PennyDreadful PD R3 Vs shadow438 BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney wiltay0494,shadow438 == Game 1 (757464882) == [Time] 1617064118 [11:28:39] PDBot has started watching. [Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 19.07 [Gatherling] Round=3 [11:28:42] wiltay0494 chooses to play first. [11:28:48] wiltay0494 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [11:28:56] [CHAT] wiltay0494: good luck have fun [11:28:56] shadow438 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [11:28:56] Turn 1: wiltay0494 [11:28:59] wiltay0494 skips their draw step. [11:29:01] wiltay0494 plays [Temple of Enlightenment]. [11:29:02] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Enlightenment] onto the stack (When Temple of Enlightenment enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [11:29:06] wiltay0494 puts 1 card on top of their library. [11:29:06] wiltay0494 scrys 1. [11:29:09] Turn 1: shadow438 [11:29:12] shadow438 plays [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:29:15] Turn 2: wiltay0494 [11:29:19] wiltay0494 plays [Glacial Fortress]. [11:29:24] Turn 2: shadow438 [11:29:27] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:29:29] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid]. [11:29:33] Turn 3: wiltay0494 [11:29:38] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:29:42] Turn 3: shadow438 [11:29:47] shadow438 plays [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:29:53] shadow438 casts [Narcomoeba]. [11:30:21] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Hermit Druid]. [11:30:26] Turn 4: wiltay0494 [11:30:29] wiltay0494 plays [Glacial Fortress]. [11:30:35] wiltay0494 casts [Ixalan's Binding]. [11:30:41] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Ixalan's Binding] onto the stack targeting [Hermit Druid] (When Ixalan's Binding enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls ...). [11:30:46] Turn 4: shadow438 [11:31:31] shadow438 casts [Elvish Mystic]. [11:31:39] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]. [11:31:46] shadow438 casts [Neoform]. [11:31:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Neoform[sU] has an unconfirmed bug. Neoform and Growth-Chamber Guardian interact incorrectly [11:31:49] Turn 5: wiltay0494 [11:32:01] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:32:10] wiltay0494 casts [Ixalan's Binding]. [11:32:13] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Ixalan's Binding] onto the stack targeting [Hermit Druid] (When Ixalan's Binding enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls ...). [11:32:16] Turn 5: shadow438 [11:32:28] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]. [11:32:33] Turn 6: wiltay0494 [11:32:38] wiltay0494 discards [Renewed Faith]. [11:32:38] wiltay0494 cycles [Renewed Faith]. [11:32:38] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Renewed Faith] onto the stack (When you cycle Renewed Faith, you may gain 2 life.). [11:33:00] Turn 6: shadow438 [11:33:03] shadow438 plays [Vivid Creek]. [11:33:06] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]. [11:33:16] wiltay0494 casts [Supreme Will] (Look at the top four cards of your library. Put one of them into your hand and the rest on the bot...). [11:33:25] Turn 7: wiltay0494 [11:33:28] wiltay0494 plays [Arch of Orazca]. [11:33:36] Turn 7: shadow438 [11:33:41] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]. [11:33:49] wiltay0494 casts [Azorius Charm] targeting [Narcomoeba] (Put target attacking or blocking creature on top of its owner's library.). [11:33:51] shadow438 puts [Narcomoeba] on top of their library with [Azorius Charm]. [11:33:54] shadow438 casts [Elvish Mystic]. [11:34:02] shadow438 casts [Neoform]. [11:34:11] wiltay0494 casts [Supreme Will] targeting [Neoform] (Counter target spell unless its controller pays {3}.). [11:34:19] Turn 8: wiltay0494 [11:34:22] wiltay0494 plays [Island]. [11:34:29] wiltay0494 casts [Approach of the Second Sun]. [11:34:31] wiltay0494 puts [Approach of the Second Sun] beneath the top 6 cards of their library. [11:34:38] Turn 8: shadow438 [11:34:44] Turn 9: wiltay0494 [11:34:48] wiltay0494 plays [Island]. [11:35:00] wiltay0494 casts [Approach of the Second Sun]. Winner: wiltay0494 Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (757465526) == [Time] 1617064614 [11:36:55] PDBot has started watching. [11:36:56] shadow438 mulligans to six cards. [11:36:59] wiltay0494 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [11:37:00] shadow438 mulligans to five cards. [11:37:09] shadow438 puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [11:37:09] Turn 1: shadow438 [11:37:11] shadow438 skips their draw step. [11:37:12] shadow438 plays [Centaur Garden]. [11:37:13] shadow438 casts [Fyndhorn Elves]. [11:37:17] Turn 1: wiltay0494 [11:37:21] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:37:23] Turn 2: shadow438 [11:37:26] shadow438 plays [Vivid Grove]. [11:37:27] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid]. [11:37:31] Turn 2: wiltay0494 [11:37:37] wiltay0494 plays [Glacial Fortress]. [11:37:41] Turn 3: shadow438 [11:37:51] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:37:54] shadow438 activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...). [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Vexing Shusher]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Angel of Glory's Rise]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Hapless Researcher]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Haunted Dead]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Phantasmagorian]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Laboratory Maniac]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Masked Vandal]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Riftsweeper]. [11:37:58] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter]. [11:37:58] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.). [11:37:58] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.). [11:37:58] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Phantasmagorian[sU] has an unconfirmed bug. The order of cards discarded by Phantasmagorian's ability is random Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Phantasmagorian` or `!notbugged Phantasmagorian` [11:38:04] wiltay0494 casts [Ravenous Trap] using an alternate cost targeting shadow438. [11:40:12] shadow438 casts [Memory's Journey] targeting shadow438, [Kitesail Freebooter], [Laboratory Maniac], and [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:40:59] shadow438 casts [Memory's Journey] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting shadow438, and [Vexing Shusher]. [11:41:25] wiltay0494 discards [Renewed Faith]. [11:41:25] wiltay0494 cycles [Renewed Faith]. [11:41:25] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Renewed Faith] onto the stack (When you cycle Renewed Faith, you may gain 2 life.). [11:41:30] Turn 3: wiltay0494 [11:41:36] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:41:40] Turn 4: shadow438 [11:41:46] shadow438 casts [Vexing Shusher]. [11:41:57] shadow438 casts [Fauna Shaman]. [11:42:12] wiltay0494 casts [Supreme Will] targeting [Fauna Shaman] (Counter target spell unless its controller pays {3}.). [11:42:19] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Hermit Druid]. [11:42:22] Turn 4: wiltay0494 [11:42:29] wiltay0494 plays [Island]. [11:42:33] wiltay0494 casts [Ixalan's Binding]. [11:42:37] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Ixalan's Binding] onto the stack targeting [Vexing Shusher] (When Ixalan's Binding enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls ...). [11:42:40] Turn 5: shadow438 [11:42:45] shadow438 casts [Kitesail Freebooter]. [11:42:47] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Kitesail Freebooter] onto the stack targeting wiltay0494 (When Kitesail Freebooter enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a ...). [11:42:49] wiltay0494 reveals their hand to [Kitesail Freebooter]'s ability, containing [Hieroglyphic Illumination], [Temple of Enlightenment], [Behold the Multiverse], and [Arch of Orazca]. [11:42:58] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Hermit Druid] and [Fyndhorn Elves]. [11:43:03] Turn 5: wiltay0494 [11:43:06] wiltay0494 plays [Temple of Enlightenment]. [11:43:06] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Enlightenment] onto the stack (When Temple of Enlightenment enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [11:43:11] wiltay0494 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [11:43:11] wiltay0494 scrys 1. [11:43:20] Turn 6: shadow438 [11:43:23] shadow438 plays [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:43:40] wiltay0494 casts [Hieroglyphic Illumination]. [11:43:41] wiltay0494 draws two cards with [Hieroglyphic Illumination]. [11:43:43] Turn 6: wiltay0494 [11:43:49] wiltay0494 plays [Glacial Fortress]. [11:43:54] Turn 7: shadow438 [11:43:58] shadow438 casts [Laboratory Maniac]. [11:44:05] Turn 7: wiltay0494 [11:44:12] wiltay0494 has conceded from the game. Winner: shadow438 Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (757466152) == [Time] 1617065094 [11:44:55] PDBot has started watching. [11:45:01] wiltay0494 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [11:45:04] shadow438 mulligans to six cards. [11:45:09] shadow438 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [11:45:09] Turn 1: wiltay0494 [11:45:11] wiltay0494 skips their draw step. [11:45:12] wiltay0494 plays [Glacial Fortress]. [11:45:15] Turn 1: shadow438 [11:45:18] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:45:19] shadow438 casts [Birds of Paradise]. [11:45:20] Turn 2: wiltay0494 [11:45:24] wiltay0494 plays [Island]. [11:45:26] Turn 2: shadow438 [11:45:28] shadow438 plays [Vivid Grove]. [11:45:36] Turn 3: wiltay0494 [11:45:41] wiltay0494 plays [Glacial Fortress]. [11:45:46] Turn 3: shadow438 [11:45:49] shadow438 plays [Vivid Grove]. [11:45:52] shadow438 casts [Fauna Shaman]. [11:46:01] wiltay0494 casts [Supreme Will] targeting [Fauna Shaman] (Counter target spell unless its controller pays {3}.). [11:46:04] shadow438 casts [Swan Song] targeting [Supreme Will]. [11:46:04] shadow438's [Swan Song] creates a Bird token under wiltay0494's control. [11:46:05] Turn 4: wiltay0494 [11:46:09] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:46:15] shadow438 is being attacked by [Bird] token. [11:46:20] Turn 4: shadow438 [11:46:29] shadow438 plays [Centaur Garden]. [11:46:35] shadow438 casts [Kira, Great Glass-Spinner]. [11:46:49] wiltay0494 discards [Renewed Faith]. [11:46:49] wiltay0494 cycles [Renewed Faith]. [11:46:49] wiltay0494 puts triggered ability from [Renewed Faith] onto the stack (When you cycle Renewed Faith, you may gain 2 life.). [11:47:03] Turn 5: wiltay0494 [11:47:10] wiltay0494 plays [Island]. [11:47:15] shadow438 is being attacked by [Bird] token. [11:47:24] shadow438 discards [Birds of Paradise]. [11:47:24] shadow438 activates an ability of [Fauna Shaman] ( Search your library for a creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle your libr...). [11:47:28] shadow438 reveals [Vexing Shusher]. [11:47:30] Turn 5: shadow438 [11:47:37] shadow438 casts [Vexing Shusher]. [11:47:54] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Kira, Great Glass-Spinner]. [11:48:01] Turn 6: wiltay0494 [11:48:04] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:48:12] shadow438 is being attacked by [Bird] token. [11:48:20] shadow438 discards [Phantasmagorian]. [11:48:21] shadow438 activates an ability of [Fauna Shaman] ( Search your library for a creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle your libr...). [11:48:44] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:48:45] Turn 6: shadow438 [11:49:07] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid]. [11:49:20] wiltay0494 is being attacked by [Vexing Shusher] and [Kira, Great Glass-Spinner]. [11:49:32] Turn 7: wiltay0494 [11:49:36] wiltay0494 plays [Plains]. [11:49:42] shadow438 is being attacked by [Bird] token. [11:49:53] shadow438 discards [Riftsweeper]. [11:49:53] shadow438 activates an ability of [Fauna Shaman] ( Search your library for a creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle your libr...). [11:49:57] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter]. [11:49:59] Turn 7: shadow438 [11:50:13] shadow438 casts [Kitesail Freebooter]. [11:50:15] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Kitesail Freebooter] onto the stack targeting wiltay0494 (When Kitesail Freebooter enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a ...). [11:50:20] wiltay0494 reveals their hand to [Kitesail Freebooter]'s ability, containing [Approach of the Second Sun], [Supreme Will], [Ravenous Trap], [Arch of Orazca], and [Dovin's Veto]. [11:50:42] shadow438 activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...). [11:50:48] wiltay0494 casts [Supreme Will] (Look at the top four cards of your library. Put one of them into your hand and the rest on the bot...). [11:50:57] swiftwarkite2 has started watching. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Angel of Glory's Rise]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Masked Vandal]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Hapless Researcher]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Neoform]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Laboratory Maniac]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves]. [11:51:09] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Haunted Dead]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Memory's Journey]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves]. [11:51:10] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [11:51:10] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.). [11:51:10] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.). [11:51:26] shadow438 casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Angel of Glory's Rise]. [11:51:32] wiltay0494 casts [Dovin's Veto] targeting [Dread Return]. [11:51:39] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vexing Shusher] targeting [Dread Return] ( Target spell can't be countered.). [11:51:49] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Angel of Glory's Rise] onto the stack (When Angel of Glory's Rise enters the battlefield, exile all Zombies, then return all Human creatu...). [11:51:56] wiltay0494 has conceded from the game. Winner: shadow438 Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: shadow438: 2–1