PennyDreadful
pd s21 testing
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Byvci,schwift_justice

== Game 1 (769987172) ==
[Time] 1627619519
[07:31:59] PDBot has started watching.
[07:32:03] schwift_justice chooses to play first.
[07:32:06] schwift_justice begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[07:32:08] Byvci begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[07:32:09] Turn 1: schwift_justice
[07:32:09] schwift_justice skips their draw step.
[07:32:10] schwift_justice plays [Mountain].
[07:32:11] schwift_justice casts [Faithless Looting].
[07:32:11] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Faithless Looting[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[07:32:13] schwift_justice draws two cards with [Faithless Looting].
[07:32:22] schwift_justice discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[07:32:22] schwift_justice discards [Plains].
[07:32:22] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Golgari Grave-Troll[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[07:32:26] Turn 1: Byvci
[07:32:32] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:32:41] Byvci casts [Usher of the Fallen].
[07:32:43] Turn 2: schwift_justice
[07:32:51] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:32:51] schwift_justice mills [Smiting Helix], [Shriekhorn], [Shriekhorn], [Thrilling Discovery], [Narcomoeba] and [Faithless Looting].
[07:32:51] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[07:32:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Narcomoeba[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[sG] In order to prevent further spamming, I'll stop warning you now.
[sG] For more information about Penny Dreadful, see pdmtgo.com or reddit.com/r/PennyDreadfulMTG
[07:33:07] schwift_justice plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[07:33:14] schwift_justice discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[07:33:14] schwift_justice discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[07:33:14] schwift_justice casts [Cathartic Reunion].
[07:33:14] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Stinkweed Imp[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Stinkweed Imp` or `!notbugged Stinkweed Imp`
[07:33:16] schwift_justice draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion].
[07:33:17] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:33:17] schwift_justice mills [Shriekhorn], [Faithless Looting], [Thrilling Discovery], [Smiting Helix], [Golgari Grave-Troll] and [Silversmote Ghoul].
[07:33:19] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:33:19] schwift_justice mills [Clifftop Retreat], [Thrilling Discovery], [Mountain], [Smiting Helix], [Narcomoeba] and [Battlefield Forge].
[07:33:20] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:33:20] schwift_justice mills [Cathartic Reunion], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Battlefield Forge] and [Insolent Neonate].
[07:33:20] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[07:33:28] Turn 2: Byvci
[07:33:30] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:33:34] Byvci casts [Student of Warfare].
[07:33:34] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Student of Warfare[sU] has a graphical bug.
If a level-up card would gain an ability that it would through leveling, it won't show it has gained that ability.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Student of Warfare` or `!notbugged Student of Warfare`
[07:33:36] Byvci casts [Student of Warfare].
[07:33:40] Turn 3: schwift_justice
[07:33:41] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:33:42] schwift_justice mills [Battlefield Forge], [Mountain], [Cathartic Reunion], [Stinkweed Imp], [Clifftop Retreat] and [Mountain].
[07:33:55] schwift_justice casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Student of Warfare].
[07:33:58] schwift_justice plays [Mountain].
[07:34:00] Byvci is being attacked by [Narcomoeba] and [Narcomoeba].
[07:34:05] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[07:34:05] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[07:34:11] Turn 3: Byvci
[07:34:16] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:34:28] Byvci casts [Precinct Captain].
[07:34:42] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Student of Warfare].
[07:34:47] Byvci activates an ability of [Student of Warfare] (Level up).
[07:34:50] Turn 4: schwift_justice
[07:34:52] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:34:52] schwift_justice mills [Pathrazer of Ulamog], [Narcomoeba], [Blazing Archon], [Clifftop Retreat] and [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[07:34:52] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[07:35:09] schwift_justice casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Precinct Captain].
[07:35:15] Byvci is being attacked by [Silversmote Ghoul], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Narcomoeba], and [Narcomoeba].
[07:35:27] [Usher of the Fallen] blocks [Silversmote Ghoul].
[07:35:32] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[07:35:35] Turn 4: Byvci
[07:35:38] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:35:42] Byvci casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:35:45] Byvci activates an ability of [Student of Warfare] (Level up).
[07:35:46] Byvci activates an ability of [Student of Warfare] (Level up).
[07:35:49] Turn 5: schwift_justice
[07:35:51] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:35:51] schwift_justice mills [Battlefield Forge], [Sire of Insanity], [Stinkweed Imp], [Cathartic Reunion], [Mountain] and [Stinkweed Imp].
[07:35:56] schwift_justice casts [Faithless Looting] from the graveyard using an alternate cost.
[07:35:57] schwift_justice draws two cards with [Faithless Looting].
[07:36:00] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:36:00] schwift_justice mills [Smiting Helix], [Narcomoeba], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Thrilling Discovery] and [Shriekhorn].
[07:36:07] schwift_justice discards [Faithless Looting].
[07:36:07] schwift_justice discards [Dread Return].
[07:36:07] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[07:36:28] schwift_justice casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Blazing Archon].
[07:36:35] Byvci is being attacked by [Narcomoeba], [Narcomoeba], and [Narcomoeba].
[07:36:39] Turn 5: Byvci
[07:36:43] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:36:47] Byvci casts [Benalish Marshal].
[07:36:49] Byvci casts [Doomed Traveler].
[07:36:52] Byvci activates an ability of [Student of Warfare] (Level up).
[07:36:54] Turn 6: schwift_justice
[07:36:58] littlefield has started watching.
[07:37:00] schwift_justice casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting Byvci.
[07:37:05] Byvci has conceded from the game.
Winner: schwift_justice
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (769987636) ==
[Time] 1627619885
[07:38:05] PDBot has started watching.
[07:38:13] Byvci chooses to play first.
[07:38:17] Byvci begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[07:38:19] schwift_justice begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[07:38:19] Turn 1: Byvci
[07:38:19] Byvci skips their draw step.
[07:38:20] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:38:22] Byvci casts [Hunted Witness].
[07:38:23] Turn 1: schwift_justice
[07:38:24] schwift_justice plays [Mountain].
[07:38:26] schwift_justice casts [Faithless Looting].
[07:38:27] schwift_justice draws two cards with [Faithless Looting].
[07:38:29] schwift_justice discards [Smiting Helix].
[07:38:29] schwift_justice discards [Mountain].
[07:38:31] Turn 2: Byvci
[07:38:38] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:38:44] Byvci casts [Precinct Captain].
[07:38:47] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Hunted Witness].
[07:38:49] Turn 2: schwift_justice
[07:38:51] schwift_justice plays [Battlefield Forge].
[07:38:53] schwift_justice casts [Thrilling Discovery].
[07:38:58] schwift_justice discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[07:38:58] schwift_justice discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[07:38:58] schwift_justice draws three cards with [Thrilling Discovery].
[07:38:59] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:38:59] schwift_justice mills [Clifftop Retreat], [Shriekhorn], [Battlefield Forge], [Cathartic Reunion] and [Thrilling Discovery].
[07:39:01] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:39:01] schwift_justice mills [Faithless Looting], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Narcomoeba], [Golgari Grave-Troll] and [Cathartic Reunion].
[07:39:02] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:39:02] schwift_justice mills [Smiting Helix], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Thrilling Discovery], [Faithless Looting], [Mountain] and [Clifftop Retreat].
[07:39:02] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[07:39:08] Turn 3: Byvci
[07:39:13] Byvci casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:39:17] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Precinct Captain] and [Hunted Witness].
[07:39:19] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Precinct Captain] onto the stack (Whenever Precinct Captain deals combat damage to a player, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature tok...).
[07:39:21] Byvci's [Precinct Captain] creates a Soldier token.
[07:39:24] Turn 3: schwift_justice
[07:39:26] schwift_justice plays [Mountain].
[07:39:31] schwift_justice casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Precinct Captain].
[07:39:36] schwift_justice exiles [Precinct Captain] with with [Force of Virtue]'s ability.
[07:39:36] Byvci casts [Force of Virtue] using an alternate cost.
[07:39:46] Byvci is being attacked by [Narcomoeba].
[07:39:52] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[07:39:52] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...).
[07:39:59] Turn 4: Byvci
[07:40:03] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:40:05] Byvci casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:40:12] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Precinct Captain], and [Hunted Witness].
[07:40:15] schwift_justice discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[07:40:15] schwift_justice casts [Lightning Axe] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[07:40:21] Byvci casts [Brave the Elements].
[07:40:24] Byvci chooses red.
[07:40:26] schwift_justice's [Lightning Axe] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[07:40:28] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Precinct Captain] onto the stack (Whenever Precinct Captain deals combat damage to a player, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature tok...).
[07:40:29] Byvci's [Precinct Captain] creates a Soldier token.
[07:40:34] Turn 4: schwift_justice
[07:40:35] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:40:35] schwift_justice mills [Cathartic Reunion], [Shriekhorn], [Mountain], [Mountain], [Stinkweed Imp] and [Lightning Axe].
[07:41:05] schwift_justice casts [Faithless Looting] from the graveyard using an alternate cost.
[07:41:08] schwift_justice draws two cards with [Faithless Looting].
[07:41:09] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:41:09] schwift_justice mills [Cathartic Reunion], [Mountain], [Narcomoeba], [Silversmote Ghoul] and [Clifftop Retreat].
[07:41:19] schwift_justice discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[07:41:19] schwift_justice discards [Smiting Helix].
[07:41:19] schwift_justice puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[07:41:24] Turn 5: Byvci
[07:41:30] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Precinct Captain], and [Hunted Witness].
[07:41:31] [Narcomoeba] blocks [Hunted Witness].
[07:41:32] [Silversmote Ghoul] blocks [Precinct Captain].
[07:41:33] [Silversmote Ghoul] blocks [Soldier] token.
[07:41:34] [Narcomoeba] blocks [Soldier] token.
[07:41:40] Turn 5: schwift_justice
[07:41:43] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:41:43] schwift_justice mills [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Battlefield Forge], [Clifftop Retreat], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Blazing Archon] and [Battlefield Forge].
[07:41:51] schwift_justice has conceded from the game.
Winner: Byvci
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (769988180) ==
[Time] 1627620298
[07:44:58] PDBot has started watching.
[07:45:07] schwift_justice chooses to play first.
[07:45:11] schwift_justice begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[07:45:12] Byvci begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[07:45:12] Turn 1: schwift_justice
[07:45:12] schwift_justice skips their draw step.
[07:45:14] schwift_justice plays [Battlefield Forge].
[07:45:16] Turn 1: Byvci
[07:45:18] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:45:20] Glenghiskhan has started watching.
[07:45:21] Byvci casts [Doomed Traveler].
[07:45:23] Glenghiskhan has stopped watching.
[07:45:27] Turn 2: schwift_justice
[07:45:28] schwift_justice plays [Clifftop Retreat].
[07:45:32] Turn 2: Byvci
[07:45:34] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:45:36] Byvci casts [Squadron Hawk].
[07:45:40] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Squadron Hawk] onto the stack (When Squadron Hawk enters the battlefield, you may search your library for up to three cards named...).
[07:45:55] Byvci reveals [Squadron Hawk].
[07:45:55] Byvci reveals [Squadron Hawk].
[07:46:06] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:46:10] Turn 3: schwift_justice
[07:46:15] schwift_justice casts [Thrilling Discovery].
[07:46:22] schwift_justice discards [Golgari Grave-Troll].
[07:46:22] schwift_justice discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[07:46:22] schwift_justice draws three cards with [Thrilling Discovery].
[07:46:23] schwift_justice returns [Golgari Grave-Troll] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:46:23] schwift_justice mills [Shriekhorn], [Mountain], [Thrilling Discovery], [Lightning Axe], [Clifftop Retreat] and [Cathartic Reunion].
[07:46:24] schwift_justice returns [Stinkweed Imp] to their hand with its dredge ability.
[07:46:25] schwift_justice mills [Mountain], [Dread Return], [Smiting Helix], [Thrilling Discovery] and [Plains].
[07:46:35] schwift_justice exiles [Squadron Hawk] with with [Force of Virtue]'s ability.
[07:46:35] Byvci casts [Force of Virtue] using an alternate cost.
[07:46:40] Turn 3: Byvci
[07:47:02] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:47:13] Byvci casts [Hunted Witness].
[07:47:17] Byvci casts [Nihil Spellbomb].
[07:47:21] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Squadron Hawk] and [Doomed Traveler].
[07:47:27] Turn 4: schwift_justice
[07:47:43] schwift_justice plays [Mountain].
[07:48:10] schwift_justice discards [Stinkweed Imp].
[07:48:10] schwift_justice casts [Lightning Axe] targeting [Squadron Hawk].
[07:48:21] Byvci casts [Brave the Elements].
[07:48:26] Byvci chooses red.
[07:48:28] schwift_justice's [Lightning Axe] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[07:48:32] Turn 4: Byvci
[07:48:35] Byvci plays [Plains].
[07:48:37] Byvci casts [Benalish Marshal].
[07:48:49] schwift_justice is being attacked by [Hunted Witness], [Squadron Hawk], and [Doomed Traveler].
[07:48:51] schwift_justice has conceded from the game.
Winner: Byvci
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Byvci: 2–1