PennyDreadful
PD LEAGUE
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Carmandor,FILO

== Game 1 (783113518) ==
[Time] 1640181396
[15:56:36] PDBot has started watching.
[15:56:37] Carmandor joined the game.
[15:56:37] FILO joined the game.
[League] Golgari Nightmare by carmandor (163713) vs High Tide by filo (163618)
[15:56:39] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[15:56:42] Carmandor chooses to play first.
[15:56:43] [CHAT] FILO: hi gl
[15:56:48] [CHAT] Carmandor: GL
[15:56:50] Carmandor begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[15:56:52] FILO mulligans to six cards.
[15:56:57] FILO puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[15:56:57] Turn 1: Carmandor
[15:56:58] Carmandor skips their draw step.
[15:57:00] Carmandor plays [Woodland Chasm].
[15:57:06] Turn 1: FILO
[15:57:08] FILO plays [Island].
[15:57:10] FILO casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Carmandor.
[15:57:11] FILO draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[15:57:22] FILO casts [Ponder].
[15:57:31] FILO chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[15:57:31] FILO draws a card with [Ponder].
[15:57:35] Turn 2: Carmandor
[15:57:39] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[15:57:43] Carmandor casts [Dread Fugue] targeting FILO.
[15:57:50] FILO discards [Counterspell].
[15:57:50] FILO reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Island], [Treasure Cruise], [Thought Scour], [Island], and [Frantic Search].
[15:57:52] Carmandor casts [Birds of Paradise].
[15:58:01] Turn 2: FILO
[15:58:04] FILO plays [Island].
[15:58:15] Turn 3: Carmandor
[15:58:18] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[15:58:23] Carmandor casts [Chittering Rats].
[15:58:34] FILO casts [Thought Scour] targeting FILO.
[15:58:35] FILO mills [Blue Sun's Zenith] and [Consider].
[15:58:35] FILO draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[15:58:38] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Chittering Rats] onto the stack targeting FILO (When Chittering Rats enters the battlefield, target opponent puts a card from their hand on top of...).
[15:58:50] Turn 3: FILO
[15:58:51] FILO plays [Island].
[15:59:01] FILO casts [Treasure Cruise].
[15:59:02] FILO draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[15:59:09] Turn 4: Carmandor
[15:59:15] Carmandor casts [Grisly Salvage].
[15:59:17] Carmandor reveals 5 cards with [Grisly Salvage]: [Birds of Paradise], [Forest], [Swamp], [Satyr Wayfinder], and [Birds of Paradise].
[15:59:26] Carmandor puts [Swamp] into their hand with with [Grisly Salvage].
[15:59:26] Carmandor puts [Forest], [Satyr Wayfinder], [Birds of Paradise], and [Birds of Paradise] into their graveyard.
[15:59:28] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[15:59:36] FILO is being attacked by [Chittering Rats].
[15:59:45] Carmandor casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:00:01] Carmandor activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Satyr Wayfinder] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[16:00:03] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...).
[16:00:05] Carmandor reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Hymn to Tourach], [Hornet Queen], [Grisly Salvage], and [Hornet Queen].
[16:00:08] Carmandor puts no cards into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability.
[16:00:08] Carmandor puts [Hymn to Tourach], [Grisly Salvage], [Hornet Queen], and [Hornet Queen] into their graveyard.
[16:00:18] Turn 4: FILO
[16:00:23] FILO plays [Island].
[16:00:31] FILO casts [Repeal] targeting [Birds of Paradise]. (X is 1).
[16:00:33] FILO returns [Birds of Paradise] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[16:00:33] FILO draws a card with [Repeal].
[16:00:40] Turn 5: Carmandor
[16:00:48] FILO is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder].
[16:00:58] Carmandor casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:01:03] FILO casts [Counterspell] targeting [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:01:06] Carmandor casts [Birds of Paradise].
[16:01:11] Turn 5: FILO
[16:01:16] FILO plays [Island].
[16:01:24] FILO casts [Frantic Search].
[16:01:25] FILO draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[16:01:42] FILO discards [Commit/Memory].
[16:01:42] FILO discards [Island].
[16:02:15] Turn 6: Carmandor
[16:02:19] FILO casts [Turnabout] targeting Carmandor.
[16:02:23] FILO chooses land for [Turnabout].
[16:02:32] FILO is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder].
[16:02:41] Turn 6: FILO
[16:02:59] FILO casts [Frantic Search].
[16:03:01] FILO draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[16:03:04] FILO discards [Twincast].
[16:03:04] FILO discards [Island].
[16:03:11] FILO casts [High Tide].
[16:03:42] FILO casts [Bond of Insight].
[16:03:42] Carmandor mills [Swamp], [Swamp], [Hornet Queen] and [Swamp].
[16:03:42] FILO mills [Ponder], [Thought Scour], [High Tide] and [Island].
[16:04:58] DworkinMTG has started watching.
[16:05:30] DworkinMTG has stopped watching.
[16:05:35] FILO returns [High Tide] and [Turnabout] to their owner's hand with [Bond of Insight].
[16:05:45] FILO casts [High Tide].
[16:05:48] FILO casts [Turnabout] targeting FILO.
[16:05:50] FILO chooses land for [Turnabout].
[16:06:04] FILO casts [Memory] from the graveyard.
[16:06:11] FILO casts [Twincast] targeting [Memory].
[16:06:17] FILO draws seven cards with [Memory].
[16:06:17] Carmandor draws seven cards with [Memory].
[16:06:30] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:06:33] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:06:35] FILO draws seven cards with [Memory].
[16:06:35] Carmandor draws seven cards with [Memory].
[16:06:42] FILO casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Carmandor.
[16:06:42] FILO draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[16:06:52] FILO plays Carmandor.
[16:06:58] FILO casts FILO targeting FILO.
[16:07:01] FILO casts [Twincast] targeting FILO.
[16:07:05] FILO mills [Island] and [High Tide].
[16:07:05] FILO draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[16:07:08] FILO mills [Treasure Cruise] and [Gitaxian Probe].
[16:07:08] FILO draws a card with FILO.
[16:07:25] FILO casts [Treasure Cruise].
[16:07:25] FILO draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[16:07:31] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:07:34] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:07:36] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:07:39] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:07:57] [CHAT] FILO: i have found atlantis!
[16:08:02] [CHAT] FILO: all island
[16:08:05] FILO has conceded from the game.
Winner: Carmandor
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (783114220) ==
[Time] 1640182144
[16:09:04] PDBot has started watching.
[16:09:10] FILO chooses to play first.
[16:09:11] FILO begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[16:09:13] Carmandor begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[16:09:13] Turn 1: FILO
[16:09:13] FILO skips their draw step.
[16:09:14] FILO plays [Island].
[16:09:18] FILO casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Carmandor.
[16:09:19] FILO draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[16:09:29] Turn 1: Carmandor
[16:09:32] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[16:09:34] Carmandor casts [Birds of Paradise].
[16:09:44] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:09:47] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:09:49] Turn 2: FILO
[16:09:51] FILO plays [Island].
[16:09:56] Turn 2: Carmandor
[16:09:58] Carmandor plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[16:10:17] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:10:21] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:10:25] FILO casts [Thought Scour] targeting FILO.
[16:10:26] FILO mills [Treasure Cruise] and [Frantic Search].
[16:10:26] FILO draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[16:10:33] Turn 3: FILO
[16:10:46] FILO casts [Treasure Cruise].
[16:10:48] FILO draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[16:10:49] FILO plays [Island].
[16:11:02] Carmandor casts [Grisly Salvage].
[16:11:11] FILO casts [Counterspell] targeting [Grisly Salvage].
[16:11:13] Turn 3: Carmandor
[16:11:16] Carmandor plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[16:11:19] Carmandor casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:11:29] Turn 4: FILO
[16:11:34] FILO plays [Island].
[16:11:36] FILO casts [High Tide].
[16:11:41] FILO casts [High Tide].
[16:11:46] FILO casts [Frantic Search].
[16:11:46] FILO draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[16:11:50] FILO discards [Commit/Memory].
[16:11:50] FILO discards [Counterspell].
[16:11:57] FILO casts [Ponder].
[16:12:08] FILO chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[16:12:08] FILO draws a card with [Ponder].
[16:12:14] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:12:17] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:12:20] FILO casts [Thought Scour] targeting FILO.
[16:12:20] FILO mills [Counterspell] and [Island].
[16:12:20] FILO draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[16:12:24] FILO casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Carmandor.
[16:12:24] FILO draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[16:12:34] FILO casts [Bond of Insight].
[16:12:34] Carmandor mills [Hymn to Tourach], [Hymn to Tourach], [Woodland Cemetery] and [Dread Fugue].
[16:12:34] FILO mills [Island], [Blue Sun's Zenith], [High Tide] and [Turnabout].
[16:12:55] FILO returns [Frantic Search] and [Treasure Cruise] to their owner's hand with [Bond of Insight].
[16:13:07] FILO casts [Treasure Cruise].
[16:13:07] FILO draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[16:13:17] FILO casts [Frantic Search].
[16:13:17] FILO draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[16:13:21] FILO discards [Island].
[16:13:21] FILO discards [Island].
[16:13:28] FILO casts [Ponder].
[16:13:38] FILO chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[16:13:38] FILO draws a card with [Ponder].
[16:13:44] FILO casts [Brain Freeze] targeting Carmandor.
[16:13:44] FILO puts triggered ability from [Brain Freeze] onto the stack (11 spells cast before Brain Freeze this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each ...).
[16:14:00] Carmandor mills [Satyr Wayfinder], [Hymn to Tourach] and [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:14:01] Carmandor mills [Grisly Salvage], [Lost Legacy] and [Satyr Wayfinder].
[16:14:02] Carmandor mills [Recurring Nightmare], [Springbloom Druid] and [Grisly Salvage].
[16:14:03] Carmandor mills [Rotting Rats], [Forest] and [Llanowar Wastes].
[16:14:03] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Rotting Rats[sU] has an advantageous bug.
The client incorrectly display that you may choose to discard either the Adventure or the creature side of an Adventure card
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Rotting Rats` or `!notbugged Rotting Rats`
[16:14:05] Carmandor mills [Birds of Paradise], [Llanowar Wastes] and [Birds of Paradise].
[16:14:06] Carmandor mills [Dread Fugue], [Woodland Cemetery] and [Swamp].
[16:14:08] Carmandor mills [Obstinate Baloth], [Swamp] and [Rotting Rats].
[16:14:10] Carmandor mills [Llanowar Wastes], [Satyr Wayfinder] and [Woodfall Primus].
[16:14:11] Carmandor mills [Forest], [Swamp] and [Hornet Queen].
[16:14:12] Carmandor mills [Chittering Rats], [Swamp] and [Woodland Chasm].
[16:14:13] Carmandor mills [Forest], [Lost Legacy] and [Dread Fugue].
[16:14:15] Carmandor mills [Swamp], [Hymn to Tourach] and [Hornet Queen].
[16:14:19] FILO casts [Brain Freeze] targeting Carmandor.
[16:14:19] FILO puts triggered ability from [Brain Freeze] onto the stack (12 spells cast before Brain Freeze this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each ...).
[16:14:35] Carmandor mills [Woodland Cemetery], [Hornet Queen] and [Hornet Queen].
[16:14:36] Carmandor mills [Birds of Paradise], [Dread Fugue] and [Timeless Witness].
[16:14:37] Carmandor mills [Grisly Salvage], [Woodland Chasm] and [Timeless Witness].
[16:14:38] Carmandor mills [Woodland Chasm].
[16:14:39] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:40] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:41] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:42] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:42] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:43] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:44] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:45] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:14:46] Carmandor mills no cards.
[16:15:13] FILO casts [Ponder].
[16:15:21] FILO chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[16:15:21] FILO draws a card with [Ponder].
[16:15:30] Turn 4: Carmandor
[16:15:32] Carmandor loses because of drawing a card with an empty library.
Winner: FILO
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (783114602) ==
[Time] 1640182554
[16:15:55] PDBot has started watching.
[16:15:55] Carmandor joined the game.
[16:15:56] FILO joined the game.
[16:16:02] Carmandor chooses to play first.
[16:16:05] Carmandor begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[16:16:10] FILO begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[16:16:10] Turn 1: Carmandor
[16:16:12] Carmandor skips their draw step.
[16:16:14] Carmandor plays [Woodland Chasm].
[16:16:19] Turn 1: FILO
[16:16:21] FILO plays [Island].
[16:16:23] FILO casts [Ponder].
[16:16:31] FILO chooses to shuffle his or her library.
[16:16:31] FILO draws a card with [Ponder].
[16:16:35] Turn 2: Carmandor
[16:16:37] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[16:16:39] Carmandor casts [Birds of Paradise].
[16:16:44] Carmandor casts [Dread Fugue] targeting FILO.
[16:16:55] FILO discards [Thought Scour].
[16:16:55] FILO reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Counterspell], [Island], [Island], [Brain Freeze], [Island], and [Counterspell].
[16:17:01] Turn 2: FILO
[16:17:03] FILO plays [Island].
[16:17:07] Turn 3: Carmandor
[16:17:14] Carmandor casts [Dread Fugue] targeting FILO.
[16:17:22] FILO discards [Counterspell].
[16:17:22] FILO reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Consider], [Island], [Brain Freeze], [Island], and [Counterspell].
[16:17:26] Carmandor casts [Grisly Salvage].
[16:17:31] FILO casts [Counterspell] targeting [Grisly Salvage].
[16:17:38] Turn 3: FILO
[16:17:42] FILO casts [Consider].
[16:17:46] FILO draws a card with [Consider].
[16:17:47] FILO plays [Island].
[16:17:54] FILO casts [Thought Scour] targeting FILO.
[16:17:56] FILO mills [Frantic Search] and [Frantic Search].
[16:17:56] FILO draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[16:18:03] Turn 4: Carmandor
[16:18:06] Carmandor plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[16:18:10] Carmandor casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FILO.
[16:18:15] FILO discards [Consider].
[16:18:15] FILO discards [Turnabout].
[16:18:23] Turn 4: FILO
[16:18:29] FILO plays [Island].
[16:18:31] FILO casts [Bond of Insight].
[16:18:33] Carmandor mills [Woodland Cemetery], [Chittering Rats], [Woodland Chasm] and [Swamp].
[16:18:33] FILO mills [High Tide], [Gitaxian Probe], [High Tide] and [Treasure Cruise].
[16:18:57] FILO returns [Treasure Cruise] and [Frantic Search] to their owner's hand with [Bond of Insight].
[16:19:03] Turn 5: Carmandor
[16:19:10] Carmandor casts [Timeless Witness].
[16:19:16] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Timeless Witness] onto the stack targeting [Hymn to Tourach] (When Timeless Witness enters the battlefield, return target card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[16:19:19] Carmandor returns [Hymn to Tourach] to its owner's hand with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[16:19:25] Turn 5: FILO
[16:19:45] FILO casts [Treasure Cruise].
[16:19:47] FILO draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[16:19:56] FILO plays [Island].
[16:20:02] Turn 6: Carmandor
[16:20:05] Carmandor plays [Woodland Chasm].
[16:20:09] Carmandor casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FILO.
[16:20:12] FILO casts [Invasive Surgery] targeting [Hymn to Tourach].
[16:20:18] FILO is being attacked by [Timeless Witness].
[16:20:28] Turn 6: FILO
[16:20:38] FILO casts [Frantic Search].
[16:20:40] FILO draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[16:20:43] FILO discards [Island].
[16:20:43] FILO discards [Island].
[16:20:51] Turn 7: Carmandor
[16:20:56] Carmandor casts [Dread Fugue] targeting FILO.
[16:21:17] FILO casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Dread Fugue].
[16:21:34] FILO casts [Brain Freeze] targeting Carmandor.
[16:21:34] FILO puts triggered ability from [Brain Freeze] onto the stack (2 spells cast before Brain Freeze this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each s...).
[16:21:42] Carmandor mills [Birds of Paradise], [Satyr Wayfinder] and [Hornet Queen].
[16:21:46] Carmandor mills [Satyr Wayfinder], [Woodland Cemetery] and [Llanowar Wastes].
[16:21:48] Carmandor mills [Hornet Queen], [Lost Legacy] and [Llanowar Wastes].
[16:21:53] FILO reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Island] and [Turnabout].
[16:21:58] FILO is being attacked by [Timeless Witness].
[16:22:07] Turn 7: FILO
[16:22:15] FILO plays [Island].
[16:22:17] Turn 8: Carmandor
[16:22:19] Carmandor plays [Forest].
[16:22:22] Carmandor casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:22:26] FILO casts [Counterspell] targeting [Recurring Nightmare].
[16:22:32] [CHAT] Carmandor: o camone
[16:22:37] [CHAT] Carmandor: you were done
[16:22:47] FILO is being attacked by [Timeless Witness].
[16:22:57] Turn 8: FILO
[16:23:07] Turn 9: Carmandor
[16:23:12] Carmandor casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FILO.
[16:23:13] [CHAT] FILO: i want to belive
[16:23:20] FILO casts [Commit] targeting [Hymn to Tourach].
[16:23:23] Carmandor puts [Hymn to Tourach] beneath the top 1 cards of their library.
[16:23:42] [CHAT] Carmandor: man...that deck is strong...if you are lucky too
[16:24:10] [CHAT] FILO: that is true if... i pick from the top an high tide
[16:24:11] [CHAT] Carmandor: there's nothing to do
[16:24:17] Turn 9: FILO
[16:24:20] FILO plays [Island].
[16:24:35] [CHAT] Carmandor: well without that counterspell I would have started the chittering rats loop
[16:24:43] FILO casts [Turnabout] targeting FILO.
[16:24:50] FILO chooses land for [Turnabout].
[16:24:59] FILO casts [Memory] from the graveyard.
[16:25:02] FILO draws seven cards with [Memory].
[16:25:02] Carmandor draws seven cards with [Memory].
[16:25:34] FILO casts [Thought Scour] targeting FILO.
[16:25:39] FILO mills [Island] and [Invasive Surgery].
[16:25:39] FILO draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[16:25:49] Turn 10: Carmandor
[16:25:53] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[16:25:57] Carmandor casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FILO.
[16:26:11] FILO casts [Twincast] targeting [Hymn to Tourach].
[16:26:16] FILO changes targets of [Hymn to Tourach] to Carmandor.
[16:26:20] Carmandor discards [Springbloom Druid].
[16:26:20] Carmandor discards [Woodland Cemetery].
[16:26:27] FILO discards [Treasure Cruise].
[16:26:27] FILO discards [Treasure Cruise].
[16:26:33] [CHAT] FILO: lol
[16:26:36] [CHAT] FILO: both of them
[16:27:03] [CHAT] Carmandor: i repeat...without that counterspell this match would been already finished
[16:27:09] FILO is being attacked by [Timeless Witness].
[16:27:19] Carmandor casts [Satyr Wayfinder].
[16:27:20] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...).
[16:27:23] Carmandor reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Recurring Nightmare], [Woodfall Primus], [Chittering Rats], and [Swamp].
[16:27:24] Carmandor puts [Swamp] into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability.
[16:27:24] Carmandor puts [Woodfall Primus], [Recurring Nightmare], and [Chittering Rats] into their graveyard.
[16:27:30] Turn 10: FILO
[16:27:33] FILO plays [Island].
[16:27:41] Carmandor casts [Grisly Salvage].
[16:27:47] FILO casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Grisly Salvage].
[16:27:51] Turn 11: Carmandor
[16:27:53] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[16:27:56] Carmandor casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting FILO.
[16:27:58] FILO discards [High Tide].
[16:27:59] FILO discards [Island].
[16:28:04] FILO is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder] and [Timeless Witness].
[16:28:14] Turn 11: FILO
[16:28:20] FILO casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Carmandor.
[16:28:22] FILO draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[16:28:26] FILO casts [Frantic Search].
[16:28:27] FILO draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[16:28:29] FILO discards [Consider].
[16:28:29] FILO discards [Spell Pierce].
[16:28:37] FILO casts [Ponder].
[16:28:43] FILO has conceded from the game.
Winner: Carmandor
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Carmandor: 2–1
[16:28:48] Carmandor draws their next card.
[16:28:48] Carmandor draws their next card.
[16:28:50] FILO has left the game.