PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality QuarterBad,Winnter == Game 1 (779961550) == [Time] 1637029363 [04:22:44] PDBot has started watching. [04:22:45] Winnter joined the game. [League] Esper Tallow by quarterbad (159706) vs Grixis Control by winnter (159630) [04:22:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [04:22:53] [CHAT] QuarterBad: Good luck, have fun! [04:22:55] QuarterBad chooses to play first. [04:22:58] QuarterBad begins the game with seven cards in hand. [04:23:15] Winnter begins the game with seven cards in hand. [04:23:15] Turn 1: QuarterBad [04:23:15] QuarterBad skips their draw step. [04:23:17] QuarterBad plays [Island]. [04:23:23] Turn 1: Winnter [04:23:30] Winnter plays [Mistvault Bridge]. [04:23:36] QuarterBad casts [Consider]. [04:23:39] QuarterBad draws a card with [Consider]. [04:23:40] Turn 2: QuarterBad [04:23:44] QuarterBad plays [Plains]. [04:23:47] Turn 2: Winnter [04:23:53] Winnter plays [Drossforge Bridge]. [04:23:58] Turn 3: QuarterBad [04:24:01] QuarterBad plays [Isolated Chapel]. [04:24:06] QuarterBad casts [Tallowisp]. [04:24:17] QuarterBad casts [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:24:17] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:24:35] QuarterBad reveals [Ethereal Armor]. [04:24:50] Turn 3: Winnter [04:25:06] Winnter plays [Swamp]. [04:25:09] Winnter casts [Filigree Familiar]. [04:25:11] Winnter puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.). [04:25:12] Turn 4: QuarterBad [04:25:28] QuarterBad plays [Caves of Koilos]. [04:25:35] QuarterBad casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Filigree Familiar]. [04:25:39] Winnter puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar dies, draw a card.). [04:25:41] Winnter draws a card with [Filigree Familiar]'s ability. [04:25:48] QuarterBad casts [Curious Obsession] targeting [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:25:54] Winnter is being attacked by [Usher of the Fallen] and [Tallowisp]. [04:25:58] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Usher of the Fallen] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [04:26:02] QuarterBad draws a card with [Usher of the Fallen]'s ability. [04:26:05] QuarterBad activates an ability of [Usher of the Fallen] ( Create a 1/1 white Human Warrior creature token.). [04:26:07] QuarterBad's [Usher of the Fallen] creates a Human Warrior Token. [04:26:11] Turn 4: Winnter [04:26:21] Winnter plays [Drossforge Bridge]. [04:26:30] Winnter casts [Radiant Flames] (with 3 colors). [04:26:36] Turn 5: QuarterBad [04:26:38] QuarterBad casts [Ponder]. [04:26:48] QuarterBad chooses to not shuffle his or her library. [04:26:48] QuarterBad draws a card with [Ponder]. [04:26:51] QuarterBad casts [Clarion Spirit]. [04:26:54] QuarterBad plays [Caves of Koilos]. [04:26:59] Turn 5: Winnter [04:27:20] Winnter casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Clarion Spirit]. [04:27:31] Winnter casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Drossforge Bridge]. [04:27:38] Winnter draws a card with [Cleansing Wildfire]. [04:27:42] Winnter plays [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:27:45] Turn 6: QuarterBad [04:27:47] QuarterBad casts [Ponder]. [04:27:56] QuarterBad chooses to shuffle his or her library. [04:27:56] QuarterBad draws a card with [Ponder]. [04:28:03] Turn 6: Winnter [04:28:08] Winnter plays [Drossforge Bridge]. [04:28:12] Turn 7: QuarterBad [04:28:15] QuarterBad casts [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:28:25] QuarterBad casts [Ethereal Armor] targeting [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:29:04] Turn 7: Winnter [04:29:24] Winnter casts [Ardent Elementalist]. [04:29:42] Winnter puts triggered ability from [Ardent Elementalist] onto the stack targeting [Bloodchief's Thirst] (When Ardent Elementalist enters the battlefield, return target instant or sorcery card from your g...). [04:29:45] Winnter returns [Bloodchief's Thirst] to its owner's hand with [Ardent Elementalist]'s ability. [04:29:51] Winnter casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:29:56] QuarterBad casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Bloodchief's Thirst]. [04:30:06] Winnter casts [Lose Focus] targeting [Memory Lapse]. [04:30:10] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:30:14] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:30:18] Turn 8: QuarterBad [04:30:20] QuarterBad casts [Consider]. [04:30:23] QuarterBad draws a card with [Consider]. [04:30:25] QuarterBad plays [Island]. [04:30:29] QuarterBad casts [Tallowisp]. [04:30:35] Turn 8: Winnter [04:30:46] Winnter casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:30:56] Winnter draws a card with [Cleansing Wildfire]. [04:31:05] Winnter plays [Mistvault Bridge]. [04:31:17] Turn 9: QuarterBad [04:31:23] QuarterBad casts [Clarion Spirit]. [04:31:23] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:31:33] QuarterBad reveals [Staggering Insight]. [04:31:45] Winnter casts [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:31:51] QuarterBad casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:32:02] QuarterBad casts [Staggering Insight] targeting [Tallowisp]. [04:32:07] Winnter is being attacked by [Tallowisp]. [04:32:15] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, draw a card.). [04:32:16] QuarterBad draws a card with [Tallowisp]'s ability. [04:32:23] Turn 9: Winnter [04:33:10] Winnter casts [Silumgar's Command] targeting [Tallowisp] (Return to hand), and [Clarion Spirit] (-3/-3). [04:33:14] Winnter returns [Tallowisp] to its owner's hand with [Silumgar's Command]. [04:33:19] QuarterBad is being attacked by [Ardent Elementalist]. [04:33:22] Winnter plays [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:33:24] Turn 10: QuarterBad [04:33:31] QuarterBad casts [Tallowisp]. [04:33:38] QuarterBad casts [Ponder]. [04:33:50] QuarterBad chooses to not shuffle his or her library. [04:33:50] QuarterBad draws a card with [Ponder]. [04:33:52] QuarterBad casts [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:33:52] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:34:03] QuarterBad reveals [Ethereal Armor]. [04:34:18] Winnter casts [Lose Focus] (Replicated 1 time) targeting [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:34:18] Winnter puts triggered ability from [Lose Focus] onto the stack (Replicate {U} (When you cast this spell, copy it for each time you paid its replicate cost @b(1)...). [04:34:28] Winnter's [Lose Focus] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [04:34:36] QuarterBad casts [Treasure Cruise]. [04:34:38] QuarterBad draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise]. [04:34:40] QuarterBad plays [Glacial Fortress]. [04:34:43] QuarterBad casts [Sisay's Ingenuity] targeting [Tallowisp]. [04:34:47] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Sisay's Ingenuity] onto the stack (When Sisay's Ingenuity enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [04:34:51] QuarterBad draws a card with [Sisay's Ingenuity]'s ability. [04:34:54] QuarterBad casts [Ethereal Armor] targeting [Tallowisp]. [04:34:59] Turn 10: Winnter [04:35:07] Winnter plays [Swamp]. [04:35:12] Turn 11: QuarterBad [04:35:17] QuarterBad casts [Tallowisp]. [04:35:17] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:35:23] QuarterBad reveals [Mogis's Favor]. [04:35:37] Winnter casts [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:35:40] QuarterBad casts [Consider]. [04:35:47] QuarterBad draws a card with [Consider]. [04:35:49] Winnter puts triggered ability from [Voracious Greatshark] onto the stack targeting [Tallowisp] (When Voracious Greatshark enters the battlefield, counter target artifact or creature spell.). [04:35:55] QuarterBad plays [Glacial Fortress]. [04:35:58] QuarterBad casts [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:35:58] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:36:02] QuarterBad reveals [Dead Weight]. [04:36:13] QuarterBad casts [Ponder]. [04:36:26] QuarterBad chooses to not shuffle his or her library. [04:36:26] QuarterBad draws a card with [Ponder]. [04:36:31] QuarterBad casts [Mogis's Favor] targeting [Ardent Elementalist]. [04:36:38] QuarterBad casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:36:44] Winnter is being attacked by [Tallowisp]. [04:36:50] [Voracious Greatshark] blocks [Tallowisp]. [04:36:56] Turn 11: Winnter [04:37:00] Winnter plays [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:37:04] Turn 12: QuarterBad [04:37:07] QuarterBad plays [Isolated Chapel]. [04:37:17] QuarterBad exiles [Memory Lapse] and [Staggering Insight] with with [Mogis's Favor]'s ability. [04:37:17] QuarterBad casts [Mogis's Favor] from the graveyard for its escape cost targeting [Tallowisp]. [04:37:21] Winnter is being attacked by [Usher of the Fallen] and [Tallowisp]. [04:37:28] QuarterBad activates an ability of [Usher of the Fallen] ( Create a 1/1 white Human Warrior creature token.). [04:37:28] QuarterBad's [Usher of the Fallen] creates a Human Warrior Token. [04:37:30] Turn 12: Winnter [04:37:40] Winnter casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Tallowisp]. [04:37:47] QuarterBad casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Bloodchief's Thirst]. [04:37:53] Winnter has conceded from the game. Winner: QuarterBad Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (779962934) == [Time] 1637030378 [04:39:38] PDBot has started watching. [04:39:43] Winnter chooses to play first. [04:39:48] Winnter begins the game with seven cards in hand. [04:39:49] QuarterBad begins the game with seven cards in hand. [04:39:49] Turn 1: Winnter [04:39:49] Winnter skips their draw step. [04:39:53] Winnter plays [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:39:55] Turn 1: QuarterBad [04:39:56] QuarterBad plays [Plains]. [04:39:58] QuarterBad casts [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:40:02] Turn 2: Winnter [04:40:05] Winnter plays [Swamp]. [04:40:09] Winnter casts [Bloodchief's Thirst] targeting [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:40:11] Turn 2: QuarterBad [04:40:13] QuarterBad plays [Glacial Fortress]. [04:40:16] QuarterBad casts [Clarion Spirit]. [04:40:22] Turn 3: Winnter [04:40:26] Winnter plays [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:40:30] Winnter casts [Heartless Act] targeting [Clarion Spirit] (Destroy target creature with no counters on it.). [04:40:33] Turn 3: QuarterBad [04:40:38] QuarterBad casts [Consider]. [04:40:41] QuarterBad draws a card with [Consider]. [04:40:42] QuarterBad plays [Plains]. [04:40:45] QuarterBad casts [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:40:49] Turn 4: Winnter [04:41:09] Winnter casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:41:17] Winnter draws a card with [Cleansing Wildfire]. [04:41:22] Turn 4: QuarterBad [04:41:27] Winnter is being attacked by [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:41:36] QuarterBad casts [Ethereal Armor] targeting [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:41:50] Turn 5: Winnter [04:42:09] Turn 5: QuarterBad [04:42:12] QuarterBad plays [Caves of Koilos]. [04:42:19] QuarterBad casts [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:42:29] Winnter casts [Sudden Edict] targeting QuarterBad. [04:42:34] QuarterBad sacrifices [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:42:41] Turn 6: Winnter [04:42:44] Winnter plays [Swamp]. [04:42:49] Turn 6: QuarterBad [04:42:52] QuarterBad plays [Isolated Chapel]. [04:42:54] QuarterBad casts [Duress] targeting Winnter. [04:43:31] Winnter discards [Fact or Fiction]. [04:43:31] Winnter reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Lose Focus], [Voracious Greatshark], [Spell Pierce], and [Cruel Ultimatum]. [04:43:46] Winnter casts [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:43:50] QuarterBad casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:43:53] Turn 7: Winnter [04:43:58] Turn 7: QuarterBad [04:44:10] Winnter casts [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:44:11] No legal targets to choose for triggered ability from [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:44:13] Turn 8: Winnter [04:44:19] QuarterBad is being attacked by [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:44:28] Winnter casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Silverbluff Bridge]. [04:44:33] QuarterBad casts [Negate] targeting [Cleansing Wildfire]. [04:44:43] Turn 8: QuarterBad [04:44:46] QuarterBad casts [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:44:51] QuarterBad casts [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:45:01] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:45:07] Turn 9: Winnter [04:45:13] QuarterBad is being attacked by [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:45:17] Turn 9: QuarterBad [04:45:23] QuarterBad casts [Curious Obsession] targeting [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:45:58] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon], [Hateful Eidolon], and [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:46:01] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [04:46:04] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:46:08] Turn 10: Winnter [04:46:19] Winnter plays [Island]. [04:46:26] Turn 10: QuarterBad [04:46:36] QuarterBad casts [Ponder]. [04:46:41] QuarterBad chooses to shuffle his or her library. [04:46:41] QuarterBad draws a card with [Ponder]. [04:46:48] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:46:52] [Voracious Greatshark] blocks [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:46:56] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:46:56] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:46:56] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:46:59] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:47:01] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:47:03] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:47:05] QuarterBad plays [Isolated Chapel]. [04:47:08] QuarterBad casts [Duress] targeting Winnter. [04:47:28] Winnter discards [Cruel Ultimatum]. [04:47:28] Winnter reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Lose Focus], [Lose Focus], and [Spell Pierce]. [04:47:36] Turn 11: Winnter [04:47:46] QuarterBad is being attacked by [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:47:53] Winnter plays [Mountain]. [04:48:00] QuarterBad discards [Rebuild]. [04:48:01] QuarterBad cycles [Rebuild]. [04:48:04] Turn 11: QuarterBad [04:48:15] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon] and [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:48:20] QuarterBad plays [Plains]. [04:48:22] QuarterBad casts [Tallowisp]. [04:49:02] QuarterBad casts [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:49:03] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:49:04] QuarterBad reveals [Ethereal Armor]. [04:49:04] Turn 12: Winnter [04:49:07] Winnter plays [Island]. [04:49:15] QuarterBad casts [Consider]. [04:49:18] QuarterBad draws a card with [Consider]. [04:49:19] Turn 12: QuarterBad [04:49:22] QuarterBad plays [Isolated Chapel]. [04:49:25] QuarterBad casts [Ethereal Armor] targeting [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:49:31] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:49:39] Turn 13: Winnter [04:50:09] Turn 13: QuarterBad [04:50:31] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:50:37] Winnter casts [Silumgar's Command] targeting [Hateful Eidolon] (Return to hand), and [Hateful Eidolon] (-3/-3). [04:50:43] Winnter returns [Hateful Eidolon] to its owner's hand with [Silumgar's Command]. [04:50:48] QuarterBad plays [Caves of Koilos]. [04:50:51] QuarterBad casts [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:50:51] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:51:02] QuarterBad reveals [Mogis's Favor]. [04:51:10] QuarterBad casts [Mogis's Favor] targeting [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:51:15] Turn 14: Winnter [04:51:18] Winnter plays [Mistvault Bridge]. [04:51:24] Turn 14: QuarterBad [04:51:32] Winnter is being attacked by [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:51:35] [Voracious Greatshark] blocks [Hateful Eidolon]. [04:51:38] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:51:38] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:51:41] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:51:43] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:51:45] QuarterBad plays [Island]. [04:51:53] QuarterBad exiles [Memory Lapse] and [Usher of the Fallen] with with [Mogis's Favor]'s ability. [04:51:53] QuarterBad casts [Mogis's Favor] from the graveyard for its escape cost targeting [Voracious Greatshark]. [04:51:55] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Hateful Eidolon] onto the stack (Whenever an enchanted creature dies, draw a card for each Aura you controlled that was attached to...). [04:51:58] QuarterBad draws a card with [Hateful Eidolon]'s ability. [04:52:01] QuarterBad casts [Ponder]. [04:52:05] QuarterBad chooses to shuffle his or her library. [04:52:05] QuarterBad draws a card with [Ponder]. [04:52:08] QuarterBad casts [Usher of the Fallen]. [04:52:08] QuarterBad puts triggered ability from [Tallowisp] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Spirit or Arcane spell, you may search your library for an Aura card with ench...). [04:52:13] QuarterBad reveals [Staggering Insight]. [04:52:18] Turn 15: Winnter [04:52:21] Winnter plays [Island]. [04:52:24] [CHAT] Winnter: gg [04:52:27] Winnter has conceded from the game. Winner: QuarterBad Game 2 Completed. Match Winner: QuarterBad: 2–0 [04:52:35] QuarterBad has left the game.