PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Carmandor,brianrstevens == Game 1 (790469530) == [Time] 1645446231 [14:23:52] PDBot has started watching. [14:23:52] brianrstevens joined the game. [14:23:52] Carmandor joined the game. [League] Restore Balance by brianrstevens (169958) vs Abzan Reaninightmare by carmandor (169578) [14:23:54] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [14:23:59] Carmandor chooses to play first. [14:24:01] [CHAT] brianrstevens: hi glhf [14:24:05] [CHAT] Carmandor: gl [14:24:06] Carmandor begins the game with seven cards in hand. [14:24:14] brianrstevens mulligans to six cards. [14:24:27] brianrstevens puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [14:24:27] Turn 1: Carmandor [14:24:29] Carmandor skips their draw step. [14:24:31] Carmandor plays [Woodland Chasm]. [14:24:41] Turn 1: brianrstevens [14:24:43] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:24:48] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Veinfire Borderpost]'s ability. [14:24:48] brianrstevens casts [Veinfire Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:24:53] Turn 2: Carmandor [14:24:56] Carmandor plays [Sunpetal Grove]. [14:24:59] Carmandor casts [Satyr Wayfinder]. [14:24:59] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...). [14:25:00] Carmandor reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Tendo Ice Bridge], [Yosei, the Morning Star], [Murmuring Bosk], and [Woodland Chasm]. [14:25:05] Carmandor puts [Murmuring Bosk] into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability. [14:25:05] Carmandor puts [Woodland Chasm], [Yosei, the Morning Star], and [Tendo Ice Bridge] into their graveyard. [14:25:10] Turn 2: brianrstevens [14:25:18] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:25:25] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Mistvein Borderpost]'s ability. [14:25:25] brianrstevens casts [Mistvein Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:25:31] brianrstevens exiles [Greater Gargadon] with 10 time counters. [14:25:32] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Greater Gargadon[sU] has a disadvantageous bug. Greater Gargadon and Nihilith don't get cast when last suspend time counter is removed by their abilities Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Greater Gargadon` or `!notbugged Greater Gargadon` [14:25:36] Turn 3: Carmandor [14:25:43] Carmandor casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star]. [14:26:04] [CHAT] brianrstevens: !stillbugged Greater Gargadon [14:26:09] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [14:26:12] Carmandor plays [Murmuring Bosk]. [14:26:16] [CHAT] PDBot: Thanks, I've updated my records! [14:26:22] brianrstevens is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder] [14:26:33] Turn 3: brianrstevens [14:26:33] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:26:54] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:27:08] Turn 4: Carmandor [14:27:14] brianrstevens is being attacked by [Yosei, the Morning Star] and [Satyr Wayfinder] [14:27:24] Carmandor plays [Snowfield Sinkhole]. [14:27:27] Turn 4: brianrstevens [14:27:27] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:27:44] brianrstevens plays [Forest]. [14:27:59] brianrstevens discards [Perplex]. [14:27:59] brianrstevens transmutes [Perplex]. [14:28:05] brianrstevens reveals [Shardless Agent]. [14:28:19] Turn 5: Carmandor [14:28:43] brianrstevens is being attacked by [Yosei, the Morning Star] and [Satyr Wayfinder] [14:29:17] Turn 5: brianrstevens [14:29:17] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:29:29] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:29:37] brianrstevens exiles [Greater Gargadon] with 10 time counters. [14:29:50] brianrstevens casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:29:51] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:29:54] brianrstevens reveals 16 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Mistvein Borderpost], [Island], [Shardless Agent], [Discovery/Dispersal], [Discovery/Dispersal], [Swamp], [Perplex], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Wildfield Borderpost], [Shardless Agent], [14:29:54] [Greater Gargadon], [Research/Development], [Failure/Comply], [Discovery/Dispersal], [Swamp], and [Restore Balance]. [14:30:02] brianrstevens casts [Restore Balance]. (X is 0). [14:30:06] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:30:11] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:30:16] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:30:54] Carmandor discards [Plains]. [14:30:54] Carmandor discards [Magister of Worth]. [14:30:54] Carmandor discards [Murmuring Bosk]. [14:30:58] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Yosei, the Morning Star] onto the stack targeting brianrstevens, and [Mistvein Borderpost] (When Yosei, the Morning Star dies, target player skips their next untap step. Tap up to five targe...). [14:30:58] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.). [14:31:13] Turn 6: Carmandor [14:31:17] Carmandor plays [Snowfield Sinkhole]. [14:31:26] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:31:36] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:31:41] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:31:44] Turn 6: brianrstevens [14:31:44] brianrstevens skips their untap step. [14:31:44] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:31:45] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:31:52] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without paying i...). [14:31:58] brianrstevens casts [Greater Gargadon]. [14:32:06] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:32:10] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Mistvein Borderpost]'s ability. [14:32:10] brianrstevens casts [Mistvein Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:32:18] Carmandor is being attacked by [Greater Gargadon] [14:32:27] Turn 7: Carmandor [14:32:39] Carmandor discards [Recurring Nightmare]. [14:32:39] Carmandor casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Greater Gargadon]. [14:32:45] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery]. [14:32:51] Turn 7: brianrstevens [14:32:51] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:32:58] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:33:04] Turn 8: Carmandor [14:33:06] Carmandor plays [Sunpetal Grove]. [14:33:12] Turn 8: brianrstevens [14:33:12] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:33:14] Valador_ has started watching. [14:33:20] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Veinfire Borderpost]'s ability. [14:33:21] brianrstevens casts [Veinfire Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:33:27] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:33:29] Turn 9: Carmandor [14:33:38] Turn 9: brianrstevens [14:33:38] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:33:49] brianrstevens exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability. [14:33:54] brianrstevens casts [The Antiquities War]. [14:33:56] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [The Antiquities War] onto the stack (Look at the top five cards of your library. You may reveal an artifact card from among them and pu...). [14:34:04] brianrstevens puts Firewild Borderpost in their hand. [14:34:11] Turn 10: Carmandor [14:34:36] Turn 10: brianrstevens [14:34:36] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:34:39] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [The Antiquities War] onto the stack (Look at the top five cards of your library. You may reveal an artifact card from among them and pu...). [14:34:46] brianrstevens puts Mistvein Borderpost in their hand. [14:34:48] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:34:52] brianrstevens returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with with [Firewild Borderpost]'s ability. [14:34:52] brianrstevens casts [Firewild Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:34:58] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Mistvein Borderpost]'s ability. [14:34:58] brianrstevens casts [Mistvein Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:35:06] Turn 11: Carmandor [14:35:08] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery]. [14:35:12] Carmandor has conceded from the game. Winner: brianrstevens Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (790470154) == [Time] 1645446965 [14:36:06] PDBot has started watching. [14:36:12] Valador_ has started watching. [14:36:15] Carmandor chooses to play first. [14:36:19] Carmandor mulligans to six cards. [14:36:51] brianrstevens mulligans to six cards. [14:36:56] Carmandor puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [14:37:02] brianrstevens mulligans to five cards. [14:37:23] brianrstevens puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [14:37:23] Turn 1: Carmandor [14:37:26] Carmandor skips their draw step. [14:37:29] Carmandor plays [Murmuring Bosk]. [14:37:36] Turn 1: brianrstevens [14:37:39] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:37:43] brianrstevens returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with with [Mistvein Borderpost]'s ability. [14:37:43] brianrstevens casts [Mistvein Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:37:49] Turn 2: Carmandor [14:37:53] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery]. [14:37:56] Carmandor casts [Commune with the Gods]. [14:38:00] Carmandor reveals 5 cards with [Commune with the Gods]: [Unburial Rites], [Murmuring Bosk], [Snowfield Sinkhole], [Commune with the Gods], and [Woodfall Primus]. [14:38:05] Carmandor puts no cards into their hand with with [Commune with the Gods]. [14:38:05] Carmandor puts [Unburial Rites], [Woodfall Primus], [Commune with the Gods], [Murmuring Bosk], and [Snowfield Sinkhole] into their graveyard. [14:38:18] Turn 2: brianrstevens [14:38:26] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:38:30] brianrstevens returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with with [Firewild Borderpost]'s ability. [14:38:30] brianrstevens casts [Firewild Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:38:41] Turn 3: Carmandor [14:38:47] Carmandor plays [Tendo Ice Bridge]. [14:38:51] Carmandor casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Woodfall Primus]. [14:38:56] brianrstevens has conceded from the game. Winner: Carmandor Game 2 Completed. [14:39:00] brianrstevens has left the game. == Game 3 (790470294) == [Time] 1645447155 [14:39:16] PDBot has started watching. [14:39:19] Carmandor joined the game. [14:39:24] brianrstevens chooses to play first. [14:39:35] Valador_ has stopped watching. [14:39:36] Valador_ has started watching. [14:39:37] brianrstevens begins the game with seven cards in hand. [14:39:39] Carmandor mulligans to six cards. [14:39:44] Carmandor mulligans to five cards. [14:39:51] Carmandor puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [14:39:51] Turn 1: brianrstevens [14:39:51] brianrstevens skips their draw step. [14:39:55] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:39:59] brianrstevens returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with with [Wildfield Borderpost]'s ability. [14:39:59] brianrstevens casts [Wildfield Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:40:06] Turn 1: Carmandor [14:40:08] Carmandor plays [Woodland Chasm]. [14:40:16] Turn 2: brianrstevens [14:40:19] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:40:25] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Mistvein Borderpost]'s ability. [14:40:25] brianrstevens casts [Mistvein Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:40:31] Turn 2: Carmandor [14:40:34] Carmandor plays [Tendo Ice Bridge]. [14:40:36] Carmandor casts [Undead Butler]. [14:40:41] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack (When Undead Butler enters the battlefield, mill three cards.). [14:40:43] Carmandor mills [Forest], [Plains] and [Satyr Wayfinder]. [14:40:51] Turn 3: brianrstevens [14:40:55] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:40:59] brianrstevens returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with with [Firewild Borderpost]'s ability. [14:40:59] brianrstevens casts [Firewild Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:41:21] Turn 3: Carmandor [14:41:30] brianrstevens is being attacked by [Undead Butler] [14:41:39] Carmandor casts [Commune with the Gods]. [14:41:42] Carmandor reveals 5 cards with [Commune with the Gods]: [Yosei, the Morning Star], [Recurring Nightmare], [Undead Butler], [Satyr Wayfinder], and [Animate Dead]. [14:41:46] Carmandor puts [Animate Dead] into their hand with with [Commune with the Gods]. [14:41:46] Carmandor puts [Undead Butler], [Satyr Wayfinder], [Recurring Nightmare], and [Yosei, the Morning Star] into their graveyard. [14:41:58] Turn 4: brianrstevens [14:42:22] brianrstevens casts [Demonic Dread] targeting [Undead Butler]. [14:42:23] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Demonic Dread] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:42:26] brianrstevens reveals 14 cards with [Demonic Dread]: [Veinfire Borderpost], [Firewild Borderpost], [Shardless Agent], [Greater Gargadon], [Ravenous Trap], [Island], [Mistvein Borderpost], [Forest], [Demonic Dread], [Discovery/Dispersal], [14:42:26] [Island], [Fieldmist Borderpost], [Island], and [Restore Balance]. [14:42:32] brianrstevens casts [Restore Balance]. (X is 0). [14:42:54] brianrstevens discards [Swamp]. [14:42:54] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack (When Undead Butler dies, you may exile it. When you do, return target creature card from your grav...). [14:43:03] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack targeting [Satyr Wayfinder] (When you exile it, return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand.). [14:43:08] Carmandor returns [Satyr Wayfinder] to its owner's hand with [Undead Butler]'s ability. [14:43:10] brianrstevens's [Demonic Dread] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [14:43:16] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:43:21] Turn 4: Carmandor [14:43:24] Carmandor plays [Snowfield Sinkhole]. [14:43:34] Turn 5: brianrstevens [14:43:41] brianrstevens exiles [Greater Gargadon] with 10 time counters. [14:43:49] brianrstevens returns [Island] to its owner's hand with with [Fieldmist Borderpost]'s ability. [14:43:49] brianrstevens casts [Fieldmist Borderpost] using an alternate cost. [14:43:53] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:43:57] Turn 5: Carmandor [14:44:01] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [14:44:05] Carmandor casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star]. [14:44:09] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [14:44:23] Turn 6: brianrstevens [14:44:23] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:44:43] brianrstevens casts [Dispersal]. [14:44:50] brianrstevens returns [Yosei, the Morning Star] to its owner's hand with [Dispersal]. [14:44:57] Carmandor chooses a card from their hand. [14:44:57] Carmandor discards [Yosei, the Morning Star]. [14:44:57] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.). [14:45:11] Turn 6: Carmandor [14:45:17] Carmandor casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star]. [14:45:19] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [14:45:32] Turn 7: brianrstevens [14:45:33] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:46:14] brianrstevens casts [The Antiquities War]. [14:46:16] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [The Antiquities War] onto the stack (Look at the top five cards of your library. You may reveal an artifact card from among them and pu...). [14:46:28] Turn 7: Carmandor [14:46:38] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery]. [14:46:42] Carmandor casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [14:46:53] brianrstevens is being attacked by [Yosei, the Morning Star] [14:47:03] Turn 8: brianrstevens [14:47:03] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:47:10] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [The Antiquities War] onto the stack (Look at the top five cards of your library. You may reveal an artifact card from among them and pu...). [14:47:23] brianrstevens plays [Swamp]. [14:47:43] brianrstevens exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability. [14:47:57] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:48:03] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:48:26] brianrstevens casts [Demonic Dread] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star]. [14:48:27] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Demonic Dread] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:48:30] brianrstevens reveals 12 cards with [Demonic Dread]: [Firewild Borderpost], [Veinfire Borderpost], [Veinfire Borderpost], [Forest], [Greater Gargadon], [The Antiquities War], [Veinfire Borderpost], [Firewild Borderpost], [Swamp], [Simian Spirit Guide], [14:48:30] [Shardless Agent], and [Restore Balance]. [14:48:37] brianrstevens casts [Restore Balance]. (X is 0). [14:48:55] Carmandor discards [Recurring Nightmare]. [14:48:55] Carmandor discards [Skylasher]. [14:48:55] Carmandor discards [Satyr Wayfinder]. [14:48:57] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.). [14:49:02] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Yosei, the Morning Star] onto the stack targeting brianrstevens, [Mistvein Borderpost], [Firewild Borderpost], [Fieldmist Borderpost], and [The Antiquities War] (When Yosei, the Morning Star dies, target player skips their next untap step. Tap up to five targe...). [14:49:11] brianrstevens's [Demonic Dread] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [14:49:21] Turn 8: Carmandor [14:49:28] [CHAT] brianrstevens: oh fudge lol [14:49:30] [CHAT] brianrstevens: got me [14:49:36] Turn 9: brianrstevens [14:49:36] brianrstevens skips their untap step. [14:49:36] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:49:46] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [The Antiquities War] onto the stack (Artifacts you control become artifact creatures with base power and toughness 5/5 until end of tur...). [14:49:57] Turn 9: Carmandor [14:49:59] Carmandor plays [Woodland Chasm]. [14:50:09] Turn 10: brianrstevens [14:50:09] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:50:38] Turn 10: Carmandor [14:50:46] Turn 11: brianrstevens [14:50:46] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:50:58] brianrstevens plays [Island]. [14:51:02] brianrstevens exiles [Simian Spirit Guide] with [Simian Spirit Guide]'s ability. [14:51:11] brianrstevens activates an ability of [Greater Gargadon] ( Remove a time counter from Greater Gargadon.). [14:51:15] brianrstevens casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:51:15] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:51:19] brianrstevens reveals 24 cards with [Shardless Agent]: [Swamp], [Mistvein Borderpost], [Discovery/Dispersal], [Mistvein Borderpost], [Simian Spirit Guide], [Greater Gargadon], [Discovery/Dispersal], [Discovery/Dispersal], [Island], [Mistvein Borderpost], [14:51:19] [Firewild Borderpost], [Fieldmist Borderpost], [Shardless Agent], [Island], [Demonic Dread], [Greater Gargadon], [Island], [Veinfire Borderpost], [Forest], [Ravenous Trap], [14:51:19] [Swamp], [Island], [Demonic Dread], and [Restore Balance]. [14:51:26] brianrstevens casts [Restore Balance]. (X is 0). [14:51:35] Carmandor discards [Satyr Wayfinder]. [14:51:35] Carmandor discards [Timeless Witness]. [14:51:43] brianrstevens casts [Ravenous Trap] using an alternate cost targeting Carmandor. [14:51:55] Turn 11: Carmandor [14:52:04] Turn 12: brianrstevens [14:52:04] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [14:52:07] brianrstevens puts triggered ability from [Greater Gargadon] onto the stack (Suspend (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without paying i...). [14:52:14] brianrstevens casts [Greater Gargadon]. [14:52:25] Carmandor is being attacked by [Greater Gargadon] and [Shardless Agent] [14:52:35] Turn 12: Carmandor [14:52:38] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery]. [14:52:40] Carmandor has conceded from the game. Winner: brianrstevens Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: brianrstevens: 2–1