PennyDreadful
Penny Dreadful League
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Aguafria,BatMana

== Game 1 (807810438) ==
[Time] 1658901191
[08:53:12] PDBot has started watching.
[08:53:12] Aguafria joined the game.
[League] Humans 2.0 by aguafria (188496) vs Soulflayer Is Bad by batmana (188485)
[08:53:14] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[08:53:14] Aguafria chooses to play first.
[08:53:16] Aguafria begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[08:53:19] BatMana begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[08:53:19] Turn 1: Aguafria
[08:53:22] Aguafria skips their draw step.
[08:53:23] Aguafria plays [Vivid Meadow].
[08:53:29] Turn 1: BatMana
[08:53:32] BatMana plays [Swamp].
[08:53:38] Turn 2: Aguafria
[08:53:41] Aguafria plays [Forest].
[08:53:46] Aguafria casts [Mayor of Avabruck].
[08:53:54] Turn 2: BatMana
[08:53:58] BatMana plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[08:54:03] BatMana casts [Mire Triton].
[08:54:05] BatMana puts triggered ability from [Mire Triton] onto the stack (When Mire Triton enters the battlefield, mill two cards and you gain 2 life.).
[08:54:07] BatMana mills [Frantic Search] and [Mistvault Bridge].
[08:54:21] Turn 3: Aguafria
[08:54:25] Aguafria plays [Secluded Courtyard].
[08:54:27] Aguafria chooses Human for [Secluded Courtyard].
[08:54:32] Aguafria casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[08:54:38] Aguafria casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[08:54:58] Turn 3: BatMana
[08:55:02] BatMana plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[08:55:08] BatMana casts [Vampire Nighthawk].
[08:55:19] Turn 4: Aguafria
[08:55:23] Aguafria plays [Caves of Koilos].
[08:55:32] datrobino has started watching.
[08:55:49] Turn 4: BatMana
[08:55:54] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.).
[08:55:54] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Mayor of Avabruck] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Mayor of Avabruck.).
[08:55:58] [Howlpack Alpha] transformed
[08:56:00] [Krallenhorde Howler] transformed
[08:56:01] robon9 has started watching.
[08:56:10] Aguafria is being attacked by [Vampire Nighthawk]
[08:56:28] BatMana casts [Gloomshrieker].
[08:56:29] BatMana puts triggered ability from [Gloomshrieker] onto the stack targeting [Mistvault Bridge] (When Gloomshrieker enters the battlefield, return target permanent card from your graveyard to you...).
[08:56:34] BatMana returns [Mistvault Bridge] to its owner's hand with [Gloomshrieker]'s ability.
[08:56:36] BatMana plays [Mistvault Bridge].
[08:56:40] Turn 5: Aguafria
[08:56:44] Aguafria plays [Battlefield Forge].
[08:57:10] Aguafria casts [Lyev Skyknight].
[08:57:18] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Lyev Skyknight] onto the stack targeting [Mire Triton] (When Lyev Skyknight enters the battlefield, detain target nonland permanent an opponent controls.).
[08:57:29] Aguafria casts [Benalish Marshal].
[08:57:36] BatMana is being attacked by [Krallenhorde Howler] and [Howlpack Alpha]
[08:57:40] [Gloomshrieker] blocks [Krallenhorde Howler].
[08:57:48] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Howlpack Alpha] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token.).
[08:57:51] Aguafria's [Howlpack Alpha] creates a Wolf Token.
[08:57:53] Turn 5: BatMana
[08:57:56] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Howlpack Alpha] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Howlpack...).
[08:57:56] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Krallenhorde Howler] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Krallenh...).
[08:57:59] [Duskwatch Recruiter] transformed
[08:58:01] [Mayor of Avabruck] transformed
[08:58:05] BatMana plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[08:58:10] BatMana casts [Frantic Search].
[08:58:11] BatMana draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[08:58:18] BatMana discards [Phylactery Lich].
[08:58:18] BatMana discards [Sign in Blood].
[08:58:23] BatMana casts [Shriekhorn].
[08:58:28] BatMana activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting BatMana ( Target player mills two cards.).
[08:58:30] BatMana mills [Soulflayer] and [Phylactery Lich].
[08:58:30] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Soulflayer[sU] has a graphical bug.
Soulflayer doesn't show that it has gained variations of abilities, such as "Hexproof from Black".
[08:58:40] BatMana casts [Sign in Blood] targeting BatMana.
[08:58:42] BatMana draws two cards with [Sign in Blood].
[08:58:53] BatMana casts [Soulflayer].
[08:59:12] Turn 6: Aguafria
[08:59:18] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[08:59:21] Aguafria puts [Benalish Marshal] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[08:59:24] Aguafria plays [Battlefield Forge].
[08:59:33] Aguafria casts [Xathrid Necromancer].
[08:59:44] BatMana is being attacked by [Lyev Skyknight]
[08:59:48] [Vampire Nighthawk] blocks [Lyev Skyknight].
[08:59:50] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Xathrid Necromancer] onto the stack (Whenever Xathrid Necromancer or another Human creature you control dies, create a tapped 2/2 black...).
[08:59:53] Aguafria's [Xathrid Necromancer] creates a Zombie Token.
[08:59:57] Turn 6: BatMana
[08:59:57] robon9 has stopped watching.
[09:00:01] BatMana plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[09:00:05] BatMana casts [Shriekhorn].
[09:00:09] BatMana activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting BatMana ( Target player mills two cards.).
[09:00:10] BatMana mills [Mire Triton] and [Vampire Nighthawk].
[09:00:13] BatMana activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting BatMana ( Target player mills two cards.).
[09:00:15] BatMana mills [Sign in Blood] and [Phylactery Lich].
[09:00:25] BatMana casts [Gloomshrieker].
[09:00:32] BatMana puts triggered ability from [Gloomshrieker] onto the stack targeting [Soulflayer] (When Gloomshrieker enters the battlefield, return target permanent card from your graveyard to you...).
[09:00:35] BatMana returns [Soulflayer] to its owner's hand with [Gloomshrieker]'s ability.
[09:00:45] BatMana casts [Soulflayer].
[09:01:08] Turn 7: Aguafria
[09:01:19] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[09:01:21] Aguafria puts [Avacyn's Pilgrim] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[09:01:35] Aguafria casts [Benalish Marshal].
[09:01:44] Aguafria casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[09:01:59] Turn 7: BatMana
[09:02:22] BatMana casts [Nightveil Predator].
[09:02:32] BatMana plays [Mistvault Bridge].
[09:02:38] Aguafria is being attacked by [Soulflayer]
[09:03:05] Turn 8: Aguafria
[09:03:12] Aguafria plays [Forest].
[09:03:17] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[09:03:20] Aguafria puts no cards into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[09:03:32] BatMana is being attacked by [Avacyn's Pilgrim], [Benalish Marshal], [Zombie Token], [Xathrid Necromancer], [Wolf Token], [Benalish Marshal], [Duskwatch Recruiter], [Avacyn's Pilgrim] and [Mayor of Avabruck]
[09:03:38] [Mire Triton] blocks [Xathrid Necromancer].
[09:03:43] [Nightveil Predator] blocks [Benalish Marshal].
[09:03:50] [Soulflayer] blocks [Benalish Marshal].
[09:03:55] [Gloomshrieker] blocks [Mayor of Avabruck].
[09:04:03] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Xathrid Necromancer] onto the stack (Whenever Xathrid Necromancer or another Human creature you control dies, create a tapped 2/2 black...).
[09:04:04] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Xathrid Necromancer] onto the stack (Whenever Xathrid Necromancer or another Human creature you control dies, create a tapped 2/2 black...).
[09:04:07] Aguafria's [Xathrid Necromancer] creates a Zombie Token.
[09:04:09] Aguafria's [Xathrid Necromancer] creates a Zombie Token.
[09:04:16] Aguafria casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[09:04:21] Turn 8: BatMana
[09:04:27] BatMana discards [Canyon Slough].
[09:04:28] BatMana cycles [Canyon Slough].
[09:04:34] BatMana casts [Nightveil Predator].
[09:04:38] robon9 has started watching.
[09:04:51] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[09:04:54] Aguafria puts [Mantis Rider] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[09:05:10] Turn 9: Aguafria
[09:05:18] Aguafria casts [Kessig Malcontents].
[09:05:25] BatMana has conceded from the game.
Winner: Aguafria
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (807811160) ==
[Time] 1658902012
[09:06:53] PDBot has started watching.
[09:07:06] BatMana chooses to play first.
[09:07:11] BatMana begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[09:07:12] Aguafria begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[09:07:12] Turn 1: BatMana
[09:07:14] BatMana skips their draw step.
[09:07:17] BatMana plays [Canyon Slough].
[09:07:23] Turn 1: Aguafria
[09:07:26] Aguafria plays [Secluded Courtyard].
[09:07:29] Aguafria chooses Human for [Secluded Courtyard].
[09:07:37] Aguafria casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[09:07:43] Turn 2: BatMana
[09:07:48] BatMana plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[09:07:54] BatMana casts [Drown in Filth] targeting [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[09:07:59] BatMana mills [Sign in Blood], [Drown in Filth], [Shriekhorn] and [Nightveil Predator].
[09:08:05] [CHAT] Aguafria: wow
[09:08:20] [CHAT] Aguafria: i remember that card from the jund dredge deck
[09:08:26] [CHAT] Aguafria: back in 2012 standard
[09:08:43] [CHAT] BatMana: haha its not a bad card usually 
[09:09:04] [CHAT] Aguafria: yeah thats just whatever normally my guy would of died
[09:09:07] Turn 2: Aguafria
[09:09:10] Aguafria plays [Battlefield Forge].
[09:09:13] Aguafria casts [Champion of the Parish].
[09:09:24] Aguafria casts [Kitesail Freebooter].
[09:09:28] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[09:09:28] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Kitesail Freebooter] onto the stack targeting BatMana (When Kitesail Freebooter enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a ...).
[09:09:31] BatMana reveals their hand to [Kitesail Freebooter]'s ability, containing [Canyon Slough], [Gloomshrieker], [Mire Triton], [Soulflayer], and [Vampire Nighthawk].
[09:09:36] [CHAT] Aguafria: lol welp
[09:09:48] [CHAT] BatMana: also not a bad card usually lol 
[09:09:58] [CHAT] Aguafria: yeah i mean hey at least you got to cast the drown
[09:10:06] Turn 3: BatMana
[09:10:19] BatMana plays [Canyon Slough].
[09:10:34] BatMana casts [Mire Triton].
[09:10:36] BatMana puts triggered ability from [Mire Triton] onto the stack (When Mire Triton enters the battlefield, mill two cards and you gain 2 life.).
[09:10:39] BatMana mills [Frantic Search] and [Mire Triton].
[09:10:49] Turn 3: Aguafria
[09:10:57] Aguafria plays [Vivid Meadow].
[09:11:16] Aguafria casts [Xathrid Necromancer].
[09:11:18] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[09:11:25] BatMana is being attacked by [Kitesail Freebooter]
[09:11:38] Turn 4: BatMana
[09:12:02] BatMana casts [Vampire Nighthawk].
[09:12:15] Turn 4: Aguafria
[09:12:19] Aguafria plays [Battlefield Forge].
[09:12:32] Aguafria casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[09:12:33] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[09:12:42] Aguafria casts [Mayor of Avabruck].
[09:12:43] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[09:12:58] Turn 5: BatMana
[09:13:12] BatMana casts [Sign in Blood] targeting BatMana.
[09:13:15] [CHAT] Aguafria: the mana base is the hardest part of this deck tbh
[09:13:17] BatMana draws two cards with [Sign in Blood].
[09:13:28] [CHAT] Aguafria: last season i had all the checklands and stuff
[09:13:58] [CHAT] BatMana: it seems good, i bet it was lightning quick with better mana
[09:14:07] [CHAT] Aguafria: turn 2 mantis rider was always good
[09:14:23] [CHAT] Aguafria: stepyard into pilgrim into land plus rider
[09:14:25] Turn 5: Aguafria
[09:14:29] Aguafria plays [Secluded Courtyard].
[09:14:34] Aguafria chooses Human for [Secluded Courtyard].
[09:14:58] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[09:15:04] Aguafria puts [Kessig Malcontents] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[09:15:19] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[09:15:21] Aguafria puts [Mantis Rider] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[09:15:27] Turn 6: BatMana
[09:15:31] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.).
[09:15:31] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Mayor of Avabruck] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Mayor of Avabruck.).
[09:15:33] [Howlpack Alpha] transformed
[09:15:39] [Krallenhorde Howler] transformed
[09:15:47] BatMana plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[09:15:57] BatMana casts [Drown in Filth] targeting [Howlpack Alpha].
[09:16:01] [CHAT] Aguafria: side board is interesting i get canonist and ghost quarter for spy and some of the combo decks
[09:16:16] [CHAT] Aguafria: and the freebooter sin collecter keeps spell based combos in check
[09:16:18] BatMana mills [Samut, Voice of Dissent], [Silumgar, the Drifting Death], [Treasure Cruise] and [Swamp].
[09:16:58] BatMana casts [Mire Triton].
[09:16:59] [CHAT] Aguafria: i struggle against jokulhaups for sure and the mono red deck i assume. this is also hard because i have no answer for an indestructible soulflayer
[09:17:02] BatMana puts triggered ability from [Mire Triton] onto the stack (When Mire Triton enters the battlefield, mill two cards and you gain 2 life.).
[09:17:09] BatMana mills [Phylactery Lich] and [Frantic Search].
[09:17:46] [CHAT] BatMana: eh this is pretty janky though so it should be fine, and that one card makes it so you dont have to attack 
[09:17:53] [CHAT] BatMana: i can see haups being an issue though 
[09:17:56] [CHAT] Aguafria: yeah i am playing 4 malcontents
[09:18:05] [CHAT] Aguafria: like if they just topdeck haups i get super rekt
[09:18:09] [CHAT] Aguafria: i mean i have xathrid but
[09:18:17] [CHAT] Aguafria: they have chain lightning vindicate
[09:18:22] [CHAT] Aguafria: blah blah blah
[09:18:32] Turn 6: Aguafria
[09:18:38] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Krallenhorde Howler] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Krallenh...).
[09:18:38] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Howlpack Alpha] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Howlpack...).
[09:18:46] [CHAT] BatMana: i might try a run with your deck sometime if you dont mind 
[09:18:49] [Mayor of Avabruck] transformed
[09:18:51] [CHAT] Aguafria: by all means
[09:18:58] [CHAT] Aguafria: its fun im still working on it
[09:19:01] [Duskwatch Recruiter] transformed
[09:19:21] [CHAT] BatMana: always a work in progress i rarely ply the same exact list twice 
[09:19:32] [CHAT] Aguafria: 100% agree
[09:19:52] Aguafria casts [Mantis Rider].
[09:19:54] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[09:20:00] Aguafria casts [Kessig Malcontents].
[09:20:04] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Champion of the Parish] onto the stack (Whenever another Human enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Champion ...).
[09:20:08] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Kessig Malcontents] onto the stack targeting BatMana (When Kessig Malcontents enters the battlefield, it deals damage to target player or planeswalker e...).
[09:20:25] BatMana is being attacked by [Mantis Rider], [Mayor of Avabruck], [Duskwatch Recruiter], [Xathrid Necromancer], [Kitesail Freebooter] and [Champion of the Parish]
[09:20:29] [Vampire Nighthawk] blocks [Mantis Rider].
[09:20:32] [Mire Triton] blocks [Champion of the Parish].
[09:20:36] [Mire Triton] blocks [Xathrid Necromancer].
[09:20:44] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Xathrid Necromancer] onto the stack (Whenever Xathrid Necromancer or another Human creature you control dies, create a tapped 2/2 black...).
[09:20:45] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Xathrid Necromancer] onto the stack (Whenever Xathrid Necromancer or another Human creature you control dies, create a tapped 2/2 black...).
[09:20:45] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Xathrid Necromancer] onto the stack (Whenever Xathrid Necromancer or another Human creature you control dies, create a tapped 2/2 black...).
[09:20:47] Aguafria's [Xathrid Necromancer] creates a Zombie Token.
[09:20:49] Aguafria's [Xathrid Necromancer] creates a Zombie Token.
[09:20:52] Aguafria's [Xathrid Necromancer] creates a Zombie Token.
[09:20:55] Turn 7: BatMana
[09:20:58] BatMana plays [Mistvault Bridge].
[09:21:17] BatMana casts [Soulflayer].
[09:21:33] [CHAT] BatMana: at least i get one flayer 
[09:22:08] [CHAT] Aguafria: ugh i dont think i can kill you unless i draw malcontents because you gain 8
[09:22:16] Aguafria is being attacked by [Soulflayer]
[09:22:18] [CHAT] Aguafria: and then again on the block
[09:22:31] Turn 7: Aguafria
[09:22:37] [CHAT] BatMana: no edict creatures? 
[09:22:54] [CHAT] Aguafria: none to be honest i didn't think id run into anything i chose to play lyev skyknight
[09:23:02] [CHAT] Aguafria: and just kinda board stall into a win
[09:23:19] Aguafria activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[09:23:25] Aguafria puts [Benalish Marshal] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[09:23:38] [CHAT] BatMana: i feel like a plague crafter type card could do work sometimes
[09:23:38] Aguafria casts [Benalish Marshal].
[09:23:43] [CHAT] Aguafria: yeah
[09:23:46] [CHAT] Aguafria: with xathrid for sure
[09:24:10] [CHAT] Aguafria: im gonna add probably 2 and try it out 
[09:24:14] [CHAT] Aguafria: there are just so many damn humans
[09:24:20] [CHAT] Aguafria: its hard to know where to start and stop
[09:24:28] [CHAT] BatMana: its a killer tribe 
[09:24:57] [CHAT] Aguafria: id kill for cartel aristocat right now
[09:25:05] [CHAT] Aguafria: aristocrat
[09:25:34] [CHAT] BatMana: i think i died if you attacked 
[09:25:39] [CHAT] Aguafria: no
[09:25:43] [CHAT] Aguafria: you go to 24
[09:25:46] [CHAT] BatMana: i only gain 4 
[09:25:46] [CHAT] Aguafria: block kessig
[09:25:58] [CHAT] Aguafria: i had 23
[09:25:59] [CHAT] Aguafria: on board
[09:26:05] [CHAT] BatMana: double strike kills it before i can hit twice 
[09:26:16] Turn 8: BatMana
[09:26:19] [CHAT] Aguafria: oh yeah
[09:26:19] [CHAT] Aguafria: but
[09:26:20] [CHAT] Aguafria: still
[09:26:25] [CHAT] Aguafria: im at 23 power on board
[09:26:27] [CHAT] Aguafria: you go to 20
[09:26:30] [CHAT] Aguafria: block a 5
[09:26:33] [CHAT] Aguafria: go to 1
[09:26:40] [CHAT] Aguafria: untap hit me for 8
[09:26:56] [CHAT] BatMana: ok fair fair i was a little off on that math 
[09:26:59] BatMana casts [Eater of Virtue].
[09:27:07] BatMana activates an ability of [Eater of Virtue] targeting [Soulflayer] (Equip {1}).
[09:27:14] BatMana casts [Phylactery Lich].
[09:27:22] Aguafria is being attacked by [Soulflayer]
[09:27:26] [Kitesail Freebooter] blocks [Soulflayer].
[09:27:36] Turn 8: Aguafria
[09:27:45] Aguafria casts [Devout Chaplain].
[09:27:56] Aguafria casts [Kitesail Freebooter].
[09:27:57] Aguafria puts triggered ability from [Kitesail Freebooter] onto the stack targeting BatMana (When Kitesail Freebooter enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a ...).
[09:28:00] BatMana reveals their hand to [Kitesail Freebooter]'s ability, containing [Vampire Nighthawk] and [Gloomshrieker].
[09:28:09] Aguafria casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[09:28:19] Turn 9: BatMana
[09:28:24] BatMana plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[09:28:32] BatMana casts [Gloomshrieker].
[09:28:36] Aguafria has conceded from the game.
Winner: BatMana
Game 2 Completed.
[09:28:40] Aguafria has left the game.

== Game 3 (807812222) ==
[Time] 1658903364
[09:29:24] PDBot has started watching.
[09:29:29] Aguafria mulligans to six cards.
[09:29:31] BatMana mulligans to six cards.