PennyDreadful
PD r4 vs cryael
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Cryael,Gobojr

== Game 1 (782087030) ==
[Time] 1639101063
[03:51:04] PDBot has started watching.
[03:51:04] Gobojr joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 23.02
[Gatherling] Round=4
[03:51:07] martyvburen has started watching.
[03:51:08] [CHAT] Gobojr: hello!
[03:51:09] [CHAT] Gobojr: glhf
[03:51:11] Gobojr chooses to play first.
[03:51:11] martyvburen has stopped watching.
[03:51:12] [CHAT] Cryael: hey u2
[03:51:16] Gobojr mulligans to six cards.
[03:51:23] Cryael begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:51:27] Gobojr puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[03:51:27] Turn 1: Gobojr
[03:51:27] Gobojr skips their draw step.
[03:51:29] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[03:51:34] Turn 1: Cryael
[03:51:36] Cryael plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[03:51:40] Turn 2: Gobojr
[03:51:41] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[03:51:44] Gobojr casts [Graveyard Marshal].
[03:51:47] Turn 2: Cryael
[03:51:49] Cryael plays [Adarkar Wastes].
[03:51:52] Cryael casts [Undead Butler].
[03:51:54] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack (When Undead Butler enters the battlefield, mill three cards.).
[03:51:55] Cryael mills [Undead Butler], [Undead Butler] and [Faithful Mending].
[03:52:00] Turn 3: Gobojr
[03:52:02] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[03:52:06] Gobojr casts [Cemetery Reaper].
[03:52:14] Cryael is being attacked by [Graveyard Marshal].
[03:52:20] Turn 3: Cryael
[03:52:24] Cryael plays [Ice Tunnel].
[03:52:30] Cryael casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[03:52:34] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Gobojr (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[03:52:57] Gobojr reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Swamp] and [Hymn to Tourach].
[03:53:06] Turn 4: Gobojr
[03:53:09] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[03:53:11] Gobojr casts [Sarcomancy].
[03:53:14] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Sarcomancy] onto the stack (When Sarcomancy enters the battlefield, create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.).
[03:53:17] Gobojr's [Sarcomancy] creates a Zombie Token.
[03:53:20] Cryael is being attacked by [Graveyard Marshal].
[03:53:30] Turn 4: Cryael
[03:53:39] Cryael casts [Champion of Wits].
[03:53:43] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Champion of Wits] onto the stack (When Champion of Wits enters the battlefield, you may draw cards equal to its power. If you do, di...).
[03:53:48] Cryael draws two cards with [Champion of Wits]'s ability.
[03:53:54] Cryael discards [Sower of Temptation].
[03:53:54] Cryael discards [Shriekmaw].
[03:54:10] Cryael plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[03:54:16] Gobojr activates an ability of [Cemetery Reaper] targeting [Sower of Temptation] ( Exile target creature card from a graveyard. Create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.).
[03:54:16] Gobojr's [Cemetery Reaper] creates a Zombie Token.
[03:54:19] Turn 5: Gobojr
[03:54:35] Gobojr casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Cryael.
[03:54:36] Cryael discards [Recurring Nightmare].
[03:54:36] Cryael discards [Sower of Temptation].
[03:55:12] Turn 5: Cryael
[03:55:17] Cryael casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[03:55:28] Cryael activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Sower of Temptation] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[03:55:28] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack (When Undead Butler dies, you may exile it. When you do, return target creature card from your grav...).
[03:55:37] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Undead Butler] onto the stack targeting [Undead Butler] (When you exile it, return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[03:55:40] Cryael returns [Undead Butler] to its owner's hand with [Undead Butler]'s ability.
[03:55:45] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Sower of Temptation] onto the stack targeting [Cemetery Reaper] (When Sower of Temptation enters the battlefield, gain control of target creature for as long as So...).
[03:55:55] Turn 6: Gobojr
[03:56:07] Gobojr casts [Dark Salvation] targeting Gobojr, and [Tidehollow Sculler]. (X is 1).
[03:56:07] Gobojr's [Dark Salvation] creates a Zombie Token.
[03:56:07] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[03:56:17] Gobojr casts [Dark Salvation] targeting Gobojr, and [Sower of Temptation]. (X is 0).
[03:56:21] Cryael has conceded from the game.
Winner: Gobojr
Game 1 Completed.
[03:56:26] Cryael has left the game.

== Game 2 (782087472) ==
[Time] 1639101464
[03:57:44] PDBot has started watching.
[03:57:47] Cryael begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:57:53] Gobojr begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:57:53] Turn 1: Cryael
[03:57:53] Cryael skips their draw step.
[03:58:00] Cryael plays [Glacial Floodplain].
[03:58:03] Turn 1: Gobojr
[03:58:05] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[03:58:07] Gobojr casts [Dark Ritual].
[03:58:08] Gobojr casts [Diregraf Colossus].
[03:58:11] Turn 2: Cryael
[03:58:12] Cryael plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[03:58:16] Cryael casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[03:58:17] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Gobojr (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[03:58:49] Gobojr reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Dread Wanderer], [Graveyard Marshal], [Eaten Alive], and [Dark Salvation].
[03:58:53] Turn 2: Gobojr
[03:58:55] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[03:59:00] Gobojr casts [Dread Wanderer].
[03:59:00] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Diregraf Colossus] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Zombie spell, create a tapped 2/2 black Zombie creature token.).
[03:59:02] Gobojr's [Diregraf Colossus] creates a Zombie Token.
[03:59:29] Gobojr casts [Dark Salvation] targeting Gobojr, and [Tidehollow Sculler]. (X is 0).
[03:59:29] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[03:59:34] Cryael is being attacked by [Diregraf Colossus].
[03:59:37] Turn 3: Cryael
[03:59:41] Cryael plays [Adarkar Wastes].
[03:59:51] Cryael casts [Reflector Mage].
[04:00:16] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Reflector Mage] onto the stack targeting [Diregraf Colossus] (When Reflector Mage enters the battlefield, return target creature an opponent controls to its own...).
[04:00:18] Cryael returns [Diregraf Colossus] to its owner's hand with [Reflector Mage]'s ability.
[04:00:22] Turn 3: Gobojr
[04:00:24] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[04:00:27] Gobojr casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[04:00:29] Gobojr casts [Graveyard Marshal].
[04:00:33] Turn 4: Cryael
[04:00:40] Cryael plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:00:49] Cryael casts [Meddling Mage].
[04:00:58] Cryael names Diregraf Colossus for [Meddling Mage].
[04:01:03] Turn 4: Gobojr
[04:01:25] Gobojr casts [Archghoul of Thraben].
[04:01:31] Cryael is being attacked by [Graveyard Marshal].
[04:01:38] Turn 5: Cryael
[04:01:47] Cryael casts [Faithful Mending].
[04:01:49] Cryael draws two cards with [Faithful Mending].
[04:01:59] Cryael discards [Drowned Catacomb].
[04:01:59] Cryael discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[04:02:00] Cryael plays [Drowned Catacomb].
[04:02:14] Cryael casts [Reflector Mage].
[04:02:22] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Reflector Mage] onto the stack targeting [Zombie Token] (When Reflector Mage enters the battlefield, return target creature an opponent controls to its own...).
[04:02:25] Cryael returns [Zombie] token to its owner's hand with [Reflector Mage]'s ability.
[04:02:32] Turn 5: Gobojr
[04:02:41] Gobojr casts [Sarcomancy].
[04:02:41] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Sarcomancy] onto the stack (When Sarcomancy enters the battlefield, create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.).
[04:02:42] Gobojr's [Sarcomancy] creates a Zombie Token.
[04:02:49] Gobojr casts [Eaten Alive] targeting [Meddling Mage].
[04:02:49] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Archghoul of Thraben] onto the stack (Whenever Archghoul of Thraben or another Zombie you control dies, look at the top card of your lib...).
[04:02:54] Gobojr puts a card into their graveyard with Archghoul of Thraben's ability.
[04:03:03] Cryael is being attacked by [Archghoul of Thraben] and [Graveyard Marshal].
[04:03:04] [Reflector Mage] blocks [Archghoul of Thraben].
[04:03:07] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Archghoul of Thraben] onto the stack (Whenever Archghoul of Thraben or another Zombie you control dies, look at the top card of your lib...).
[04:03:14] Gobojr puts a card into their graveyard with Archghoul of Thraben's ability.
[04:03:16] Turn 6: Cryael
[04:03:29] Cryael casts [Faithful Mending] from the graveyard.
[04:03:30] Cryael draws two cards with [Faithful Mending].
[04:03:41] Cryael discards [Glacial Fortress].
[04:03:41] Cryael discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[04:03:48] Turn 6: Gobojr
[04:03:50] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[04:03:54] Gobojr casts [Diregraf Colossus].
[04:03:57] Cryael is being attacked by [Graveyard Marshal].
[04:03:59] [Reflector Mage] blocks [Graveyard Marshal].
[04:04:03] Turn 7: Cryael
[04:04:09] Cryael casts [Sower of Temptation].
[04:04:13] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Sower of Temptation] onto the stack targeting [Diregraf Colossus] (When Sower of Temptation enters the battlefield, gain control of target creature for as long as So...).
[04:04:20] Turn 7: Gobojr
[04:04:30] Gobojr activates an ability of [Nihil Spellbomb] targeting Cryael ( Exile target player's graveyard.).
[04:04:30] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Nihil Spellbomb] onto the stack (When Nihil Spellbomb is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, dra...).
[04:04:34] Gobojr draws a card with [Nihil Spellbomb]'s ability.
[04:04:38] Gobojr casts [Archghoul of Thraben].
[04:04:40] Turn 8: Cryael
[04:04:50] Cryael plays [Glacial Fortress].
[04:04:59] Gobojr is being attacked by [Sower of Temptation].
[04:05:08] Cryael casts [Champion of Wits].
[04:05:09] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Champion of Wits] onto the stack (When Champion of Wits enters the battlefield, you may draw cards equal to its power. If you do, di...).
[04:05:12] Cryael draws two cards with [Champion of Wits]'s ability.
[04:05:15] Cryael discards [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:05:15] Cryael discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[04:05:21] Turn 8: Gobojr
[04:05:25] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[04:05:28] Gobojr casts [Gray Merchant of Asphodel].
[04:05:28] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] onto the stack (When Gray Merchant of Asphodel enters the battlefield, each opponent loses X life, where X is your...).
[04:05:38] Turn 9: Cryael
[04:06:11] Gobojr is being attacked by [Sower of Temptation] and [Diregraf Colossus].
[04:06:43] Cryael casts [Magister of Worth].
[04:07:03] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...).
[04:07:13] Cryael votes for Condemnation
[04:07:20] Gobojr votes for Condemnation
[04:07:20] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Archghoul of Thraben] onto the stack (Whenever Archghoul of Thraben or another Zombie you control dies, look at the top card of your lib...).
[04:07:20] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Archghoul of Thraben] onto the stack (Whenever Archghoul of Thraben or another Zombie you control dies, look at the top card of your lib...).
[04:07:20] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Archghoul of Thraben] onto the stack (Whenever Archghoul of Thraben or another Zombie you control dies, look at the top card of your lib...).
[04:07:24] Gobojr puts a card into their graveyard with Archghoul of Thraben's ability.
[04:07:29] Gobojr puts a card into their graveyard with Archghoul of Thraben's ability.
[04:07:31] Gobojr puts a card into their graveyard with Archghoul of Thraben's ability.
[04:07:33] Turn 9: Gobojr
[04:07:34] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Sarcomancy] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are no Zombies on the battlefield, Sarcomancy deals 1 da...).
[04:07:39] Gobojr casts [Graveyard Marshal].
[04:07:52] Gobojr exiles [Archghoul of Thraben] with with [Graveyard Marshal]'s ability.
[04:07:53] Gobojr activates an ability of [Graveyard Marshal] ( Create a tapped 2/2 black Zombie creature token.).
[04:07:53] Gobojr's [Graveyard Marshal] creates a Zombie Token.
[04:07:56] Turn 10: Cryael
[04:08:02] Gobojr is being attacked by [Magister of Worth].
[04:08:08] Cryael plays [Glacial Fortress].
[04:08:15] Cryael exiles [Champion of Wits] with [Champion of Wits]'s ability.
[04:08:15] Cryael activates an ability of [Champion of Wits] (Eternalize {5UU}).
[04:08:17] Cryael's [Champion of Wits] creates a Champion of Wits.
[04:08:17] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Champion of Wits] onto the stack (When Champion of Wits enters the battlefield, you may draw cards equal to its power. If you do, di...).
[04:08:20] Cryael draws four cards with [Champion of Wits]'s ability.
[04:08:25] Cryael discards [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:08:25] Cryael discards [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:08:29] Turn 10: Gobojr
[04:08:35] Gobojr casts [Cemetery Reaper].
[04:08:45] Turn 11: Cryael
[04:08:52] Cryael plays [Ice Tunnel].
[04:08:58] jerrybeansman has started watching.
[04:09:00] Gobojr is being attacked by [Champion of Wits] and [Magister of Worth].
[04:09:05] [Graveyard Marshal] blocks [Champion of Wits].
[04:09:05] jerrybeansman has stopped watching.
[04:09:12] Cryael casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:09:19] Cryael activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:09:26] Cryael casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:09:30] jerrybeansman has started watching.
[04:09:32] Cryael activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Magister of Worth] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:09:37] jerrybeansman has stopped watching.
[04:09:37] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Yosei, the Morning Star] onto the stack targeting Gobojr, [Swamp], [Swamp], [Zombie Token], [Cemetery Reaper], and [Sarcomancy] (When Yosei, the Morning Star dies, target player skips their next untap step. Tap up to five targe...).
[04:09:42] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...).
[04:09:45] Cryael votes for Condemnation
[04:09:49] Gobojr votes for Grace
[04:09:52] Turn 11: Gobojr
[04:09:52] Gobojr skips their untap step.
[04:09:52] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Sarcomancy] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are no Zombies on the battlefield, Sarcomancy deals 1 da...).
[04:10:01] [CHAT] Gobojr: gg
[04:10:04] Gobojr has conceded from the game.
Winner: Cryael
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (782088392) ==
[Time] 1639102255
[04:10:55] PDBot has started watching.
[04:11:01] Gobojr chooses to play first.
[04:11:04] Gobojr mulligans to six cards.
[04:11:07] Cryael mulligans to six cards.
[04:11:15] Gobojr puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[04:11:21] Cryael mulligans to five cards.
[04:11:53] Cryael puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[04:11:53] Turn 1: Gobojr
[04:11:53] Gobojr skips their draw step.
[04:11:57] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[04:11:58] Gobojr casts [Dark Ritual].
[04:12:00] Gobojr casts [Lord of the Undead].
[04:12:03] Turn 1: Cryael
[04:12:04] Cryael plays [Adarkar Wastes].
[04:12:07] Turn 2: Gobojr
[04:12:09] Gobojr plays [Leechridden Swamp].
[04:12:11] Gobojr casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[04:12:14] Cryael is being attacked by [Lord of the Undead].
[04:12:16] Turn 2: Cryael
[04:12:18] Cryael plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:12:23] Cryael casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:12:26] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting Gobojr (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[04:12:32] Gobojr reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Dark Salvation].
[04:12:39] Turn 3: Gobojr
[04:12:57] Turn 3: Cryael
[04:12:59] Cryael plays [Adarkar Wastes].
[04:13:04] Cryael casts [Reflector Mage].
[04:13:07] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Reflector Mage] onto the stack targeting [Lord of the Undead] (When Reflector Mage enters the battlefield, return target creature an opponent controls to its own...).
[04:13:09] Cryael returns [Lord of the Undead] to its owner's hand with [Reflector Mage]'s ability.
[04:13:13] Gobojr is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:13:18] Turn 4: Gobojr
[04:13:25] Turn 4: Cryael
[04:13:32] Gobojr is being attacked by [Reflector Mage] and [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:13:38] Cryael casts [Champion of Wits].
[04:13:40] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Champion of Wits] onto the stack (When Champion of Wits enters the battlefield, you may draw cards equal to its power. If you do, di...).
[04:13:43] Cryael draws two cards with [Champion of Wits]'s ability.
[04:13:53] Cryael discards [Magister of Worth].
[04:13:53] Cryael discards [Meddling Mage].
[04:13:55] Cryael plays [Snow-Covered Island].
[04:13:56] MrCringe has started watching.
[04:14:00] Turn 5: Gobojr
[04:14:03] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[04:14:17] Gobojr casts [Lord of the Undead].
[04:14:22] Turn 5: Cryael
[04:14:28] Gobojr is being attacked by [Champion of Wits], [Reflector Mage], and [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:14:38] [Lord of the Undead] blocks [Champion of Wits].
[04:14:47] Cryael casts [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage].
[04:14:55] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage] onto the stack targeting [Reflector Mage] (When Barrin, Tolarian Archmage enters the battlefield, return up to one other target creature or p...).
[04:14:57] Cryael returns [Reflector Mage] to its owner's hand with [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage]'s ability.
[04:14:58] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if a permanent was put into your hand from the battlefield this...).
[04:15:01] Cryael draws a card with [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage]'s ability.
[04:15:03] Turn 6: Gobojr
[04:15:16] Gobojr activates an ability of [Nihil Spellbomb] targeting Cryael ( Exile target player's graveyard.).
[04:15:16] Gobojr puts triggered ability from [Nihil Spellbomb] onto the stack (When Nihil Spellbomb is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, dra...).
[04:15:22] Gobojr draws a card with [Nihil Spellbomb]'s ability.
[04:15:26] Gobojr plays [Swamp].
[04:15:48] Gobojr casts [Dark Salvation] targeting Gobojr, and [Tidehollow Sculler]. (X is 1).
[04:15:48] Gobojr's [Dark Salvation] creates a Zombie Token.
[04:15:51] Turn 6: Cryael
[04:16:13] Cryael casts [Reflector Mage].
[04:16:43] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Reflector Mage] onto the stack targeting [Zombie Token] (When Reflector Mage enters the battlefield, return target creature an opponent controls to its own...).
[04:16:44] Cryael returns [Zombie] token to its owner's hand with [Reflector Mage]'s ability.
[04:16:44] Gobojr is being attacked by [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage] and [Tidehollow Sculler].
[04:16:44] Cryael plays [Ice Tunnel].
[04:16:44] Turn 7: Gobojr
[04:16:44] Gobojr casts [Diregraf Colossus].
[04:16:48] Gobojr casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[04:16:51] Turn 7: Cryael
[04:16:55] Cryael casts [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage].
[04:17:01] Cryael puts triggered ability from [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage] onto the stack targeting [Diregraf Colossus] (When Barrin, Tolarian Archmage enters the battlefield, return up to one other target creature or p...).
[04:17:05] Cryael returns [Diregraf Colossus] to its owner's hand with [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage]'s ability.
[04:17:11] [CHAT] Gobojr: ggs
[04:17:13] [CHAT] Cryael: ggs
[04:17:15] Gobojr is being attacked by [Reflector Mage], [Barrin, Tolarian Archmage], and [Tidehollow Sculler].
Winner: Cryael
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Cryael: 2–1
[04:17:24] Gobojr has left the game.