PennyDreadful pd practice BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality nightarya,The_Selesnyian == Game 1 (787103570) == [Time] 1642562430 [05:20:31] PDBot has started watching. [League] Host doesn't have active run [05:20:39] nightarya chooses to play first. [05:20:41] nightarya begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:20:47] The_Selesnyian begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:20:47] Turn 1: nightarya [05:20:47] nightarya skips their draw step. [05:21:01] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:21:03] Turn 1: The_Selesnyian [05:21:07] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:21:09] The_Selesnyian casts [Soul Warden]. [05:21:18] nightarya casts [Lava Dart] targeting [Soul Warden]. [05:21:20] Turn 2: nightarya [05:21:24] nightarya plays [Barbarian Ring]. [05:21:26] nightarya casts [Shrine of Burning Rage]. [05:21:34] Turn 2: The_Selesnyian [05:21:42] The_Selesnyian casts [Hunted Witness]. [05:21:45] The_Selesnyian plays [Alpine Meadow]. [05:21:49] Turn 3: nightarya [05:21:49] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:21:56] nightarya casts [Shrine of Burning Rage]. [05:22:02] Turn 3: The_Selesnyian [05:22:14] nightarya is being attacked by [Hunted Witness]. [05:22:41] The_Selesnyian casts [Kami of False Hope]. [05:22:47] The_Selesnyian plays [Battlefield Forge]. [05:23:03] The_Selesnyian casts [Goblin Bombardment]. [05:23:11] Turn 4: nightarya [05:23:12] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:23:12] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:23:20] nightarya casts [Abbot of Keral Keep]. [05:23:20] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:23:20] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:23:25] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Abbot of Keral Keep] onto the stack (When Abbot of Keral Keep enters the battlefield, exile the top card of your library. Until end of ...). [05:23:41] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Abbot of Keral Keep] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.). [05:23:42] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Hunted Witness] onto the stack (When Hunted Witness dies, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token with lifelink.). [05:23:45] The_Selesnyian's [Hunted Witness] creates a Soldier Token. [05:23:49] Turn 4: The_Selesnyian [05:23:58] nightarya is being attacked by [Soldier Token] and [Kami of False Hope]. [05:24:16] The_Selesnyian casts [Mogg Fanatic]. [05:24:19] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:24:24] The_Selesnyian casts [Abiding Grace]. [05:24:33] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Hunted Witness] (Return target creature card with mana value one from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [05:24:43] Turn 5: nightarya [05:24:43] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:24:43] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:24:48] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:25:07] nightarya casts [Lava Dart] targeting [Kami of False Hope]. [05:25:07] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:25:07] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:25:22] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting nightarya ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.). [05:25:30] nightarya casts [Play with Fire] targeting The_Selesnyian. [05:25:30] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:25:30] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:25:30] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Play with Fire[sU] has an advantageous bug. Play with Fire lets you scry when damage is prevented [05:25:38] nightarya casts [Play with Fire] targeting The_Selesnyian. [05:25:38] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:25:38] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:25:53] nightarya puts 1 card on top of their library. [05:25:53] nightarya scrys 1. [05:26:02] nightarya puts 1 card on top of their library. [05:26:02] nightarya scrys 1. [05:26:07] nightarya's [Lava Dart] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [05:26:14] Turn 5: The_Selesnyian [05:26:22] nightarya is being attacked by [Hunted Witness], [Mogg Fanatic], and [Soldier Token]. [05:26:39] The_Selesnyian casts [Weaponize the Monsters]. [05:26:46] The_Selesnyian plays [Clifftop Retreat]. [05:26:56] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Weaponize the Monsters] targeting nightarya ( Weaponize the Monsters deals 2 damage to any target.). [05:26:56] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Hunted Witness] onto the stack (When Hunted Witness dies, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token with lifelink.). [05:27:01] The_Selesnyian's [Hunted Witness] creates a Soldier Token. [05:27:15] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Abiding Grace] onto the stack targeting [Hunted Witness] (Return target creature card with mana value one from your graveyard to the battlefield.). [05:27:20] Turn 6: nightarya [05:27:20] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:27:20] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Shrine of Burning Rage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep or whenever you cast a red spell, put a charge counter on Shrine o...). [05:27:35] nightarya has conceded from the game. Winner: The_Selesnyian Game 1 Completed. [05:27:39] nightarya has left the game. == Game 2 (787104400) == [Time] 1642562953 [05:29:13] PDBot has started watching. [05:29:16] nightarya chooses to play first. [05:29:19] nightarya begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:29:22] The_Selesnyian begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:29:22] Turn 1: nightarya [05:29:22] nightarya skips their draw step. [05:29:23] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:29:27] nightarya casts [Monastery Swiftspear]. [05:29:32] [CHAT] The_Selesnyian: modern is sweet [05:29:35] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Monastery Swiftspear]. [05:29:40] Turn 1: The_Selesnyian [05:29:42] [CHAT] nightarya: jund is bae [05:29:47] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:29:50] The_Selesnyian casts [Deafening Silence]. [05:29:57] Turn 2: nightarya [05:30:01] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:30:05] nightarya casts [Flame Rift]. [05:30:06] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Monastery Swiftspear] onto the stack (Prowess (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, this creature gets +1/+1 until end of turn.)). [05:30:17] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Monastery Swiftspear]. [05:30:28] Turn 2: The_Selesnyian [05:30:38] The_Selesnyian casts [Thraben Inspector]. [05:30:48] [CHAT] nightarya: esp with f8s [05:30:50] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Thraben Inspector] onto the stack (When Thraben Inspector enters the battlefield, investigate.). [05:30:53] The_Selesnyian investigates. [05:30:53] The_Selesnyian's [Thraben Inspector] creates a Clue Token. [05:30:58] The_Selesnyian plays [Mountain]. [05:31:00] The_Selesnyian casts [Grim Initiate]. [05:31:05] Turn 3: nightarya [05:31:08] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:31:26] nightarya casts [Spikefield Hazard] targeting [Grim Initiate]. [05:31:26] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Monastery Swiftspear] onto the stack (Prowess (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, this creature gets +1/+1 until end of turn.)). [05:31:36] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Monastery Swiftspear]. [05:31:40] Turn 3: The_Selesnyian [05:31:54] The_Selesnyian casts [Goblin Bombardment]. [05:32:00] [CHAT] nightarya: this is the first magic I've played in like over a year [05:32:04] The_Selesnyian plays [Clifftop Retreat]. [05:32:06] The_Selesnyian casts [Mogg Fanatic]. [05:32:16] [CHAT] nightarya: a neckbeard called me out for my cards and I raged about 2 years ago [05:32:53] [CHAT] The_Selesnyian: thats too bad. glad your back! [05:32:57] nightarya casts [Play with Fire] targeting The_Selesnyian. [05:32:57] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Monastery Swiftspear] onto the stack (Prowess (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, this creature gets +1/+1 until end of turn.)). [05:33:11] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Mogg Fanatic] targeting [Monastery Swiftspear] ( Mogg Fanatic deals 1 damage to any target.). [05:33:21] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Monastery Swiftspear] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.). [05:33:30] [CHAT] nightarya: legacy players who care about fake duals confuse the hell out of me [05:33:40] nightarya puts 1 card on top of their library. [05:33:40] nightarya scrys 1. [05:33:55] [CHAT] nightarya: do you want me to dump 5k on lands or do you want me to play your format [05:34:01] Turn 4: nightarya [05:34:06] nightarya casts [Ghitu Lavarunner]. [05:34:10] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Ghitu Lavarunner]. [05:34:15] nightarya plays [Barbarian Ring]. [05:34:23] Turn 4: The_Selesnyian [05:34:36] [CHAT] The_Selesnyian: yeah that seems to be a huge barrier of entry. i feel like proxying lands that are like hundreds of dollars should be ok [05:34:48] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.). [05:34:56] The_Selesnyian draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability. [05:34:59] [CHAT] nightarya: totally [05:35:00] The_Selesnyian casts [Hunted Witness]. [05:35:23] [CHAT] nightarya: and like if you're playing to _play_ (trying to fleece people is truly unethical) [05:35:38] [CHAT] nightarya: who cares if wotc got a piece of the pie of your cards [05:35:51] Turn 5: nightarya [05:35:55] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:36:05] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Ghitu Lavarunner]. [05:36:18] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Goblin Bombardment] targeting [Ghitu Lavarunner] ( Goblin Bombardment deals 1 damage to any target.). [05:36:19] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Hunted Witness] onto the stack (When Hunted Witness dies, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token with lifelink.). [05:36:21] The_Selesnyian's [Hunted Witness] creates a Soldier Token. [05:36:29] [Soldier Token] blocks [Ghitu Lavarunner]. [05:36:37] nightarya casts [Chain Lightning] targeting The_Selesnyian. [05:36:44] Turn 5: The_Selesnyian [05:36:49] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:36:53] Turn 6: nightarya [05:37:03] nightarya casts [Zurgo Bellstriker] for its dash cost. [05:37:09] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Zurgo Bellstriker]. [05:37:17] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Zurgo Bellstriker] onto the stack (Dash (At the beginning of the end step, return Zurgo Bellstriker to its owner's hand.)). [05:37:20] Turn 6: The_Selesnyian [05:37:30] Turn 7: nightarya [05:37:39] nightarya casts [Zurgo Bellstriker] for its dash cost. [05:37:48] The_Selesnyian is being attacked by [Zurgo Bellstriker]. [05:37:55] nightarya casts [Shrine of Burning Rage]. [05:38:00] nightarya puts triggered ability from [Zurgo Bellstriker] onto the stack (Dash (At the beginning of the end step, return Zurgo Bellstriker to its owner's hand.)). [05:38:05] Turn 7: The_Selesnyian [05:38:24] The_Selesnyian has conceded from the game. Winner: nightarya Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (787105370) == [Time] 1642563554 [05:39:14] PDBot has started watching. [05:39:16] The_Selesnyian chooses to play first. [05:39:20] The_Selesnyian begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:39:22] nightarya begins the game with seven cards in hand. [05:39:22] Turn 1: The_Selesnyian [05:39:24] The_Selesnyian skips their draw step. [05:39:26] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:39:28] The_Selesnyian casts [Thraben Inspector]. [05:39:29] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Thraben Inspector] onto the stack (When Thraben Inspector enters the battlefield, investigate.). [05:39:35] [CHAT] nightarya: what formats do you like [05:39:36] The_Selesnyian investigates. [05:39:36] The_Selesnyian's [Thraben Inspector] creates a Clue Token. [05:39:37] Turn 1: nightarya [05:39:38] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:39:42] nightarya casts [Ghitu Lavarunner]. [05:39:49] [CHAT] The_Selesnyian: commander [05:39:51] Turn 2: The_Selesnyian [05:40:00] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:40:01] [CHAT] nightarya: I feel that [05:40:06] The_Selesnyian casts [Doomed Traveler]. [05:40:14] [CHAT] nightarya: not my thing, but like proxy cards matter even less there [05:40:31] The_Selesnyian casts [Burrenton Forge-Tender]. [05:41:14] nightarya is being attacked by [Thraben Inspector]. [05:41:18] [Ghitu Lavarunner] blocks [Thraben Inspector]. [05:41:19] Turn 2: nightarya [05:41:20] nightarya plays [Mountain]. [05:41:22] nightarya casts [Play with Fire] targeting The_Selesnyian. [05:41:22] [CHAT] The_Selesnyian: but penny dreadful is really cool too. people get made about proxying in commander too [05:41:23] nightarya puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [05:41:23] nightarya scrys 1. [05:41:42] Turn 3: The_Selesnyian [05:41:44] The_Selesnyian activates an ability of [Clue Token] ( Draw a card.). [05:41:49] [CHAT] nightarya: penny dreadful is near perfect magic [05:42:04] [CHAT] nightarya: if it wasn't for the scecondary market manipulating some fucking card [05:42:14] [CHAT] nightarya: for each meta deck each season [05:42:35] [CHAT] nightarya: its the cheapest magic format but it isn't some <$1 deck format unless you're a rogue brewer [05:42:39] The_Selesnyian draws a card with [Clue Token]'s ability. [05:42:45] The_Selesnyian plays [Plains]. [05:42:59] nightarya casts [Lava Dart] targeting [Doomed Traveler]. [05:43:04] The_Selesnyian puts triggered ability from [Doomed Traveler] onto the stack (When Doomed Traveler dies, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [05:43:06] The_Selesnyian's [Doomed Traveler] creates a Spirit Token. [05:43:20] Turn 3: nightarya [05:43:25] Turn 4: The_Selesnyian [05:43:33] The_Selesnyian casts [Hunted Witness]. [05:43:42] nightarya has conceded from the game. Winner: The_Selesnyian Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: The_Selesnyian: 2–1 [05:43:45] nightarya has left the game.