PennyDreadful
PD practice
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Aeskulap,Shminky

== Game 1 (788916812) ==
[Time] 1644169877
[19:51:18] PDBot has started watching.
[19:51:18] Aeskulap joined the game.
[19:51:18] Shminky joined the game.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
[19:51:32] Shminky chooses to play first.
[19:51:36] Shminky begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[19:51:39] Aeskulap mulligans to six cards.
[19:51:47] Aeskulap puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[19:51:47] Turn 1: Shminky
[19:51:47] Shminky skips their draw step.
[19:51:49] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[19:51:51] Turn 1: Aeskulap
[19:51:53] Aeskulap plays [Grasslands].
[19:52:02] Turn 2: Shminky
[19:52:04] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[19:52:08] Shminky casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Aeskulap.
[19:52:10] Aeskulap discards [Swamp].
[19:52:10] Aeskulap discards [Rotting Rats].
[19:52:10] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Rotting Rats[sU] has an advantageous bug.
You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card
[19:52:14] Turn 2: Aeskulap
[19:52:17] Aeskulap activates an ability of [Grasslands] ( Search your library for a Forest or Plains card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle.).
[19:52:25] Aeskulap casts [Birds of Paradise].
[19:52:27] Turn 3: Shminky
[19:52:36] Shminky casts [Duress] targeting Aeskulap.
[19:53:14] Aeskulap discards [Recurring Nightmare].
[19:53:14] Aeskulap reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Shriekmaw], [Drown in Filth], and [Commune with the Gods].
[19:53:20] Shminky casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Birds of Paradise].
[19:53:21] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[19:53:23] Turn 3: Aeskulap
[19:53:25] Aeskulap plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[19:53:27] Aeskulap casts [Commune with the Gods].
[19:53:29] Aeskulap reveals 5 cards with [Commune with the Gods]: [Commune with the Gods], [Recurring Nightmare], [Rotting Rats], [Forest], and [Woodland Cemetery].
[19:53:34] Aeskulap puts [Recurring Nightmare] into their hand with with [Commune with the Gods].
[19:53:34] Aeskulap puts [Forest], [Woodland Cemetery], [Commune with the Gods], and [Rotting Rats] into their graveyard.
[19:53:45] Turn 4: Shminky
[19:53:47] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[19:53:50] Shminky casts [Nezumi Shortfang].
[19:53:55] Turn 4: Aeskulap
[19:54:01] Aeskulap casts [Drown in Filth] targeting [Nezumi Shortfang].
[19:54:09] Aeskulap mills [Llanowar Wastes], [Commune with the Gods], [Drown in Filth] and [Grisly Salvage].
[19:54:19] Turn 5: Shminky
[19:54:31] Shminky casts [Nether Spirit].
[19:54:35] Shminky casts [Shrieking Affliction].
[19:54:45] Turn 5: Aeskulap
[19:54:49] Aeskulap casts [Commune with the Gods].
[19:54:51] Aeskulap reveals 5 cards with [Commune with the Gods]: [Yosei, the Morning Star], [Woodland Cemetery], [Birds of Paradise], [Satyr Wayfinder], and [Llanowar Wastes].
[19:54:55] Aeskulap puts [Satyr Wayfinder] into their hand with with [Commune with the Gods].
[19:54:55] Aeskulap puts [Llanowar Wastes], [Woodland Cemetery], [Birds of Paradise], and [Yosei, the Morning Star] into their graveyard.
[19:55:13] Turn 6: Shminky
[19:55:21] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit].
[19:55:21] Turn 6: Aeskulap
[19:55:25] Aeskulap casts [Satyr Wayfinder].
[19:55:29] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...).
[19:55:32] Aeskulap reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Recurring Nightmare], [Grisly Salvage], [Golgari Rot Farm], and [Birds of Paradise].
[19:55:34] Aeskulap puts [Golgari Rot Farm] into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability.
[19:55:34] Aeskulap puts [Recurring Nightmare], [Birds of Paradise], and [Grisly Salvage] into their graveyard.
[19:55:35] Aeskulap plays [Golgari Rot Farm].
[19:55:35] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Golgari Rot Farm] onto the stack (When Golgari Rot Farm enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[19:55:42] Aeskulap returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with [Golgari Rot Farm]'s ability.
[19:55:50] Turn 7: Shminky
[19:56:00] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit].
[19:56:10] Shminky casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Satyr Wayfinder].
[19:56:15] Shminky casts [Dread Fugue] for its cleave cost using an alternate cost targeting Aeskulap.
[19:56:30] Aeskulap discards [Recurring Nightmare].
[19:56:30] Aeskulap reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Forest], [Timeless Witness], [Recurring Nightmare], and [Shriekmaw].
[19:56:32] Turn 7: Aeskulap
[19:56:36] Aeskulap plays [Forest].
[19:56:39] Aeskulap casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[19:56:42] Turn 8: Shminky
[19:56:51] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit].
[19:56:58] Shminky casts [Wrench Mind] targeting Aeskulap.
[19:57:02] Aeskulap discards [Lotleth Giant].
[19:57:02] Aeskulap discards [Shriekmaw].
[19:57:03] Turn 8: Aeskulap
[19:57:03] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[19:57:15] Aeskulap casts [Timeless Witness].
[19:57:27] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Timeless Witness] onto the stack targeting [Woodland Cemetery] (When Timeless Witness enters the battlefield, return target card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[19:57:32] Aeskulap returns [Woodland Cemetery] to its owner's hand with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[19:57:33] Aeskulap plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[19:57:44] Aeskulap activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[19:57:56] Aeskulap casts [Birds of Paradise].
[19:58:30] Shminky casts [Heartless Act] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (Destroy target creature with no counters on it.).
[19:58:36] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Yosei, the Morning Star] onto the stack targeting Shminky, [Shrieking Affliction], [Nether Spirit], [Swamp], [Swamp], and [Swamp] (When Yosei, the Morning Star dies, target player skips their next untap step. Tap up to five targe...).
[19:58:39] Turn 9: Shminky
[19:58:39] Shminky skips their untap step.
[19:58:45] Turn 9: Aeskulap
[19:58:45] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[19:58:56] Aeskulap casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[19:59:00] Aeskulap activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[19:59:05] Aeskulap casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[19:59:13] Aeskulap activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Lotleth Giant] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[19:59:16] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Yosei, the Morning Star] onto the stack targeting Shminky (When Yosei, the Morning Star dies, target player skips their next untap step. Tap up to five targe...).
[19:59:20] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting Shminky (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...).
[19:59:30] Turn 10: Shminky
[19:59:30] Shminky skips their untap step.
[19:59:33] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[19:59:45] Shminky casts [Murderous Cut] targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[19:59:56] Turn 10: Aeskulap
[20:00:06] Aeskulap activates an ability of [Rotting Rats] (Unearth for {1B}).
[20:00:09] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Rotting Rats] onto the stack (When Rotting Rats enters the battlefield, each player discards a card.).
[20:00:19] Aeskulap chooses a card from their hand.
[20:00:19] Aeskulap discards [Woodland Chasm].
[20:00:23] Aeskulap casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[20:00:26] Shminky has conceded from the game.
Winner: Aeskulap
Game 1 Completed.
[20:00:30] Aeskulap draws their next card.
[20:00:31] Shminky has left the game.

== Game 2 (788917936) ==
[Time] 1644170527
[20:02:07] PDBot has started watching.
[20:02:11] Shminky chooses to play first.
[20:02:14] Shminky begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:02:26] Aeskulap begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:02:26] Turn 1: Shminky
[20:02:26] Shminky skips their draw step.
[20:02:27] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:02:31] Shminky casts [Dread Fugue] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:02:35] Aeskulap discards [Commune with the Gods].
[20:02:35] Aeskulap reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Llanowar Wastes], [Woodland Cemetery], [Grasslands], [Woodland Chasm], [Dread Return], and [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[20:02:49] Turn 1: Aeskulap
[20:02:51] Aeskulap plays [Woodland Chasm].
[20:02:55] Turn 2: Shminky
[20:02:58] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:03:01] Shminky casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:03:03] Aeskulap discards [Grasslands].
[20:03:03] Aeskulap discards [Llanowar Wastes].
[20:03:07] Turn 2: Aeskulap
[20:03:09] Aeskulap plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[20:03:14] Turn 3: Shminky
[20:03:29] Shminky casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:03:31] Aeskulap discards [Forest].
[20:03:31] Aeskulap discards [Animate Dead].
[20:03:37] Turn 3: Aeskulap
[20:03:39] Aeskulap plays [Woodland Chasm].
[20:03:48] Turn 4: Shminky
[20:03:52] Shminky casts [Sign in Blood] targeting Shminky.
[20:03:54] Shminky draws two cards with [Sign in Blood].
[20:03:55] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:03:57] Shminky casts [Shrieking Affliction].
[20:04:02] Turn 4: Aeskulap
[20:04:09] Turn 5: Shminky
[20:04:12] Shminky casts [Nether Spirit].
[20:04:15] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:04:17] Turn 5: Aeskulap
[20:04:21] Aeskulap casts [Commune with the Gods].
[20:04:24] Aeskulap reveals 5 cards with [Commune with the Gods]: [Woodland Cemetery], [Forest], [Birds of Paradise], [Birds of Paradise], and [Llanowar Wastes].
[20:04:28] Aeskulap puts [Birds of Paradise] into their hand with with [Commune with the Gods].
[20:04:28] Aeskulap puts [Llanowar Wastes], [Forest], [Woodland Cemetery], and [Birds of Paradise] into their graveyard.
[20:04:30] Aeskulap casts [Birds of Paradise].
[20:04:37] Turn 6: Shminky
[20:04:48] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit].
[20:04:57] Shminky casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Birds of Paradise].
[20:05:00] Shminky casts [Nether Spirit].
[20:05:02] Turn 6: Aeskulap
[20:05:04] Aeskulap plays [Swamp].
[20:05:12] Turn 7: Shminky
[20:05:17] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit] and [Nether Spirit].
[20:05:22] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:05:23] Turn 7: Aeskulap
[20:05:26] Aeskulap casts [Birds of Paradise].
[20:05:31] Turn 8: Shminky
[20:05:41] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit] and [Nether Spirit].
[20:05:52] Shminky casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Birds of Paradise].
[20:05:54] Turn 8: Aeskulap
[20:06:12] Turn 9: Shminky
[20:06:16] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit] and [Nether Spirit].
[20:06:21] Turn 9: Aeskulap
[20:06:39] Aeskulap casts [Dread Return] targeting [Birds of Paradise].
[20:06:48] Turn 10: Shminky
[20:06:56] Aeskulap is being attacked by [Nether Spirit] and [Nether Spirit].
[20:07:02] Turn 10: Aeskulap
[20:07:07] Aeskulap has conceded from the game.
Winner: Shminky
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (788918446) ==
[Time] 1644170857
[20:07:37] PDBot has started watching.
[20:07:42] Aeskulap chooses to play first.
[20:07:49] Aeskulap mulligans to six cards.
[20:07:51] Shminky begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[20:07:56] Aeskulap puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[20:07:56] Turn 1: Aeskulap
[20:07:56] Aeskulap skips their draw step.
[20:07:57] Aeskulap plays [Forest].
[20:08:02] Turn 1: Shminky
[20:08:04] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:08:08] Shminky casts [Dread Fugue] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:08:20] Aeskulap discards [Commune with the Gods].
[20:08:20] Aeskulap reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Woodland Cemetery], [Swamp], [Forest], and [Animate Dead].
[20:08:23] Turn 2: Aeskulap
[20:08:24] Aeskulap plays [Swamp].
[20:08:29] Turn 2: Shminky
[20:08:31] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:08:39] Shminky casts [Duress] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:08:44] Aeskulap discards [Animate Dead].
[20:08:44] Aeskulap reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Dread Return], [Woodland Cemetery], and [Forest].
[20:08:48] Turn 3: Aeskulap
[20:08:49] Aeskulap plays [Forest].
[20:08:54] Turn 3: Shminky
[20:08:55] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:08:58] Shminky casts [Lost Legacy] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:09:05] Shminky names Recurring Nightmare for [Lost Legacy].
[20:09:36] Shminky exiled 4 copies of Recurring Nightmare (0 from graveyard, 0 from hand, 4 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[20:09:39] Turn 4: Aeskulap
[20:09:48] Aeskulap plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[20:09:55] Turn 4: Shminky
[20:09:57] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:10:02] Shminky casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:10:03] Aeskulap discards [Pack Rat].
[20:10:03] Aeskulap discards [Forest].
[20:10:12] Shminky casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[20:10:15] Turn 5: Aeskulap
[20:10:22] Aeskulap casts [Dread Return] targeting [Pack Rat].
[20:10:28] Shminky activates an ability of [Nihil Spellbomb] targeting Aeskulap ( Exile target player's graveyard.).
[20:10:28] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Nihil Spellbomb] onto the stack (When Nihil Spellbomb is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, dra...).
[20:10:35] Shminky draws a card with [Nihil Spellbomb]'s ability.
[20:10:38] Aeskulap's [Dread Return] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[20:10:45] Turn 5: Shminky
[20:10:48] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:10:50] Shminky casts [Shrieking Affliction].
[20:11:02] Turn 6: Aeskulap
[20:11:02] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[20:11:14] Turn 6: Shminky
[20:11:36] Turn 7: Aeskulap
[20:11:47] Turn 7: Shminky
[20:11:49] Shminky plays [Swamp].
[20:11:54] Turn 8: Aeskulap
[20:11:59] Aeskulap casts [Timeless Witness].
[20:12:02] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Timeless Witness] onto the stack targeting [Dread Return] (When Timeless Witness enters the battlefield, return target card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[20:12:16] Aeskulap returns [Dread Return] to its owner's hand with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[20:12:23] Shminky casts [Heartless Act] targeting [Timeless Witness] (Destroy target creature with no counters on it.).
[20:12:25] Turn 8: Shminky
[20:12:29] Shminky casts [Shrieking Affliction].
[20:12:35] Shminky casts [Lost Legacy] targeting Aeskulap.
[20:12:42] Shminky names Dread Return for [Lost Legacy].
[20:13:02] Shminky exiled 2 copies of Dread Return (0 from graveyard, 1 from hand, 1 from library) using [Lost Legacy]'s ability.
[20:13:02] Aeskulap draws a card with [Lost Legacy].
[20:13:07] Turn 9: Aeskulap
[20:13:20] Aeskulap casts [Rotting Rats].
[20:13:22] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Rotting Rats] onto the stack (When Rotting Rats enters the battlefield, each player discards a card.).
[20:13:28] Aeskulap chooses a card from their hand.
[20:13:28] Shminky chooses a card from their hand.
[20:13:28] Shminky discards [Swamp].
[20:13:28] Aeskulap discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[20:13:31] Aeskulap plays [Golgari Rot Farm].
[20:13:31] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Golgari Rot Farm] onto the stack (When Golgari Rot Farm enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[20:13:36] Aeskulap returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with [Golgari Rot Farm]'s ability.
[20:13:38] Aeskulap casts [Birds of Paradise].
[20:13:40] Turn 9: Shminky
[20:13:44] Shminky casts [Smallpox].
[20:13:44] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Smallpox[sU] has an advantageous bug.
You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card
[20:13:53] Aeskulap chooses a card from their hand.
[20:13:53] Aeskulap discards [Forest].
[20:14:09] Shminky sacrifices [Swamp].
[20:14:11] Aeskulap sacrifices [Forest].
[20:14:17] Turn 10: Aeskulap
[20:14:17] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[20:14:17] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[20:14:32] Aeskulap casts [Birds of Paradise].
[20:14:38] Turn 10: Shminky
[20:14:43] Turn 11: Aeskulap
[20:14:43] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[20:14:43] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[20:15:00] Aeskulap plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[20:15:08] Aeskulap exiles [Timeless Witness] with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[20:15:08] Aeskulap activates an ability of [Timeless Witness] (Eternalize {5GG}).
[20:15:10] Aeskulap's [Timeless Witness] creates a Timeless Witness.
[20:15:17] Aeskulap puts triggered ability from [Timeless Witness] onto the stack targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (When Timeless Witness enters the battlefield, return target card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[20:15:19] Aeskulap returns [Yosei, the Morning Star] to its owner's hand with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[20:15:20] Turn 11: Shminky
[20:15:28] Shminky casts [Dread Fugue] for its cleave cost using an alternate cost targeting Aeskulap.
[20:15:45] Aeskulap discards [Hornet Queen].
[20:15:45] Aeskulap reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[20:15:50] Turn 12: Aeskulap
[20:15:50] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
[20:15:50] Shminky puts triggered ability from [Shrieking Affliction] onto the stack (At the beginning of each opponent's upkeep, if that player has one or fewer cards in hand, they lo...).
Winner: Shminky
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Shminky: 2–1
[20:15:53] Aeskulap draws their next card.
[20:15:55] Shminky has left the game.