PennyDreadful
PD s26
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Kithkin,Plrt

== Game 1 (813491854) ==
[Time] 1663282406
[01:53:26] PDBot has started watching.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
[01:53:34] [CHAT] Kithkin: glhf
[01:53:35] Plrt chooses to play first.
[01:53:38] [CHAT] Plrt: gl
[01:53:40] Plrt begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[01:53:45] Kithkin begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[01:53:45] Turn 1: Plrt
[01:53:48] Plrt skips their draw step.
[01:53:49] Plrt plays [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[01:53:49] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[01:53:50] Turn 1: Kithkin
[01:53:51] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[01:53:53] Kithkin casts [Goldhound].
[01:53:55] Turn 2: Plrt
[01:54:03] Plrt plays [Mountain].
[01:54:10] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[01:54:10] Plrt discards [Narcomoeba].
[01:54:10] Plrt casts [Cathartic Reunion].
[01:54:10] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Stinkweed Imp[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Stinkweed Imp` or `!notbugged Stinkweed Imp`
[01:54:10] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Narcomoeba[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[01:54:17] Plrt draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion].
[01:54:19] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:54:19] Plrt mills [Island], [Stinkweed Imp], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Mountain] and [Simian Spirit Guide].
[01:54:20] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Simian Spirit Guide[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[01:54:21] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:54:21] Plrt mills [Island], [Shivan Reef], [Swiftwater Cliffs], [Creeping Chill] and [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:54:22] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:54:22] Plrt mills [Shambling Shell], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Shivan Reef], [Insolent Neonate], [Island] and [Insolent Neonate].
[01:54:22] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[01:54:23] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Shivan Reef[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[sG] In order to prevent further spamming, I'll stop warning you now.
[sG] For more information about Penny Dreadful, see pdmtgo.com or reddit.com/r/PennyDreadfulMTG
[01:54:31] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[01:54:43] Turn 2: Kithkin
[01:54:51] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[01:54:55] Kithkin casts [Captain Lannery Storm].
[01:54:59] Plrt is being attacked by [Captain Lannery Storm]
[01:54:59] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Captain Lannery Storm] onto the stack (Whenever Captain Lannery Storm attacks, create a Treasure token.).
[01:54:59] Kithkin's [Captain Lannery Storm] creates a Treasure Token.
[01:55:03] Turn 3: Plrt
[01:55:07] Plrt returns [Shambling Shell] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:55:07] Plrt mills [Shambling Shell], [Merchant of the Vale] and [Simian Spirit Guide].
[01:55:11] Plrt casts [Insolent Neonate].
[01:55:15] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:55:15] Plrt activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.).
[01:55:17] Plrt draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability.
[01:55:18] Plrt returns [Shambling Shell] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:55:19] Plrt mills [Cathartic Reunion], [Narcomoeba] and [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[01:55:19] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[01:55:26] Plrt casts [Breakthrough]. (X is 0).
[01:55:31] Plrt draws four cards with [Breakthrough].
[01:55:34] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:55:34] Plrt mills [Narcomoeba], [Breakthrough], [Cathartic Reunion], [Swiftwater Cliffs], [Breakthrough] and [Mountain].
[01:55:34] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:55:34] Plrt mills [Shivan Reef], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Narcomoeba], [Stinkweed Imp] and [Hellspark Elemental].
[01:55:34] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:55:34] Plrt mills [Island], [Cathartic Reunion], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Insolent Neonate], [Merchant of the Vale] and [Silversmote Ghoul].
[01:55:35] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:55:35] Plrt mills [Shivan Reef], [Creeping Chill], [Stinkweed Imp], [Golgari Brownscale], [Silversmote Ghoul] and Kithkin.
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Breakthrough].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Shambling Shell].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Shambling Shell].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:55:41] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:55:43] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[01:55:43] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[01:55:43] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[01:55:45] [CHAT] Kithkin: ooh breakthrough thats a neat card forgot about that one
[01:55:58] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[01:55:58] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[01:55:58] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[01:55:58] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[01:55:59] Turn 3: Kithkin
[01:56:07] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[01:56:13] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Captain Lannery Storm] onto the stack (Whenever you sacrifice a Treasure, Captain Lannery Storm gets +1/+0 until end of turn.).
[01:56:19] Kithkin discards [Intervention Pact].
[01:56:19] Kithkin casts [Thrill of Possibility].
[01:56:19] Kithkin draws two cards with [Thrill of Possibility].
[01:56:24] Kithkin exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[01:56:28] Kithkin casts [Pyretic Ritual].
[01:56:32] Kithkin discards [Platinum Angel].
[01:56:32] Kithkin casts [Thrill of Possibility].
[01:56:32] Kithkin draws two cards with [Thrill of Possibility].
[01:56:36] Kithkin casts [Goldhound].
[01:56:40] Plrt is being attacked by [Captain Lannery Storm]
[01:56:40] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Captain Lannery Storm] onto the stack (Whenever Captain Lannery Storm attacks, create a Treasure token.).
[01:56:41] Kithkin's [Captain Lannery Storm] creates a Treasure Token.
[01:56:48] Turn 4: Plrt
[01:57:01] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:57:01] Plrt mills [Merchant of the Vale], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Shambling Shell], [Creeping Chill] and [Golgari Brownscale].
[01:57:01] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[01:57:06] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[01:57:11] Plrt activates an ability of [Hellspark Elemental] (Unearth for {1R}).
[01:57:18] Kithkin is being attacked by [Hellspark Elemental], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Narcomoeba], [Narcomoeba] and [Narcomoeba]
[01:57:23] Kithkin has conceded from the game.
Winner: Plrt
Game 1 Completed.
[01:57:26] Kithkin has left the game.

== Game 2 (813492230) ==
[Time] 1663282676
[01:57:56] PDBot has started watching.
[01:58:00] Plrt joined the game.
[01:58:01] Kithkin chooses to play first.
[01:58:11] Kithkin begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[01:58:13] Plrt begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[01:58:13] Turn 1: Kithkin
[01:58:14] Kithkin skips their draw step.
[01:58:16] Kithkin plays [Keldon Megaliths].
[01:58:17] Turn 1: Plrt
[01:58:20] TheWatchWander has started watching.
[01:58:23] Plrt plays [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[01:58:23] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[01:58:27] Turn 2: Kithkin
[01:58:27] TheWatchWander has stopped watching.
[01:58:30] Kithkin plays [Hanweir Battlements].
[01:58:35] Kithkin exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[01:58:36] Kithkin casts [Relic Robber].
[01:58:40] Plrt is being attacked by [Relic Robber]
[01:58:42] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Relic Robber] onto the stack (Whenever Relic Robber deals combat damage to a player, that player creates a 0/1 colorless Goblin ...).
[01:58:43] Plrt's [Relic Robber] creates a Goblin Construct Token under Plrt's control.
[01:58:44] Turn 2: Plrt
[01:58:44] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Goblin Construct Token] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, this creature deals 1 damage to you.).
[01:58:51] Plrt plays [Mountain].
[01:58:59] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:58:59] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:58:59] Plrt casts [Cathartic Reunion].
[01:59:00] Plrt draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion].
[01:59:01] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:59:01] Plrt mills [Shivan Reef], [Shambling Shell], [Cathartic Reunion], [Cathartic Reunion], [Shenanigans] and [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[01:59:02] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:59:02] Plrt mills [Cathartic Reunion], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Shivan Reef], [Breakthrough], [Island] and [Stinkweed Imp].
[01:59:04] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:59:04] Plrt mills [Narcomoeba], [Shivan Reef], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Creeping Chill], [Mountain] and [Insolent Neonate].
[01:59:06] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[01:59:06] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[01:59:08] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[01:59:14] Turn 3: Kithkin
[01:59:16] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[01:59:19] Kithkin casts [Hanweir Garrison].
[01:59:23] Plrt is being attacked by [Relic Robber]
[01:59:26] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Relic Robber] onto the stack (Whenever Relic Robber deals combat damage to a player, that player creates a 0/1 colorless Goblin ...).
[01:59:27] Plrt's [Relic Robber] creates a Goblin Construct Token under Plrt's control.
[01:59:28] Turn 3: Plrt
[01:59:28] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Goblin Construct Token] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, this creature deals 1 damage to you.).
[01:59:28] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Goblin Construct Token] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, this creature deals 1 damage to you.).
[01:59:35] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[01:59:35] Plrt mills [Shambling Shell], [Creeping Chill], [Creeping Chill], [Narcomoeba], [Breakthrough] and [Simian Spirit Guide].
[01:59:37] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[01:59:37] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[01:59:37] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[01:59:44] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[01:59:45] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[01:59:56] Plrt casts [Haggle].
[01:59:59] Plrt discards [Silversmote Ghoul].
[01:59:59] Plrt draws a card with [Haggle].
[02:00:02] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:00:02] Plrt mills [Shenanigans], [Merchant of the Vale], [Island], [Insolent Neonate] and [Shivan Reef].
[02:00:10] Kithkin is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]
[02:00:16] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[02:00:23] Turn 4: Kithkin
[02:00:29] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[02:00:31] Kithkin casts [Goldhound].
[02:00:42] Plrt is being attacked by [Hanweir Garrison] and [Relic Robber]
[02:00:42] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Hanweir Garrison] onto the stack (Whenever Hanweir Garrison attacks, create two 1/1 red Human creature tokens that are tapped and at...).
[02:00:43] Kithkin's [Hanweir Garrison] creates two Human Tokens.
[02:00:43] Kithkin puts [Human Token] onto the battlefield attacking Plrt
[02:00:43] Kithkin puts [Human Token] onto the battlefield attacking Plrt
[02:00:49] Kithkin puts triggered ability from [Relic Robber] onto the stack (Whenever Relic Robber deals combat damage to a player, that player creates a 0/1 colorless Goblin ...).
[02:00:50] Plrt's [Relic Robber] creates a Goblin Construct Token under Plrt's control.
[02:00:53] Turn 4: Plrt
[02:00:53] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Goblin Construct Token] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, this creature deals 1 damage to you.).
[02:01:02] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Goblin Construct Token] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, this creature deals 1 damage to you.).
[02:01:02] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Goblin Construct Token] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, this creature deals 1 damage to you.).
[02:01:02] Plrt returns [Shenanigans] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:01:02] Plrt mills [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[02:01:06] Plrt casts [Shenanigans] targeting [Goldhound].
[02:01:14] Kithkin is being attacked by [Goblin Construct Token], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Narcomoeba], [Goblin Construct Token], [Narcomoeba] and [Goblin Construct Token]
[02:01:18] Turn 5: Kithkin
[02:01:21] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[02:01:25] Kithkin exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[02:01:29] Kithkin activates an ability of [Hanweir Battlements] ( If you both own and control Hanweir Battlements and a creature named Hanweir Garrison, exile them...).
[02:01:37] Plrt has conceded from the game.
Winner: Kithkin
Game 2 Completed.
[02:01:41] Kithkin has left the game.

== Game 3 (813492552) ==
[Time] 1663282916
[02:01:56] PDBot has started watching.
[02:01:58] Plrt joined the game.
[02:02:12] Plrt chooses to play first.
[02:02:15] Plrt begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:02:18] Kithkin begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[02:02:18] Turn 1: Plrt
[02:02:20] Plrt skips their draw step.
[02:02:22] Plrt plays [Mountain].
[02:02:23] Plrt casts [Insolent Neonate].
[02:02:29] Turn 1: Kithkin
[02:02:32] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[02:02:35] Turn 2: Plrt
[02:02:43] Kithkin is being attacked by [Insolent Neonate]
[02:02:57] Plrt casts [Haggle].
[02:03:02] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[02:03:02] Plrt draws a card with [Haggle].
[02:03:03] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:03] Plrt mills [Shambling Shell], [Narcomoeba], [Swiftwater Cliffs], [Silversmote Ghoul] and [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[02:03:03] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[02:03:10] Plrt exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability.
[02:03:12] Plrt casts [Insolent Neonate].
[02:03:16] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[02:03:16] Plrt activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.).
[02:03:17] Plrt draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability.
[02:03:19] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:20] Plrt mills [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Mountain], [Stinkweed Imp], [Swiftwater Cliffs], [Simian Spirit Guide] and [Cathartic Reunion].
[02:03:24] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[02:03:24] Plrt activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.).
[02:03:26] Plrt draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability.
[02:03:27] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:27] Plrt mills [Silversmote Ghoul], [Mountain], [Narcomoeba], [Shivan Reef], [Silversmote Ghoul] and [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[02:03:27] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[02:03:31] Plrt plays [Island].
[02:03:34] Plrt casts [Breakthrough]. (X is 0).
[02:03:39] Plrt draws four cards with [Breakthrough].
[02:03:41] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:41] Plrt mills [Creeping Chill], [Island], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Stinkweed Imp], [Stinkweed Imp] and [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[02:03:42] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:42] Plrt mills [Cathartic Reunion], [Narcomoeba], [Breakthrough], [Shivan Reef], [Narcomoeba] and [Cathartic Reunion].
[02:03:45] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:45] Plrt mills [Island], [Stern Dismissal], [Shambling Shell], [Breakthrough] and [Breakthrough].
[02:03:47] Plrt returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:03:47] Plrt mills [Simian Spirit Guide], [Creeping Chill], [Insolent Neonate], [Swiftwater Cliffs] and [Shivan Reef].
[02:03:52] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[02:03:52] Plrt discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[02:03:52] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[02:03:52] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[02:03:52] Plrt discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[02:03:53] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[02:03:54] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[02:03:54] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[02:03:54] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[02:03:55] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[02:03:56] Plrt exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability.
[02:03:58] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[02:03:58] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[02:03:58] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[02:03:59] Turn 2: Kithkin
[02:04:03] Kithkin plays [Mountain].
[02:04:05] Kithkin casts [Harsh Mentor].
[02:04:09] Turn 3: Plrt
[02:04:16] Plrt returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[02:04:16] Plrt mills [Shambling Shell], [Creeping Chill], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Merchant of the Vale], [Silversmote Ghoul] and [Insolent Neonate].
[02:04:16] Plrt puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...).
[02:04:29] [CHAT] Kithkin: ggs. rematch?
[02:04:32] [CHAT] Plrt: ggs
[02:04:37] Kithkin has conceded from the game.
Winner: Plrt
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Plrt: 2–1
[02:04:40] Kithkin has left the game.