PennyDreadful
PD vs DownToValueTown
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
DownToValueTown,RenatoSky

== Game 1 (838466732) ==
[Time] 1684546065
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 29.04
[Gatherling] Round=5
[04:27:46] PDBot has started watching.
[04:27:54] RenatoSky chooses to play first.
[04:28:08] RenatoSky mulligans to six cards.
[04:28:13] DownToValueTown begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:28:15] RenatoSky mulligans to five cards.
[04:28:31] RenatoSky puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[04:28:31] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[04:28:31] RenatoSky.
[04:28:31] RenatoSky skips their draw step.
[04:28:34] RenatoSky plays [Zof Bloodbog].
[04:28:35] Turn 1: DownToValueTown
[04:28:35] DownToValueTown.
[04:28:38] DownToValueTown plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:28:40] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[04:28:40] RenatoSky.
[04:28:47] RenatoSky plays [Spikefield Cave].
[04:28:51] RenatoSky casts [Dark Ritual].
[04:28:55] RenatoSky casts [Cabal Ritual].
[04:28:57] RenatoSky casts [Balustrade Spy].
[04:29:02] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Balustrade Spy] onto the stack targeting RenatoSky (When Balustrade Spy enters the battlefield, target player reveals cards from the top of their libr...).
[04:29:03] RenatoSky reveals 58 cards with [Balustrade Spy]'s ability: [Blackbloom Rogue], [Narcomoeba], [Cabal Ritual], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Malakir Rebirth], [Angel of Glory's Rise], [Gitaxian Probe], [Zof Consumption], [Undercity Informer], [Pelakka Predation], 
[04:29:03] [Undercity Informer], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Undercity Informer], [Zof Consumption], [Dread Return], [Duress], [Spikefield Hazard], [Pelakka Predation], [Duress], 
[04:29:03] [Dread Return], [Gitaxian Probe], [Lost Legacy], [Lotleth Giant], [Pelakka Predation], [Gitaxian Probe], [Dark Ritual], [Gitaxian Probe], [Balustrade Spy], [Pelakka Predation], 
[04:29:03] [Undercity Informer], [Cabal Ritual], [Dark Ritual], [Malakir Rebirth], [Balustrade Spy], [Dark Ritual], [Phantasmagorian], [Malakir Rebirth], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Cabal Ritual], 
[04:29:03] [Goblin Charbelcher], [Lost Legacy], [Narcomoeba], [Spikefield Hazard], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Azami, Lady of Scrolls], [Duress], [Zof Consumption], [Narcomoeba], 
[04:29:03] [Haunted Dead], [Narcomoeba], [Malakir Rebirth], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Duress], [Laboratory Maniac], RenatoSky, and DownToValueTown.
[04:29:05] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:29:05] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:29:05] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:29:05] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[04:29:38] RenatoSky casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[04:29:39] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting DownToValueTown (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...).
[04:29:39] RenatoSky wins the game.
Winner: RenatoSky
Game 1 Completed.
[04:29:45] DownToValueTown has left the game.

== Game 2 (838467106) ==
[Time] 1684546293
[04:31:33] PDBot has started watching.
[04:31:34] DownToValueTown chooses to play first.
[04:31:46] DownToValueTown mulligans to six cards.
[04:31:54] RenatoSky mulligans to six cards.
[04:31:58] DownToValueTown puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:32:00] RenatoSky mulligans to five cards.
[04:32:03] RenatoSky mulligans to four cards.
[04:32:13] RenatoSky mulligans to three cards.
[04:32:58] RenatoSky puts four cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with three cards in hand.
[04:32:58] Turn 1: DownToValueTown
[04:32:58] DownToValueTown.
[04:32:58] DownToValueTown skips their draw step.
[04:33:03] DownToValueTown plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:33:05] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[04:33:05] RenatoSky.
[04:33:09] RenatoSky plays [Malakir Mire].
[04:33:14] Turn 2: DownToValueTown
[04:33:14] DownToValueTown.
[04:33:21] DownToValueTown plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:33:25] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[04:33:25] RenatoSky.
[04:33:29] RenatoSky plays [Malakir Mire].
[04:33:42] DownToValueTown discards [Secluded Steppe].
[04:33:42] DownToValueTown cycles [Secluded Steppe].
[04:33:45] Turn 3: DownToValueTown
[04:33:45] DownToValueTown.
[04:33:49] DownToValueTown plays [Fetid Heath].
[04:33:52] DownToValueTown casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[04:33:54] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting RenatoSky (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...).
[04:34:20] RenatoSky reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Undercity Informer] and [Sickening Dreams].
[04:34:21] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sickening Dreams[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If a card that requires an additional cost involving X would be cast without paying its mana cost, it restarts the game when the next spell is cast
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Sickening Dreams` or `!notbugged Sickening Dreams`
[04:34:27] Turn 3: RenatoSky
[04:34:27] RenatoSky.
[04:34:46] RenatoSky plays [Blackbloom Bog].
[04:34:55] Turn 4: DownToValueTown
[04:34:55] DownToValueTown.
[04:34:59] DownToValueTown plays [Fetid Heath].
[04:35:04] RenatoSky is being attacked by [Mesmeric Fiend]
[04:35:16] DownToValueTown casts [Valiant Rescuer].
[04:35:22] Turn 4: RenatoSky
[04:35:22] RenatoSky.
[04:35:35] RenatoSky discards [Dread Return].
[04:35:35] RenatoSky casts [Sickening Dreams]. (X is 1).
[04:35:40] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack (When Mesmeric Fiend leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[04:35:50] RenatoSky casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting DownToValueTown.
[04:35:52] RenatoSky draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:36:15] DownToValueTown discards [Fade from Memory].
[04:36:15] DownToValueTown cycles [Fade from Memory].
[04:36:20] Turn 5: DownToValueTown
[04:36:20] DownToValueTown.
[04:36:26] DownToValueTown plays [Snow-Covered Plains].
[04:36:32] DownToValueTown casts ability from [Yorion, Sky Nomad] ( Put Yorion, Sky Nomad into your hand.).
[04:36:38] Turn 5: RenatoSky
[04:36:38] RenatoSky.
[04:36:50] Turn 6: DownToValueTown
[04:36:50] DownToValueTown.
[04:37:30] DownToValueTown casts [Combat Thresher].
[04:37:33] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Combat Thresher] onto the stack (When Combat Thresher enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[04:37:36] DownToValueTown draws a card with [Combat Thresher]'s ability.
[04:37:41] DownToValueTown plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:37:49] Turn 6: RenatoSky
[04:37:49] RenatoSky.
[04:37:54] RenatoSky plays [Pelakka Caverns].
[04:37:59] RenatoSky casts [Undercity Informer].
[04:38:05] Turn 7: DownToValueTown
[04:38:05] DownToValueTown.
[04:38:09] DownToValueTown plays [Snow-Covered Plains].
[04:38:23] DownToValueTown casts [Yorion, Sky Nomad].
[04:38:24] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Yorion, Sky Nomad] onto the stack (When Yorion, Sky Nomad enters the battlefield, exile any number of other nonland permanents you ow...).
[04:38:31] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Yorion, Sky Nomad] onto the stack (Return those cards to the battlefield at the beginning of the next end step.).
[04:38:34] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Combat Thresher] onto the stack (When Combat Thresher enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[04:38:34] DownToValueTown draws a card with [Combat Thresher]'s ability.
[04:38:37] Turn 7: RenatoSky
[04:38:37] RenatoSky.
[04:39:02] RenatoSky casts [Goblin Charbelcher].
[04:39:12] DownToValueTown discards [Fade from Memory].
[04:39:12] DownToValueTown cycles [Fade from Memory].
[04:39:15] Turn 8: DownToValueTown
[04:39:15] DownToValueTown.
[04:39:24] RenatoSky is being attacked by [Combat Thresher] and [Yorion, Sky Nomad]
[04:39:43] DownToValueTown discards [Valiant Rescuer].
[04:39:43] DownToValueTown cycles [Valiant Rescuer].
[04:39:53] DownToValueTown discards [Valiant Rescuer].
[04:39:53] DownToValueTown cycles [Valiant Rescuer].
[04:39:59] DownToValueTown plays [Snow-Covered Plains].
[04:40:05] DownToValueTown discards [Fade from Memory].
[04:40:05] DownToValueTown cycles [Fade from Memory].
[04:40:17] DownToValueTown discards [Scarab Feast].
[04:40:17] DownToValueTown cycles [Scarab Feast].
[04:40:23] DownToValueTown has conceded from the game.
[04:40:23] RenatoSky wins the game.
Winner: RenatoSky
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: RenatoSky: 2–0
[04:40:31] RenatoSky has left the game.
[04:40:35] DownToValueTown draws their next card.
[04:40:36] DownToValueTown draws their next card.
[04:40:37] DownToValueTown draws their next card.