PennyDreadful
PDT R4 vs. Shadow438
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
emerald000,shadow438

== Game 1 (757045818) ==
[Time] 1616720460
[12:01:00] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 19.06
[Gatherling] Round=4
[12:01:05] [CHAT] emerald000: Hello and good luck!
[12:01:07] shadow438 chooses to play first.
[12:01:12] shadow438 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[12:01:14] emerald000 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[12:01:14] Turn 1: shadow438
[12:01:14] shadow438 skips their draw step.
[12:01:16] shadow438 plays [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:01:18] Turn 1: emerald000
[12:01:20] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:01:21] emerald000 casts [Delver of Secrets].
[12:01:22] Turn 2: shadow438
[12:01:24] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:01:27] shadow438 casts [Fauna Shaman].
[12:01:27] Turn 2: emerald000
[12:01:27] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[12:01:37] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:02:03] Turn 3: shadow438
[12:02:06] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:02:10] shadow438 discards [Fauna Shaman].
[12:02:10] shadow438 activates an ability of [Fauna Shaman] ( Search your library for a creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle your libr...).
[12:02:14] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:02:17] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid].
[12:02:22] emerald000 casts [Thought Scour] targeting emerald000.
[12:02:22] emerald000 mills [Mana Leak] and [Opt].
[12:02:22] emerald000 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[12:02:29] emerald000 casts [Unsummon] targeting [Hermit Druid].
[12:02:29] emerald000 returns [Hermit Druid] to its owner's hand with [Unsummon].
[12:02:29] Turn 3: emerald000
[12:02:29] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[12:02:38] emerald000 reveals [Thought Scour].
[12:02:40] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:02:50] shadow438 is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[12:02:51] Turn 4: shadow438
[12:02:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Insectile Aberration[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[12:02:56] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid].
[12:02:59] emerald000 casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Hermit Druid].
[12:03:04] shadow438 plays [Vivid Creek].
[12:03:16] emerald000 casts [Thought Scour] targeting emerald000.
[12:03:17] emerald000 mills [Opt] and [Island].
[12:03:17] emerald000 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[12:03:18] Turn 4: emerald000
[12:03:28] emerald000 casts [Treasure Cruise].
[12:03:30] emerald000 draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[12:03:40] shadow438 is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[12:03:46] Turn 5: shadow438
[12:03:51] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid].
[12:04:16] shadow438 casts [Birds of Paradise].
[12:04:33] emerald000 casts [Thought Scour] targeting emerald000.
[12:04:35] emerald000 mills [Unsummon] and [Island].
[12:04:35] emerald000 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[12:04:44] emerald000 casts [Opt].
[12:04:51] emerald000 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[12:04:51] emerald000 scrys 1.
[12:04:51] emerald000 draws a card with [Opt].
[12:04:52] Turn 5: emerald000
[12:04:55] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:05:06] shadow438 is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[12:05:10] Turn 6: shadow438
[12:05:16] shadow438 plays [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers].
[12:05:18] shadow438 activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Laboratory Maniac].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Memory's Journey].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Hapless Researcher].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Crashing Drawbridge].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Postmortem Lunge].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Crashing Drawbridge].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Haunted Dead].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Postmortem Lunge].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Phantasmagorian].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Postmortem Lunge].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:05:21] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba].
[12:05:21] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[12:05:21] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[12:05:21] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Neoform[sU] has an unconfirmed bug.
Neoform and Growth-Chamber Guardian interact incorrectly
[12:05:22] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Phantasmagorian[sU] has an unconfirmed bug.
The order of cards discarded by Phantasmagorian's ability is random
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Phantasmagorian` or `!notbugged Phantasmagorian`
[12:05:38] shadow438 casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:05:44] emerald000 casts [Counterspell] targeting [Dread Return].
[12:06:05] shadow438 casts [Dread Return] targeting [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:06:12] emerald000 casts [Spell Pierce] targeting [Dread Return].
[12:06:27] Turn 6: emerald000
[12:06:37] emerald000 casts [Treasure Cruise].
[12:06:39] emerald000 draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[12:06:42] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:06:47] shadow438 is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration].
[12:06:50] [Birds of Paradise] blocks [Insectile Aberration].
[12:07:07] shadow438 casts [Memory's Journey] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting shadow438, and [Hapless Researcher].
[12:07:21] Turn 7: shadow438
[12:07:29] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:07:31] shadow438 casts [Hapless Researcher].
[12:07:44] shadow438 casts [Postmortem Lunge] targeting [Laboratory Maniac]. (X is 3).
[12:07:51] emerald000 casts [Brineborn Cutthroat].
[12:07:57] emerald000 casts [Counterspell] targeting [Postmortem Lunge].
[12:07:57] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Brineborn Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell during an opponent's turn, put a +1/+1 counter on Brineborn Cutthroat.).
[12:07:59] shadow438 has conceded from the game.
Winner: emerald000
Game 1 Completed.
[12:08:03] shadow438 has left the game.

== Game 2 (757046514) ==
[Time] 1616720945
[12:09:05] PDBot has started watching.
[12:09:07] shadow438 mulligans to six cards.
[12:09:23] emerald000 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[12:09:31] shadow438 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[12:09:31] Turn 1: shadow438
[12:09:31] shadow438 skips their draw step.
[12:09:32] shadow438 plays [Centaur Garden].
[12:09:34] shadow438 casts [Birds of Paradise].
[12:09:35] Turn 1: emerald000
[12:09:38] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:09:39] Turn 2: shadow438
[12:09:48] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:09:50] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid].
[12:10:03] emerald000 casts [Opt].
[12:10:09] emerald000 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[12:10:09] emerald000 scrys 1.
[12:10:09] emerald000 draws a card with [Opt].
[12:10:09] Turn 2: emerald000
[12:10:14] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:10:27] Turn 3: shadow438
[12:10:41] shadow438 activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
[12:10:52] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba].
[12:10:52] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic].
[12:10:52] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Postmortem Lunge].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Postmortem Lunge].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Masked Vandal].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Phantasmagorian].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Kira, Great Glass-Spinner].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Narcomoeba].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Memory's Journey].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Ancient Grudge].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Haunted Dead].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Laboratory Maniac].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Hapless Researcher].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:10:53] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return].
[12:10:53] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[12:10:53] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[12:11:17] shadow438 casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:11:21] emerald000 casts [Opt].
[12:11:26] emerald000 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[12:11:26] emerald000 scrys 1.
[12:11:26] emerald000 draws a card with [Opt].
[12:11:47] emerald000 has conceded from the game.
Winner: shadow438
Game 2 Completed.
[12:11:51] emerald000 has left the game.

== Game 3 (757046786) ==
[Time] 1616721135
[12:12:15] PDBot has started watching.
[12:12:18] emerald000 chooses to play first.
[12:12:21] emerald000 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[12:12:51] shadow438 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[12:12:51] Turn 1: emerald000
[12:12:51] emerald000 skips their draw step.
[12:12:55] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:13:01] Turn 1: shadow438
[12:13:03] shadow438 plays [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:13:05] shadow438 casts [Birds of Paradise].
[12:13:09] emerald000 casts [Opt].
[12:13:14] emerald000 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[12:13:14] emerald000 scrys 1.
[12:13:14] emerald000 draws a card with [Opt].
[12:13:14] Turn 2: emerald000
[12:13:16] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:13:18] Turn 2: shadow438
[12:13:23] shadow438 plays [Vivid Creek].
[12:13:31] shadow438 casts [Fauna Shaman].
[12:13:38] emerald000 casts [Memory Lapse] targeting [Fauna Shaman].
[12:13:39] Turn 3: emerald000
[12:13:44] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:13:46] Turn 3: shadow438
[12:13:52] shadow438 casts [Fauna Shaman].
[12:13:59] emerald000 casts [Brineborn Cutthroat].
[12:14:06] emerald000 casts [Thought Scour] targeting emerald000.
[12:14:06] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Brineborn Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell during an opponent's turn, put a +1/+1 counter on Brineborn Cutthroat.).
[12:14:09] emerald000 mills [Island] and [Unsummon].
[12:14:09] emerald000 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[12:14:09] Turn 4: emerald000
[12:14:18] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:14:31] shadow438 is being attacked by [Brineborn Cutthroat].
[12:14:36] emerald000 casts [Delver of Secrets].
[12:14:39] Turn 4: shadow438
[12:14:57] shadow438 casts [Vexing Shusher].
[12:15:11] emerald000 casts [Opt].
[12:15:11] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Brineborn Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell during an opponent's turn, put a +1/+1 counter on Brineborn Cutthroat.).
[12:15:18] emerald000 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[12:15:18] emerald000 scrys 1.
[12:15:18] emerald000 draws a card with [Opt].
[12:15:22] Turn 5: emerald000
[12:15:22] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[12:15:28] emerald000 reveals [Thought Scour].
[12:15:55] emerald000 casts [Thought Scour] targeting emerald000.
[12:15:56] emerald000 mills [Silent Gravestone] and [Unsummon].
[12:15:56] emerald000 draws a card with [Thought Scour].
[12:16:07] emerald000 casts [Treasure Cruise].
[12:16:09] emerald000 draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[12:16:12] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:16:16] emerald000 casts [Delver of Secrets].
[12:16:21] shadow438 is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration] and [Brineborn Cutthroat].
[12:16:29] [Fauna Shaman] blocks [Brineborn Cutthroat].
[12:16:38] shadow438 discards [Haunted Dead].
[12:16:38] shadow438 activates an ability of [Fauna Shaman] ( Search your library for a creature card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle your libr...).
[12:16:42] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:16:49] Turn 5: shadow438
[12:17:05] shadow438 casts [Hermit Druid].
[12:17:17] emerald000 casts [Counterspell] targeting [Hermit Druid].
[12:17:18] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Brineborn Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell during an opponent's turn, put a +1/+1 counter on Brineborn Cutthroat.).
[12:17:28] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vexing Shusher] targeting [Hermit Druid] ( Target spell can't be countered.).
[12:17:31] Turn 6: emerald000
[12:17:31] emerald000 puts triggered ability from [Delver of Secrets] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, look at the top card of your library. You may reveal that card. I...).
[12:17:58] emerald000 plays [Island].
[12:18:03] shadow438 is being attacked by [Insectile Aberration] and [Brineborn Cutthroat].
[12:18:10] Turn 6: shadow438
[12:18:36] shadow438 activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Memory's Journey].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Laboratory Maniac].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Phantasmagorian].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Centaur Garden].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Fyndhorn Elves].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Kitesail Freebooter].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Kira, Great Glass-Spinner].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Yavimaya Coast].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Creek].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Fauna Shaman].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Ancient Grudge].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Wastes].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Birds of Paradise].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Masked Vandal].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Neoform].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Dread Return].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Swan Song].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Hapless Researcher].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Vivid Grove].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Llanowar Elves].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Hermit Druid].
[12:18:40] shadow438 reveals [Elvish Mystic].
[12:18:56] shadow438 casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Angel of Glory's Rise].
[12:19:04] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Angel of Glory's Rise] onto the stack (When Angel of Glory's Rise enters the battlefield, exile all Zombies, then return all Human creatu...).
[12:19:10] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Kitesail Freebooter] onto the stack targeting emerald000 (When Kitesail Freebooter enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a ...).
[12:19:10] No legal targets to choose for [Masked Vandal]'s triggered ability.
[12:19:12] emerald000 reveals their hand to [Kitesail Freebooter]'s ability, containing [Island], [Island], and [Island].
[12:19:17] shadow438 activates an ability of [Hapless Researcher] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
[12:19:19] shadow438 draws a card with [Hapless Researcher]'s ability.
[12:19:19] shadow438 wins the game by drawing a card while their library has no cards in it.
Winner: shadow438
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: shadow438: 2–1
[12:19:22] shadow438 has left the game.