PennyDreadful
PDS R2 shepherd
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
ShepherdJohn,_counterspell

== Game 1 (798561122) ==
[Time] 1652033744
[21:15:45] PDBot has started watching.
[21:15:45] _counterspell joined the game.
[21:15:45] ShepherdJohn joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 25.01
[Gatherling] Round=2
[21:15:52] [CHAT] ShepherdJohn: gl hf
[21:15:53] _counterspell chooses to play first.
[21:15:56] [CHAT] _counterspell: gl !
[21:15:58] _counterspell begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:16:09] ShepherdJohn mulligans to six cards.
[21:16:36] ShepherdJohn puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[21:16:36] Turn 1: _counterspell
[21:16:36] _counterspell skips their draw step.
[21:16:43] _counterspell plays [Temple of Malady].
[21:16:44] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Temple of Malady] onto the stack (When Temple of Malady enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[21:16:56] _counterspell puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[21:16:56] _counterspell scrys 1.
[21:17:03] Turn 1: ShepherdJohn
[21:17:07] ShepherdJohn plays [Forest].
[21:17:09] Turn 2: _counterspell
[21:17:11] _counterspell plays [Swamp].
[21:17:14] _counterspell casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting ShepherdJohn.
[21:17:16] ShepherdJohn discards [General Ferrous Rokiric].
[21:17:16] ShepherdJohn discards [Mountain].
[21:17:17] Turn 2: ShepherdJohn
[21:17:25] Turn 3: _counterspell
[21:17:30] _counterspell plays [Snow-Covered Forest].
[21:17:33] Turn 3: ShepherdJohn
[21:17:40] ShepherdJohn casts [Safewright Quest].
[21:17:47] ShepherdJohn reveals [Plains].
[21:17:50] ShepherdJohn plays [Plains].
[21:17:53] Turn 4: _counterspell
[21:17:57] _counterspell plays [Mouth of Ronom].
[21:18:03] _counterspell casts [Migration Path].
[21:18:12] Turn 4: ShepherdJohn
[21:18:17] ShepherdJohn casts [Hero of Precinct One].
[21:18:19] Turn 5: _counterspell
[21:18:23] _counterspell casts [Abundant Harvest].
[21:18:26] _counterspell chooses nonland for [Abundant Harvest].
[21:18:26] _counterspell reveals [Garruk Wildspeaker] with [Abundant Harvest].
[21:18:30] _counterspell plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[21:18:38] _counterspell activates an ability of [Mouth of Ronom] targeting [Hero of Precinct One] ( Mouth of Ronom deals 4 damage to target creature.).
[21:18:41] Turn 5: ShepherdJohn
[21:18:47] ShepherdJohn casts [Safehold Elite].
[21:18:49] Turn 6: _counterspell
[21:18:53] _counterspell casts [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[21:18:57] _counterspell plays [Ghost Quarter].
[21:19:09] _counterspell activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[21:19:12] _counterspell's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[21:19:14] Turn 6: ShepherdJohn
[21:19:20] ShepherdJohn casts [Safewright Quest].
[21:19:25] ShepherdJohn reveals [Forest].
[21:19:27] ShepherdJohn plays [Forest].
[21:19:34] ShepherdJohn casts [Safehold Elite].
[21:19:41] Turn 7: _counterspell
[21:19:47] _counterspell casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting ShepherdJohn.
[21:19:50] ShepherdJohn discards [General Ferrous Rokiric].
[21:19:50] ShepherdJohn discards [Good-Fortune Unicorn].
[21:19:55] _counterspell activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[21:20:00] _counterspell's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[21:20:01] _counterspell plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[21:20:04] Turn 7: ShepherdJohn
[21:20:19] Turn 8: _counterspell
[21:20:26] _counterspell discards [Migration Path].
[21:20:26] _counterspell cycles [Migration Path].
[21:20:30] _counterspell plays [Hissing Quagmire].
[21:20:33] _counterspell activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] targeting [Swamp], and [Hissing Quagmire] ( Untap two target lands.).
[21:20:37] Turn 8: ShepherdJohn
[21:20:53] ShepherdJohn returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with with [Firewild Borderpost]'s ability.
[21:20:53] ShepherdJohn casts [Firewild Borderpost] using an alternate cost.
[21:20:57] ShepherdJohn plays [Forest].
[21:21:06] Turn 9: _counterspell
[21:21:09] _counterspell plays [Hissing Quagmire].
[21:21:11] _counterspell activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[21:21:16] _counterspell's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[21:21:20] Turn 9: ShepherdJohn
[21:21:26] ShepherdJohn plays [Rootbound Crag].
[21:21:36] ShepherdJohn casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[21:21:49] ShepherdJohn casts [Grumgully, the Generous].
[21:22:03] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:22:03] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Safehold Elite] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[21:22:30] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Beast Token] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:22:30] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Safehold Elite] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[21:22:35] _counterspell casts [Force of Despair].
[21:23:13] Turn 10: _counterspell
[21:23:26] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Beast Token], [Beast Token] and [Beast Token]
[21:23:49] [Safehold Elite] blocks [Beast Token].
[21:23:57] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting _counterspell ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:24:06] _counterspell casts [Golgari Signet].
[21:24:13] Turn 10: ShepherdJohn
[21:24:19] ShepherdJohn casts [Hero of Precinct One].
[21:24:42] Turn 11: _counterspell
[21:24:48] _counterspell casts [Tireless Provisioner].
[21:24:58] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Beast Token], [Beast Token] and [Beast Token]
[21:25:02] [Safehold Elite] blocks [Beast Token].
[21:25:17] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting _counterspell ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:25:17] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Safehold Elite] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[21:25:32] Turn 11: ShepherdJohn
[21:25:50] ShepherdJohn casts [Murderous Redcap].
[21:25:50] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Hero of Precinct One] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a multicolored spell, create a 1/1 white Human creature token.).
[21:25:54] ShepherdJohn's [Hero of Precinct One] creates a Human Token.
[21:26:02] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting [Tireless Provisioner] (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[21:26:22] Turn 12: _counterspell
[21:26:36] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Beast Token], [Beast Token] and [Beast Token]
[21:26:42] [Murderous Redcap] blocks [Beast Token].
[21:27:01] [Human Token] blocks [Beast Token].
[21:27:08] [Safehold Elite] blocks [Beast Token].
[21:27:36] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Beast Token] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:27:46] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[21:27:55] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting [Beast Token] (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[21:28:03] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Beast Token] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:28:14] Turn 12: ShepherdJohn
[21:28:41] ShepherdJohn casts [Murderous Redcap].
[21:28:42] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Hero of Precinct One] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a multicolored spell, create a 1/1 white Human creature token.).
[21:28:47] ShepherdJohn's [Hero of Precinct One] creates a Human Token.
[21:28:52] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting [Beast Token] (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[21:28:57] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Beast Token] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:29:04] _counterspell is being attacked by [Hero of Precinct One]
[21:29:08] Turn 13: _counterspell
[21:29:14] _counterspell casts [Oracle of Mul Daya].
[21:29:21] _counterspell plays [Cryptic Caves].
[21:29:23] _counterspell plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[21:29:28] _counterspell activates an ability of [Cryptic Caves] ( Draw a card.).
[21:29:30] _counterspell draws a card with [Cryptic Caves]'s ability.
[21:29:43] _counterspell casts [Ritual of Soot].
[21:30:09] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Oracle of Mul Daya] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:30:14] gearhulkazul has started watching.
[21:30:18] Murpady has started watching.
[21:30:24] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Oracle of Mul Daya] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:30:25] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[21:30:29] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting _counterspell (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.).
[21:30:45] _counterspell casts [Sylvan Library].
[21:30:50] Turn 13: ShepherdJohn
[21:31:00] ShepherdJohn exiles [Greater Gargadon] with 10 time counters.
[21:31:01] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Greater Gargadon[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Greater Gargadon and Nihilith don't get cast when last suspend time counter is removed by their abilities
[21:31:07] ShepherdJohn casts [Wild Cantor].
[21:31:21] _counterspell is being attacked by [Murderous Redcap]
[21:31:23] Turn 14: _counterspell
[21:31:24] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Library] onto the stack (At the beginning of your draw step, you may draw two additional cards. If you do, choose two cards...).
[21:31:31] _counterspell draws two cards with [Sylvan Library]'s ability.
[21:31:36] _counterspell put a card on top of _counterspell's library.
[21:31:41] _counterspell kept a card.
[21:31:43] _counterspell casts [Abundant Harvest].
[21:31:49] _counterspell chooses nonland for [Abundant Harvest].
[21:31:49] _counterspell reveals 2 cards with [Abundant Harvest]: [Snow-Covered Forest] and [Abundant Harvest].
[21:31:51] _counterspell casts [Abundant Harvest].
[21:31:55] _counterspell chooses nonland for [Abundant Harvest].
[21:31:55] _counterspell reveals [Seasons Past] with [Abundant Harvest].
[21:31:55] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Seasons Past[sU] has an unclassified bug.
There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves.
[21:32:07] _counterspell casts [Seasons Past].
[21:32:44] _counterspell chooses [Mouth of Ronom], [Abundant Harvest], [Hymn to Tourach], [Force of Despair], and [Garruk Wildspeaker] for [Seasons Past].
[21:32:44] _counterspell puts [Seasons Past] on the bottom of the library.
[21:32:55] _counterspell plays [Mouth of Ronom].
[21:33:03] _counterspell casts [Garruk Wildspeaker].
[21:33:11] _counterspell activates an ability of [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token.).
[21:33:13] _counterspell's [Garruk Wildspeaker] creates a Beast Token.
[21:33:16] _counterspell casts [Abundant Harvest].
[21:33:19] _counterspell chooses nonland for [Abundant Harvest].
[21:33:19] _counterspell reveals [Force of Despair] with [Abundant Harvest].
[21:33:24] Turn 14: ShepherdJohn
[21:33:24] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[21:33:36] ShepherdJohn casts [Grumgully, the Generous].
[21:33:47] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting _counterspell ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:33:55] ShepherdJohn exiles [Hymn to Tourach] with with [Force of Despair]'s ability.
[21:33:55] _counterspell casts [Force of Despair] using an alternate cost.
[21:34:23] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:35:02] ShepherdJohn activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Garruk Wildspeaker] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.).
[21:35:12] Turn 15: _counterspell
[21:35:12] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Library] onto the stack (At the beginning of your draw step, you may draw two additional cards. If you do, choose two cards...).
[21:35:14] _counterspell draws two cards with [Sylvan Library]'s ability.
[21:35:22] _counterspell put a card on top of _counterspell's library.
[21:35:27] _counterspell put a card on top of _counterspell's library.
[21:35:34] _counterspell activates an ability of [Hissing Quagmire] ( Hissing Quagmire becomes a 2/2 black and green Elemental creature with deathtouch until end of tu...).
[21:35:39] _counterspell activates an ability of [Hissing Quagmire] ( Hissing Quagmire becomes a 2/2 black and green Elemental creature with deathtouch until end of tu...).
[21:35:44] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Beast Token], [Hissing Quagmire] and [Hissing Quagmire]
[21:35:59] _counterspell casts [Ramunap Excavator].
[21:36:03] _counterspell plays [Cryptic Caves].
[21:36:05] Turn 15: ShepherdJohn
[21:36:06] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[21:36:16] ShepherdJohn has conceded from the game.
Winner: _counterspell
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (798563418) ==
[Time] 1652035086
[21:38:06] PDBot has started watching.
[21:38:10] ShepherdJohn chooses to play first.
[21:38:14] ShepherdJohn begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:38:17] _counterspell begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[21:38:17] Turn 1: ShepherdJohn
[21:38:17] ShepherdJohn skips their draw step.
[21:38:25] ShepherdJohn plays [Forest].
[21:38:29] ShepherdJohn casts [Safewright Quest].
[21:38:33] ShepherdJohn reveals [Plains].
[21:38:35] Turn 1: _counterspell
[21:38:37] _counterspell plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[21:38:43] Turn 2: ShepherdJohn
[21:38:46] ShepherdJohn plays [Plains].
[21:38:48] ShepherdJohn casts [Hero of Precinct One].
[21:38:50] Turn 2: _counterspell
[21:38:55] _counterspell plays [Snow-Covered Forest].
[21:38:59] _counterspell casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Hero of Precinct One].
[21:39:04] _counterspell casts [Lantern of the Lost].
[21:39:10] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Lantern of the Lost] onto the stack targeting [Safewright Quest] (When Lantern of the Lost enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[21:39:17] Turn 3: ShepherdJohn
[21:39:24] ShepherdJohn plays [Plains].
[21:39:39] ShepherdJohn casts [Safehold Elite].
[21:39:44] ShepherdJohn returns [Plains] to its owner's hand with with [Wildfield Borderpost]'s ability.
[21:39:44] ShepherdJohn casts [Wildfield Borderpost] using an alternate cost.
[21:39:47] Turn 3: _counterspell
[21:39:52] _counterspell plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[21:39:57] _counterspell casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting ShepherdJohn.
[21:40:00] ShepherdJohn discards [Beckon Apparition].
[21:40:00] ShepherdJohn discards [Rootbound Crag].
[21:40:06] Turn 4: ShepherdJohn
[21:40:11] ShepherdJohn plays [Fire-Lit Thicket].
[21:40:12] bakert99 has started watching.
[21:40:19] [CHAT] bakert99: !record
[21:40:20] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  _counterspell 1-0 ShepherdJohn
[21:40:21] ShepherdJohn casts [Dauntless Escort].
[21:40:33] _counterspell is being attacked by [Safehold Elite]
[21:40:37] Turn 4: _counterspell
[21:40:41] _counterspell plays [Cryptic Caves].
[21:40:48] _counterspell casts [Gonti, Lord of Luxury].
[21:40:55] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Gonti, Lord of Luxury] onto the stack targeting ShepherdJohn (When Gonti, Lord of Luxury enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of target opponent's...).
[21:41:19] Turn 5: ShepherdJohn
[21:41:24] ShepherdJohn plays [Plains].
[21:41:29] _counterspell is being attacked by [Dauntless Escort]
[21:41:33] [Gonti, Lord of Luxury] blocks [Dauntless Escort].
[21:41:45] ShepherdJohn casts [Loxodon Smiter].
[21:41:47] Turn 5: _counterspell
[21:41:52] _counterspell plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[21:42:11] _counterspell casts [Loxodon Smiter].
[21:42:19] Turn 6: ShepherdJohn
[21:42:34] _counterspell is being attacked by [Loxodon Smiter]
[21:42:39] [Loxodon Smiter] blocks [Loxodon Smiter].
[21:42:51] _counterspell casts [Grapple with the Past].
[21:42:56] _counterspell mills [Woodland Cemetery], [Vampire Nighthawk] and [Deglamer].
[21:43:00] _counterspell returns [Gonti, Lord of Luxury] to its owner's hand with [Grapple with the Past].
[21:43:09] Turn 6: _counterspell
[21:43:20] _counterspell casts [Gonti, Lord of Luxury].
[21:43:22] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Gonti, Lord of Luxury] onto the stack targeting ShepherdJohn (When Gonti, Lord of Luxury enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of target opponent's...).
[21:43:32] _counterspell plays [Temple of Malady].
[21:43:32] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Temple of Malady] onto the stack (When Temple of Malady enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[21:43:37] _counterspell puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[21:43:37] _counterspell scrys 1.
[21:43:41] Turn 7: ShepherdJohn
[21:43:45] ShepherdJohn plays [Forest].
[21:43:51] Turn 7: _counterspell
[21:43:53] _counterspell plays [Hissing Quagmire].
[21:44:01] Turn 8: ShepherdJohn
[21:44:19] ShepherdJohn casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[21:44:24] ShepherdJohn plays [Plains].
[21:44:35] _counterspell activates an ability of [Cryptic Caves] ( Draw a card.).
[21:44:35] _counterspell draws a card with [Cryptic Caves]'s ability.
[21:44:40] _counterspell casts [Deglamer] targeting [Goblin Bombardment].
[21:44:44] Turn 8: _counterspell
[21:44:49] _counterspell casts [Abundant Harvest].
[21:44:51] _counterspell chooses nonland for [Abundant Harvest].
[21:44:51] _counterspell reveals [Vampire Nighthawk] with [Abundant Harvest].
[21:44:57] _counterspell casts [Vampire Nighthawk].
[21:45:00] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Gonti, Lord of Luxury]
[21:45:04] Turn 9: ShepherdJohn
[21:45:11] JayceArveduin has started watching.
[21:45:28] Cearbhail has started watching.
[21:45:35] ShepherdJohn casts [Sundering Growth] targeting [Lantern of the Lost].
[21:45:38] [CHAT] Cearbhail: !record
[21:45:39] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  _counterspell 1-0 ShepherdJohn
[21:45:39] ShepherdJohn exiles [Lantern of the Lost] with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[21:45:39] _counterspell activates an ability of [Lantern of the Lost] ( Exile all cards from all graveyards, then draw a card.).
[21:45:40] _counterspell draws a card with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[21:45:43] ShepherdJohn's [Sundering Growth] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[21:45:48] Turn 9: _counterspell
[21:45:55] _counterspell casts [Tireless Provisioner].
[21:45:56] _counterspell plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[21:45:57] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Tireless Provisioner] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, create a Food token or a Treasure token...).
[21:46:00] _counterspell chooses a Food token for [Tireless Provisioner].
[21:46:00] _counterspell's [Tireless Provisioner] creates a Food Token.
[21:46:04] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Vampire Nighthawk] and [Gonti, Lord of Luxury]
[21:46:15] Turn 10: ShepherdJohn
[21:46:28] Turn 10: _counterspell
[21:46:34] _counterspell casts [Ravenous Chupacabra].
[21:46:41] _counterspell puts triggered ability from [Ravenous Chupacabra] onto the stack targeting [Safehold Elite] (When Ravenous Chupacabra enters the battlefield, destroy target creature an opponent controls.).
[21:46:43] ShepherdJohn puts triggered ability from [Safehold Elite] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[21:46:49] _counterspell casts [Crypt Incursion] targeting ShepherdJohn.
[21:46:59] crazybaloth has started watching.
[21:47:07] ShepherdJohn is being attacked by [Tireless Provisioner], [Vampire Nighthawk] and [Gonti, Lord of Luxury]
[21:47:14] Turn 11: ShepherdJohn
[21:47:26] Rakura has started watching.
[21:48:03] ShepherdJohn casts [Grumgully, the Generous].
[21:48:05] fran1 has started watching.
[21:48:08] ShepherdJohn casts [Goblin Bombardment].
[21:48:11] Rakura has stopped watching.
[21:48:22] Turn 11: _counterspell
[21:48:29] _counterspell activates an ability of [Hissing Quagmire] ( Hissing Quagmire becomes a 2/2 black and green Elemental creature with deathtouch until end of tu...).
[21:48:34] ShepherdJohn has conceded from the game.
Winner: _counterspell
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: _counterspell: 2–0
[21:48:36] [CHAT] ShepherdJohn: ggs