PennyDreadful
PD League
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
auhosj877,CathWithGuac

== Game 1 (813550652) ==
[Time] 1663339143
[17:39:03] PDBot has started watching.
[17:39:03] CathWithGuac joined the game.
[League] Cracking Plans by auhosj877 (193695) vs Izzet Dredge by cathwithguac (193714)
[17:39:05] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[17:39:17] [CHAT] CathWithGuac: gl hf!
[17:39:41] Honorbound84 has started watching.
[17:40:02] Honorbound84 has stopped watching.
[17:40:09] auhosj877 chooses to play first.
[17:40:13] [CHAT] auhosj877: u2!
[17:40:14] auhosj877 mulligans to six cards.
[17:40:55] CathWithGuac begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[17:40:59] auhosj877 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[17:40:59] Turn 1: auhosj877
[17:41:01] auhosj877 skips their draw step.
[17:41:02] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:41:05] auhosj877 casts [Ponder].
[17:41:11] auhosj877 chooses to shuffle their library.
[17:41:11] auhosj877 draws a card with [Ponder].
[17:41:12] Turn 1: CathWithGuac
[17:41:17] CathWithGuac plays [Mountain].
[17:41:19] Turn 2: auhosj877
[17:41:25] auhosj877 casts [Hard Evidence].
[17:41:25] auhosj877's [Hard Evidence] creates a Crab Token.
[17:41:25] auhosj877 investigates.
[17:41:25] auhosj877's [Hard Evidence] creates a Clue Token.
[17:41:26] auhosj877 plays [Shivan Reef].
[17:41:27] Turn 2: CathWithGuac
[17:41:32] CathWithGuac plays [Mountain].
[17:41:36] CathWithGuac discards [Silversmote Ghoul].
[17:41:36] CathWithGuac discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[17:41:36] CathWithGuac casts [Cathartic Reunion].
[17:41:42] CathWithGuac exiles [Snapback] with with [Disrupting Shoal]'s ability.
[17:41:42] auhosj877 casts [Disrupting Shoal] using an alternate cost targeting [Cathartic Reunion]. (X is 2).
[17:41:51] Turn 3: auhosj877
[17:41:57] auhosj877 has conceded from the game.
Winner: CathWithGuac
Game 1 Completed.
[17:42:00] auhosj877 has left the game.

== Game 2 (813550908) ==
[Time] 1663339380
[17:43:00] PDBot has started watching.
[17:43:03] auhosj877 chooses to play first.
[17:43:06] auhosj877 mulligans to six cards.
[17:43:20] CathWithGuac begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[17:43:22] auhosj877 mulligans to five cards.
[17:43:38] auhosj877 puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[17:43:38] Turn 1: auhosj877
[17:43:41] auhosj877 skips their draw step.
[17:43:41] auhosj877 plays [Shivan Reef].
[17:43:44] auhosj877 casts [Ponder].
[17:43:52] auhosj877 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[17:43:52] auhosj877 draws a card with [Ponder].
[17:43:57] Turn 1: CathWithGuac
[17:44:03] CathWithGuac plays [Shivan Reef].
[17:44:09] Turn 2: auhosj877
[17:44:13] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:44:14] auhosj877 casts [Ponder].
[17:44:21] auhosj877 chooses to shuffle their library.
[17:44:21] auhosj877 draws a card with [Ponder].
[17:44:24] Turn 2: CathWithGuac
[17:44:30] CathWithGuac plays [Mountain].
[17:44:46] CathWithGuac discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[17:44:46] CathWithGuac discards [Conflagrate].
[17:44:46] CathWithGuac casts [Cathartic Reunion].
[17:44:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Stinkweed Imp[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing.
[17:44:50] auhosj877 casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Cathartic Reunion].
[17:44:58] Turn 3: auhosj877
[17:45:02] auhosj877 casts [Hatching Plans].
[17:45:03] auhosj877 plays [Wandering Fumarole].
[17:45:04] Turn 3: CathWithGuac
[17:45:15] CathWithGuac returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:45:15] CathWithGuac mills [Master of Death], [Shivan Reef], [Lonely Sandbar], [Shenanigans] and [Molten Tributary].
[17:45:18] CathWithGuac plays [Shivan Reef].
[17:45:40] CathWithGuac discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[17:45:40] CathWithGuac casts [Conflagrate] from the graveyard targeting auhosj877 for 1. (X is 1).
[17:45:49] CathWithGuac casts [Breakthrough]. (X is 0).
[17:45:52] CathWithGuac draws four cards with [Breakthrough].
[17:45:54] CathWithGuac returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:45:54] CathWithGuac mills [Conflagrate], [Cathartic Reunion], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Stinkweed Imp] and [Deep Analysis].
[17:45:55] CathWithGuac returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:45:55] CathWithGuac mills [Silversmote Ghoul], [Creeping Chill], [Shenanigans], [Mountain], [Mountain] and [Shenanigans].
[17:46:03] CathWithGuac returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:46:03] CathWithGuac mills [Stinkweed Imp], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Mountain], [Golgari Grave-Troll] and [Mountain].
[17:46:06] CathWithGuac returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:46:06] CathWithGuac mills [Mountain], [Forgotten Cave], [Creeping Chill], [Deep Analysis], [Shivan Reef] and [Molten Tributary].
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac discards [Breakthrough].
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac discards [Master of Death].
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac discards CathWithGuac.
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[17:46:11] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[17:46:17] CathWithGuac exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[17:46:22] CathWithGuac exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[17:46:27] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[17:46:27] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[17:46:31] Turn 4: auhosj877
[17:46:37] auhosj877 casts [Perilous Research].
[17:46:37] auhosj877 draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
[17:46:38] auhosj877 sacrifices [Hatching Plans].
[17:46:38] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Hatching Plans] onto the stack (When Hatching Plans is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw three cards.).
[17:46:39] auhosj877 draws three cards with [Hatching Plans]'s ability.
[17:47:10] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:47:14] auhosj877 exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[17:47:15] auhosj877 casts [Pyroclasm].
[17:47:21] Turn 4: CathWithGuac
[17:47:22] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Master of Death] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if Master of Death is in your graveyard, you may pay 1 life. If y...).
[17:47:22] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Master of Death] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if Master of Death is in your graveyard, you may pay 1 life. If y...).
[17:47:38] CathWithGuac returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:47:38] CathWithGuac mills [Creeping Chill], [Master of Death], [Conflagrate], [Mountain], [Mountain] and [Molten Tributary].
[17:47:38] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[17:47:42] CathWithGuac exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[17:47:54] CathWithGuac casts [Deep Analysis] from the graveyard targeting CathWithGuac.
[17:47:58] auhosj877 casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Deep Analysis].
[17:48:04] Kazzzarazara has started watching.
[17:48:10] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[17:48:10] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[17:48:12] Turn 5: auhosj877
[17:48:16] auhosj877 casts [Ponder].
[17:48:24] auhosj877 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[17:48:24] auhosj877 draws a card with [Ponder].
[17:48:27] auhosj877 casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[17:48:31] auhosj877 activates an ability of [Nihil Spellbomb] targeting CathWithGuac ( Exile target player's graveyard.).
[17:48:31] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Nihil Spellbomb] onto the stack (When Nihil Spellbomb is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, dra...).
[17:48:43] auhosj877 casts [Tolarian Terror].
[17:48:46] auhosj877 casts [Tolarian Terror].
[17:48:52] Turn 5: CathWithGuac
[17:49:04] CathWithGuac casts [Breakthrough]. (X is 0).
[17:49:09] CathWithGuac draws four cards with [Breakthrough].
[17:49:13] CathWithGuac discards [Master of Death].
[17:49:13] CathWithGuac discards [Master of Death].
[17:49:14] CathWithGuac discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[17:49:14] CathWithGuac discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[17:49:14] CathWithGuac discards [Cathartic Reunion].
[17:49:14] CathWithGuac discards [Island].
[17:49:14] CathWithGuac discards [Creeping Chill].
[17:49:32] Turn 6: auhosj877
[17:49:35] auhosj877 casts [Hatching Plans].
[17:49:38] auhosj877 casts [Perilous Research].
[17:49:40] auhosj877 draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
[17:49:41] auhosj877 sacrifices [Hatching Plans].
[17:49:41] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Hatching Plans] onto the stack (When Hatching Plans is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw three cards.).
[17:49:43] auhosj877 draws three cards with [Hatching Plans]'s ability.
[17:49:57] CathWithGuac is being attacked by [Tolarian Terror]
[17:50:07] Turn 6: CathWithGuac
[17:50:07] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Master of Death] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if Master of Death is in your graveyard, you may pay 1 life. If y...).
[17:50:07] CathWithGuac puts triggered ability from [Master of Death] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if Master of Death is in your graveyard, you may pay 1 life. If y...).
[17:50:15] CathWithGuac returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[17:50:15] CathWithGuac mills [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Lonely Sandbar], [Forgotten Cave], [Conflagrate], [Cathartic Reunion] and [Mountain].
[17:50:28] auhosj877 is being attacked by [Silversmote Ghoul] and [Silversmote Ghoul]
[17:50:32] [Tolarian Terror] blocks [Silversmote Ghoul].
[17:51:21] CathWithGuac discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[17:51:21] CathWithGuac discards [Master of Death].
[17:51:21] CathWithGuac discards [Master of Death].
[17:51:21] CathWithGuac casts [Conflagrate] from the graveyard targeting [Tolarian Terror] for 2, and auhosj877 for 1. (X is 3).
[17:51:21] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Tolarian Terror] onto the stack (Ward {2} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[17:51:31] CathWithGuac has conceded from the game.
Winner: auhosj877
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (813551632) ==
[Time] 1663339951
[17:52:31] PDBot has started watching.
[17:52:31] CathWithGuac chooses to play first.
[17:52:32] CathWithGuac mulligans to six cards.
[17:52:36] auhosj877 mulligans to six cards.
[17:52:48] CathWithGuac puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[17:53:05] auhosj877 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[17:53:05] Turn 1: CathWithGuac
[17:53:08] CathWithGuac skips their draw step.
[17:53:09] CathWithGuac plays [Molten Tributary].
[17:53:12] Turn 1: auhosj877
[17:53:20] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:53:21] auhosj877 casts [Ponder].
[17:53:27] auhosj877 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[17:53:27] auhosj877 draws a card with [Ponder].
[17:53:29] Turn 2: CathWithGuac
[17:53:34] CathWithGuac plays [Mountain].
[17:53:38] CathWithGuac casts [Breakthrough]. (X is 1).
[17:53:44] CathWithGuac exiles [Hatching Plans] with with [Disrupting Shoal]'s ability.
[17:53:44] auhosj877 casts [Disrupting Shoal] using an alternate cost targeting [Breakthrough]. (X is 2).
[17:53:52] Turn 2: auhosj877
[17:53:54] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:53:57] auhosj877 casts [Hatching Plans].
[17:53:58] Turn 3: CathWithGuac
[17:54:02] CathWithGuac plays [Molten Tributary].
[17:54:06] CathWithGuac casts [Breakthrough]. (X is 1).
[17:54:07] CathWithGuac draws four cards with [Breakthrough].
[17:54:15] CathWithGuac discards [Shivan Reef].
[17:54:15] CathWithGuac discards [Deep Analysis].
[17:54:15] CathWithGuac discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[17:54:15] CathWithGuac discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[17:54:15] CathWithGuac discards [Conflagrate].
[17:54:15] CathWithGuac discards [Conflagrate].
[17:54:20] Turn 3: auhosj877
[17:54:23] auhosj877 casts [Perilous Research].
[17:54:23] auhosj877 draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
[17:54:24] auhosj877 sacrifices [Hatching Plans].
[17:54:24] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Hatching Plans] onto the stack (When Hatching Plans is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw three cards.).
[17:54:25] auhosj877 draws three cards with [Hatching Plans]'s ability.
[17:54:26] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:54:29] auhosj877 casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[17:54:30] auhosj877 activates an ability of [Nihil Spellbomb] targeting CathWithGuac ( Exile target player's graveyard.).
[17:54:30] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Nihil Spellbomb] onto the stack (When Nihil Spellbomb is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, dra...).
[17:54:34] Turn 4: CathWithGuac
[17:54:46] Turn 4: auhosj877
[17:54:50] auhosj877 casts [Thought Scour] targeting auhosj877.
[17:54:52] auhosj877 mills [Island] and auhosj877.
[17:54:52] auhosj877 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[17:54:59] auhosj877 casts [Thought Scour] targeting auhosj877.
[17:55:01] auhosj877 mills [Disrupting Shoal] and [Wandering Fumarole].
[17:55:01] auhosj877 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[17:55:07] auhosj877 casts [Ponder].
[17:55:22] auhosj877 chooses to not shuffle their library.
[17:55:22] auhosj877 draws a card with [Ponder].
[17:55:23] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:55:24] auhosj877 casts [Tolarian Terror].
[17:55:26] Turn 5: CathWithGuac
[17:55:33] CathWithGuac plays [Shivan Reef].
[17:55:39] CathWithGuac discards [Mountain].
[17:55:39] CathWithGuac casts [Lightning Axe] targeting [Tolarian Terror].
[17:55:39] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Tolarian Terror] onto the stack (Ward {2} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[17:55:56] Turn 5: auhosj877
[17:55:56] auhosj877 casts [Perilous Research].
[17:55:56] auhosj877 draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
[17:55:57] auhosj877 sacrifices [Island].
[17:55:58] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:56:02] Turn 6: CathWithGuac
[17:56:14] Turn 6: auhosj877
[17:56:19] auhosj877 casts [Perilous Research].
[17:56:20] auhosj877 draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
[17:56:21] auhosj877 sacrifices [Island].
[17:56:22] auhosj877 plays [Island].
[17:56:29] Turn 7: CathWithGuac
[17:56:36] Turn 7: auhosj877
[17:56:39] auhosj877 casts [Tolarian Terror].
[17:56:55] CathWithGuac discards [Island].
[17:56:55] CathWithGuac casts [Lightning Axe] targeting [Tolarian Terror].
[17:56:56] auhosj877 puts triggered ability from [Tolarian Terror] onto the stack (Ward {2} (Whenever this permanent becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls,...).
[17:57:07] auhosj877 casts [Disrupting Shoal] targeting [Lightning Axe]. (X is 1).
[17:57:15] Turn 8: CathWithGuac
[17:57:22] Turn 8: auhosj877
[17:57:26] CathWithGuac is being attacked by [Tolarian Terror]
[17:57:30] Turn 9: CathWithGuac
[17:57:36] Turn 9: auhosj877
[17:57:40] CathWithGuac is being attacked by [Tolarian Terror]
[17:57:47] auhosj877 discards [Pyroclasm].
[17:57:47] Turn 10: CathWithGuac
[17:58:20] CathWithGuac casts [Conflagrate]. (X is 0).
[17:58:40] CathWithGuac discards [Master of Death].
[17:58:40] CathWithGuac discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[17:58:40] CathWithGuac casts [Conflagrate] from the graveyard targeting auhosj877 for 2. (X is 2).
[17:59:00] auhosj877 casts [Perilous Research].
[17:59:00] auhosj877 draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
[17:59:16] auhosj877 sacrifices [Island].
[17:59:18] Turn 10: auhosj877
[17:59:22] auhosj877 plays [Shivan Reef].
[17:59:27] auhosj877 casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[17:59:30] CathWithGuac has conceded from the game.
Winner: auhosj877
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: auhosj877: 2–1