PennyDreadful
PD r1 vs thyshuffler
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
ThyShuffler,gearhulkazul

== Game 1 (833690170) ==
[Time] 1680305930
[02:38:51] PDBot has started watching.
[02:38:51] ThyShuffler joined the game.
[02:38:51] gearhulkazul joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 28.07
[Gatherling] Round=2
[02:38:58] ThyShuffler chooses to play first.
[02:39:01] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:39:10] [CHAT] gearhulkazul: gl hf
[02:39:12] gearhulkazul mulligans to six cards.
[02:39:14] [CHAT] ThyShuffler: you too
[02:39:20] thejacob has started watching.
[02:39:33] gearhulkazul puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[02:39:33] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[02:39:34] ThyShuffler skips their draw step.
[02:39:40] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[02:39:42] Turn 1: gearhulkazul
[02:39:45] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:39:54] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[02:39:56] ThyShuffler plays [Caves of Koilos].
[02:39:59] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[02:40:13] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting gearhulkazul (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[02:40:16] slasha has started watching.
[02:40:27] gearhulkazul reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Spell Pierce], [Island], [Ponder], [Vapor Snag], and [Ponder].
[02:40:47] gearhulkazul casts [Vapor Snag] targeting [Tidehollow Sculler].
[02:40:47] gearhulkazul returns [Tidehollow Sculler] to its owner's hand with [Vapor Snag].
[02:40:48] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[02:40:52] Turn 2: gearhulkazul
[02:40:55] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:40:58] gearhulkazul casts [Ponder].
[02:41:07] gearhulkazul chooses to shuffle their library.
[02:41:07] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Ponder].
[02:41:12] gearhulkazul casts [Ponder].
[02:41:33] thejacob has stopped watching.
[02:41:38] gearhulkazul chooses to not shuffle their library.
[02:41:38] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Ponder].
[02:41:44] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[02:41:50] ThyShuffler casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting gearhulkazul.
[02:41:53] gearhulkazul reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Lonely Sandbar], [Island], [Phyrexian Dreadnought], [Spell Pierce], and [Ponder].
[02:42:04] Turn 3: gearhulkazul
[02:42:07] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:42:11] gearhulkazul casts [Ponder].
[02:42:30] gearhulkazul chooses to not shuffle their library.
[02:42:30] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Ponder].
[02:42:37] gearhulkazul casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting ThyShuffler.
[02:42:37] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[02:42:55] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[02:43:04] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[02:43:13] gearhulkazul casts [Impulse].
[02:43:38] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting gearhulkazul (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[02:43:42] gearhulkazul reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Island], [Island], and [Lonely Sandbar].
[02:43:47] Turn 4: gearhulkazul
[02:43:54] gearhulkazul discards [Lonely Sandbar].
[02:43:54] gearhulkazul cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
[02:44:02] gearhulkazul discards [Lonely Sandbar].
[02:44:02] gearhulkazul cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
[02:44:04] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:44:07] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[02:44:16] gearhulkazul is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler]
[02:44:25] ThyShuffler casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting gearhulkazul.
[02:44:32] gearhulkazul reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Defabricate], [Island], and [Island].
[02:44:41] Turn 5: gearhulkazul
[02:44:43] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:44:56] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[02:44:58] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[02:45:05] gearhulkazul is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler]
[02:45:15] ThyShuffler casts [Kambal, Consul of Allocation].
[02:45:19] Turn 6: gearhulkazul
[02:45:22] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:45:28] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[02:45:30] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[02:45:39] gearhulkazul is being attacked by [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] and [Tidehollow Sculler]
[02:45:47] ThyShuffler casts [Sin Collector].
[02:45:56] gearhulkazul returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Deprive]'s ability.
[02:45:56] gearhulkazul casts gearhulkazul targeting [Sin Collector].
[02:45:56] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a noncreature spell, that player loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[02:46:05] Turn 7: gearhulkazul
[02:46:11] gearhulkazul casts [Impulse].
[02:46:12] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a noncreature spell, that player loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[02:46:31] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:46:34] gearhulkazul casts [Tempest Djinn].
[02:46:38] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[02:46:55] ThyShuffler casts [Phyrexian Arena].
[02:47:06] Turn 8: gearhulkazul
[02:47:38] Turn 9: ThyShuffler
[02:47:38] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[02:47:43] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[02:47:45] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[02:47:52] ThyShuffler casts [Gray Merchant of Asphodel].
[02:47:59] gearhulkazul casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Gray Merchant of Asphodel].
[02:47:59] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a noncreature spell, that player loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[02:48:09] Turn 9: gearhulkazul
[02:48:21] gearhulkazul has conceded from the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (833690968) ==
[Time] 1680306675
[02:51:16] PDBot has started watching.
[02:51:21] gearhulkazul chooses to play first.
[02:51:29] gearhulkazul begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:51:32] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:51:32] Turn 1: gearhulkazul
[02:51:32] gearhulkazul skips their draw step.
[02:51:34] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:51:37] gearhulkazul casts [Ponder].
[02:51:41] gearhulkazul chooses to shuffle their library.
[02:51:41] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Ponder].
[02:51:46] gearhulkazul casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting ThyShuffler.
[02:51:46] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[02:52:01] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[02:52:04] ThyShuffler plays [Temple of Silence].
[02:52:04] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[02:52:16] ThyShuffler scrys 1 (1 top, 0 bottom).
[02:52:21] Turn 2: gearhulkazul
[02:52:23] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:52:26] gearhulkazul casts [Delver of Secrets].
[02:52:30] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[02:52:33] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[02:52:37] Turn 3: gearhulkazul
[02:52:37] gearhulkazul puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[02:52:48] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:52:51] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Delver of Secrets]
[02:52:55] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[02:52:58] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[02:53:02] ThyShuffler casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting gearhulkazul.
[02:53:03] gearhulkazul reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Island], [Island], [Deprive], [Defabricate], and [Repeal].
[02:53:24] Turn 4: gearhulkazul
[02:53:25] gearhulkazul puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[02:53:33] gearhulkazul reveals [Vapor Snag].
[02:53:33] [Delver of Secrets] transforms into [Insectile Aberration].
[02:53:36] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:53:40] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration]
[02:53:46] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[02:53:49] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[02:53:53] ThyShuffler casts [Kambal, Consul of Allocation].
[02:54:28] Turn 5: gearhulkazul
[02:54:31] gearhulkazul plays [Island].
[02:54:35] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration]
[02:54:52] gearhulkazul casts [Vapor Snag] targeting [Kambal, Consul of Allocation].
[02:54:52] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a noncreature spell, that player loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[02:54:58] gearhulkazul returns [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] to its owner's hand with [Vapor Snag].
[02:55:01] gearhulkazul casts [Ponder].
[02:55:30] gearhulkazul chooses to not shuffle their library.
[02:55:30] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Ponder].
[02:55:35] gearhulkazul casts [Tempest Djinn].
[02:55:38] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[02:55:44] ThyShuffler casts [Ravenous Chupacabra].
[02:55:51] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Ravenous Chupacabra] onto the stack targeting [Tempest Djinn] (When Ravenous Chupacabra enters the battlefield, destroy target creature an opponent controls.).
[02:55:54] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[02:56:00] Turn 6: gearhulkazul
[02:56:07] gearhulkazul casts [Impulse].
[02:56:29] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration]
[02:56:35] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[02:56:42] gearhulkazul is being attacked by [Ravenous Chupacabra]
[02:57:00] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[02:57:14] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting gearhulkazul (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[02:57:21] gearhulkazul casts [Defabricate] targeting Triggered ability from Tidehollow Sculler (Counter target activated or triggered ability.).
[02:57:29] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Insectile Aberration].
[02:57:34] gearhulkazul casts [Slip Out the Back] targeting [Insectile Aberration].
[02:57:34] gearhulkazul puts a +1/+1 counter on [Insectile Aberration].
[02:57:37] ThyShuffler's [Vindicate] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[02:57:41] Turn 7: gearhulkazul
[02:57:48] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration]
[02:57:57] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[02:57:59] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[02:58:11] ThyShuffler casts [Kambal, Consul of Allocation].
[02:58:24] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Insectile Aberration].
[02:58:33] gearhulkazul casts [Repeal] targeting [Insectile Aberration]. (X is 1).
[02:58:33] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a noncreature spell, that player loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[02:58:33] Ray_Penber has started watching.
[02:58:38] gearhulkazul returns [Delver of Secrets] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[02:58:38] gearhulkazul draws a card with [Repeal].
[02:58:42] ThyShuffler's [Vindicate] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[02:58:48] gearhulkazul is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler] and [Ravenous Chupacabra]
[02:58:58] Turn 8: gearhulkazul
[02:59:02] [CHAT] Ray_Penber: game 2?
[02:59:03] gearhulkazul casts gearhulkazul.
[02:59:06] gearhulkazul casts ThyShuffler.
[02:59:11] [CHAT] ThyShuffler: yes
[02:59:12] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[02:59:15] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[02:59:30] gearhulkazul is being attacked by [Kambal, Consul of Allocation], [Tidehollow Sculler], and [Ravenous Chupacabra]
[02:59:42] ThyShuffler casts [Obzedat, Ghost Council].
[02:59:47] gearhulkazul has conceded from the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: ThyShuffler: 2–0
[02:59:51] ThyShuffler has left the game.