PennyDreadful
PD vs earterms123
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
earterms123,RenatoSky

== Game 1 (836923994) ==
[Time] 1683394779
[20:39:40] PDBot has started watching.
[20:39:40] RenatoSky joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Season 29 Kickoff
[Gatherling] Round=1
[20:39:53] RenatoSky chooses to play first.
[20:40:09] RenatoSky mulligans to six cards.
[20:40:12] earterms123 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:40:15] RenatoSky mulligans to five cards.
[20:40:28] RenatoSky puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[20:40:28] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[20:40:28] RenatoSky.
[20:40:30] RenatoSky skips their draw step.
[20:40:39] RenatoSky plays [Pelakka Caverns].
[20:40:43] Turn 1: earterms123
[20:40:43] earterms123.
[20:40:45] earterms123 plays [Island].
[20:40:50] earterms123 casts [Ponder].
[20:41:01] earterms123 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[20:41:01] earterms123 draws a card with [Ponder].
[20:41:03] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[20:41:03] RenatoSky.
[20:41:12] RenatoSky casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting earterms123.
[20:41:12] RenatoSky draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[20:41:20] RenatoSky plays [Spikefield Cave].
[20:41:24] Turn 2: earterms123
[20:41:24] earterms123.
[20:41:36] earterms123 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[20:41:39] earterms123 casts [Founding the Third Path].
[20:41:47] earterms123 puts triggered ability from [Founding the Third Path] onto the stack (You may cast an instant or sorcery spell with mana value 1 or two from your hand without paying it...).
[20:41:49] earterms123 casts [Ponder].
[20:42:20] earterms123 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[20:42:20] earterms123 draws a card with [Ponder].
[20:42:26] Turn 3: RenatoSky
[20:42:26] RenatoSky.
[20:42:29] TheWatchWander has started watching.
[20:42:35] RenatoSky casts [Dark Ritual].
[20:42:42] RenatoSky casts [Balustrade Spy].
[20:42:47] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Balustrade Spy] onto the stack targeting RenatoSky (When Balustrade Spy enters the battlefield, target player reveals cards from the top of their libr...).
[20:42:50] RenatoSky reveals 56 cards with [Balustrade Spy]'s ability: [Azami, Lady of Scrolls], [Balustrade Spy], [Cabal Ritual], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Pelakka Predation], [Undercity Informer], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Cabal Ritual], [Duress], [Malakir Rebirth], 
[20:42:50] [Lotleth Giant], [Balustrade Spy], [Angel of Glory's Rise], [Dark Ritual], [Narcomoeba], [Cabal Ritual], [Spikefield Hazard], [Dread Return], [Duress], [Gitaxian Probe], 
[20:42:50] [Balustrade Spy], [Sickening Dreams], [Gitaxian Probe], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Dread Return], [Blackbloom Rogue], [Laboratory Maniac], [Sickening Dreams], [Narcomoeba], [Duress], 
[20:42:50] [Malakir Rebirth], [Spikefield Hazard], [Zof Consumption], [Narcomoeba], [Dark Ritual], [Zof Consumption], [Duress], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Phantasmagorian], [Simian Spirit Guide], 
[20:42:50] [Lotleth Giant], [Cabal Ritual], [Undercity Informer], [Undercity Informer], [Pelakka Predation], [Malakir Rebirth], [Haunted Dead], [Dark Ritual], [Zof Consumption], [Zof Consumption], 
[20:42:50] [Goblin Charbelcher], [Undercity Informer], [Goblin Charbelcher], [Pelakka Predation], [Narcomoeba], and [Spikefield Hazard].
[20:42:52] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[20:42:52] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[20:42:52] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[20:42:52] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[20:42:52] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Sickening Dreams[sU] has an avoidable game breaking bug.
If a card that requires an additional cost involving X would be cast without paying its mana cost, it restarts the game when the next spell is cast
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Sickening Dreams` or `!notbugged Sickening Dreams`
[20:43:27] RenatoSky casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[20:43:28] RenatoSky puts triggered ability from [Angel of Glory's Rise] onto the stack (When Angel of Glory's Rise enters the battlefield, exile all Zombies, then return all Human creatu...).
[20:43:43] RenatoSky activates an ability of [Azami, Lady of Scrolls] ( Draw a card.).
[20:43:43] RenatoSky draws a card with [Azami, Lady of Scrolls]'s ability.
[20:43:43] RenatoSky wins the game.
Winner: RenatoSky
Game 1 Completed.
[20:43:47] earterms123 has left the game.

== Game 2 (836924640) ==
[Time] 1683395146
[20:45:47] PDBot has started watching.
[20:46:06] earterms123 mulligans to six cards.
[20:46:14] RenatoSky mulligans to six cards.
[20:46:16] earterms123 mulligans to five cards.
[20:46:27] RenatoSky puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[20:46:31] earterms123 mulligans to four cards.
[20:46:34] earterms123 mulligans to three cards.
[20:46:43] earterms123 puts four cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with three cards in hand.
[20:46:43] Turn 1: earterms123
[20:46:43] earterms123.
[20:46:45] earterms123 skips their draw step.
[20:46:45] earterms123 plays [Island].
[20:46:47] earterms123 casts [Silent Gravestone].
[20:46:49] Turn 1: RenatoSky
[20:46:49] RenatoSky.
[20:47:03] RenatoSky plays [Spikefield Cave].
[20:47:04] Turn 2: earterms123
[20:47:04] earterms123.
[20:47:10] earterms123 casts [Ponder].
[20:47:21] earterms123 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[20:47:21] earterms123 draws a card with [Ponder].
[20:47:21] earterms123 plays [Swamp].
[20:47:23] Turn 2: RenatoSky
[20:47:23] RenatoSky.
[20:47:33] RenatoSky plays [Malakir Mire].
[20:47:39] Turn 3: earterms123
[20:47:40] earterms123.
[20:47:45] earterms123 casts [Ponder].
[20:47:57] earterms123 chooses to shuffle their library.
[20:47:57] earterms123 draws a card with [Ponder].
[20:48:09] Turn 3: RenatoSky
[20:48:09] RenatoSky.
[20:48:17] RenatoSky plays [Spikefield Cave].
[20:48:30] Turn 4: earterms123
[20:48:30] earterms123.
[20:48:42] earterms123 casts [Dark Ritual].
[20:48:46] earterms123 casts [Lost Legacy] targeting RenatoSky.
[20:49:00] earterms123 names Dread Return for [Lost Legacy].
[20:49:16] earterms123 exiled 2 copies of Dread Return (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 2 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[20:49:22] Turn 4: RenatoSky
[20:49:22] RenatoSky.
[20:49:35] RenatoSky casts [Blackbloom Rogue].
[20:49:38] Turn 5: earterms123
[20:49:38] earterms123.
[20:49:43] Turn 5: RenatoSky
[20:49:43] RenatoSky.
[20:49:50] Turn 6: earterms123
[20:49:50] earterms123.
[20:50:10] earterms123 casts [Cabal Ritual].
[20:50:12] earterms123 casts [Cruel Bargain].
[20:50:14] earterms123 draws four cards with [Cruel Bargain].
[20:50:17] earterms123 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[20:50:22] Turn 6: RenatoSky
[20:50:22] RenatoSky.
[20:50:53] RenatoSky casts [Cabal Ritual].
[20:51:00] RenatoSky casts [Dark Ritual].
[20:51:06] RenatoSky casts [Dark Ritual].
[20:51:17] RenatoSky casts [Cabal Ritual].
[20:51:30] RenatoSky casts [Goblin Charbelcher].
[20:51:33] earterms123 has conceded from the game.
[20:51:33] RenatoSky wins the game.
Winner: RenatoSky
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: RenatoSky: 2–0
[20:51:37] earterms123 has left the game.