PennyDreadful
PD LEAGUE
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Kwww,EstiFG555

== Game 1 (830862044) ==
[Time] 1677845683
[14:14:44] PDBot has started watching.
[14:14:44] Kwww joined the game.
[14:14:44] EstiFG555 joined the game.
[League] Dimir Proliferate by estifg555 (210505) vs Red Dredge by kwww (210614)
[14:14:47] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[14:14:47] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Due to a Magic Online bug, PDBot is unable to tell which player is which.  Please report this league match manually.
[14:14:50] EstiFG555 chooses to play first.
[14:15:12] EstiFG555 mulligans to six cards.
[14:15:14] Kwww begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:15:25] EstiFG555 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[14:15:25] Turn 1: EstiFG555
[14:15:31] EstiFG555 skips their draw step.
[14:15:32] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:15:36] Turn 1: Kwww
[14:15:49] Kwww discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[14:15:49] Turn 2: EstiFG555
[14:15:51] EstiFG555 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[14:15:58] EstiFG555 casts [Ponder].
[14:16:15] EstiFG555 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[14:16:15] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Ponder].
[14:16:20] Turn 2: Kwww
[14:16:31] Kwww returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:16:31] Kwww mills [Mountain], [Bridge from Below], [Stinkweed Imp], [Bitter Reunion], [Altar of Dementia], and [Bridge from Below].
[14:16:32] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Stinkweed Imp[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing.
[14:16:36] Kwww plays [Foreboding Ruins].
[14:16:50] Turn 3: EstiFG555
[14:16:57] EstiFG555 casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Kwww.
[14:17:20] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[14:17:49] EstiFG555 plays [Dreadship Reef].
[14:18:14] EstiFG555 casts [Dark Ritual].
[14:18:37] EstiFG555 casts [Everflowing Chalice] (kicked 2 times).
[14:18:38] EstiFG555 puts two charge counters on [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:18:46] EstiFG555 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[14:18:46] EstiFG555 puts a storage counter on [Dreadship Reef].
[14:18:53] Turn 3: Kwww
[14:18:56] Kwww returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:18:56] Kwww mills [Lantern-Lit Graveyard], [Altar of Dementia], [Lantern-Lit Graveyard], [Burning Inquiry], and [Foreboding Ruins].
[14:18:59] Kwww plays [Lantern-Lit Graveyard].
[14:19:02] Kwww casts [Dregscape Zombie].
[14:19:07] Turn 4: EstiFG555
[14:19:10] EstiFG555 plays [Dreadship Reef].
[14:19:45] EstiFG555 casts [Infectious Inquiry].
[14:19:45] EstiFG555 draws two cards with [Infectious Inquiry].
[14:19:45] EstiFG555 puts a poison counter on Kwww.
[14:20:49] EstiFG555 casts [Everflowing Chalice] (with kicker).
[14:20:49] EstiFG555 puts a charge counter on [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:20:54] EstiFG555 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[14:20:54] EstiFG555 puts a storage counter on [Dreadship Reef].
[14:20:58] Turn 4: Kwww
[14:21:07] Kwww plays [Mountain].
[14:21:12] Kwww casts [Dregscape Zombie].
[14:21:20] EstiFG555 is being attacked by [Dregscape Zombie]
[14:21:30] Turn 5: EstiFG555
[14:21:35] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:21:44] EstiFG555 casts [Experimental Augury].
[14:22:05] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], and Kwww.
[14:22:19] EstiFG555 casts [Ponder].
[14:22:50] EstiFG555 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[14:22:50] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Ponder].
[14:23:13] EstiFG555 casts [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:23:13] EstiFG555 puts a poison counter on Kwww.
[14:23:13] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:23:40] EstiFG555 removes a storage counter from [Dreadship Reef].
[14:23:41] EstiFG555 casts [Treasure Cruise].
[14:23:41] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[14:23:54] Turn 5: Kwww
[14:24:05] EstiFG555 is being attacked by [Dregscape Zombie] and [Dregscape Zombie]
[14:24:16] Kwww casts EstiFG555.
[14:24:32] EstiFG555 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[14:24:32] EstiFG555 puts a storage counter on [Dreadship Reef].
[14:24:47] EstiFG555 removes a storage counter from [Dreadship Reef].
[14:24:51] EstiFG555 casts [Experimental Augury].
[14:25:06] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], and Kwww.
[14:25:08] Turn 6: EstiFG555
[14:25:12] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:25:39] EstiFG555 removes two storage counters from [Dreadship Reef].
[14:25:44] EstiFG555 casts [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:25:44] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:25:52] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], and Kwww.
[14:26:00] EstiFG555 casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Kwww.
[14:26:00] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[14:26:20] EstiFG555 casts [Dark Ritual].
[14:26:46] EstiFG555 casts [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:26:46] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:26:55] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], and Kwww.
[14:27:02] EstiFG555 casts [Dark Ritual].
[14:27:13] EstiFG555 casts [Treasure Cruise].
[14:27:14] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[14:27:48] EstiFG555 removes two storage counters from [Dreadship Reef].
[14:27:53] EstiFG555 casts [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:27:53] EstiFG555 puts a poison counter on Kwww.
[14:27:53] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:27:59] EstiFG555 casts [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:27:59] EstiFG555 puts a poison counter on Kwww.
[14:27:59] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:28:12] EstiFG555 removes a storage counter from [Dreadship Reef].
[14:28:15] EstiFG555 casts [Ponder].
[14:28:30] EstiFG555 chooses to shuffle their library.
[14:28:30] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Ponder].
[14:29:06] EstiFG555 casts [Whisper of the Dross] targeting EstiFG555.
[14:29:16] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], [Everflowing Chalice], [Dreadship Reef], and Kwww.
[14:29:30] EstiFG555 discards [Dreadship Reef].
[14:29:30] Turn 6: Kwww
[14:29:46] Kwww plays [Swamp].
[14:29:48] Kwww casts [Putrid Imp].
[14:30:00] EstiFG555 is being attacked by EstiFG555, [Dregscape Zombie], and [Dregscape Zombie]
[14:30:13] EstiFG555 removes three storage counters from [Dreadship Reef].
[14:30:13] EstiFG555 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef]. (X is 3) ( Add X mana in any combination of {U} and/or {B}.).
[14:30:28] EstiFG555 casts [Suffocating Fumes].
[14:30:36] Kwww discards [Bridge from Below].
[14:30:36] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:30:49] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:30:49] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:30:49] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:30:49] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:30:49] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:30:49] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:30:52] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:30:54] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:30:55] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:30:57] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:30:58] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:31:00] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:31:11] Turn 7: EstiFG555
[14:31:21] EstiFG555 casts [Whisper of the Dross] targeting EstiFG555.
[14:31:26] Kwww has conceded from the game.
Winner: EstiFG555
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (830862824) ==
[Time] 1677846733
[14:32:13] PDBot has started watching.
[14:32:20] Kwww chooses to play first.
[14:32:24] Kwww mulligans to six cards.
[14:32:30] EstiFG555 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:32:35] Kwww puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[14:32:35] Turn 1: Kwww
[14:32:36] Kwww skips their draw step.
[14:32:38] Kwww plays [Lantern-Lit Graveyard].
[14:32:41] Kwww casts [Putrid Imp].
[14:32:50] Turn 1: EstiFG555
[14:33:00] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:33:07] Turn 2: Kwww
[14:33:10] Kwww plays [Swamp].
[14:33:16] EstiFG555 is being attacked by [Putrid Imp]
[14:33:26] Turn 2: EstiFG555
[14:33:33] EstiFG555 plays [Dreadship Reef].
[14:33:50] EstiFG555 casts [Everflowing Chalice] (with kicker).
[14:33:52] EstiFG555 puts a charge counter on [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:34:05] Kwww discards [Bridge from Below].
[14:34:06] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:34:10] Kwww discards [Bridge from Below].
[14:34:10] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:34:18] Kwww discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[14:34:18] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:34:22] Turn 3: Kwww
[14:34:25] Kwww returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:34:25] Kwww mills [Foreboding Ruins], [Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis], [Foreboding Ruins], [Stinkweed Imp], [Bitter Reunion], and [Mountain].
[14:34:33] Kwww casts [Insolent Neonate].
[14:34:39] Kwww discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[14:34:39] Kwww activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.).
[14:34:39] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:34:39] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:34:46] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:34:47] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:34:48] Kwww draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability.
[14:34:50] Kwww returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:34:50] Kwww mills [Dregscape Zombie], [Putrid Imp], [Altar of Dementia], [Mountain], [Ashen Ghoul], and [Swamp].
[14:35:00] Kwww activates an ability of [Dregscape Zombie] (Unearth for {B}).
[14:35:12] Kwww casts [Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis] from the graveyard.
[14:35:21] EstiFG555 is being attacked by [Dregscape Zombie] and [Putrid Imp]
[14:35:23] EstiFG555 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Kwww
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (830863014) ==
[Time] 1677846953
[14:35:53] PDBot has started watching.
[14:35:59] EstiFG555 chooses to play first.
[14:36:04] EstiFG555 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[14:36:16] Kwww mulligans to six cards.
[14:36:38] Kwww puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[14:36:38] Turn 1: EstiFG555
[14:36:40] EstiFG555 skips their draw step.
[14:36:42] EstiFG555 plays [Swamp].
[14:36:46] EstiFG555 casts [Lantern of the Lost].
[14:36:47] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Lantern of the Lost] on the stack.
[14:36:50] Turn 1: Kwww
[14:36:52] Kwww plays [Foreboding Ruins].
[14:36:58] Turn 2: EstiFG555
[14:37:01] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:37:06] EstiFG555 casts [Dark Ritual].
[14:37:18] EstiFG555 casts [Everflowing Chalice] (kicked 2 times).
[14:37:18] EstiFG555 puts two charge counters on [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:37:22] Turn 2: Kwww
[14:37:25] Kwww plays [Mountain].
[14:37:31] Kwww casts [Altar of Dementia].
[14:37:38] Turn 3: EstiFG555
[14:37:42] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:37:55] EstiFG555 casts [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:37:56] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:38:00] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:38:04] Turn 3: Kwww
[14:38:12] Kwww casts [Insolent Neonate].
[14:38:19] Kwww casts [Duress] targeting EstiFG555.
[14:38:26] EstiFG555 discards [Experimental Augury].
[14:38:26] EstiFG555 reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Island], [Island], [Swamp], and [Experimental Augury].
[14:38:35] Turn 4: EstiFG555
[14:38:39] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:38:50] EstiFG555 casts [Experimental Augury].
[14:39:02] EstiFG555 proliferates [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:39:07] EstiFG555 casts [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:39:10] EstiFG555 puts a poison counter on Kwww.
[14:39:10] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:39:33] Kwww discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[14:39:33] Kwww activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.).
[14:39:35] Kwww draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability.
[14:39:37] Kwww returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:39:37] Kwww mills [Ashen Ghoul], [Mountain], [Swamp], [Lantern-Lit Graveyard], and [Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis].
[14:39:38] Turn 4: Kwww
[14:39:51] Kwww casts [Putrid Imp].
[14:40:02] Kwww exiles [Lantern of the Lost] with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[14:40:02] EstiFG555 activates an ability of [Lantern of the Lost] ( Exile all cards from all graveyards, then draw a card.).
[14:40:06] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[14:40:14] Kwww casts [Insolent Neonate].
[14:40:21] Turn 5: EstiFG555
[14:40:26] EstiFG555 plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[14:40:52] EstiFG555 casts [Everflowing Chalice] (kicked 3 times).
[14:40:57] EstiFG555 puts three charge counters on [Everflowing Chalice].
[14:41:10] Kwww discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[14:41:10] Kwww activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.).
[14:41:12] Kwww draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability.
[14:41:14] Kwww returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:41:14] Kwww mills [Bridge from Below], [Stinkweed Imp], [Insolent Neonate], [Swamp], and EstiFG555.
[14:41:26] Kwww discards [Ashen Ghoul].
[14:41:26] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:41:33] Kwww discards [Ashen Ghoul].
[14:41:33] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:41:37] Kwww discards Kwww.
[14:41:37] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:41:44] Turn 5: Kwww
[14:41:48] Kwww returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:41:48] Kwww mills [Mountain], [Mountain], [Bitter Reunion], [Mountain], and [Bridge from Below].
[14:41:56] EstiFG555 is being attacked by [Putrid Imp]
[14:42:15] Turn 6: EstiFG555
[14:42:23] EstiFG555 plays [Island].
[14:42:33] EstiFG555 casts [Treasure Cruise].
[14:42:35] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[14:42:54] EstiFG555 casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Kwww.
[14:42:56] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[14:43:06] EstiFG555 casts [Ponder].
[14:43:18] EstiFG555 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[14:43:18] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Ponder].
[14:43:37] Turn 6: Kwww
[14:43:40] Kwww discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[14:43:40] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:43:47] Kwww activates an ability of [Ashen Ghoul] ( Return Ashen Ghoul from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[14:43:59] Kwww returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[14:44:00] Kwww mills [Sorcerous Spyglass], [Stinkweed Imp], [Putrid Imp], [Swamp], and [Altar of Dementia].
[14:44:09] EstiFG555 casts [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:44:11] EstiFG555 puts a poison counter on Kwww.
[14:44:11] EstiFG555 draws a card with [Prologue to Phyresis].
[14:44:15] EstiFG555 is being attacked by [Ashen Ghoul] and [Putrid Imp]
[14:44:26] Kwww activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting Kwww ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.).
[14:44:26] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:44:27] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:44:32] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:44:34] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:44:35] Kwww mills [Altar of Dementia], [Bridge from Below], and [Swamp].
[14:44:49] Turn 7: EstiFG555
[14:44:54] EstiFG555 plays [Dreadship Reef].
[14:45:05] EstiFG555 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[14:45:07] EstiFG555 puts a storage counter on [Dreadship Reef].
[14:45:11] EstiFG555 casts [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:45:12] EstiFG555 draws three cards with [Vivisurgeon's Insight].
[14:45:23] EstiFG555 proliferates [Dreadship Reef], [Everflowing Chalice], [Everflowing Chalice], and Kwww.
[14:45:56] Kwww discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[14:45:56] Kwww activates an ability of [Putrid Imp] ( Putrid Imp gains flying until end of turn.).
[14:46:16] Kwww activates an ability of [Altar of Dementia] targeting Kwww ( Target player mills cards equal to the sacrificed creature's power.).
[14:46:16] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:46:16] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:46:17] Kwww puts triggered ability from [Bridge from Below] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, if Bridge from Below...).
[14:46:26] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:46:28] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:46:29] Kwww's [Bridge from Below] creates a Zombie Token.
[14:46:31] Kwww mills [Golgari Grave-Troll] and [Foreboding Ruins].
[14:46:39] EstiFG555 discards [Infectious Inquiry].
[14:46:39] Turn 7: Kwww
[14:46:47] Kwww activates an ability of [Ashen Ghoul] ( Return Ashen Ghoul from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[14:46:50] EstiFG555 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Kwww
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Kwww: 2–1
[14:46:55] EstiFG555 has left the game.