PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Garcia_Edu,_counterspell == Game 1 (808270590) == [Time] 1659277967 [17:32:48] PDBot has started watching. [17:32:48] _counterspell joined the game. [17:32:49] Garcia_Edu joined the game. [League] Pile by _counterspell (189096) vs Orzhov-Midrange by garcia_edu (189020) [17:32:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [17:32:55] _counterspell chooses to play first. [17:33:00] _counterspell begins the game with seven cards in hand. [17:33:22] Garcia_Edu mulligans to six cards. [17:33:28] Garcia_Edu puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [17:33:28] Turn 1: _counterspell [17:33:29] _counterspell skips their draw step. [17:33:33] _counterspell plays [Obscura Storefront]. [17:33:33] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Obscura Storefront] onto the stack (When Obscura Storefront enters the battlefield, sacrifice it. When you do, search your library for...). [17:33:34] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Obscura Storefront] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Obscura Storefront, search your library for a basic Plains, Island, or Swamp ca...). [17:33:38] Turn 1: Garcia_Edu [17:33:51] Garcia_Edu plays [Temple of Silence]. [17:33:51] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [17:33:57] Garcia_Edu puts 1 card on top of their library. [17:33:57] Garcia_Edu scrys 1. [17:33:57] Turn 2: _counterspell [17:34:00] _counterspell plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:34:02] Turn 2: Garcia_Edu [17:34:05] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:34:06] Placebo has started watching. [17:34:09] Garcia_Edu casts [Castigate] targeting _counterspell. [17:34:15] _counterspell casts [Faithful Mending]. [17:34:17] _counterspell draws two cards with [Faithful Mending]. [17:34:22] _counterspell discards [Dream Trawler]. [17:34:22] _counterspell discards [Angel of Despair]. [17:34:27] _counterspell reveals their hand to [Castigate], containing [Island], [Swamp], [Swamp], and [Snowfield Sinkhole]. [17:34:38] Turn 3: _counterspell [17:34:40] _counterspell plays [Glacial Fortress]. [17:34:42] Turn 3: Garcia_Edu [17:34:56] Garcia_Edu plays [Skyclave Basilica]. [17:35:04] _counterspell casts [Faithful Mending] from the graveyard. [17:35:05] _counterspell draws two cards with [Faithful Mending]. [17:35:07] _counterspell discards [Swamp]. [17:35:07] _counterspell discards [Snowfield Sinkhole]. [17:35:26] Turn 4: _counterspell [17:35:27] _counterspell plays [Island]. [17:35:30] _counterspell casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Dream Trawler]. [17:35:30] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [17:35:31] Turn 4: Garcia_Edu [17:35:39] Garcia_Edu casts [Vindicate] targeting [Animate Dead]. [17:35:41] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.). [17:35:45] Turn 5: _counterspell [17:35:48] _counterspell plays [Swamp]. [17:35:51] _counterspell casts [Buried Alive]. [17:35:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Buried Alive[sU] has a disadvantageous bug. The order of cards put into the graveyard by Buried Alive is random [17:36:04] Turn 5: Garcia_Edu [17:36:07] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:36:12] Garcia_Edu casts [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]. [17:36:13] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Kaya, Ghost Assassin[sU] has an unconfirmed bug. If Kaya, Ghost Assassin exiles a commander with the first ability, and its controller chooses not to replace exile with the command zone, the commander will still go to the command zone until Kaya returns it. Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Kaya, Ghost Assassin` or `!notbugged Kaya, Ghost Assassin` [17:36:18] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent discards a card and you draw a card.). [17:36:22] _counterspell chooses a card from their hand. [17:36:22] _counterspell discards [Glacial Fortress]. [17:36:22] Garcia_Edu draws a card with [Kaya, Ghost Assassin]'s ability. [17:36:26] Turn 6: _counterspell [17:36:28] _counterspell plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:36:35] _counterspell casts [Dream Trawler]. [17:36:36] Turn 6: Garcia_Edu [17:36:51] Garcia_Edu casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] (with kicker) targeting [Dream Trawler]. [17:36:57] Garcia_Edu plays [Temple of Silence]. [17:36:58] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [17:37:01] Garcia_Edu puts 1 card on top of their library. [17:37:01] Garcia_Edu scrys 1. [17:37:03] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.). [17:37:07] Turn 7: _counterspell [17:37:09] _counterspell plays [Snowfield Sinkhole]. [17:37:11] Turn 7: Garcia_Edu [17:37:13] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.). [17:37:18] Turn 8: _counterspell [17:37:20] _counterspell plays [Mortuary Mire]. [17:37:47] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Mortuary Mire] onto the stack targeting [Angel of Despair] (When Mortuary Mire enters the battlefield, you may put target creature card from your graveyard on...). [17:37:58] _counterspell puts [Angel of Despair] on top of their library with [Mortuary Mire]'s ability. [17:38:06] Garcia_Edu casts [Restoration Angel]. [17:38:06] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Restoration Angel] on the stack. [17:38:10] Turn 8: Garcia_Edu [17:38:18] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Exile Kaya, Ghost Assassin or up to one target creature. Return that card to the battlefield unde...). [17:38:26] _counterspell is being attacked by [Restoration Angel] [17:38:30] Turn 9: _counterspell [17:38:45] _counterspell casts [Angel of Despair]. [17:38:59] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Angel of Despair] onto the stack targeting [Restoration Angel] (When Angel of Despair enters the battlefield, destroy target permanent.). [17:39:05] Garcia_Edu casts [Cathar Commando]. [17:39:08] Turn 9: Garcia_Edu [17:39:08] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from Kaya, Ghost Assassin onto the stack (Return Kaya, Ghost Assassin to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of your ...). [17:39:13] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains]. [17:39:19] Garcia_Edu casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] (with kicker) targeting [Angel of Despair]. [17:39:23] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] ( Each opponent loses 2 life and you gain 2 life.). [17:39:26] _counterspell is being attacked by [Cathar Commando] [17:39:30] Turn 10: _counterspell [17:39:34] _counterspell casts [Thought Scour] targeting _counterspell. [17:39:36] _counterspell mills [Obscura Storefront] and [Unburial Rites]. [17:39:36] _counterspell draws a card with [Thought Scour]. [17:40:27] _counterspell casts [Unburial Rites] from the graveyard targeting [Angel of Despair]. [17:40:41] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Angel of Despair] onto the stack targeting [Kaya, Ghost Assassin] (When Angel of Despair enters the battlefield, destroy target permanent.). [17:40:50] Turn 10: Garcia_Edu [17:41:00] Garcia_Edu casts [Dread Fugue] for its cleave cost using an alternate cost targeting _counterspell. [17:41:03] _counterspell discards [Aethermage's Touch]. [17:41:03] _counterspell reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing no cards. [17:41:08] Garcia_Edu plays [Goldmire Bridge]. [17:41:14] Turn 11: _counterspell [17:41:45] _counterspell casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Rune-Scarred Demon]. [17:41:50] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [17:41:52] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Rune-Scarred Demon] onto the stack (When Rune-Scarred Demon enters the battlefield, search your library for a card, put it into your h...). [17:42:10] _counterspell casts [Karmic Guide]. [17:42:24] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Karmic Guide] onto the stack targeting [Soulherder] (When Karmic Guide enters the battlefield, return target creature card from your graveyard to the b...). [17:42:34] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Angel of Despair] [17:42:40] Garcia_Edu casts [Condemn] targeting [Angel of Despair]. [17:42:47] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack targeting [Karmic Guide] (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile another target creature you control, then return ...). [17:42:53] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack (Whenever a creature is exiled from the battlefield, put a +1/+1 counter on Soulherder.). [17:42:57] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Karmic Guide] onto the stack targeting [Dinrova Horror] (When Karmic Guide enters the battlefield, return target creature card from your graveyard to the b...). [17:42:59] Garcia_Edu has conceded from the game. Winner: _counterspell Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (808271708) == [Time] 1659278661 [17:44:21] PDBot has started watching. [17:44:21] Garcia_Edu chooses to play first. [17:44:26] Garcia_Edu begins the game with seven cards in hand. [17:44:28] _counterspell begins the game with seven cards in hand. [17:44:28] Turn 1: Garcia_Edu [17:44:28] Garcia_Edu skips their draw step. [17:44:30] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains]. [17:44:31] Garcia_Edu casts [Lantern of the Lost]. [17:44:33] Couldn't put triggered ability from [Lantern of the Lost] on the stack. [17:44:34] Turn 1: _counterspell [17:44:41] _counterspell plays [Obscura Storefront]. [17:44:41] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Obscura Storefront] onto the stack (When Obscura Storefront enters the battlefield, sacrifice it. When you do, search your library for...). [17:44:42] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Obscura Storefront] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Obscura Storefront, search your library for a basic Plains, Island, or Swamp ca...). [17:44:46] Turn 2: Garcia_Edu [17:44:50] Garcia_Edu plays [Plains]. [17:44:53] Turn 2: _counterspell [17:44:55] _counterspell plays [Island]. [17:44:59] Turn 3: Garcia_Edu [17:45:01] Garcia_Edu plays [Temple of Silence]. [17:45:01] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [17:45:04] Garcia_Edu puts 1 card on top of their library. [17:45:04] Garcia_Edu scrys 1. [17:45:07] Turn 3: _counterspell [17:45:08] _counterspell plays [Plains]. [17:45:16] Garcia_Edu casts [Cathar Commando]. [17:45:18] Turn 4: Garcia_Edu [17:45:23] _counterspell is being attacked by [Cathar Commando] [17:45:46] _counterspell casts [Faithful Mending]. [17:45:48] _counterspell draws two cards with [Faithful Mending]. [17:45:52] _counterspell discards [Animate Dead]. [17:45:52] _counterspell discards [Buried Alive]. [17:45:54] Turn 4: _counterspell [17:46:00] _counterspell casts [Fblthp, the Lost]. [17:46:05] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Fblthp, the Lost] onto the stack (When Fblthp, the Lost enters the battlefield, draw a card. If it entered from your library or was ...). [17:46:10] _counterspell draws a card with [Fblthp, the Lost]'s ability. [17:46:18] Garcia_Edu casts [Cathar Commando]. [17:46:22] Turn 5: Garcia_Edu [17:46:30] _counterspell is being attacked by [Cathar Commando] and [Cathar Commando] [17:46:34] [Fblthp, the Lost] blocks [Cathar Commando]. [17:46:44] Garcia_Edu casts [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos]. [17:46:44] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Kunoros, Hound of Athreos[sU] has a disadvantageous bug. Kunoros's static ability prevents cards below it in the graveyard from entering the battlefield when reanimated together. [17:46:45] Turn 5: _counterspell [17:47:06] _counterspell discards [Animate Dead]. [17:47:06] Turn 6: Garcia_Edu [17:47:20] _counterspell is being attacked by [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos] and [Cathar Commando] [17:47:30] Garcia_Edu casts [Castigate] targeting _counterspell. [17:47:41] _counterspell reveals their hand to [Castigate], containing [Dream Trawler], [Aethermage's Touch], [Aethermage's Touch], [Liliana Vess], [Karmic Guide], and [Aethermage's Touch]. [17:47:43] Turn 6: _counterspell [17:47:48] _counterspell plays [Glacial Fortress]. [17:47:55] Turn 7: Garcia_Edu [17:47:58] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:48:03] _counterspell is being attacked by [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos] and [Cathar Commando] [17:48:08] _counterspell casts [Aethermage's Touch]. [17:48:10] _counterspell reveals 4 cards with [Aethermage's Touch]: [Mortuary Mire], [Dinrova Horror], [Champion of Wits], and [Dream Trawler]. [17:48:30] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dinrova Horror] onto the stack targeting [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos] (When Dinrova Horror enters the battlefield, return target permanent to its owner's hand, then that...). [17:48:40] _counterspell returns [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos] to its owner's hand with [Dinrova Horror]'s ability. [17:48:50] Garcia_Edu discards [Vindicate]. [17:48:53] [Dinrova Horror] blocks [Cathar Commando]. [17:49:02] Garcia_Edu casts [Vindicate] targeting [Dinrova Horror]. [17:49:08] Turn 7: _counterspell [17:49:15] _counterspell plays [Obscura Storefront]. [17:49:15] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Obscura Storefront] onto the stack (When Obscura Storefront enters the battlefield, sacrifice it. When you do, search your library for...). [17:49:19] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Obscura Storefront] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Obscura Storefront, search your library for a basic Plains, Island, or Swamp ca...). [17:49:43] Turn 8: Garcia_Edu [17:49:44] Garcia_Edu plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:49:48] Garcia_Edu casts [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos]. [17:49:58] _counterspell casts [Aethermage's Touch]. [17:50:02] _counterspell reveals 4 cards with [Aethermage's Touch]: [Glacial Fortress], [Dream Trawler], [Champion of Wits], and [Soulherder]. [17:50:22] Turn 8: _counterspell [17:50:22] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, Dream Trawler gets +1/+0 until end of turn.). [17:50:30] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Dream Trawler] [17:50:31] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (Whenever Dream Trawler attacks, draw a card.). [17:50:32] _counterspell draws a card with [Dream Trawler]'s ability. [17:50:32] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, Dream Trawler gets +1/+0 until end of turn.). [17:50:45] _counterspell casts [Liliana Vess]. [17:50:51] _counterspell activates an ability of [Liliana Vess] targeting Garcia_Edu ( Target player discards a card.). [17:50:56] Garcia_Edu discards [Blade Splicer]. [17:50:59] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, return this creature to its owner's hand.). [17:51:04] Turn 9: Garcia_Edu [17:51:14] Garcia_Edu casts [Vindicate] targeting [Liliana Vess]. [17:51:19] _counterspell is being attacked by [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos] [17:51:22] Turn 9: _counterspell [17:51:25] _counterspell plays [Caves of Koilos]. [17:51:39] _counterspell casts [Dream Trawler]. [17:51:50] _counterspell exiles [Lantern of the Lost] with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability. [17:51:50] Garcia_Edu activates an ability of [Lantern of the Lost] ( Exile all cards from all graveyards, then draw a card.). [17:51:51] Garcia_Edu draws a card with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability. [17:51:55] Turn 10: Garcia_Edu [17:52:01] _counterspell is being attacked by [Kunoros, Hound of Athreos] [17:52:10] Garcia_Edu casts [Blade Splicer]. [17:52:12] Garcia_Edu puts triggered ability from [Blade Splicer] onto the stack (When Blade Splicer enters the battlefield, create a 3/3 colorless Phyrexian Golem artifact creatur...). [17:52:14] Garcia_Edu's [Blade Splicer] creates a Phyrexian Golem Token. [17:52:19] Turn 10: _counterspell [17:52:20] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, Dream Trawler gets +1/+0 until end of turn.). [17:52:28] Garcia_Edu is being attacked by [Dream Trawler] [17:52:28] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (Whenever Dream Trawler attacks, draw a card.). [17:52:31] Garcia_Edu casts [Condemn] targeting [Dream Trawler]. [17:52:35] _counterspell discards [Kederekt Leviathan]. [17:52:35] _counterspell activates an ability of [Dream Trawler] ( Dream Trawler gains hexproof until end of turn. Tap it.). [17:52:36] Garcia_Edu's [Condemn] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [17:52:37] _counterspell draws a card with [Dream Trawler]'s ability. [17:52:37] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Dream Trawler] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, Dream Trawler gets +1/+0 until end of turn.). [17:52:52] _counterspell casts [Dream Trawler]. [17:52:57] Turn 11: Garcia_Edu [17:53:06] Garcia_Edu has conceded from the game. Winner: _counterspell Game 2 Completed. Match Winner: _counterspell: 2–0