PennyDreadful
PD vs Tivini 
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
ThyShuffler,Tivini

== Game 1 (831630536) ==
[Time] 1678501668
[04:27:49] PDBot has started watching.
[04:27:49] Tivini joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 28.04
[Gatherling] Round=4
[04:27:59] [CHAT] ThyShuffler: gl
[04:28:01] [CHAT] Tivini: gl hf
[04:28:06] Tivini chooses to play first.
[04:28:08] Tivini begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:28:13] ThyShuffler mulligans to six cards.
[04:28:23] ThyShuffler puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:28:23] Turn 1: Tivini
[04:28:24] Tivini skips their draw step.
[04:28:25] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:28:32] Tivini casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:28:32] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:28:43] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:28:44] Turn 2: Tivini
[04:28:45] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:28:47] Tivini casts [Dauntless Bodyguard].
[04:28:49] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:28:52] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:28:54] Tivini casts [Thraben Inspector].
[04:28:55] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:28:57] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Thraben Inspector] onto the stack (When Thraben Inspector enters the battlefield, investigate.).
[04:28:58] Tivini investigates.
[04:28:59] Tivini's [Thraben Inspector] creates a Clue Token.
[04:29:00] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:29:03] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Champion of the Parish]
[04:29:09] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:29:13] ThyShuffler plays [Temple of Silence].
[04:29:14] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[04:29:22] ThyShuffler scrys 1 (0 top, 1 bottom).
[04:29:24] ThyShuffler casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Champion of the Parish].
[04:29:30] Tivini activates an ability of [Dauntless Bodyguard] ( The chosen creature gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[04:29:33] Turn 3: Tivini
[04:29:36] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:29:41] Tivini casts [Benalish Marshal].
[04:29:42] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:29:43] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:29:45] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Thraben Inspector] and [Champion of the Parish]
[04:29:48] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:29:51] ThyShuffler plays [Demolition Field].
[04:29:55] ThyShuffler casts [Vindicate] targeting [Benalish Marshal].
[04:29:56] Turn 4: Tivini
[04:30:00] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:30:13] Tivini casts [Dryad Militant].
[04:30:16] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Thraben Inspector] and [Champion of the Parish]
[04:30:22] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[04:30:25] Tivini casts [Orim's Chant] targeting ThyShuffler.
[04:30:30] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:30:38] Tivini activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.).
[04:30:40] Tivini draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability.
[04:30:40] Turn 5: Tivini
[04:30:42] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:30:50] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Dryad Militant], [Thraben Inspector], and [Champion of the Parish]
[04:31:05] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Shambling Vent] ( Shambling Vent becomes a 2/3 white and black Elemental creature with lifelink until end of turn. ...).
[04:31:31] [Shambling Vent] blocks [Dryad Militant].
[04:31:39] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[04:31:51] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:31:57] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:32:00] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Tivini (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[04:32:05] Tivini reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Plains].
[04:32:11] ThyShuffler casts [Kambal, Consul of Allocation].
[04:32:17] Turn 6: Tivini
[04:32:26] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Champion of the Parish]
[04:32:29] [Tidehollow Sculler] blocks [Champion of the Parish].
[04:32:30] [Kambal, Consul of Allocation] blocks [Champion of the Parish].
[04:32:35] Blockers for [Champion of the Parish] are ordered as follows: [Kambal, Consul of Allocation], [Tidehollow Sculler]
[04:32:42] Tivini casts [Legion's Landing].
[04:32:43] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Legion's Landing] onto the stack (When Legion's Landing enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Vampire creature token with lifel...).
[04:32:45] Tivini's [Legion's Landing] creates a Vampire Token.
[04:32:48] Turn 6: ThyShuffler
[04:32:51] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:33:16] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:33:18] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Tivini (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[04:33:23] Tivini reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Plains].
[04:33:28] ThyShuffler casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:33:30] ThyShuffler puts five loyalty counters on [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:33:33] ThyShuffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:33:33] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[04:33:41] Turn 7: Tivini
[04:33:45] Tivini casts [Honor of the Pure].
[04:33:51] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Vampire Token] and [Thraben Inspector]
[04:33:55] [Tidehollow Sculler] blocks [Thraben Inspector].
[04:33:57] [Tidehollow Sculler] blocks [Thraben Inspector].
[04:34:05] Blockers for [Thraben Inspector] are ordered as follows: [Tidehollow Sculler], [Tidehollow Sculler]
[04:34:07] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[04:34:11] Turn 7: ThyShuffler
[04:34:18] ThyShuffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:34:18] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[04:34:29] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Shambling Vent] ( Shambling Vent becomes a 2/3 white and black Elemental creature with lifelink until end of turn. ...).
[04:34:36] Tivini is being attacked by [Shambling Vent]
[04:34:42] Turn 8: Tivini
[04:34:46] Tivini casts [Thraben Inspector].
[04:34:48] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Thraben Inspector] onto the stack (When Thraben Inspector enters the battlefield, investigate.).
[04:34:49] Tivini investigates.
[04:34:49] Tivini's [Thraben Inspector] creates a Clue Token.
[04:34:51] Tivini activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.).
[04:34:51] Tivini draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability.
[04:35:01] Tivini casts [Legion's Landing].
[04:35:04] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Legion's Landing] onto the stack (When Legion's Landing enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Vampire creature token with lifel...).
[04:35:04] Tivini's [Legion's Landing] creates a Vampire Token.
[04:35:10] Turn 8: ThyShuffler
[04:35:13] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:35:19] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] targeting [Vampire Token] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...).
[04:35:36] Turn 9: Tivini
[04:35:41] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:35:53] Turn 9: ThyShuffler
[04:35:54] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Vampire Token to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your next up...).
[04:36:05] ThyShuffler removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:36:05] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[04:36:06] Tivini chooses a card from their hand.
[04:36:06] Tivini discards [Orim's Chant].
[04:36:06] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[04:36:09] ThyShuffler plays [Caves of Koilos].
[04:36:19] Turn 10: Tivini
[04:36:31] Turn 10: ThyShuffler
[04:36:48] ThyShuffler removes a loyalty counter from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:36:48] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.).
[04:36:55] ThyShuffler casts [Phyrexian Arena].
[04:37:04] Turn 11: Tivini
[04:37:07] Tivini casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:37:18] Turn 11: ThyShuffler
[04:37:18] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[04:37:22] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[04:37:34] ThyShuffler casts [Ravenous Chupacabra].
[04:37:39] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Ravenous Chupacabra] onto the stack targeting [Champion of the Parish] (When Ravenous Chupacabra enters the battlefield, destroy target creature an opponent controls.).
[04:37:49] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:37:50] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Tivini (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[04:37:55] Tivini reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Plains].
[04:38:04] Turn 12: Tivini
[04:38:07] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:38:16] Turn 12: ThyShuffler
[04:38:17] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[04:38:18] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[04:38:21] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[04:38:25] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Shambling Vent] ( Shambling Vent becomes a 2/3 white and black Elemental creature with lifelink until end of turn. ...).
[04:38:34] Tivini is being attacked by [Shambling Vent]
[04:38:38] [Thraben Inspector] blocks [Shambling Vent].
[04:38:39] [Vampire Token] blocks [Shambling Vent].
[04:38:44] Blockers for [Shambling Vent] are ordered as follows: [Vampire Token], [Thraben Inspector]
[04:38:54] Turn 13: Tivini
[04:38:57] Tivini casts [Dauntless Bodyguard].
[04:39:05] Turn 13: ThyShuffler
[04:39:06] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[04:39:08] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[04:39:11] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:39:16] ThyShuffler casts [Ravenous Chupacabra].
[04:39:21] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Ravenous Chupacabra] onto the stack targeting [Thraben Inspector] (When Ravenous Chupacabra enters the battlefield, destroy target creature an opponent controls.).
[04:39:29] Tivini activates an ability of [Dauntless Bodyguard] ( The chosen creature gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[04:39:40] Turn 14: Tivini
[04:39:44] Tivini casts [Benalish Marshal].
[04:39:51] Turn 14: ThyShuffler
[04:39:52] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Arena] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[04:39:54] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Phyrexian Arena]'s ability.
[04:39:59] ThyShuffler plays [Caves of Koilos].
[04:40:23] Tivini is being attacked by [Ravenous Chupacabra], [Tidehollow Sculler], [Ravenous Chupacabra], and [Tidehollow Sculler]
[04:40:29] [Thraben Inspector] blocks [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:40:30] [Benalish Marshal] blocks [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:40:37] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[04:40:37] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[04:40:53] ThyShuffler casts [Wrath of God].
[04:41:03] ThyShuffler casts [Obzedat, Ghost Council].
[04:41:06] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack targeting Tivini (When Obzedat, Ghost Council enters the battlefield, target opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 li...).
[04:41:11] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Obzedat, Ghost Council] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile Obzedat, Ghost Council. If you do, return it to t...).
[04:41:18] Turn 15: Tivini
[04:41:23] Tivini has conceded from the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (831631730) ==
[Time] 1678502563
[04:42:44] PDBot has started watching.
[04:42:53] Tivini chooses to play first.
[04:42:56] Tivini begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:43:06] ThyShuffler mulligans to six cards.
[04:43:10] ThyShuffler mulligans to five cards.
[04:43:19] ThyShuffler puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[04:43:19] Turn 1: Tivini
[04:43:19] Tivini skips their draw step.
[04:43:21] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:43:22] Tivini casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:43:25] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:43:27] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:43:28] Turn 2: Tivini
[04:43:31] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:43:33] Tivini casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:43:33] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:43:36] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:43:38] Tivini casts [Dauntless Bodyguard].
[04:43:40] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:43:40] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:43:40] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:43:40] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:43:44] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Champion of the Parish]
[04:43:50] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:43:52] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:43:58] Turn 3: Tivini
[04:43:59] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:44:02] Tivini casts [Benalish Marshal].
[04:44:03] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:44:03] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:44:04] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:44:04] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:44:08] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Dauntless Bodyguard], [Champion of the Parish], and [Champion of the Parish]
[04:44:08] ThyShuffler has conceded from the game.
Winner: Tivini
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (831631848) ==
[Time] 1678502664
[04:44:24] PDBot has started watching.
[04:44:25] Tivini joined the game.
[04:44:30] ThyShuffler chooses to play first.
[04:44:33] ThyShuffler begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:44:35] Tivini begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:44:35] Turn 1: ThyShuffler
[04:44:36] ThyShuffler skips their draw step.
[04:44:37] ThyShuffler plays [Shambling Vent].
[04:44:40] Turn 1: Tivini
[04:44:42] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:44:43] Tivini casts [Champion of the Parish].
[04:44:45] Turn 2: ThyShuffler
[04:44:47] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:44:50] ThyShuffler casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:44:51] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Tivini (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[04:45:08] Tivini reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Benalish Marshal], [Brave the Elements], [Benalish Marshal], [Plains], and [Recruitment Officer].
[04:45:09] Turn 2: Tivini
[04:45:11] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:45:15] Tivini casts [Recruitment Officer].
[04:45:16] Tivini puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[04:45:18] Tivini puts a +1/+1 counter on [Champion of the Parish].
[04:45:23] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Champion of the Parish]
[04:45:31] Turn 3: ThyShuffler
[04:45:34] ThyShuffler plays [Plains].
[04:45:37] ThyShuffler casts [Wasteland Strangler].
[04:45:42] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Wasteland Strangler] onto the stack targeting [Champion of the Parish] (When Wasteland Strangler enters the battlefield, you may put a card an opponent owns from exile in...).
[04:45:52] ThyShuffler chooses [Recruitment Officer] with [Wasteland Strangler]'s ability.
[04:46:01] Tivini is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler]
[04:46:12] Turn 3: Tivini
[04:46:14] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:46:16] Tivini casts [Benalish Marshal].
[04:46:20] ThyShuffler is being attacked by [Recruitment Officer]
[04:46:35] Turn 4: ThyShuffler
[04:46:43] ThyShuffler plays [Swamp].
[04:46:48] ThyShuffler casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:46:49] ThyShuffler puts five loyalty counters on [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:46:52] ThyShuffler removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:46:52] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[04:47:02] Tivini chooses a card from their hand.
[04:47:02] Tivini discards [Plains].
[04:47:02] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[04:47:06] Turn 4: Tivini
[04:47:08] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:47:11] Tivini casts [Benalish Marshal].
[04:47:28] ThyShuffler's [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] is being attacked by [Benalish Marshal] and [Recruitment Officer]
[04:47:31] [Wasteland Strangler] blocks [Recruitment Officer].
[04:47:33] [Tidehollow Sculler] blocks [Benalish Marshal].
[04:47:38] ThyShuffler puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[04:47:42] Turn 5: ThyShuffler
[04:47:46] ThyShuffler plays [Isolated Chapel].
[04:47:51] ThyShuffler casts [Wrath of God].
[04:47:56] ThyShuffler removes two loyalty counters from [Kaya, Ghost Assassin].
[04:47:57] ThyShuffler activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.).
[04:47:59] Tivini chooses a card from their hand.
[04:48:00] Tivini discards [Brave the Elements].
[04:48:01] ThyShuffler draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability.
[04:48:05] Turn 5: Tivini
[04:48:06] Tivini plays [Plains].
[04:48:10] [CHAT] Tivini: gg
[04:48:12] [CHAT] ThyShuffler: gg
[04:48:13] Tivini has conceded from the game.
Winner: ThyShuffler
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: ThyShuffler: 2–1
[04:48:16] Tivini draws their next card.
[04:48:17] ThyShuffler has left the game.