PennyDreadful
pd fnm t4 vs blackhorrorghost
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
fartak,blackhorrorghost

== Game 1 (782739810) ==
[Time] 1639795197
[04:39:57] PDBot has started watching.
[04:39:57] fartak joined the game.
[04:39:57] blackhorrorghost joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 23.04
[Gatherling] Round=5
[04:39:59] MimberyEarth has started watching.
[04:40:14] blackhorrorghost chooses to play first.
[04:40:19] blackhorrorghost mulligans to six cards.
[04:40:22] fartak mulligans to six cards.
[04:40:32] blackhorrorghost puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:40:38] fartak puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:40:38] Turn 1: blackhorrorghost
[04:40:38] blackhorrorghost skips their draw step.
[04:40:42] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:40:44] blackhorrorghost casts [Delver of Secrets].
[04:40:48] Turn 1: fartak
[04:40:50] fartak plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:40:54] fartak discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[04:40:54] fartak casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Delver of Secrets].
[04:41:02] Turn 2: blackhorrorghost
[04:41:03] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:41:06] MimberyEarth has stopped watching.
[04:41:20] Turn 2: fartak
[04:41:22] fartak plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[04:41:29] blackhorrorghost casts [Faerie Vandal].
[04:41:30] Turn 3: blackhorrorghost
[04:41:37] blackhorrorghost casts [Ponder].
[04:41:37] MimberyEarth has started watching.
[04:41:47] blackhorrorghost chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[04:41:47] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Ponder].
[04:41:47] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Faerie Vandal] onto the stack (Whenever you draw your second card each turn, put a +1/+1 counter on Faerie Vandal.).
[04:41:52] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:41:55] fartak is being attacked by [Faerie Vandal].
[04:41:58] Turn 3: fartak
[04:42:06] fartak plays [Snow-Covered Forest].
[04:42:10] fartak discards [Woodfall Primus].
[04:42:10] fartak casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Faerie Vandal].
[04:42:15] blackhorrorghost casts [Counterspell] targeting [Bone Shards].
[04:42:21] Turn 4: blackhorrorghost
[04:42:30] fartak is being attacked by [Faerie Vandal].
[04:42:40] Turn 4: fartak
[04:42:45] fartak casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:42:57] blackhorrorghost casts [Faerie Vandal].
[04:42:58] Turn 5: blackhorrorghost
[04:43:03] fartak is being attacked by [Faerie Vandal] and [Faerie Vandal].
[04:43:10] blackhorrorghost casts [Vedalken Shackles].
[04:43:10] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Vedalken Shackles[sU] has an unclassified bug.
Vedalken Shackles interacts incorrectly with creatures that enter the battlefield tapped and attacking.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Vedalken Shackles` or `!notbugged Vedalken Shackles`
[04:43:12] Turn 5: fartak
[04:43:18] fartak discards [Bone Shards].
[04:43:19] fartak casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Faerie Vandal].
[04:43:36] Turn 6: blackhorrorghost
[04:43:42] fartak is being attacked by [Faerie Vandal].
[04:43:48] blackhorrorghost casts [Tempest Djinn].
[04:43:50] Turn 6: fartak
[04:43:54] fartak plays [Murmuring Bosk].
[04:44:07] Turn 7: blackhorrorghost
[04:44:22] fartak is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn] and [Faerie Vandal].
[04:44:27] Turn 7: fartak
[04:44:33] fartak casts [Timeless Witness].
[04:44:38] fartak puts triggered ability from [Timeless Witness] onto the stack targeting [Bone Shards] (When Timeless Witness enters the battlefield, return target card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[04:44:43] fartak returns [Bone Shards] to its owner's hand with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[04:44:49] fartak activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Woodfall Primus] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:44:59] fartak puts triggered ability from [Woodfall Primus] onto the stack targeting [Island] (When Woodfall Primus enters the battlefield, destroy target noncreature permanent.).
[04:45:12] fartak plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[04:45:22] fartak casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Tempest Djinn].
[04:45:22] fartak puts triggered ability from [Woodfall Primus] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[04:45:34] blackhorrorghost casts [Lose Focus] targeting [Bone Shards].
[04:45:42] fartak puts triggered ability from [Woodfall Primus] onto the stack targeting [Island] (When Woodfall Primus enters the battlefield, destroy target noncreature permanent.).
[04:45:49] Turn 8: blackhorrorghost
[04:45:51] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:46:02] blackhorrorghost casts [Treasure Cruise].
[04:46:02] blackhorrorghost draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[04:46:02] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Faerie Vandal] onto the stack (Whenever you draw your second card each turn, put a +1/+1 counter on Faerie Vandal.).
[04:46:09] fartak is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn] and [Faerie Vandal].
[04:46:14] Turn 8: fartak
[04:46:28] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Woodfall Primus].
[04:46:45] fartak casts [Timeless Witness].
[04:46:53] fartak puts triggered ability from [Timeless Witness] onto the stack targeting [Bone Shards] (When Timeless Witness enters the battlefield, return target card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[04:46:55] fartak returns [Bone Shards] to its owner's hand with [Timeless Witness]'s ability.
[04:47:01] fartak casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Faerie Vandal].
[04:47:11] Turn 9: blackhorrorghost
[04:47:13] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:47:17] fartak is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn].
[04:47:21] Turn 9: fartak
[04:47:31] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Woodfall Primus].
[04:47:38] fartak casts [Shriekmaw] for its evoke cost.
[04:47:52] blackhorrorghost casts [Counterspell] targeting [Shriekmaw].
[04:47:56] fartak casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:48:04] fartak activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:48:10] Turn 10: blackhorrorghost
[04:48:12] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:48:37] Turn 10: fartak
[04:48:48] fartak casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:48:57] fartak activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Woodfall Primus] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:49:01] fartak puts triggered ability from [Yosei, the Morning Star] onto the stack targeting blackhorrorghost, [Island], [Island], [Island], [Island], and [Tempest Djinn] (When Yosei, the Morning Star dies, target player skips their next untap step. Tap up to five targe...).
[04:49:16] fartak puts triggered ability from [Woodfall Primus] onto the stack targeting [Island] (When Woodfall Primus enters the battlefield, destroy target noncreature permanent.).
[04:49:23] fartak casts [Birds of Paradise].
[04:49:32] Turn 11: blackhorrorghost
[04:49:32] blackhorrorghost skips their untap step.
[04:49:34] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:49:39] Turn 11: fartak
[04:49:53] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Woodfall Primus].
[04:50:10] fartak casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:50:26] fartak activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Shriekmaw] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:50:26] fartak puts triggered ability from [Woodfall Primus] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
[04:50:32] fartak puts triggered ability from [Woodfall Primus] onto the stack targeting [Vedalken Shackles] (When Woodfall Primus enters the battlefield, destroy target noncreature permanent.).
[04:50:39] fartak puts triggered ability from [Shriekmaw] onto the stack targeting [Tempest Djinn] (When Shriekmaw enters the battlefield, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature.).
[04:50:42] Plrt has started watching.
[04:50:51] fartak casts [Commune with the Gods].
[04:50:53] fartak reveals 5 cards with [Commune with the Gods]: [Snow-Covered Forest], [Satyr Wayfinder], [Stirring Wildwood], [Murmuring Bosk], and [Satyr Wayfinder].
[04:50:54] fartak puts [Satyr Wayfinder] into their hand with with [Commune with the Gods].
[04:50:54] fartak puts [Snow-Covered Forest], [Satyr Wayfinder], [Murmuring Bosk], and [Stirring Wildwood] into their graveyard.
[04:50:58] Turn 12: blackhorrorghost
[04:51:04] blackhorrorghost casts [Thought Scour] targeting blackhorrorghost.
[04:51:04] blackhorrorghost mills [Gitaxian Probe] and [Counterspell].
[04:51:04] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[04:51:06] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:51:12] blackhorrorghost has conceded from the game.
Winner: fartak
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (782740626) ==
[Time] 1639796001
[04:53:21] PDBot has started watching.
[04:53:29] blackhorrorghost chooses to play first.
[04:53:30] MimberyEarth has started watching.
[04:53:34] blackhorrorghost begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:53:56] fartak begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:53:56] Turn 1: blackhorrorghost
[04:53:57] blackhorrorghost skips their draw step.
[04:54:01] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:54:12] Turn 1: fartak
[04:54:14] fartak plays [Snow-Covered Forest].
[04:54:15] fartak casts [Birds of Paradise].
[04:54:27] blackhorrorghost casts [Thought Scour] targeting blackhorrorghost.
[04:54:27] blackhorrorghost mills [Thought Scour] and [Ponder].
[04:54:27] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[04:54:32] Turn 2: blackhorrorghost
[04:54:36] blackhorrorghost casts [Thought Scour] targeting blackhorrorghost.
[04:54:38] blackhorrorghost mills [Vedalken Shackles] and [Stern Dismissal].
[04:54:38] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[04:54:45] Turn 2: fartak
[04:54:50] fartak casts [Birds of Paradise].
[04:54:56] fartak casts [Dread Fugue] targeting blackhorrorghost.
[04:55:22] blackhorrorghost discards [Delver of Secrets].
[04:55:22] blackhorrorghost reveals their hand to [Dread Fugue], containing [Treasure Cruise], [Faerie Vandal], [Faerie Vandal], [Faerie Vandal], [Lantern of the Lost], and [Lantern of the Lost].
[04:55:24] fartak plays [Murmuring Bosk].
[04:55:39] Turn 3: blackhorrorghost
[04:55:41] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:55:57] blackhorrorghost casts [Lantern of the Lost].
[04:56:03] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Lantern of the Lost] onto the stack targeting [Dread Fugue] (When Lantern of the Lost enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[04:56:10] Turn 3: fartak
[04:56:14] fartak casts [Undead Butler].
[04:56:18] fartak puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack (When Undead Butler enters the battlefield, mill three cards.).
[04:56:26] fartak mills [Commune with the Gods], [Mistcutter Hydra] and [Bone Shards].
[04:56:29] fartak plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[04:56:40] Turn 4: blackhorrorghost
[04:56:45] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:56:54] blackhorrorghost casts [Treasure Cruise].
[04:56:56] blackhorrorghost draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[04:57:05] blackhorrorghost casts [Delver of Secrets].
[04:57:10] Turn 4: fartak
[04:57:21] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Undead Butler].
[04:57:30] fartak casts [Timeless Witness].
[04:57:34] blackhorrorghost exiles [Lantern of the Lost] with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[04:57:34] blackhorrorghost activates an ability of [Lantern of the Lost] ( Exile all cards from all graveyards, then draw a card.).
[04:57:36] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[04:57:39] No legal targets to choose for triggered ability from [Timeless Witness].
[04:57:40] fartak plays [Murmuring Bosk].
[04:57:44] Turn 5: blackhorrorghost
[04:57:45] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[04:58:02] blackhorrorghost casts [Lantern of the Lost].
[04:58:02] No legal targets to choose for triggered ability from [Lantern of the Lost].
[04:58:28] blackhorrorghost casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting fartak.
[04:58:28] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[04:58:33] Turn 5: fartak
[04:59:08] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Timeless Witness] and [Undead Butler].
[04:59:16] fartak plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[04:59:20] blackhorrorghost casts [Faerie Vandal].
[04:59:23] Turn 6: blackhorrorghost
[04:59:23] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[04:59:29] blackhorrorghost reveals [Vapor Snag].
[04:59:29] [Insectile Aberration] transformed
[04:59:34] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[04:59:43] fartak is being attacked by [Faerie Vandal] and [Insectile Aberration].
[04:59:51] Turn 6: fartak
[05:00:01] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Timeless Witness] and [Undead Butler].
[05:00:29] blackhorrorghost casts [Faerie Vandal].
[05:00:35] [Faerie Vandal] blocks [Undead Butler].
[05:00:42] fartak casts [Undead Butler].
[05:00:46] fartak puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack (When Undead Butler enters the battlefield, mill three cards.).
[05:00:49] fartak mills [Woodfall Primus], [Commune with the Gods] and [Llanowar Wastes].
[05:00:50] fartak plays [Snow-Covered Forest].
[05:00:55] blackhorrorghost casts [Faerie Vandal].
[05:00:59] Turn 7: blackhorrorghost
[05:01:20] fartak is being attacked by [Faerie Vandal], [Faerie Vandal], [Faerie Vandal], and [Insectile Aberration].
[05:01:36] Turn 7: fartak
[05:01:39] fartak casts [Satyr Wayfinder].
[05:01:44] fartak puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...).
[05:01:46] fartak reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Llanowar Wastes], [Snow-Covered Swamp], [Llanowar Wastes], and [Satyr Wayfinder].
[05:01:50] fartak has conceded from the game.
Winner: blackhorrorghost
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (782741284) ==
[Time] 1639796562
[05:02:42] PDBot has started watching.
[05:02:51] MimberyEarth has started watching.
[05:02:52] fartak chooses to play first.
[05:02:59] fartak mulligans to six cards.
[05:03:08] blackhorrorghost begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[05:03:11] fartak puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[05:03:11] Turn 1: fartak
[05:03:11] fartak skips their draw step.
[05:03:12] fartak plays [Stirring Wildwood].
[05:03:25] Turn 1: blackhorrorghost
[05:03:27] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[05:03:29] blackhorrorghost casts [Delver of Secrets].
[05:03:33] Turn 2: fartak
[05:03:37] fartak plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[05:03:39] fartak casts [Satyr Wayfinder].
[05:03:40] fartak puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...).
[05:03:43] fartak reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Birds of Paradise], [Shriekmaw], [Birds of Paradise], and [Commune with the Gods].
[05:03:45] fartak puts no cards into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability.
[05:03:45] fartak puts [Birds of Paradise], [Shriekmaw], [Birds of Paradise], and [Commune with the Gods] into their graveyard.
[05:04:02] Turn 2: blackhorrorghost
[05:04:02] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[05:04:07] blackhorrorghost reveals [Thought Scour].
[05:04:07] [Insectile Aberration] transformed
[05:04:09] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[05:04:14] fartak is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[05:04:23] Turn 3: fartak
[05:04:28] fartak discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[05:04:28] fartak casts [Bone Shards] targeting [Insectile Aberration].
[05:04:48] blackhorrorghost casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Bone Shards].
[05:04:49] [CHAT] MimberyEarth: Should'nt the card to transform Delver be revealed?
[05:05:02] [CHAT] fartak: it is
[05:05:17] [CHAT] MimberyEarth: Not for me, strange.
[05:05:19] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder].
[05:05:29] fartak plays [Woodland Cemetery].
[05:05:30] [CHAT] Plrt: you can see it in the log
[05:05:35] blackhorrorghost casts [Thought Scour] targeting blackhorrorghost.
[05:05:35] blackhorrorghost mills [Delver of Secrets] and [Vapor Snag].
[05:05:35] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[05:05:38] Turn 3: blackhorrorghost
[05:05:39] [CHAT] Plrt: cards aren't revealed for spectators
[05:05:43] blackhorrorghost casts [Lantern of the Lost].
[05:05:44] [CHAT] fartak: or click in the eye beneath their name
[05:05:58] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Lantern of the Lost] onto the stack targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (When Lantern of the Lost enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[05:06:06] fartak is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[05:06:11] Turn 4: fartak
[05:06:12] fartak plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[05:06:20] blackhorrorghost is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder].
[05:06:41] Turn 4: blackhorrorghost
[05:06:50] fartak is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[05:07:14] blackhorrorghost casts [Delver of Secrets].
[05:07:16] Turn 5: fartak
[05:07:18] fartak plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[05:07:34] fartak exiles [Lantern of the Lost] with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[05:07:34] blackhorrorghost activates an ability of [Lantern of the Lost] ( Exile all cards from all graveyards, then draw a card.).
[05:07:37] blackhorrorghost draws a card with [Lantern of the Lost]'s ability.
[05:07:43] Turn 5: blackhorrorghost
[05:07:43] blackhorrorghost puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[05:07:53] blackhorrorghost plays [Island].
[05:08:01] fartak is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[05:08:11] Turn 6: fartak
[05:08:14] fartak has conceded from the game.
Winner: blackhorrorghost
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: blackhorrorghost: 2–1
[05:08:18] fartak draws their next card.
[05:08:19] blackhorrorghost has left the game.
[05:08:19] fartak draws their next card.
[05:08:19] fartak draws their next card.
[05:08:20] fartak draws their next card.