PennyDreadful
PD vs ThyShuffler
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
ThyShuffler,RenatoSky

== Game 1 (843607564) ==
[Time] 1688778060
[04:01:01] PDBot has started watching.
[04:01:01] RenatoSky joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 29.11
[Gatherling] Round=5
[04:01:01] ThyShuffler joined the game.
[04:01:06] RenatoSky chooses to play first.
[04:01:10] RenatoSky mulligans to six cards.
[04:01:14] ThyShuffler mulligans to six cards.
[04:01:16] RenatoSky mulligans to five cards.
[04:01:27] ThyShuffler mulligans to five cards.
[04:01:31] RenatoSky mulligans to four cards.
[04:01:49] ThyShuffler puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[04:02:01] RenatoSky puts three cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with four cards in hand.
[04:02:01] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[04:02:02] RenatoSky skips their draw step.
[04:02:06] RenatoSky casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting ThyShuffler.
[04:02:14] RenatoSky draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:02:20] RenatoSky plays [Blackbloom Bog].
[04:02:26] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:02:31] ThyShuffler plays [Pelakka Caverns].
[04:02:36] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[04:02:44] RenatoSky casts [Dark Ritual].
[04:02:47] RenatoSky casts [Undercity Informer].
[04:02:57] RenatoSky exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[04:03:02] RenatoSky activates an ability of [Undercity Informer] targeting RenatoSky ( Target player reveals cards from the top of their library until they reveal a land card, then put...).
[04:03:02] RenatoSky reveals 57 cards with [Undercity Informer]'s ability: [Zof Consumption], [Balustrade Spy], [Tangled Florahedron], [Ancient Grudge], [Balustrade Spy], [Undercity Informer], [Laboratory Maniac], [Tangled Florahedron], [Cabal Ritual], [Pelakka Predation], 
[04:03:02] [Malakir Rebirth], [Cabal Ritual], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Pelakka Predation], [Narcomoeba], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Narcomoeba], [Angel of Glory's Rise], [Dread Return], 
[04:03:02] [Gitaxian Probe], [Malakir Rebirth], [Wild Cantor], [Wild Cantor], [Wild Cantor], [Balustrade Spy], [Lotleth Giant], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Gitaxian Probe], [Malakir Rebirth], 
[04:03:02] [Narcomoeba], [Cabal Ritual], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Ray of Revelation], [Memory's Journey], [Cabal Ritual], [Dark Ritual], [Azami, Lady of Scrolls], [Dark Ritual], [Wild Cantor], 
[04:03:02] [Malakir Rebirth], [Pelakka Predation], [Balustrade Spy], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Undercity Informer], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Halo Scarab], [Narcomoeba], [Tangled Florahedron], [Pelakka Predation], 
[04:03:02] [Blackbloom Rogue], [Tangled Florahedron], [Zof Consumption], [Dark Ritual], [Haunted Dead], [Dread Return], and [Phantasmagorian].
[04:03:04] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:03:04] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:03:05] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:03:05] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:03:41] RenatoSky casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[04:03:41] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting ThyShuffler (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...).
[04:03:42] RenatoSky wins the game.
Winner: RenatoSky
Game 1 Completed.
[04:03:49] RenatoSky has left the game.

== Game 2 (843607838) ==
[Time] 1688778298
[04:04:59] PDBot has started watching.
[04:05:11] ThyShuffler chooses to play first.
[04:05:15] ThyShuffler mulligans to six cards.
[04:05:27] RenatoSky mulligans to six cards.
[04:05:32] ThyShuffler puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:05:36] RenatoSky mulligans to five cards.
[04:05:46] RenatoSky puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[04:05:46] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:05:46] ThyShuffler skips their draw step.
[04:05:49] ThyShuffler plays [Malakir Mire].
[04:05:51] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[04:05:55] RenatoSky plays [Malakir Mire].
[04:05:56] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:06:09] ThyShuffler casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting RenatoSky.
[04:06:09] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:06:23] ThyShuffler casts [Duress] targeting RenatoSky.
[04:06:36] RenatoSky discards [Dark Ritual].
[04:06:36] RenatoSky reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Malakir Mire], [Malakir Rebirth], ThyShuffler, [Tangled Vale], [Tangled Florahedron], [Tangled Vale], and [Tangled Florahedron].
[04:06:39] ThyShuffler plays [Malakir Mire].
[04:06:40] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[04:06:45] RenatoSky plays [Tangled Vale].
[04:06:47] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:06:56] ThyShuffler casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting RenatoSky.
[04:06:56] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:06:59] ThyShuffler plays [Blackbloom Bog].
[04:07:02] ThyShuffler casts [Dark Ritual].
[04:07:05] ThyShuffler casts [Goblin Charbelcher].
[04:07:07] Turn 3: RenatoSky
[04:07:17] RenatoSky plays [Malakir Mire].
[04:07:34] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[04:07:38] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Goblin Charbelcher] targeting RenatoSky ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a land card. Goblin Charbelcher deals ...).
[04:07:42] ThyShuffler reveals 54 cards with [Goblin Charbelcher]'s ability: [Blackbloom Rogue], [Balustrade Spy], [Bile Blight], [Pelakka Predation], [Narcomoeba], [Gitaxian Probe], [Undercity Informer], [Dark Ritual], [Azami, Lady of Scrolls], [Undercity Informer], 
[04:07:42] [Balustrade Spy], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Undercity Informer], [Bile Blight], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Balustrade Spy], [Malakir Rebirth], [Duress], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Cabal Ritual], 
[04:07:42] [Narcomoeba], [Cabal Ritual], [Lost Legacy], [Zof Consumption], [Scarab Feast], [Zof Consumption], [Laboratory Maniac], [Cabal Ritual], [Pelakka Predation], [Gitaxian Probe], 
[04:07:42] [Scarab Feast], [Zof Consumption], [Dark Ritual], [Pelakka Predation], [Undercity Informer], [Balustrade Spy], [Zof Consumption], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Phantasmagorian], [Dark Ritual], 
[04:07:42] [Simian Spirit Guide], [Bloodchief's Thirst], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Narcomoeba], [Angel of Glory's Rise], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Duress], [Bloodchief's Thirst], [Pelakka Predation], [Duress], 
[04:07:42] [Goblin Charbelcher], [Malakir Rebirth], [Scarab Feast], and [Narcomoeba].
[04:07:46] ThyShuffler wins the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (843608176) ==
[Time] 1688778507
[04:08:27] PDBot has started watching.
[04:08:32] RenatoSky chooses to play first.
[04:08:40] RenatoSky begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:08:56] ThyShuffler mulligans to six cards.
[04:09:13] ThyShuffler puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:09:13] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[04:09:13] RenatoSky skips their draw step.
[04:09:16] RenatoSky plays [Blackbloom Bog].
[04:09:17] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:09:20] ThyShuffler plays [Zof Bloodbog].
[04:09:21] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[04:09:55] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:10:08] ThyShuffler casts [Duress] targeting RenatoSky.
[04:10:18] RenatoSky discards [Dark Ritual].
[04:10:18] RenatoSky reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Simian Spirit Guide], [Nether Traitor], [Lotleth Giant], [Cabal Ritual], [Halo Scarab], and [Ancient Grudge].
[04:10:18] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Nether Traitor[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Nether Traitor triggers when it goes to the graveyard alongside other creatures.
[04:10:22] Turn 3: RenatoSky
[04:10:31] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:10:48] ThyShuffler exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[04:10:49] ThyShuffler casts [Cabal Ritual].
[04:10:56] ThyShuffler casts [Cabal Ritual].
[04:11:00] ThyShuffler casts [Balustrade Spy].
[04:11:11] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Balustrade Spy] onto the stack targeting RenatoSky (When Balustrade Spy enters the battlefield, target player reveals cards from the top of their libr...).
[04:11:21] RenatoSky reveals 55 cards with [Balustrade Spy]'s ability: [Memory's Journey], [Dread Return], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Scarab Feast], [Cabal Ritual], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Dark Ritual], [Tangled Florahedron], [Dread Return], [Narcomoeba], 
[04:11:21] [Gitaxian Probe], [Narcomoeba], [Haunted Dead], [Zof Consumption], [Balustrade Spy], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Soulshriek], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Cabal Ritual], [Laboratory Maniac], 
[04:11:21] [Tangled Florahedron], [Malakir Rebirth], [Azami, Lady of Scrolls], [Pelakka Predation], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Gitaxian Probe], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Balustrade Spy], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Narcomoeba], 
[04:11:21] [Scarab Feast], [Undercity Informer], [Pelakka Predation], [Pelakka Predation], [Undercity Informer], [Zof Consumption], [Tangled Florahedron], [Cabal Ritual], [Malakir Rebirth], [Dark Ritual], 
[04:11:21] [Simian Spirit Guide], [Tangled Florahedron], [Dark Ritual], [Mortal Combat], [Pelakka Predation], [Gitaxian Probe], [Malakir Rebirth], [Balustrade Spy], [Angel of Glory's Rise], [Balustrade Spy], 
[04:11:21] [Gitaxian Probe], [Malakir Rebirth], [Phantasmagorian], [Wild Cantor], and [Undercity Informer].
[04:11:22] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:11:22] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:11:22] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:12:15] RenatoSky exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[04:12:21] RenatoSky casts [Cabal Ritual].
[04:12:50] RenatoSky discards [Halo Scarab].
[04:12:50] RenatoSky discards [Lotleth Giant].
[04:12:50] RenatoSky discards [Nether Traitor].
[04:12:50] RenatoSky activates an ability of [Phantasmagorian] ( Return Phantasmagorian from your graveyard to your hand.).
[04:12:50] [Phantasmagorian] is returned to RenatoSky's hand from the graveyard.
[04:13:00] RenatoSky exiles [Halo Scarab] with [Halo Scarab]'s ability.
[04:13:00] RenatoSky activates an ability of [Halo Scarab] ( Create a Treasure token.).
[04:13:00] RenatoSky's [Halo Scarab] creates a Treasure Token.
[04:13:40] RenatoSky casts [Memory's Journey] from the graveyard targeting RenatoSky, [Soulshriek], [Gitaxian Probe], and [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:13:57] RenatoSky discards [Phantasmagorian].
[04:13:57] RenatoSky discards [Narcomoeba].
[04:13:57] RenatoSky activates an ability of [Haunted Dead] ( Return Haunted Dead from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
[04:13:58] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.).
[04:13:58] RenatoSky's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit Token.
[04:14:06] Turn 4: RenatoSky
[04:14:16] RenatoSky casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting ThyShuffler.
[04:14:16] RenatoSky draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:14:23] Quiritim has started watching.
[04:14:32] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Spirit Token], [Haunted Dead], [Narcomoeba], [Narcomoeba], and [Narcomoeba]
[04:14:37] [Balustrade Spy] blocks [Haunted Dead].
[04:14:44] RenatoSky casts [Soulshriek] targeting [Narcomoeba].
[04:14:44] RenatoSky wins the game.
[04:14:44] ThyShuffler loses the game.
Winner: RenatoSky
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: RenatoSky: 2–1
[04:14:51] ThyShuffler has left the game.