PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality ERIC1988,ennosytallo == Game 1 (798758668) == [Time] 1652196266 [18:24:27] PDBot has started watching. [18:24:27] ennosytallo joined the game. [18:24:27] ERIC1988 joined the game. [League] A Sweet Deck by ennosytallo (178891) vs Merfolks Control by eric1988 (178923) [18:24:29] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [18:24:35] ERIC1988 chooses to play first. [18:24:38] ERIC1988 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [18:24:49] ennosytallo begins the game with seven cards in hand. [18:24:49] Turn 1: ERIC1988 [18:24:49] ERIC1988 skips their draw step. [18:24:51] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:24:53] ERIC1988 casts [Cursecatcher]. [18:25:05] Turn 1: ennosytallo [18:25:10] ennosytallo plays [Battlefield Forge]. [18:25:13] ennosytallo casts [Doomed Traveler]. [18:25:20] Turn 2: ERIC1988 [18:25:23] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:25:28] ERIC1988 casts [Tide Shaper] (with kicker). [18:25:38] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Tide Shaper] onto the stack targeting [Battlefield Forge] (When Tide Shaper enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target land becomes an Island for as lo...). [18:25:51] Turn 2: ennosytallo [18:26:00] ennosytallo plays [Mountain]. [18:26:07] ennosytallo casts [Mogg War Marshal]. [18:26:11] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:26:13] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:26:19] Turn 3: ERIC1988 [18:26:22] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:26:38] ERIC1988 casts [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [18:26:53] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Tide Shaper] and [Cursecatcher] [18:27:22] Turn 3: ennosytallo [18:27:22] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (Pay cost). [18:27:29] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:27:34] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:27:40] ennosytallo plays [Clifftop Retreat]. [18:27:57] ennosytallo casts [Kami of False Hope]. [18:28:26] ennosytallo casts [Mogg War Marshal]. [18:28:28] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:28:30] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:28:38] Turn 4: ERIC1988 [18:28:41] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:28:45] ERIC1988 casts [Renegade Doppelganger]. [18:29:22] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Tide Shaper] and [Cursecatcher] [18:29:26] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Kami of False Hope] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt this turn.). [18:29:32] 2 damage caused by [Cursecatcher] to ennosytallo is prevented. [18:29:33] 3 damage caused by [Tide Shaper] to ennosytallo is prevented. [18:29:37] Turn 4: ennosytallo [18:29:37] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (Pay cost). [18:29:44] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:29:48] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:30:06] ennosytallo casts [Doomed Traveler]. [18:30:29] ennosytallo exiles [Greater Gargadon] with 10 time counters. [18:30:29] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Greater Gargadon[sU] has a disadvantageous bug. Greater Gargadon and Nihilith don't get cast when last suspend time counter is removed by their abilities [18:30:51] Turn 5: ERIC1988 [18:30:54] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:31:00] ERIC1988 casts [Merrow Reejerey]. [18:31:01] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Renegade Doppelganger] onto the stack (Whenever another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may have Renegade Doppelg...). [18:31:52] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Merrow Reejerey], [Tide Shaper] and [Cursecatcher] [18:32:02] Turn 5: ennosytallo [18:32:02] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [18:32:14] ennosytallo has conceded from the game. Winner: ERIC1988 Game 1 Completed. [18:32:18] ennosytallo has left the game. == Game 2 (798759462) == [Time] 1652196867 [18:34:27] PDBot has started watching. [18:34:29] ennosytallo chooses to play first. [18:34:32] ennosytallo begins the game with seven cards in hand. [18:34:34] ERIC1988 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [18:34:34] Turn 1: ennosytallo [18:34:38] ennosytallo skips their draw step. [18:34:40] ennosytallo plays [Plains]. [18:34:42] ennosytallo casts [Hunted Witness]. [18:34:44] Turn 1: ERIC1988 [18:34:46] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:34:51] ERIC1988 casts [Benthic Biomancer]. [18:35:06] Turn 2: ennosytallo [18:35:12] ennosytallo plays [Mountain]. [18:35:21] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Hunted Witness] [18:35:37] ennosytallo casts [Mogg War Marshal]. [18:35:40] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:35:41] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:35:43] Turn 2: ERIC1988 [18:35:47] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:35:54] ERIC1988 casts [Tide Shaper] (with kicker). [18:36:03] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Tide Shaper] onto the stack targeting [Mountain] (When Tide Shaper enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target land becomes an Island for as lo...). [18:36:17] Turn 3: ennosytallo [18:36:18] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (Pay cost). [18:36:31] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:36:34] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:36:40] ennosytallo plays [Battlefield Forge]. [18:36:52] ennosytallo casts [Dark-Dweller Oracle]. [18:37:10] Turn 3: ERIC1988 [18:37:23] ERIC1988 reveals [Tidal Warrior] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:37:23] ERIC1988 casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Tidal Warrior]). [18:37:25] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [18:37:29] ERIC1988 draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:37:57] Turn 4: ennosytallo [18:38:07] ennosytallo casts [Claim the Firstborn] targeting [Tide Shaper]. [18:38:26] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Goblin Token], [Tide Shaper], [Goblin Token] and [Hunted Witness] [18:38:37] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Dark-Dweller Oracle] ( Exile the top card of your library. You may play that card this turn.). [18:38:51] ennosytallo casts [Unlucky Witness]. [18:38:57] Turn 4: ERIC1988 [18:39:06] ERIC1988 casts [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [18:39:21] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Silvergill Adept] and [Benthic Biomancer] [18:39:46] Turn 5: ennosytallo [18:39:54] ennosytallo casts [Abiding Grace]. [18:40:07] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Unlucky Witness], [Goblin Token], [Goblin Token] and [Hunted Witness] [18:40:16] [Master of the Pearl Trident] blocks [Goblin Token]. [18:40:31] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack (You gain 1 life.). [18:40:36] Turn 5: ERIC1988 [18:40:40] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:40:49] ERIC1988 casts [Merrow Reejerey]. [18:41:00] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Master of the Pearl Trident], [Silvergill Adept] and [Benthic Biomancer] [18:41:09] Turn 6: ennosytallo [18:41:24] ennosytallo casts [Kami of False Hope]. [18:41:31] ennosytallo casts [Mogg War Marshal]. [18:41:33] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:41:35] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:41:42] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Unlucky Witness], [Goblin Token] and [Hunted Witness] [18:41:50] [Merrow Reejerey] blocks [Goblin Token]. [18:42:10] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack (You gain 1 life.). [18:42:13] Turn 6: ERIC1988 [18:42:16] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:42:30] ERIC1988 casts [Tidal Warrior]. [18:42:54] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Merrow Reejerey] onto the stack targeting [Benthic Biomancer] (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, you may tap or untap target permanent.). [18:43:24] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Silvergill Adept] and [Benthic Biomancer] [18:43:28] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Kami of False Hope] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt this turn.). [18:43:51] 3 damage caused by [Benthic Biomancer] to ennosytallo is prevented. [18:43:51] 4 damage caused by [Silvergill Adept] to ennosytallo is prevented. [18:43:57] Turn 7: ennosytallo [18:43:57] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (Pay cost). [18:44:08] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Dark-Dweller Oracle] ( Exile the top card of your library. You may play that card this turn.). [18:44:08] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:44:12] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:44:31] ennosytallo casts [Doomed Traveler]. [18:44:52] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Unlucky Witness] [18:45:01] [Master of the Pearl Trident] blocks [Unlucky Witness]. [18:45:05] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Unlucky Witness] onto the stack (When Unlucky Witness dies, exile the top two cards of your library. Until your next end step, you ...). [18:45:13] ennosytallo plays [Plains]. [18:45:24] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Kami of False Hope] (Return target creature card with mana value 1 from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [18:45:33] ERIC1988 has conceded from the game. Winner: ennosytallo Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (798760434) == [Time] 1652197598 [18:46:38] PDBot has started watching. [18:46:39] ERIC1988 chooses to play first. [18:46:46] ERIC1988 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [18:46:53] ennosytallo begins the game with seven cards in hand. [18:46:53] Turn 1: ERIC1988 [18:46:53] ERIC1988 skips their draw step. [18:46:54] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:47:02] Turn 1: ennosytallo [18:47:12] ennosytallo plays [Mountain]. [18:47:14] ennosytallo casts [Unlucky Witness]. [18:47:20] Turn 2: ERIC1988 [18:47:24] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:47:29] ERIC1988 casts [Tide Shaper] (with kicker). [18:47:34] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Tide Shaper] onto the stack targeting [Mountain] (When Tide Shaper enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target land becomes an Island for as lo...). [18:47:44] Turn 2: ennosytallo [18:47:59] ennosytallo plays [Battlefield Forge]. [18:48:16] ennosytallo exiles [Greater Gargadon] with 10 time counters. [18:48:37] Turn 3: ERIC1988 [18:48:40] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:48:48] ERIC1988 reveals [Silvergill Adept] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:48:48] ERIC1988 casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Silvergill Adept]). [18:48:50] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [18:48:54] ERIC1988 draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:49:08] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Tide Shaper] [18:49:13] [Unlucky Witness] blocks [Tide Shaper]. [18:49:18] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [18:49:19] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Unlucky Witness] onto the stack (When Unlucky Witness dies, exile the top two cards of your library. Until your next end step, you ...). [18:49:42] Turn 3: ennosytallo [18:49:43] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [18:49:50] ennosytallo plays [Plains]. [18:50:32] ennosytallo casts [Abiding Grace]. [18:50:57] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Unlucky Witness] (Return target creature card with mana value 1 from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [18:50:59] Turn 4: ERIC1988 [18:51:03] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [18:51:11] ERIC1988 reveals [Cursecatcher] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:51:11] ERIC1988 casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Cursecatcher]). [18:51:13] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [18:51:16] ERIC1988 draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:51:25] ERIC1988 casts [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [18:51:37] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Silvergill Adept] and [Tide Shaper] [18:51:55] Turn 4: ennosytallo [18:51:55] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [18:52:05] ennosytallo plays [Plains]. [18:52:29] ennosytallo casts [Claim the Firstborn] targeting [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [18:52:48] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Master of the Pearl Trident] [18:53:04] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [18:54:03] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack (You gain 1 life.). [18:54:04] Turn 5: ERIC1988 [18:54:10] ERIC1988 casts [Merrow Reejerey]. [18:54:13] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Silvergill Adept], [Silvergill Adept] and [Tide Shaper] [18:54:13] [Unlucky Witness] blocks [Tide Shaper]. [18:54:47] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [18:54:48] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Unlucky Witness] onto the stack (When Unlucky Witness dies, exile the top two cards of your library. Until your next end step, you ...). [18:54:53] Turn 5: ennosytallo [18:54:53] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [18:54:54] ennosytallo casts [Kami of False Hope]. [18:55:13] ennosytallo casts [Claim the Firstborn] targeting [Tide Shaper]. [18:55:41] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Tide Shaper] [18:55:51] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [18:56:41] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Unlucky Witness] (Return target creature card with mana value 1 from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [18:56:42] Turn 6: ERIC1988 [18:56:44] ERIC1988 reveals [Cursecatcher] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:56:44] ERIC1988 casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Cursecatcher]). [18:56:45] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Merrow Reejerey] onto the stack targeting [Silvergill Adept] (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, you may tap or untap target permanent.). [18:56:46] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Kami of False Hope] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt this turn.). [18:56:46] ERIC1988 taps [Silvergill Adept]. [18:56:50] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [18:56:52] ERIC1988 draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [18:57:16] ERIC1988 casts [Cursecatcher]. [18:57:20] ERIC1988 puts triggered ability from [Merrow Reejerey] onto the stack targeting [Silvergill Adept] (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, you may tap or untap target permanent.). [18:57:26] ERIC1988 untaps [Silvergill Adept]. [18:57:35] Turn 6: ennosytallo [18:57:35] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [18:57:48] ennosytallo casts [Claim the Firstborn] targeting [Merrow Reejerey]. [18:58:16] ERIC1988 is being attacked by [Unlucky Witness] and [Merrow Reejerey] [18:58:33] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [18:58:39] ennosytallo casts [Kami of False Hope]. [18:58:48] ennosytallo casts [Mogg War Marshal]. [18:59:01] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [18:59:04] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [18:59:13] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Kami of False Hope] (Return target creature card with mana value 1 from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [18:59:17] Turn 7: ERIC1988 [19:00:00] ERIC1988 casts [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [19:00:21] ennosytallo is being attacked by [Silvergill Adept] and [Silvergill Adept] [19:00:24] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Kami of False Hope] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt this turn.). [19:00:33] 3 damage caused by [Silvergill Adept] to ennosytallo is prevented. [19:00:33] 3 damage caused by [Silvergill Adept] to ennosytallo is prevented. [19:00:38] Turn 7: ennosytallo [19:00:47] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [19:00:47] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (Pay cost). [19:00:52] ennosytallo activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [19:00:52] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [19:00:56] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [19:01:23] ennosytallo casts [Mogg War Marshal]. [19:01:33] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Mogg War Marshal] onto the stack (When Mogg War Marshal enters the battlefield or dies, create a 1/1 red Goblin creature token.). [19:01:38] ennosytallo's [Mogg War Marshal] creates a Goblin Token. [19:01:46] ennosytallo casts [Dark-Dweller Oracle]. [19:02:47] ennosytallo puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Kami of False Hope] (Return target creature card with mana value 1 from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [19:02:53] Turn 8: ERIC1988 [19:02:56] ERIC1988 plays [Island]. [19:03:07] ERIC1988 has conceded from the game. Winner: ennosytallo Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: ennosytallo: 2–1