silver Myr] ( Target artifact creature's controller sacrifices it. That player may search their library for a n...). [07:57:11] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:57:12] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:57:52] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:57:55] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:57:58] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:57:59] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:57:59] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:57:59] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:58:25] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:58:28] Inferno18 has conceded from the game. [07:58:28] Inferno18 loses the game. [07:58:28] Inferno18 is now a watcher. [07:58:28] Inferno18 has stopped watching. [07:58:33] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:58:50] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:58:52] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:58:54] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:58:55] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:58:56] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:58:56] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:59:10] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:59:14] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:59:26] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:59:29] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:59:42] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [07:59:47] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [07:59:59] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:00:04] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:00:13] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:00:13] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:00:29] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:00:31] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:00:36] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:00:36] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:01:01] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:01:05] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:01:17] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:01:19] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:01:24] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:01:24] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:01:26] [CHAT] Arose090: Boring [08:01:42] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:01:43] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: I think it's pretty cool [08:01:44] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:01:49] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:01:50] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:02:09] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:02:13] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:02:32] Silvergriffyn casts Arose090. [08:02:36] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from Arose090 onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:02:38] Bafflement has stopped watching. [08:03:01] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: for 3 tix its ok lol [08:03:05] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:03:06] Arose090 has conceded from the game. [08:03:06] Arose090 loses the game. [08:03:07] Arose090 is now a watcher. [08:03:11] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:03:21] Arose090 has stopped watching. [08:03:24] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:03:28] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:03:46] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Who would you have chosen to mill out first if no one conceded? [08:04:03] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: oh arose for sure, taq is terrifying [08:04:27] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Each of us would need 21 PP to be milled out [08:04:35] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:04:36] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: how many is the deck running? [08:04:42] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: 33 in all [08:04:47] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:04:59] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:05:02] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:05:06] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:05:07] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:05:25] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:05:29] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:05:39] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: I'm totally cool either way, but would you be open to waiting a turn before milling me out? To replicate what it would have been if Arose didn't concede [08:05:56] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: oh totally fine by me, i just know that I managed to pull it off [08:05:57] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: If not, no hard feelings :) I just hate losing to a concession lol [08:05:59] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:06:02] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:06:10] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:06:10] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:06:17] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: It is definitely a sweet deck [08:06:27] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: I wasn't lying when I said that earlier [08:06:43] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: i origionally made it for a 1v1 budget tournement in paper, hadnt tried it in regular [08:07:03] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: and just like that that should be all of them [08:07:51] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: I think for multiple players, you really need cards that can untap all your creatures. Do you have any cards like that? [08:08:06] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: sadly not yet, I would have to explore more options [08:08:18] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: lemme see what I can find [08:08:47] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: admittedly it does have a back up, if I had waited one more turn I also have aetherflux [08:09:23] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Dramatic Reversal and Intruder Alarm are two solid inclusions [08:09:37] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: for sure! [08:10:09] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:10:10] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:10:35] Turn 5: Magical_Hacker [08:10:42] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Here are some others: Turnabout, Intellectual Offering, Breaking Wave, and Riptide Chronologist. [08:10:47] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: all great options [08:11:01] Magical_Hacker casts [Day of Judgment]. [08:11:04] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: I will say the aetherflux does do very well, since you can stack the triggers to get stupid amounts of life [08:11:11] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Very true [08:11:20] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:11:23] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:11:35] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:11:38] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:11:47] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:11:50] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:11:52] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: It's tough to get both out on the same turn though. Getting them out one at a time will definitely sound the alarm [08:11:59] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:12:03] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:12:10] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: its def tricky [08:12:22] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:12:26] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:12:35] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:12:39] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:12:50] Silvergriffyn activates an ability of [Persistent Petitioners] targeting Magical_Hacker ( Target player mills 12 cards.). [08:12:53] Magical_Hacker mills 12 cards. [08:13:00] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: GG WP :) [08:13:06] [CHAT] Silvergriffyn: you too there mate [08:13:23] Magical_Hacker plays [Wooded Foothills]. [08:13:43] Silvergriffyn is being attacked by [Anara, Wolvid Familiar] [08:14:01] Silvergriffyn has been dealt 4 total damage by Magical_Hacker's commander, [Anara, Wolvid Familiar]. [08:14:16] Turn 5: Silvergriffyn [08:14:22] Silvergriffyn plays [Snow-Covered Island]. [08:14:27] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:14:28] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:14:44] Silvergriffyn casts [Persistent Petitioners]. [08:14:45] Silvergriffyn puts triggered ability from [Persistent Petitioners] onto the stack (Ripple 4). [08:15:05] Turn 6: Magical_Hacker [08:15:07] Silvergriffyn wins the game. Winner: Silvergriffyn Game 1 Completed. [08:15:17] [CHAT] Magical_Hacker: Take care! [08:15:20] Silvergriffyn has left the game.