PennyDreadful
PD VS HotcoolJoe
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
DownToValueTown,hotcooljoe

== Game 1 (797760396) ==
[Time] 1651352871
[00:07:52] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful 500 (Season 24)
[Gatherling] Round=5
[00:07:59] hotcooljoe chooses to play first.
[00:07:59] [CHAT] DownToValueTown: glh
[00:08:01] [CHAT] DownToValueTown: f
[00:08:04] hotcooljoe begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[00:08:06] DownToValueTown begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[00:08:06] Turn 1: hotcooljoe
[00:08:09] hotcooljoe skips their draw step.
[00:08:11] hotcooljoe plays [Mystic Monastery].
[00:08:14] Turn 1: DownToValueTown
[00:08:17] DownToValueTown plays [Scattered Groves].
[00:08:23] Turn 2: hotcooljoe
[00:08:30] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:08:34] hotcooljoe casts [Harmonic Prodigy].
[00:08:35] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Harmonic Prodigy[sU] has a disadvantageous bug.
Shaman of the Great Hunt only puts one counter on creatures with Harmonic Prodigy in play
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Harmonic Prodigy` or `!notbugged Harmonic Prodigy`
[00:08:37] Turn 2: DownToValueTown
[00:08:39] DownToValueTown plays [Isolated Chapel].
[00:08:42] DownToValueTown casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[00:08:44] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[00:09:06] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Step Through], [Sea Gate Oracle], [Watcher for Tomorrow], and [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:09:06] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Watcher for Tomorrow[sU] has a graphical bug.
Watcher for Tomorrow's reminder text in the game log says "This land" (Hideaway ability)
[00:09:12] Turn 3: hotcooljoe
[00:09:15] hotcooljoe plays [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:09:19] hotcooljoe chooses Wizard for [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:09:35] hotcooljoe casts [Sea Gate Oracle].
[00:09:35] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Sea Gate Oracle] onto the stack (When Sea Gate Oracle enters the battlefield, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one of...).
[00:09:35] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Sea Gate Oracle] onto the stack (When Sea Gate Oracle enters the battlefield, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one of...).
[00:09:46] Turn 3: DownToValueTown
[00:09:57] DownToValueTown casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[00:09:58] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[00:10:11] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Reflector Mage], [Island], [Step Through], and [Watcher for Tomorrow].
[00:10:14] DownToValueTown plays [Barren Moor].
[00:10:20] Turn 4: hotcooljoe
[00:10:27] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:10:35] hotcooljoe casts [Reflector Mage].
[00:10:38] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Reflector Mage] onto the stack targeting [Tidehollow Sculler] (When Reflector Mage enters the battlefield, return target creature an opponent controls to its own...).
[00:10:39] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Reflector Mage] onto the stack targeting [Tidehollow Sculler] (When Reflector Mage enters the battlefield, return target creature an opponent controls to its own...).
[00:10:40] hotcooljoe returns [Tidehollow Sculler] to its owner's hand with [Reflector Mage]'s ability.
[00:10:40] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[00:10:43] hotcooljoe returns [Tidehollow Sculler] to its owner's hand with [Reflector Mage]'s ability.
[00:10:43] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[00:10:49] DownToValueTown is being attacked by [Sea Gate Oracle] and [Harmonic Prodigy]
[00:10:54] Turn 4: DownToValueTown
[00:11:08] DownToValueTown plays [Forest].
[00:11:11] DownToValueTown casts [Astral Slide].
[00:11:22] Turn 5: hotcooljoe
[00:11:33] hotcooljoe plays [Riptide Laboratory].
[00:11:39] DownToValueTown is being attacked by [Reflector Mage], [Sea Gate Oracle] and [Harmonic Prodigy]
[00:11:54] hotcooljoe casts [Venser, Shaper Savant].
[00:11:58] DownToValueTown discards [Tranquil Thicket].
[00:11:58] DownToValueTown cycles [Tranquil Thicket].
[00:12:00] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Harmonic Prodigy] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...).
[00:12:22] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Venser, Shaper Savant] onto the stack targeting [Astral Slide] (When Venser, Shaper Savant enters the battlefield, return target spell or permanent to its owner's...).
[00:12:24] hotcooljoe returns [Astral Slide] to its owner's hand with [Venser, Shaper Savant]'s ability.
[00:12:26] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end ste...).
[00:12:30] Turn 5: DownToValueTown
[00:12:39] DownToValueTown casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[00:12:51] hotcooljoe casts [Essence Flux] targeting [Venser, Shaper Savant].
[00:12:51] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Harmonic Prodigy] onto the stack (Prowess (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, this creature gets +1/+1 until end of turn.)).
[00:13:05] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Venser, Shaper Savant] onto the stack targeting [Isolated Chapel] (When Venser, Shaper Savant enters the battlefield, return target spell or permanent to its owner's...).
[00:13:13] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Venser, Shaper Savant] onto the stack targeting [Scattered Groves] (When Venser, Shaper Savant enters the battlefield, return target spell or permanent to its owner's...).
[00:13:21] hotcooljoe returns [Scattered Groves] to its owner's hand with [Venser, Shaper Savant]'s ability.
[00:13:23] hotcooljoe returns [Isolated Chapel] to its owner's hand with [Venser, Shaper Savant]'s ability.
[00:13:25] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...).
[00:13:53] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Ponder] and [Watcher for Tomorrow].
[00:13:55] DownToValueTown plays [Isolated Chapel].
[00:14:00] DownToValueTown casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[00:14:02] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[00:14:07] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Watcher for Tomorrow].
[00:14:15] Turn 6: hotcooljoe
[00:14:32] hotcooljoe casts [Essence Flux] targeting [Venser, Shaper Savant].
[00:14:32] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Harmonic Prodigy] onto the stack (Prowess (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, this creature gets +1/+1 until end of turn.)).
[00:14:37] DownToValueTown has conceded from the game.
Winner: hotcooljoe
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (797761244) ==
[Time] 1651353371
[00:16:12] PDBot has started watching.
[00:16:12] DownToValueTown mulligans to six cards.
[00:16:15] hotcooljoe begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[00:16:20] DownToValueTown puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[00:16:20] Turn 1: DownToValueTown
[00:16:22] DownToValueTown skips their draw step.
[00:16:24] DownToValueTown plays [Scattered Groves].
[00:16:27] Turn 1: hotcooljoe
[00:16:31] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:16:33] hotcooljoe casts [Ponder].
[00:16:45] hotcooljoe chooses to not shuffle their library.
[00:16:45] hotcooljoe draws a card with [Ponder].
[00:16:47] Turn 2: DownToValueTown
[00:16:49] DownToValueTown plays [Swamp].
[00:16:51] DownToValueTown casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[00:16:52] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...).
[00:17:09] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Secluded Courtyard], [Secluded Courtyard], [Naban, Dean of Iteration], [Ponder], [Secluded Courtyard], and [Sulfur Falls].
[00:17:18] Turn 2: hotcooljoe
[00:17:29] hotcooljoe plays [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:17:34] hotcooljoe chooses Wizard for [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:17:45] hotcooljoe casts [Ponder].
[00:17:57] hotcooljoe chooses to not shuffle their library.
[00:17:57] hotcooljoe draws a card with [Ponder].
[00:18:00] Turn 3: DownToValueTown
[00:18:04] DownToValueTown plays [Plains].
[00:18:08] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Mesmeric Fiend]
[00:18:13] DownToValueTown casts [Astral Drift].
[00:18:24] Turn 3: hotcooljoe
[00:18:32] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:18:41] hotcooljoe casts [Watcher for Tomorrow].
[00:18:41] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Watcher for Tomorrow] onto the stack (Hideaway 4 (When this permanent enters the battlefield, look at the top 4 cards of your library....).
[00:18:48] Turn 4: DownToValueTown
[00:18:52] DownToValueTown plays [Swamp].
[00:18:56] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Mesmeric Fiend]
[00:19:01] DownToValueTown casts [Wasteland Strangler].
[00:19:06] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Wasteland Strangler] onto the stack targeting [Watcher for Tomorrow] (When Wasteland Strangler enters the battlefield, you may put a card an opponent owns from exile in...).
[00:19:12] DownToValueTown chooses an exiled face-down card with [Wasteland Strangler]'s ability.
[00:19:12] hotcooljoe puts triggered ability from [Watcher for Tomorrow] onto the stack (When Watcher for Tomorrow leaves the battlefield, put the exiled card into its owner's hand.).
[00:19:18] Turn 4: hotcooljoe
[00:19:47] hotcooljoe plays [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:19:50] hotcooljoe chooses Wizard for [Secluded Courtyard].
[00:19:58] Turn 5: DownToValueTown
[00:20:05] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Wasteland Strangler] and [Mesmeric Fiend]
[00:20:16] Turn 5: hotcooljoe
[00:20:20] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:20:26] Turn 6: DownToValueTown
[00:20:35] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Wasteland Strangler] and [Mesmeric Fiend]
[00:20:41] DownToValueTown casts [Valiant Rescuer].
[00:20:49] Turn 6: hotcooljoe
[00:21:04] hotcooljoe plays [Sulfur Falls].
[00:21:06] Turn 7: DownToValueTown
[00:21:10] DownToValueTown casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
[00:21:11] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...).
[00:21:21] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Harmonic Prodigy], [Harmonic Prodigy], [Secluded Courtyard], and [Naban, Dean of Iteration].
[00:21:25] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Valiant Rescuer], [Wasteland Strangler] and [Mesmeric Fiend]
[00:21:32] Turn 7: hotcooljoe
[00:21:51] one3 has started watching.
[00:21:55] one3 has stopped watching.
[00:22:01] hotcooljoe has conceded from the game.
Winner: DownToValueTown
Game 2 Completed.
[00:22:05] hotcooljoe has left the game.

== Game 3 (797761786) ==
[Time] 1651353753
[00:22:33] PDBot has started watching.
[00:22:35] hotcooljoe chooses to play first.
[00:22:42] hotcooljoe begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[00:22:45] DownToValueTown begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[00:22:45] Turn 1: hotcooljoe
[00:22:48] hotcooljoe skips their draw step.
[00:22:49] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:22:52] hotcooljoe casts [Ponder].
[00:23:10] hotcooljoe chooses to not shuffle their library.
[00:23:10] hotcooljoe draws a card with [Ponder].
[00:23:13] Turn 1: DownToValueTown
[00:23:18] DownToValueTown plays [Scattered Groves].
[00:23:23] Turn 2: hotcooljoe
[00:23:28] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:23:30] hotcooljoe casts [Naban, Dean of Iteration].
[00:23:33] Turn 2: DownToValueTown
[00:23:37] DownToValueTown plays [Swamp].
[00:23:39] DownToValueTown casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[00:23:40] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[00:23:49] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Step Through], [Prairie Stream], [Venser, Shaper Savant], and [Naban, Dean of Iteration].
[00:23:54] Turn 3: hotcooljoe
[00:23:58] hotcooljoe plays [Prairie Stream].
[00:24:04] DownToValueTown is being attacked by [Naban, Dean of Iteration]
[00:24:10] Turn 3: DownToValueTown
[00:24:18] DownToValueTown casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[00:24:31] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[00:24:41] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Naban, Dean of Iteration], [Venser, Shaper Savant], and [Naban, Dean of Iteration].
[00:24:48] DownToValueTown plays [Secluded Steppe].
[00:24:54] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler]
[00:24:59] Turn 4: hotcooljoe
[00:25:06] hotcooljoe plays [Mystic Monastery].
[00:25:10] Turn 4: DownToValueTown
[00:25:22] DownToValueTown plays [Swamp].
[00:25:24] DownToValueTown casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[00:25:25] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting hotcooljoe (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[00:25:29] hotcooljoe reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Naban, Dean of Iteration] and [Naban, Dean of Iteration].
[00:25:34] DownToValueTown casts [Flourishing Fox].
[00:25:44] Turn 5: hotcooljoe
[00:25:47] hotcooljoe plays [Island].
[00:25:56] DownToValueTown discards [Barren Moor].
[00:25:56] DownToValueTown cycles [Barren Moor].
[00:25:56] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Flourishing Fox] onto the stack (Whenever you cycle another card, put a +1/+1 counter on Flourishing Fox.).
[00:26:04] Turn 5: DownToValueTown
[00:26:12] DownToValueTown casts [Astral Drift].
[00:26:20] DownToValueTown discards [Flourishing Fox].
[00:26:20] DownToValueTown cycles [Flourishing Fox].
[00:26:22] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Astral Drift] onto the stack targeting [Naban, Dean of Iteration] (Whenever you cycle Astral Drift or cycle another card while Astral Drift is on the battlefield, yo...).
[00:26:22] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Flourishing Fox] onto the stack (Whenever you cycle another card, put a +1/+1 counter on Flourishing Fox.).
[00:26:34] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Flourishing Fox], [Tidehollow Sculler], [Tidehollow Sculler] and [Tidehollow Sculler]
[00:26:37] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Astral Drift] onto the stack (return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end ste...).
[00:26:41] Turn 6: hotcooljoe
[00:26:45] hotcooljoe plays [Riptide Laboratory].
[00:26:48] Turn 6: DownToValueTown
[00:26:55] DownToValueTown casts [Wasteland Strangler].
[00:26:59] DownToValueTown puts triggered ability from [Wasteland Strangler] onto the stack targeting [Naban, Dean of Iteration] (When Wasteland Strangler enters the battlefield, you may put a card an opponent owns from exile in...).
[00:27:03] DownToValueTown chooses [Step Through] with [Wasteland Strangler]'s ability.
[00:27:08] hotcooljoe is being attacked by [Flourishing Fox], [Tidehollow Sculler], [Tidehollow Sculler] and [Tidehollow Sculler]
Winner: DownToValueTown
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: DownToValueTown: 2–1
[00:27:21] hotcooljoe has left the game.