PennyDreadful
PD R1 vs mtgfan1996
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Bob49,MTGfan1996

== Game 1 (851959078) ==
[Time] 1695490623
[20:37:04] PDBot has started watching.
[20:37:04] Bob49 joined the game.
[20:37:04] MTGfan1996 joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Season 30 Kickoff
[Gatherling] Round=1
[20:37:11] [CHAT] Bob49: gl hf
[20:37:13] MTGfan1996 chooses to play first.
[20:37:23] MTGfan1996 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:37:24] Bob49 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:37:24] Turn 1: MTGfan1996
[20:37:27] MTGfan1996 skips their draw step.
[20:37:33] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:37:39] Turn 1: Bob49
[20:37:43] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[20:37:53] Turn 2: MTGfan1996
[20:37:59] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:38:05] Turn 2: Bob49
[20:38:08] Bob49 plays [Wooded Bastion].
[20:38:11] Bob49 casts [Sylvan Library].
[20:38:18] MTGfan1996 casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Sylvan Library].
[20:38:27] Turn 3: MTGfan1996
[20:38:33] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:38:40] Turn 3: Bob49
[20:38:42] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[20:38:45] Bob49 casts [Solemnity].
[20:38:45] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Solemnity[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Solemnity does not prevent a player from paying tribute cost, but the creature won't get the +1/+1 counter
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Solemnity` or `!notbugged Solemnity`
[20:38:52] MTGfan1996 casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Solemnity].
[20:39:05] MTGfan1996 casts [Borne Upon a Wind].
[20:39:05] MTGfan1996 draws a card with [Borne Upon a Wind].
[20:39:05] Turn 4: MTGfan1996
[20:39:17] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:39:25] Turn 4: Bob49
[20:39:28] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[20:39:31] Bob49 casts [Delaying Shield].
[20:39:52] Turn 5: MTGfan1996
[20:39:59] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:40:22] Turn 5: Bob49
[20:40:22] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:40:30] Bob49 plays [Sunpetal Grove].
[20:40:36] Bob49 casts [Nine Lives].
[20:40:48] Turn 6: MTGfan1996
[20:40:57] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:41:01] MTGfan1996 casts [Sleight of Hand].
[20:41:11] MTGfan1996 casts [High Tide].
[20:41:26] MTGfan1996 casts ability from [Kaheera, the Orphanguard] ( Put Kaheera, the Orphanguard into your hand.).
[20:41:31] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[20:41:31] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[20:41:38] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[20:41:38] MTGfan1996 discards [Kaheera, the Orphanguard].
[20:41:50] MTGfan1996 casts [See the Truth].
[20:42:19] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[20:42:19] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[20:42:27] MTGfan1996 discards [Founding the Third Path].
[20:42:27] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[20:42:28] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Founding the Third Path[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Primal Wellspring doesn't copy spells cast by the third chapter of Founding the Third Path
[20:42:58] MTGfan1996 casts [Founding the Third Path].
[20:43:10] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Founding the Third Path] onto the stack targeting [Frantic Search] (Exile target instant or sorcery card from your graveyard. Copy it. You may cast the copy.).
[20:43:28] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[20:43:28] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[20:43:47] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[20:43:47] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[20:44:19] Turn 6: Bob49
[20:44:20] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:44:27] Bob49 casts [Sterling Grove].
[20:44:33] Bob49 plays [Wooded Bastion].
[20:44:43] Turn 7: MTGfan1996
[20:45:04] Bob49 activates an ability of [Sterling Grove] ( Search your library for an enchantment card, reveal it, then shuffle and put that card on top.).
[20:45:16] Bob49 reveals [Nevermore].
[20:45:35] Turn 7: Bob49
[20:45:35] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:45:56] Bob49 plays [Wooded Bastion].
[20:45:58] Bob49 casts [Nevermore].
[20:46:08] Bob49 names High Tide for [Nevermore].
[20:46:18] Turn 8: MTGfan1996
[20:46:33] Turn 8: Bob49
[20:46:34] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:46:42] Bob49 plays [Wooded Bastion].
[20:46:45] Sacritor has started watching.
[20:46:48] Bob49 casts [Axis of Mortality].
[20:47:05] Turn 9: MTGfan1996
[20:47:11] Sacritor has stopped watching.
[20:47:14] MTGfan1996 casts [Sleight of Hand].
[20:47:26] Turn 9: Bob49
[20:47:28] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:48:27] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Axis of Mortality] onto the stack targeting Bob49, and MTGfan1996 (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may have two target players exchange life totals.).
[20:48:29] Bob49 chooses not to use [Axis of Mortality]'s ability.
[20:49:49] Bob49 casts [Sterling Grove].
[20:49:53] MTGfan1996 casts [Repeal] targeting [Sterling Grove]. (X is 2).
[20:49:53] Bob49 activates an ability of [Sterling Grove] ( Search your library for an enchantment card, reveal it, then shuffle and put that card on top.).
[20:50:03] Bob49 reveals [Shigeki, Jukai Visionary].
[20:50:04] MTGfan1996's [Repeal] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[20:50:04] Turn 10: MTGfan1996
[20:50:06] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:50:07] MTGfan1996 casts [Repeal] targeting [Nevermore]. (X is 3).
[20:50:07] MTGfan1996 returns [Nevermore] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[20:50:07] MTGfan1996 draws a card with [Repeal].
[20:50:08] Turn 10: Bob49
[20:50:08] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:50:08] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Axis of Mortality] onto the stack targeting MTGfan1996, and Bob49 (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may have two target players exchange life totals.).
[20:50:12] Bob49 casts [Nevermore].
[20:50:19] Bob49 names High Tide for [Nevermore].
[20:50:29] Turn 11: MTGfan1996
[20:50:39] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:50:48] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[20:50:50] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[20:51:30] MTGfan1996 discards [Repeal].
[20:51:30] MTGfan1996 discards [Turnabout].
[20:51:41] MTGfan1996 casts [See the Truth].
[20:52:07] Bob49 discards [Shigeki, Jukai Visionary].
[20:52:07] Bob49 activates an ability of [Shigeki, Jukai Visionary] targeting [Sterling Grove]. (X is 1) ( Return X target nonlegendary cards from your graveyard to your hand.).
[20:52:10] [Sterling Grove] is returned to Bob49's hand from the graveyard.
[20:52:14] Turn 11: Bob49
[20:52:16] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:52:18] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Axis of Mortality] onto the stack targeting MTGfan1996, and Bob49 (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may have two target players exchange life totals.).
[20:52:31] Bob49 casts [Sterling Grove].
[20:52:36] Bob49 exiles [Lotus Bloom] with 3 time counters.
[20:52:36] Bob49 puts three time counters on [Lotus Bloom].
[20:52:51] Turn 12: MTGfan1996
[20:53:09] Turn 12: Bob49
[20:53:13] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:53:17] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Axis of Mortality] onto the stack targeting MTGfan1996, and Bob49 (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may have two target players exchange life totals.).
[20:53:17] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Lotus Bloom] onto the stack (Suspend 3{0} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[20:53:23] Bob49 removes a time counter from [Lotus Bloom].
[20:54:25] Bob49 chooses not to use [Axis of Mortality]'s ability.
[20:54:42] Bob49 casts [Commune with Spirits].
[20:54:58] Bob49 reveals [Phyrexian Unlife] with [Commune with Spirits].
[20:55:01] Bob49 casts [Phyrexian Unlife].
[20:55:17] Turn 13: MTGfan1996
[20:55:28] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[20:55:44] Turn 13: Bob49
[20:55:46] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:55:48] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Axis of Mortality] onto the stack targeting MTGfan1996, and Bob49 (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may have two target players exchange life totals.).
[20:55:48] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Lotus Bloom] onto the stack (Suspend 3{0} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[20:55:55] Bob49 removes a time counter from [Lotus Bloom].
[20:56:06] Bob49 casts [Commune with Spirits].
[20:56:09] Bob49 reveals [Dovescape] with [Commune with Spirits].
[20:56:19] Turn 14: MTGfan1996
[20:56:44] MTGfan1996 has lost connection to the game.
[20:56:52] MTGfan1996 joined the game.
[20:57:22] MTGfan1996 casts [Sleight of Hand].
[20:57:36] MTGfan1996 casts [Flow of Knowledge].
[20:57:38] MTGfan1996 draws nine cards with [Flow of Knowledge].
[20:57:59] MTGfan1996 discards [Borne Upon a Wind].
[20:57:59] MTGfan1996 discards [High Tide].
[20:58:29] MTGfan1996 discards [Founding the Third Path].
[20:58:29] MTGfan1996 discards [Impulse].
[20:58:29] MTGfan1996 discards [Impulse].
[20:58:30] Turn 14: Bob49
[20:58:30] CoilingSliver has started watching.
[20:58:32] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Delaying Shield] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove all delay counters from Delaying Shield. For each delay co...).
[20:58:34] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Axis of Mortality] onto the stack targeting MTGfan1996, and Bob49 (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may have two target players exchange life totals.).
[20:58:35] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Lotus Bloom] onto the stack (Suspend 3{0} (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[20:58:38] Bob49 removes a time counter from [Lotus Bloom].
[20:58:38] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Lotus Bloom] onto the stack (Suspend 3{0} (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without p...).
[20:58:43] Bob49 casts [Lotus Bloom].
[20:59:02] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[20:59:05] Bob49 casts [Dovescape].
[20:59:31] Turn 15: MTGfan1996
[20:59:36] MTGfan1996 has conceded from the game.
[20:59:36] Bob49 wins the game.
Winner: Bob49
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (851961596) ==
[Time] 1695492100
[21:01:40] PDBot has started watching.
[21:01:44] MTGfan1996 chooses to play first.
[21:01:52] MTGfan1996 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:01:59] Bob49 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:01:59] Turn 1: MTGfan1996
[21:02:01] MTGfan1996 skips their draw step.
[21:02:05] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:02:10] Turn 1: Bob49
[21:02:13] Bob49 plays [Mistveil Plains].
[21:02:17] Turn 2: MTGfan1996
[21:02:21] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:02:24] MTGfan1996 casts [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:02:31] Turn 2: Bob49
[21:02:34] Bob49 plays [Forest].
[21:02:37] Bob49 casts [Gaea's Blessing] targeting Bob49.
[21:02:37] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Gaea's Blessing[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Gaea's Blessing doesn't shuffle opponent's library if no cards in their graveyard are targeted
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Gaea's Blessing` or `!notbugged Gaea's Blessing`
[21:02:39] Bob49 draws a card with [Gaea's Blessing].
[21:02:44] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[21:02:44] MTGfan1996 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:02:45] Turn 3: MTGfan1996
[21:02:48] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:02:52] MTGfan1996 casts [Compulsive Research] targeting MTGfan1996.
[21:02:52] MTGfan1996 draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[21:02:53] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding in a specific case
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Compulsive Research` or `!notbugged Compulsive Research`
[21:03:13] MTGfan1996 discards [Repeal].
[21:03:13] MTGfan1996 discards [Commit/Memory].
[21:03:20] Turn 3: Bob49
[21:03:24] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[21:03:27] Bob49 casts [Nevermore].
[21:03:33] Bob49 names High Tide for [Nevermore].
[21:03:41] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[21:03:42] MTGfan1996 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:03:42] Turn 4: MTGfan1996
[21:03:47] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:03:53] MTGfan1996 casts [Founding the Third Path].
[21:04:01] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Founding the Third Path] onto the stack targeting MTGfan1996 (Target player mills four cards.).
[21:04:04] MTGfan1996 mills [Island], [Island], [Island], and [Island].
[21:04:04] Quiritim has started watching.
[21:04:14] Turn 4: Bob49
[21:04:19] Bob49 plays [Temple of Plenty].
[21:04:19] Bob49 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Plenty] onto the stack (When Temple of Plenty enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[21:04:25] Bob49 scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[21:04:32] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[21:04:33] MTGfan1996 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:04:37] Turn 5: MTGfan1996
[21:04:39] MTGfan1996 puts a lore counter on [Founding the Third Path].
[21:04:43] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Founding the Third Path] onto the stack targeting [Compulsive Research] (Exile target instant or sorcery card from your graveyard. Copy it. You may cast the copy.).
[21:04:57] MTGfan1996 casts [Compulsive Research] targeting MTGfan1996.
[21:05:02] MTGfan1996 draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[21:05:06] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[21:05:13] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:05:16] caffeinatedpolygons has started watching.
[21:05:21] Turn 5: Bob49
[21:05:26] Bob49 casts [Commune with Spirits].
[21:05:32] Bob49 reveals [Plains] with [Commune with Spirits].
[21:05:33] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[21:05:37] Bob49 casts [Sterling Grove].
[21:05:51] MTGfan1996 casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Sterling Grove].
[21:05:59] Turn 6: MTGfan1996
[21:06:03] Honorbound84 has started watching.
[21:06:16] Turn 6: Bob49
[21:06:28] MTGfan1996 casts [Turnabout] targeting Bob49.
[21:06:35] MTGfan1996 chooses land for [Turnabout].
[21:06:41] Turn 7: MTGfan1996
[21:06:50] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Destroy each nonland permanent with mana value equal to the number of charge counters on Ratchet ...).
[21:06:55] MTGfan1996 casts [High Tide].
[21:07:11] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[21:07:13] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[21:07:19] MTGfan1996 discards [Spell Pierce].
[21:07:19] MTGfan1996 discards [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:07:29] MTGfan1996 casts Bob49.
[21:07:31] MTGfan1996 draws five cards with Bob49.
[21:07:35] DepressedDuck has started watching.
[21:07:39] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[21:07:39] MTGfan1996 discards [Repeal].
[21:07:44] MTGfan1996 casts [High Tide].
[21:07:53] MTGfan1996 casts [Impulse].
[21:08:08] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[21:08:10] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[21:08:15] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[21:08:15] MTGfan1996 discards MTGfan1996.
[21:08:26] crazybaloth has started watching.
[21:08:29] MTGfan1996 casts [See the Truth].
[21:08:52] MTGfan1996 casts [Turnabout] targeting MTGfan1996.
[21:08:56] MTGfan1996 chooses land for [Turnabout].
[21:09:00] DepressedDuck has stopped watching.
[21:09:10] MTGfan1996 casts [Blue Sun's Zenith] targeting MTGfan1996. (X is 11).
[21:09:12] MTGfan1996 draws eleven cards with [Blue Sun's Zenith].
[21:09:20] MTGfan1996 casts [High Tide].
[21:09:21] ThyShuffler has started watching.
[21:09:31] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[21:09:34] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[21:09:38] MTGfan1996 discards [Commit/Memory].
[21:09:38] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[21:10:02] MTGfan1996 casts [See the Truth].
[21:10:08] Bibbsribbs has started watching.
[21:10:16] MTGfan1996 casts [Frantic Search].
[21:10:21] MTGfan1996 draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[21:10:24] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[21:10:24] MTGfan1996 discards [Island].
[21:10:40] MTGfan1996 casts [Turnabout] targeting MTGfan1996.
[21:11:05] MTGfan1996 chooses land for [Turnabout].
[21:11:14] MTGfan1996 casts [Founding the Third Path].
[21:11:41] MTGfan1996 puts triggered ability from [Founding the Third Path] onto the stack targeting [Turnabout] (Exile target instant or sorcery card from your graveyard. Copy it. You may cast the copy.).
[21:11:46] Bibbsribbs has stopped watching.
[21:11:51] MTGfan1996 casts [Turnabout] targeting MTGfan1996.
[21:11:54] MTGfan1996 chooses land for [Turnabout].
[21:12:09] caffeinatedpolygons has stopped watching.
[21:12:13] BirdsAndBees has started watching.
[21:12:22] MTGfan1996 casts [Blue Sun's Zenith] targeting Bob49. (X is 46).
[21:12:22] Bob49 draws forty-six cards with [Blue Sun's Zenith].
[21:12:24] MTGfan1996 wins the game.
Winner: MTGfan1996
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (851962724) ==
[Time] 1695492771
[21:12:51] PDBot has started watching.
[21:13:02] Bob49 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:13:04] MTGfan1996 mulligans to six cards.
[21:13:12] MTGfan1996 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[21:13:12] Turn 1: Bob49
[21:13:18] Bob49 skips their draw step.
[21:13:19] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[21:13:21] Turn 1: MTGfan1996
[21:13:25] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:13:34] Turn 2: Bob49
[21:13:37] Bob49 plays [Sunpetal Grove].
[21:13:43] Turn 2: MTGfan1996
[21:13:46] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:13:47] CoilingSliver has stopped watching.
[21:13:49] MTGfan1996 casts [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:13:58] Turn 3: Bob49
[21:14:01] Bob49 plays [Wooded Bastion].
[21:14:04] Bob49 casts [Sterling Grove].
[21:14:14] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[21:14:15] MTGfan1996 puts a charge counter on [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:14:16] Turn 3: MTGfan1996
[21:14:20] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:14:24] MTGfan1996 casts [Ratchet Bomb].
[21:14:35] Bob49 activates an ability of [Sterling Grove] ( Search your library for an enchantment card, reveal it, then shuffle and put that card on top.).
[21:14:40] Bob49 reveals [Solemnity].
[21:14:44] Turn 4: Bob49
[21:14:47] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[21:14:49] Bob49 casts [Solemnity].
[21:15:00] MTGfan1996 activates an ability of [Ratchet Bomb] ( Put a charge counter on Ratchet Bomb.).
[21:15:04] Turn 4: MTGfan1996
[21:15:11] MTGfan1996 casts [See the Truth].
[21:15:19] MTGfan1996 plays [Island].
[21:15:31] Turn 5: Bob49
[21:15:33] Bob49 plays [Plains].
[21:15:35] Bob49 casts [Phyrexian Unlife].
[21:15:43] Turn 5: MTGfan1996
[21:16:24] [CHAT] MTGfan1996: ggs got super unlucky g1, but ggs I guess
[21:16:28] MTGfan1996 has conceded from the game.
[21:16:28] Bob49 wins the game.
Winner: Bob49
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Bob49: 2–1
[21:16:35] MTGfan1996 has left the game.