PennyDreadful
PD fnm R3 vs Shadowater0
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Shadowater0,NimbleThroatPunch

== Game 1 (773494320) ==
[Time] 1630715974
[03:39:34] PDBot has started watching.
[03:39:34] Shadowater0 joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 21.06
[Gatherling] Round=3
[03:39:43] [CHAT] NimbleThroatPunch: yo glhf
[03:39:44] [CHAT] Shadowater0: hey, gl hf
[03:39:46] Shadowater0 chooses to play first.
[03:39:52] Shadowater0 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:39:54] NimbleThroatPunch mulligans to six cards.
[03:39:59] NimbleThroatPunch puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[03:39:59] Turn 1: Shadowater0
[03:39:59] Shadowater0 skips their draw step.
[03:40:01] Shadowater0 plays [Island].
[03:40:03] Shadowater0 casts [Ponder].
[03:40:32] Shadowater0 chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[03:40:32] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Ponder].
[03:40:35] Turn 1: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:40:39] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Hissing Quagmire].
[03:40:45] Turn 2: Shadowater0
[03:40:50] Shadowater0 plays [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:40:52] Shadowater0 casts [Ponder].
[03:41:10] Shadowater0 chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[03:41:10] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Ponder].
[03:41:12] Turn 2: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:41:16] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Forest].
[03:41:19] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Shadowater0.
[03:41:41] Shadowater0 reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Island], [Cascading Cataracts], [Explosion], [Expansion], [Expansion/Explosion], [Seething Song], [Explosion], [Expansion], and [Expansion/Explosion].
[03:41:44] Turn 3: Shadowater0
[03:41:51] Shadowater0 casts [See Beyond].
[03:41:55] Shadowater0 draws two cards with [See Beyond].
[03:42:00] Shadowater0 plays [Island].
[03:42:02] Turn 3: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:42:06] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Sunpetal Grove].
[03:42:10] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:42:13] Turn 4: Shadowater0
[03:42:17] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[03:42:23] Turn 4: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:42:29] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:42:33] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Swamp].
[03:42:37] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Coercive Portal].
[03:42:43] Turn 5: Shadowater0
[03:42:45] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[03:42:52] Turn 5: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:42:52] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Coercive Portal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, starting with you, each player votes for carnage or homage. If ca...).
[03:42:56] NimbleThroatPunch votes for Homage
[03:43:01] Shadowater0 votes for Carnage
[03:43:01] NimbleThroatPunch draws a card with [Coercive Portal]'s ability.
[03:43:16] NimbleThroatPunch discards [Timeless Dragon].
[03:43:16] NimbleThroatPunch cycles [Timeless Dragon].
[03:43:22] NimbleThroatPunch reveals [Scattered Groves].
[03:43:24] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Scattered Groves].
[03:43:26] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Fauna Shaman].
[03:43:35] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:43:45] Turn 6: Shadowater0
[03:43:47] Shadowater0 plays [Cascading Cataracts].
[03:43:54] Shadowater0 casts [Explosion] targeting [Fauna Shaman] (X damage), and Shadowater0. (X is 2).
[03:43:56] Shadowater0 draws two cards with [Explosion].
[03:44:02] Turn 6: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:44:02] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Coercive Portal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, starting with you, each player votes for carnage or homage. If ca...).
[03:44:05] NimbleThroatPunch votes for Homage
[03:44:07] Shadowater0 votes for Carnage
[03:44:07] NimbleThroatPunch draws a card with [Coercive Portal]'s ability.
[03:44:19] NimbleThroatPunch exiles [Timeless Dragon] with [Timeless Dragon]'s ability.
[03:44:19] NimbleThroatPunch activates an ability of [Timeless Dragon] (Eternalize {2WW}).
[03:44:19] NimbleThroatPunch's [Timeless Dragon] creates a Timeless Dragon.
[03:44:22] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Stirring Wildwood].
[03:44:25] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:44:28] Turn 7: Shadowater0
[03:44:41] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[03:44:48] Shadowater0 casts [Niv-Mizzet, Parun].
[03:44:53] Turn 7: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:44:53] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Coercive Portal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, starting with you, each player votes for carnage or homage. If ca...).
[03:44:59] NimbleThroatPunch votes for Homage
[03:45:02] Shadowater0 votes for Carnage
[03:45:02] NimbleThroatPunch draws a card with [Coercive Portal]'s ability.
[03:45:06] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Plains].
[03:45:18] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:45:23] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Coercive Portal].
[03:45:28] Turn 8: Shadowater0
[03:45:36] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack targeting [Timeless Dragon] (Whenever you draw a card, Niv-Mizzet, Parun deals 1 damage to any target.).
[03:45:44] Shadowater0 casts [Fire Prophecy] targeting [Timeless Dragon].
[03:45:44] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack (Whenever a player casts an instant or sorcery spell, you draw a card.).
[03:45:46] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Niv-Mizzet, Parun]'s ability.
[03:45:51] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack targeting NimbleThroatPunch (Whenever you draw a card, Niv-Mizzet, Parun deals 1 damage to any target.).
[03:45:57] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Fire Prophecy].
[03:46:01] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack targeting NimbleThroatPunch (Whenever you draw a card, Niv-Mizzet, Parun deals 1 damage to any target.).
[03:46:10] Shadowater0 casts [Geomancer's Gambit] targeting [Cascading Cataracts].
[03:46:10] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack (Whenever a player casts an instant or sorcery spell, you draw a card.).
[03:46:10] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Niv-Mizzet, Parun]'s ability.
[03:46:14] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack targeting NimbleThroatPunch (Whenever you draw a card, Niv-Mizzet, Parun deals 1 damage to any target.).
[03:46:20] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Geomancer's Gambit].
[03:46:23] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack targeting NimbleThroatPunch (Whenever you draw a card, Niv-Mizzet, Parun deals 1 damage to any target.).
[03:46:31] Shadowater0 plays [Izzet Boilerworks].
[03:46:31] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Izzet Boilerworks] onto the stack (When Izzet Boilerworks enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[03:46:37] Shadowater0 returns [Cascading Cataracts] to its owner's hand with [Izzet Boilerworks]'s ability.
[03:46:41] NimbleThroatPunch is being attacked by [Niv-Mizzet, Parun].
[03:46:44] Turn 8: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:46:45] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Coercive Portal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, starting with you, each player votes for carnage or homage. If ca...).
[03:46:45] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Coercive Portal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, starting with you, each player votes for carnage or homage. If ca...).
[03:46:52] NimbleThroatPunch votes for Homage
[03:46:53] Shadowater0 votes for Carnage
[03:46:54] NimbleThroatPunch draws a card with [Coercive Portal]'s ability.
[03:46:57] NimbleThroatPunch votes for Homage
[03:46:59] Shadowater0 votes for Carnage
[03:46:59] NimbleThroatPunch draws a card with [Coercive Portal]'s ability.
[03:47:06] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Forest].
[03:47:08] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Anguished Unmaking] targeting [Niv-Mizzet, Parun].
[03:47:09] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack (Whenever a player casts an instant or sorcery spell, you draw a card.).
[03:47:11] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Niv-Mizzet, Parun]'s ability.
[03:47:15] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Niv-Mizzet, Parun] onto the stack targeting NimbleThroatPunch (Whenever you draw a card, Niv-Mizzet, Parun deals 1 damage to any target.).
[03:47:21] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Warden of the First Tree].
[03:47:28] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Tocatli Honor Guard] and [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:47:34] Turn 9: Shadowater0
[03:47:41] Shadowater0 plays [Cascading Cataracts].
[03:47:48] Shadowater0 casts [Seething Song].
[03:48:30] Shadowater0 casts [Solve the Equation].
[03:48:43] Shadowater0 reveals [Seething Song].
[03:48:46] Shadowater0 casts [Seething Song].
[03:49:01] Shadowater0 casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:49:14] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Cleansing Wildfire].
[03:49:16] Shadowater0 casts [Dragonstorm].
[03:49:16] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Dragonstorm] onto the stack (4 spells cast before Dragonstorm this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each sp...).
[03:49:33] Shadowater0 fails to find a Dragon permanent card.
[03:49:36] Shadowater0 fails to find a Dragon permanent card.
[03:49:45] NimbleThroatPunch is being attacked by [Karrthus, Tyrant of Jund], [Glorybringer], and [Bogardan Hellkite].
[03:49:47] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Glorybringer] onto the stack targeting [Warden of the First Tree] (Whenever Glorybringer attacks and exerts, it deals 4 damage to target non-Dragon creature an oppon...).
[03:49:53] NimbleThroatPunch has conceded from the game.
Winner: Shadowater0
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (773495318) ==
[Time] 1630716727
[03:52:08] PDBot has started watching.
[03:52:13] NimbleThroatPunch chooses to play first.
[03:52:16] NimbleThroatPunch mulligans to six cards.
[03:52:20] Shadowater0 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:52:24] NimbleThroatPunch puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[03:52:24] Turn 1: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:52:24] NimbleThroatPunch skips their draw step.
[03:52:25] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Forest].
[03:52:26] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Birds of Paradise].
[03:52:28] Turn 1: Shadowater0
[03:52:30] Shadowater0 plays [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:52:32] Turn 2: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:52:34] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Stirring Wildwood].
[03:52:37] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Kitesail Freebooter].
[03:52:38] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Kitesail Freebooter] onto the stack targeting Shadowater0 (When Kitesail Freebooter enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a ...).
[03:52:39] Shadowater0 reveals their hand to [Kitesail Freebooter]'s ability, containing [Lathliss, Dragon Queen], [Explosion], [Expansion], [Expansion/Explosion], [Seething Song], [Island], [See Beyond], [Silverbluff Bridge], and [Island].
[03:52:59] Turn 2: Shadowater0
[03:53:03] Shadowater0 plays [Island].
[03:53:06] Shadowater0 casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:53:10] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Cleansing Wildfire].
[03:53:12] Turn 3: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:53:15] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Fauna Shaman].
[03:53:18] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Kitesail Freebooter].
[03:53:27] Turn 3: Shadowater0
[03:53:33] Shadowater0 plays [Island].
[03:54:00] Shadowater0 casts [Seething Song].
[03:54:05] Shadowater0 casts [Lathliss, Dragon Queen].
[03:54:07] Turn 4: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:54:12] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Tocatli Honor Guard].
[03:54:14] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[03:54:20] Turn 4: Shadowater0
[03:54:25] Shadowater0 casts [Cleansing Wildfire] targeting [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:54:29] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Cleansing Wildfire].
[03:54:31] Shadowater0 casts [Ponder].
[03:54:37] Shadowater0 chooses to shuffle his or her library.
[03:54:37] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Ponder].
[03:54:39] Shadowater0 plays [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:54:48] NimbleThroatPunch is being attacked by [Lathliss, Dragon Queen].
[03:54:52] Turn 5: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:54:56] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[03:55:02] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Hissing Quagmire].
[03:55:05] NimbleThroatPunch discards [Varolz, the Scar-Striped].
[03:55:05] NimbleThroatPunch activates an ability of [Fauna Shaman] ( Search your library for a creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle.).
[03:55:08] NimbleThroatPunch reveals [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[03:55:10] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[03:55:12] Turn 5: Shadowater0
[03:55:21] Shadowater0 has conceded from the game.
Winner: NimbleThroatPunch
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (773495588) ==
[Time] 1630716958
[03:55:58] PDBot has started watching.
[03:56:01] Shadowater0 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:56:04] NimbleThroatPunch begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[03:56:04] Turn 1: Shadowater0
[03:56:04] Shadowater0 skips their draw step.
[03:56:05] Shadowater0 plays [Island].
[03:56:07] Shadowater0 casts [Ponder].
[03:56:16] Shadowater0 chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[03:56:16] Shadowater0 draws a card with [Ponder].
[03:56:17] Turn 1: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:56:20] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[03:56:22] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Birds of Paradise].
[03:56:24] Turn 2: Shadowater0
[03:56:27] Shadowater0 plays [Silverbluff Bridge].
[03:56:29] Turn 2: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:56:57] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Birds of Paradise].
[03:57:02] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Birds of Paradise].
[03:57:05] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Hissing Quagmire].
[03:57:07] Turn 3: Shadowater0
[03:57:08] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[03:57:11] Shadowater0 casts [Solve the Equation].
[03:57:17] Shadowater0 reveals [Sweltering Suns].
[03:57:21] Turn 3: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:57:26] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Shadowater0.
[03:57:34] Shadowater0 reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Smelt], [Vandalblast], [Steel Hellkite], [Mountain], and [Mountain].
[03:57:36] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[03:57:37] NimbleThroatPunch puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Dreadnought] onto the stack (When Phyrexian Dreadnought enters the battlefield, sacrifice it unless you sacrifice any number of...).
[03:57:42] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Tend the Pests].
[03:57:43] NimbleThroatPunch's [Tend the Pests] creates twelve Pest tokens.
[03:57:47] NimbleThroatPunch plays [Sunpetal Grove].
[03:57:49] Turn 4: Shadowater0
[03:57:53] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[03:57:59] Turn 4: NimbleThroatPunch
[03:58:07] Shadowater0 is being attacked by [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, [Pest] token, 
[03:58:07] [Pest] token, and [Pest] token.
[03:58:16] NimbleThroatPunch casts [Timeless Dragon].
[03:58:18] Turn 5: Shadowater0
[03:58:21] [CHAT] Shadowater0: ggs
[03:58:23] [CHAT] NimbleThroatPunch: ggs
[03:58:23] Shadowater0 has conceded from the game.
Winner: NimbleThroatPunch
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: NimbleThroatPunch: 2–1
[03:58:28] Shadowater0 has left the game.