PennyDreadfulCommander
Sir Chadwick Thornberry Penny Dreadful
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
LandFetchShockTake2,Haay,HoffFather,TonyBombay

== Game 1 (843149430) ==
[Time] 1688431071
[03:37:57] PDBot has started watching.
[03:37:57] TonyBombay joined the game.
[03:37:57] HoffFather joined the game.
[03:38:05] TonyBombay chooses to play first.
[03:38:05] TonyBombay chooses [Sharuum the Hegemon] as their commander.
[03:38:06] HoffFather chooses [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire] as their commander.
[03:38:06] LandFetchShockTake2 chooses [Zur the Enchanter] as their commander.
[03:38:06] Haay chooses [Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker] as their commander.
[03:38:08] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
If control of Grave Betrayal or  Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker changes between a creature dying and the delayed EOT trigger going on the stack, the new controller gets the creature rather than the player who created the delayed trigger.
[03:38:21] TonyBombay begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:38:28] HoffFather begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:38:31] LandFetchShockTake2 mulligans to seven cards.
[03:38:35] Haay begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:38:38] LandFetchShockTake2 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:38:38] Turn 1: TonyBombay
[03:38:44] TonyBombay plays [Path of Ancestry].
[03:39:44] Turn 1: HoffFather
[03:39:53] HoffFather plays [Path of Ancestry].
[03:40:27] Turn 1: LandFetchShockTake2
[03:40:34] LandFetchShockTake2 plays [Island].
[03:40:49] Turn 1: Haay
[03:42:18] Haay plays [Reliquary Tower].
[03:42:22] Turn 2: TonyBombay
[03:42:22] TonyBombay plays [Swamp].
[03:42:23] TonyBombay casts [Orzhov Signet].
[03:42:24] Turn 2: HoffFather
[03:42:25] HoffFather plays [Forest].
[03:42:26] HoffFather casts [Nest Invader].
[03:42:48] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Nest Invader] onto the stack (When Nest Invader enters the battlefield, create a 0/1 colorless Eldrazi Spawn creature token. It ...).
[03:42:53] HoffFather's [Nest Invader] creates an Eldrazi Spawn Token.
[03:43:03] Turn 2: LandFetchShockTake2
[03:43:10] LandFetchShockTake2 plays [Plains].
[03:43:13] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Sphere of the Suns].
[03:43:34] Turn 2: Haay
[03:43:55] Haay plays [Swamp].
[03:44:00] Haay casts [Clattering Augur].
[03:44:11] Haay puts triggered ability from [Clattering Augur] onto the stack (When Clattering Augur enters the battlefield, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[03:44:42] Haay draws a card with [Clattering Augur]'s ability.
[03:44:52] Turn 3: TonyBombay
[03:44:59] TonyBombay plays [Fetid Heath].
[03:45:40] TonyBombay casts [Padeem, Consul of Innovation].
[03:45:58] Turn 3: HoffFather
[03:46:06] HoffFather plays [Mountain].
[03:46:34] LandFetchShockTake2 is being attacked by [Nest Invader]
[03:47:00] Turn 3: LandFetchShockTake2
[03:47:06] LandFetchShockTake2 plays [Plains].
[03:47:23] LandFetchShockTake2 removes a charge counter from [Sphere of the Suns].
[03:47:27] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Oath of Liliana].
[03:47:39] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Oath of Liliana] onto the stack (When Oath of Liliana enters the battlefield, each opponent sacrifices a creature.).
[03:48:46] Turn 3: Haay
[03:48:53] Haay plays [Swamp].
[03:49:00] Haay casts [Maggot Carrier].
[03:49:13] Haay puts triggered ability from [Maggot Carrier] onto the stack (When Maggot Carrier enters the battlefield, each player loses 1 life.).
[03:49:55] Turn 4: TonyBombay
[03:50:13] TonyBombay plays [Razortide Bridge].
[03:50:48] TonyBombay casts [Helm of the Host].
[03:51:05] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[03:51:49] Turn 4: HoffFather
[03:51:58] HoffFather plays [Blighted Woodland].
[03:52:37] Turn 4: LandFetchShockTake2
[03:52:46] LandFetchShockTake2 removes a charge counter from [Sphere of the Suns].
[03:52:49] LandFetchShockTake2 plays [Vivid Meadow].
[03:52:53] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Zur the Enchanter].
[03:53:14] Turn 4: Haay
[03:53:20] Haay plays [Swamp].
[03:53:38] Haay casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] (with kicker) targeting [Zur the Enchanter].
[03:54:13] Turn 5: TonyBombay
[03:54:37] TonyBombay plays TonyBombay.
[03:54:48] TonyBombay casts HoffFather.
[03:55:07] HoffFather activates an ability of [Blighted Woodland] ( Search your library for up to two basic land cards, put them onto the battlefield tapped, then sh...).
[03:55:51] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[03:55:59] Turn 5: HoffFather
[03:56:08] HoffFather plays [Mountain].
[03:56:24] HoffFather casts [Bloodgift Demon].
[03:56:49] Turn 5: LandFetchShockTake2
[03:56:54] LandFetchShockTake2 plays [Plains].
[03:57:06] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Confounding Conundrum].
[03:57:09] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Confounding Conundrum] onto the stack (When Confounding Conundrum enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[03:57:12] LandFetchShockTake2 draws a card with [Confounding Conundrum]'s ability.
[03:57:21] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Oblivion Ring].
[03:57:46] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Oblivion Ring] onto the stack targeting [Bloodgift Demon] (When Oblivion Ring enters the battlefield, exile another target nonland permanent.).
[03:58:16] Turn 5: Haay
[03:58:25] Haay plays [Swamp].
[03:59:04] TonyBombay activates an ability of HoffFather ( Draw a card.).
[03:59:04] TonyBombay draws a card with HoffFather's ability.
[03:59:11] Turn 6: TonyBombay
[03:59:41] TonyBombay plays [Swamp].
[03:59:50] TonyBombay casts [Hedron Archive].
[04:00:50] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:01:03] Turn 6: HoffFather
[04:01:16] HoffFather plays [Rogue's Passage].
[04:01:37] HoffFather casts [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire].
[04:01:37] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire] onto the stack (When that mana is spent to cast a creature spell that shares a creature type with your commander, ...).
[04:02:15] Haay activates an ability of [Clattering Augur] ( Return Clattering Augur from your graveyard to your hand.).
[04:02:23] [Clattering Augur] is returned to Haay's hand from the graveyard.
[04:02:39] HoffFather scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[04:03:11] Turn 6: LandFetchShockTake2
[04:03:21] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Kasmina's Transmutation] targeting [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire].
[04:03:45] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Thopter Arrest].
[04:04:03] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Thopter Arrest] onto the stack targeting HoffFather (When Thopter Arrest enters the battlefield, exile target artifact or creature an opponent controls...).
[04:04:26] TonyBombay activates an ability of HoffFather ( Draw a card.).
[04:04:27] TonyBombay draws a card with HoffFather's ability.
[04:04:32] LandFetchShockTake2's Triggered ability from Thopter Arrest is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[04:04:45] Turn 6: Haay
[04:04:58] Haay casts [Clattering Augur].
[04:05:03] Haay puts triggered ability from [Clattering Augur] onto the stack (When Clattering Augur enters the battlefield, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[04:05:04] Haay draws a card with [Clattering Augur]'s ability.
[04:05:50] Turn 7: TonyBombay
[04:06:00] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:06:59] TonyBombay plays [Island].
[04:08:50] TonyBombay casts [Sharuum the Hegemon].
[04:08:51] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Sharuum the Hegemon] onto the stack (When that mana is spent to cast a creature spell that shares a creature type with your commander, ...).
[04:09:09] TonyBombay scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[04:09:28] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Sharuum the Hegemon] onto the stack targeting [Trading Post] (When Sharuum the Hegemon enters the battlefield, you may return target artifact card from your gra...).
[04:10:04] Turn 7: HoffFather
[04:10:16] HoffFather plays [Forest].
[04:10:42] HoffFather casts [Ulamog's Crusher].
[04:11:25] Turn 7: LandFetchShockTake2
[04:11:29] LandFetchShockTake2 plays [Island].
[04:11:34] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Porphyry Nodes].
[04:11:34] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Porphyry Nodes[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Porphyry Nodes allows a creature to regenerate if it's tied for the least power.
[04:12:01] LandFetchShockTake2 removes a charge counter from [Sphere of the Suns].
[04:12:04] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Zur the Enchanter].
[04:12:23] Turn 7: Haay
[04:12:29] Haay plays [Swamp].
[04:12:37] Haay casts [Grave Pact].
[04:14:09] HoffFather is being attacked by [Maggot Carrier]
[04:14:30] [Ulamog's Crusher] blocks [Maggot Carrier].
[04:14:48] Haay puts triggered ability from [Grave Pact] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control dies, each other player sacrifices a creature.).
[04:15:10] TonyBombay activates an ability of [Trading Post] ( Create a 0/1 white Goat creature token.).
[04:15:41] TonyBombay's [Trading Post] creates a Goat Token.
[04:16:05] Haay casts [Doom Blade] targeting [Goat Token].
[04:16:28] TonyBombay sacrifices [Sharuum the Hegemon].
[04:16:29] HoffFather sacrifices [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire].
[04:16:32] LandFetchShockTake2 sacrifices [Zur the Enchanter].
[04:17:20] Turn 8: TonyBombay
[04:17:29] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:18:28] TonyBombay casts [Dreamstone Hedron].
[04:18:56] TonyBombay casts [Scourglass].
[04:19:30] Turn 8: HoffFather
[04:19:41] HoffFather plays [Grim Backwoods].
[04:20:07] TonyBombay is being attacked by [Ulamog's Crusher]
[04:20:08] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Ulamog's Crusher] onto the stack (Annihilator 2 (Whenever this creature attacks, defending player sacrifices two permanents.)).
[04:20:24] TonyBombay sacrifices [Swamp].
[04:20:31] TonyBombay sacrifices [Hedron Archive].
[04:21:06] Turn 8: LandFetchShockTake2
[04:21:07] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Porphyry Nodes] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy the creature with the least power. It can't be regenerate...).
[04:21:27] Haay puts triggered ability from [Grave Pact] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control dies, each other player sacrifices a creature.).
[04:21:58] HoffFather activates an ability of [Grim Backwoods] ( Draw a card.).
[04:21:59] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Porphyry Nodes] onto the stack (When there are no creatures on the battlefield, sacrifice Porphyry Nodes.).
[04:22:19] HoffFather draws a card with [Grim Backwoods]'s ability.
[04:22:47] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Ashes of the Abhorrent].
[04:23:08] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Monastery Siege].
[04:23:26] LandFetchShockTake2 chooses Khans for [Monastery Siege].
[04:23:53] Turn 8: Haay
[04:26:13] Turn 9: TonyBombay
[04:26:22] TonyBombay plays [Plains].
[04:26:29] TonyBombay casts [Invasion of New Capenna].
[04:28:00] LandFetchShockTake2 is protecting TonyBombay's [Invasion of New Capenna].
[04:28:00] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Invasion of New Capenna] onto the stack (When Invasion of New Capenna enters the battlefield, you may sacrifice an artifact or creature. Wh...).
[04:28:08] TonyBombay casts [Ethersworn Adjudicator].
[04:28:10] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:28:25] Turn 9: HoffFather
[04:28:44] HoffFather casts [From Beyond].
[04:29:18] HoffFather casts [Varragoth, Bloodsky Sire].
[04:30:04] Turn 9: LandFetchShockTake2
[04:30:06] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Monastery Siege] onto the stack (At the beginning of your draw step, draw an additional card, then discard a card.).
[04:30:17] LandFetchShockTake2 draws a card with [Monastery Siege]'s ability.
[04:30:24] LandFetchShockTake2 discards [Dauthi Embrace].
[04:30:45] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Bound by Moonsilver] targeting [Varragoth, Bloodsky Sire].
[04:31:07] Turn 9: Haay
[04:31:38] Haay casts [Crypt Ghast].
[04:32:39] Haay casts [Vampiric Rites].
[04:32:39] Haay puts triggered ability from [Crypt Ghast] onto the stack (Extort (Whenever you cast a spell, you may pay {;b}. If you do, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[04:34:33] Turn 10: TonyBombay
[04:34:36] TonyBombay activates an ability of [Scourglass] ( Destroy all permanents except for artifacts and lands.).
[04:34:52] HoffFather activates an ability of [From Beyond] ( Search your library for an Eldrazi card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle.).
[04:35:08] Haay activates an ability of [Vampiric Rites] ( You gain 1 life and draw a card.).
[04:35:09] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Ashes of the Abhorrent] onto the stack (Whenever a creature dies, you gain 1 life.).
[04:35:10] Haay puts triggered ability from [Grave Pact] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control dies, each other player sacrifices a creature.).
[04:35:32] TonyBombay activates an ability of [Trading Post] ( Create a 0/1 white Goat creature token.).
[04:36:15] TonyBombay's [Trading Post] creates a Goat Token.
[04:36:42] TonyBombay sacrifices [Goat Token].
[04:36:43] HoffFather sacrifices [Varragoth, Bloodsky Sire].
[04:36:45] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Ashes of the Abhorrent] onto the stack (Whenever a creature dies, you gain 1 life.).
[04:36:45] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Ashes of the Abhorrent] onto the stack (Whenever a creature dies, you gain 1 life.).
[04:37:34] Haay draws a card with [Vampiric Rites]'s ability.
[04:38:19] HoffFather reveals [Deceiver of Form].
[04:38:34] LandFetchShockTake2 puts triggered ability from [Oblivion Ring] onto the stack (When Oblivion Ring leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to the battlefield under its own...).
[04:38:48] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:40:07] Turn 10: HoffFather
[04:40:14] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Bloodgift Demon] onto the stack targeting HoffFather (At the beginning of your upkeep, target player draws a card and loses 1 life.).
[04:40:20] HoffFather draws a card with [Bloodgift Demon]'s ability.
[04:40:56] HoffFather casts [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire].
[04:41:24] Haay is being attacked by [Bloodgift Demon]
[04:41:56] Turn 10: LandFetchShockTake2
[04:42:34] Turn 10: Haay
[04:42:40] Haay plays [Swamp].
[04:42:52] Haay casts [Reprocess].
[04:43:25] Haay draws seven cards with [Reprocess].
[04:44:06] TonyBombay activates an ability of [Dreamstone Hedron] ( Draw three cards.).
[04:44:13] TonyBombay draws three cards with [Dreamstone Hedron]'s ability.
[04:45:04] TonyBombay activates an ability of [Ethersworn Adjudicator] targeting [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire] ( Destroy target creature or enchantment.).
[04:46:18] Haay discards [Bone Shredder].
[04:46:18] Haay discards [Harvester of Souls].
[04:46:18] Haay discards [Swamp].
[04:46:18] Haay discards [Gray Merchant of Asphodel].
[04:46:18] Haay discards [Killing Wave].
[04:46:21] Turn 11: TonyBombay
[04:47:18] TonyBombay casts [Reality Heist].
[04:47:33] TonyBombay puts [Nevinyrral's Disk] and [Dowsing Dagger] into their hand with with [Reality Heist].
[04:47:50] TonyBombay casts [Dowsing Dagger].
[04:48:05] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Dowsing Dagger] onto the stack targeting Haay (When Dowsing Dagger enters the battlefield, target opponent creates two 0/2 green Plant creature t...).
[04:48:14] Haay's [Dowsing Dagger] creates two Plant Tokens under Haay's control.
[04:48:29] TonyBombay activates an ability of [Dowsing Dagger] targeting [Ethersworn Adjudicator] (Equip {2}).
[04:48:43] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:48:52] HoffFather is being attacked by [Ethersworn Adjudicator]
[04:49:05] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Dowsing Dagger] onto the stack (Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, you may transform Dowsing Dagger.).
[04:49:11] [Dowsing Dagger] transforms into [Lost Vale].
[04:49:24] Turn 11: HoffFather
[04:49:36] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Bloodgift Demon] onto the stack targeting HoffFather (At the beginning of your upkeep, target player draws a card and loses 1 life.).
[04:49:45] HoffFather draws a card with [Bloodgift Demon]'s ability.
[04:49:52] HoffFather plays [Swamp].
[04:50:24] HoffFather casts [Artisan of Kozilek].
[04:50:52] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Artisan of Kozilek] onto the stack targeting [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire] (When you cast this spell, you may return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefie...).
[04:51:43] TonyBombay is being attacked by [Bloodgift Demon]
[04:52:22] Turn 11: LandFetchShockTake2
[04:52:31] LandFetchShockTake2 casts [Talisman of Hierarchy].
[04:52:55] Turn 11: Haay
[04:53:29] Haay plays [Swamp].
[04:53:42] Haay casts [Bone Splinters] targeting [Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire].
[04:54:07] Turn 12: TonyBombay
[04:54:13] TonyBombay puts triggered ability from [Helm of the Host] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, create a token that's a copy of equipped creature, except...).
[04:55:23] TonyBombay plays Haay.
[04:55:38] TonyBombay casts TonyBombay.
[04:55:56] Haay has conceded from the game.
[04:56:00] Haay loses the game.
[04:56:00] Haay is now a watcher.
[04:56:19] Turn 12: HoffFather
[04:56:23] TonyBombay has conceded from the game.
[04:56:25] TonyBombay loses the game.
[04:56:26] TonyBombay is now a watcher.
[04:56:36] HoffFather puts triggered ability from [Bloodgift Demon] onto the stack targeting HoffFather (At the beginning of your upkeep, target player draws a card and loses 1 life.).
[04:56:44] LandFetchShockTake2 has conceded from the game.
[04:56:44] HoffFather wins the game.
Winner: HoffFather
Game 1 Completed.
[04:57:05] HoffFather has left the game.
[04:57:24] TonyBombay has stopped watching.
[04:57:26] LandFetchShockTake2 has left the game.