PennyDreadful
PD FNM r1 vs Shadowater0
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Murpady,Shadowater0

== Game 1 (750440748) ==
[Time] 1611965611
[11:13:32] PDBot has started watching.
[11:13:32] Shadowater0 joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful FNM 18.18
[Gatherling] Round=1
[11:13:44] [CHAT] Shadowater0: hey gl hf
[11:13:46] Shadowater0 chooses to play first.
[11:13:53] [CHAT] Murpady: thx, u2
[11:13:56] Shadowater0 mulligans to six cards.
[11:14:08] Murpady begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:14:13] Shadowater0 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[11:14:13] Turn 1: Shadowater0
[11:14:13] Shadowater0 skips their draw step.
[11:14:15] Shadowater0 plays [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[11:14:17] Turn 1: Murpady
[11:14:21] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:14:40] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:14:58] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:14:59] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:15:18] Murpady plays [Bad River].
[11:15:20] Turn 2: Shadowater0
[11:15:23] Shadowater0 plays [Swamp].
[11:15:27] Shadowater0 casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Murpady.
[11:15:29] Murpady discards [Island].
[11:15:29] Murpady discards [Chromatic Star].
[11:15:34] Turn 2: Murpady
[11:15:40] Murpady activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[11:15:49] Murpady plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:15:52] Murpady casts [Ransack the Lab].
[11:16:00] Murpady puts [Ponder] and [River of Tears] into their graveyard.
[11:16:03] Turn 3: Shadowater0
[11:16:11] Shadowater0 plays [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[11:16:12] Turn 3: Murpady
[11:16:36] Murpady plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:16:40] Murpady casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:16:52] Murpady reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Sunken Ruins], [Ransack the Lab], [Frantic Search], [Island], and [Ponder].
[11:17:02] Murpady puts [Frantic Search] and [Ponder] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:17:02] Murpady puts [Island], [Ransack the Lab], and [Sunken Ruins] into their graveyard.
[11:17:05] Turn 4: Shadowater0
[11:17:28] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[11:17:32] Shadowater0 casts [Chandra, Pyromaster].
[11:17:32] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Chandra, Pyromaster[sU] has a non-functional ability bug.
Chandra, Pyromaster's ultimate resolves without copying the selected spell.
[11:17:35] Shadowater0 activates an ability of [Chandra, Pyromaster] targeting Murpady ( Chandra, Pyromaster deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker and 1 damage to up to one tar...).
[11:17:37] Turn 4: Murpady
[11:17:44] Murpady casts [Dark Ritual].
[11:17:51] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:17:56] Murpady casts [Cruel Bargain].
[11:17:56] Murpady draws four cards with [Cruel Bargain].
[11:18:07] Murpady casts [Frantic Search].
[11:18:08] Murpady draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[11:18:14] Murpady discards [Bad River].
[11:18:14] Murpady discards [Repeal].
[11:18:28] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:18:28] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:18:45] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:18:45] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:18:50] Murpady plays [Island].
[11:18:56] Murpady casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:18:56] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (6 spells cast before Tendrils of Agony this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for e...).
[11:19:26] Murpady discards [Evolving Wilds].
[11:19:26] Murpady discards [Bad River].
[11:19:26] Turn 5: Shadowater0
[11:19:33] Shadowater0 activates an ability of [Chandra, Pyromaster] targeting Murpady ( Chandra, Pyromaster deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker and 1 damage to up to one tar...).
[11:19:34] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[11:19:37] Shadowater0 casts [The Scorpion God].
[11:19:38] Turn 5: Murpady
[11:20:15] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:20:37] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:20:37] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:20:41] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:20:51] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:20:52] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:20:54] Murpady plays [Swamp].
[11:20:56] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:21:01] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:21:01] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:21:02] Murpady casts [Dark Ritual].
[11:21:05] Murpady casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:21:06] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (5 spells cast before Tendrils of Agony this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for e...).
[11:21:09] Shadowater0 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Murpady
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (750441658) ==
[Time] 1611966177
[11:22:58] PDBot has started watching.
[11:23:00] Shadowater0 chooses to play first.
[11:23:04] Shadowater0 begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:23:07] Murpady begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:23:07] Turn 1: Shadowater0
[11:23:08] Shadowater0 skips their draw step.
[11:23:09] Shadowater0 plays [Spikefield Cave].
[11:23:10] Turn 1: Murpady
[11:23:14] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:23:15] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:23:17] Murpady plays [River of Tears].
[11:23:19] Turn 2: Shadowater0
[11:23:21] Shadowater0 plays [Graven Cairns].
[11:23:27] Shadowater0 casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Murpady.
[11:23:29] Murpady casts [Brainstorm].
[11:23:29] Murpady draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[11:23:45] Murpady discards [Dark Ritual].
[11:23:45] Murpady discards [Treasure Cruise].
[11:23:45] Turn 2: Murpady
[11:23:50] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:24:03] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:24:03] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:24:04] Murpady plays [Bad River].
[11:24:07] Turn 3: Shadowater0
[11:24:10] Shadowater0 plays [Swamp].
[11:24:12] Shadowater0 discards [Barren Moor].
[11:24:12] Shadowater0 cycles [Barren Moor].
[11:24:18] Turn 3: Murpady
[11:24:25] Murpady casts [Brainstorm].
[11:24:28] Murpady draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[11:24:46] Murpady activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[11:25:05] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:25:23] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:25:23] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:25:28] Murpady plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:25:35] Shadowater0 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting Murpady.
[11:25:36] Turn 4: Shadowater0
[11:25:39] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[11:25:42] Shadowater0 casts [Tectonic Giant].
[11:25:46] Turn 4: Murpady
[11:25:51] Murpady plays [Island].
[11:25:53] Murpady casts [Dark Ritual].
[11:25:55] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:25:57] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:26:03] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:26:03] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:26:07] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:26:08] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:26:16] Murpady casts [Frantic Search].
[11:26:16] Murpady draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[11:26:32] Murpady discards [Island].
[11:26:32] Murpady discards [Feed the Swarm].
[11:26:40] Murpady casts [Ransack the Lab].
[11:26:46] Murpady puts [Dark Ritual] and [Cabal Ritual] into their graveyard.
[11:26:47] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:27:55] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:27:55] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:27:58] Murpady casts [Murmuring Mystic].
[11:28:10] Murpady casts [Frantic Search].
[11:28:11] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:28:13] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:28:14] Murpady draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[11:28:16] Murpady discards [Bad River].
[11:28:16] Murpady discards [Dark Ritual].
[11:28:26] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:28:27] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:28:27] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:28:30] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:28:34] Murpady casts [Ransack the Lab].
[11:28:34] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:28:35] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:28:42] Murpady puts [Frantic Search] and [Island] into their graveyard.
[11:28:46] Murpady casts [Brainstorm].
[11:28:46] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:28:48] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:28:49] Murpady draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[11:29:17] Turn 5: Shadowater0
[11:29:20] Shadowater0 plays [Graven Cairns].
[11:29:24] Murpady is being attacked by [Tectonic Giant].
[11:29:30] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Tectonic Giant] onto the stack (Tectonic Giant deals 3 damage to each opponent.).
[11:29:41] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Tectonic Giant].
[11:29:42] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Tectonic Giant].
[11:29:44] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Tectonic Giant].
[11:29:46] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Tectonic Giant].
[11:29:46] crazybaloth has started watching.
[11:29:50] Blockers for [Tectonic Giant] are ordered as follows: [Bird Illusion] token, [Bird Illusion] token, [Bird Illusion] token, [Bird Illusion] token
[11:29:55] Shadowater0 casts [Spikefield Hazard] targeting [Bird Illusion] token.
[11:30:06] Shadowater0 casts [Tectonic Giant].
[11:30:09] Turn 5: Murpady
[11:30:18] Murpady casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:30:18] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:30:20] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:30:21] Murpady reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Treasure Cruise], [Tendrils of Agony], [River of Tears], [Sunken Ruins], and [Tendrils of Agony].
[11:30:27] Murpady puts [Treasure Cruise] and [Tendrils of Agony] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:30:27] Murpady puts [River of Tears], [Sunken Ruins], and [Tendrils of Agony] into their graveyard.
[11:30:34] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:30:34] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:30:36] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:30:38] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:30:41] Murpady plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:30:46] Turn 6: Shadowater0
[11:31:08] Murpady is being attacked by [Tectonic Giant] and [Tectonic Giant].
[11:31:16] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Tectonic Giant] onto the stack (Exile the top two cards of your library. Choose one of them. Until the end of your next turn, you ...).
[11:31:18] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Tectonic Giant] onto the stack (Exile the top two cards of your library. Choose one of them. Until the end of your next turn, you ...).
[11:31:24] Shadowater0 chooses Burst Lightning with Tectonic Giant's ability.
[11:31:27] Shadowater0 chooses Goblin Dark-Dwellers with Tectonic Giant's ability.
[11:31:34] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Tectonic Giant].
[11:31:36] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Tectonic Giant].
[11:31:47] Shadowater0 casts [Goblin Dark-Dwellers].
[11:31:50] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Goblin Dark-Dwellers] onto the stack targeting [Hymn to Tourach] (When Goblin Dark-Dwellers enters the battlefield, you may cast target instant or sorcery card with...).
[11:31:55] Shadowater0 casts [Hymn to Tourach] from the graveyard targeting Murpady. (X is 0).
[11:31:56] Murpady discards [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:31:56] Murpady discards [Wipe Away].
[11:32:02] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[11:32:05] Murpady activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:32:11] Turn 6: Murpady
[11:32:18] Murpady casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:32:18] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:32:22] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:32:24] Murpady reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Island], [Brainstorm], [Ponder], [Eliminate], and [Repeal].
[11:32:33] Murpady puts [Ponder] and [Brainstorm] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:32:33] Murpady puts [Island], [Repeal], and [Eliminate] into their graveyard.
[11:32:38] Murpady casts [Brainstorm].
[11:32:38] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:32:40] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:32:42] Murpady draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[11:32:58] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:32:58] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...).
[11:33:00] Murpady's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token.
[11:33:13] Murpady chooses to shuffle his or her library.
[11:33:13] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:33:18] Turn 7: Shadowater0
[11:33:27] Murpady is being attacked by [Goblin Dark-Dwellers], [Tectonic Giant], and [Tectonic Giant].
[11:33:30] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Tectonic Giant] onto the stack (Tectonic Giant deals 3 damage to each opponent.).
[11:33:32] Shadowater0 puts triggered ability from [Tectonic Giant] onto the stack (Tectonic Giant deals 3 damage to each opponent.).
[11:33:35] Murpady has conceded from the game.
Winner: Shadowater0
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (750442832) ==
[Time] 1611966899
[11:34:59] PDBot has started watching.
[11:35:04] Murpady begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[11:36:20] Shadowater0 mulligans to six cards.
[11:36:27] Shadowater0 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[11:36:27] Turn 1: Murpady
[11:36:31] Murpady skips their draw step.
[11:36:33] SeismicSandwich has started watching.
[11:36:34] Murpady plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:36:38] Turn 1: Shadowater0
[11:36:39] Shadowater0 plays [Swamp].
[11:36:41] Shadowater0 casts [Duress] targeting Murpady.
[11:37:13] Murpady discards [Ponder].
[11:37:13] Murpady reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Ponder], [Dark Ritual], [Gitaxian Probe], [Bad River], and [Cabal Ritual].
[11:37:16] Murpady activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:37:21] Turn 2: Murpady
[11:37:24] j_meka has started watching.
[11:37:24] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:37:30] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:37:32] [CHAT] j_meka: !record
[11:37:32] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  Murpady 1-1 Shadowater0
[11:37:34] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:37:56] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:37:56] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:37:57] Murpady plays [Bad River].
[11:37:59] Turn 2: Shadowater0
[11:38:06] Shadowater0 plays [Swamp].
[11:38:08] Shadowater0 casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Murpady.
[11:38:11] Murpady discards [Eliminate].
[11:38:11] Murpady discards [Dark Ritual].
[11:38:17] Turn 3: Murpady
[11:38:22] Murpady casts [Chromatic Star].
[11:38:22] DepressedDuck has started watching.
[11:38:24] Murpady plays [Dimir Aqueduct].
[11:38:24] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Dimir Aqueduct] onto the stack (When Dimir Aqueduct enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[11:38:26] Murpady returns [Island] to its owner's hand with [Dimir Aqueduct]'s ability.
[11:38:29] Turn 3: Shadowater0
[11:38:35] ThiGuyAgain365164 has started watching.
[11:38:37] Shadowater0 casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting Murpady.
[11:38:46] Murpady reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Island] and [Cabal Ritual].
[11:38:49] Shadowater0 plays [Barren Moor].
[11:38:49] [CHAT] ThiGuyAgain365164: !cored
[11:38:55] [CHAT] ThiGuyAgain365164: !record
[11:38:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  Murpady 1-1 Shadowater0
[11:38:59] Turn 4: Murpady
[11:39:03] Murpady activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[11:39:08] Murpady plays [Island].
[11:39:18] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.).
[11:39:20] Murpady draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability.
[11:39:22] Murpady casts [Cruel Bargain].
[11:39:22] Murpady draws four cards with [Cruel Bargain].
[11:39:30] Turn 4: Shadowater0
[11:39:48] Shadowater0 casts [Duress] targeting Murpady.
[11:39:53] Murpady discards [Treasure Cruise].
[11:39:53] Murpady reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Island], [Sunken Ruins], [Pieces of the Puzzle], [Bad River], and [Cabal Ritual].
[11:39:56] Shadowater0 discards [Barren Moor].
[11:39:56] Shadowater0 cycles [Barren Moor].
[11:40:00] Turn 5: Murpady
[11:40:09] Murpady casts [Ponder].
[11:40:22] Murpady chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[11:40:22] Murpady draws a card with [Ponder].
[11:40:28] Murpady casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:40:28] Murpady reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Repeal], [Island], [Island], [Ransack the Lab], and [Ransack the Lab].
[11:40:33] Murpady puts [Ransack the Lab] and [Ransack the Lab] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[11:40:33] Murpady puts [Repeal], [Island], and [Island] into their graveyard.
[11:40:40] Murpady plays [Bad River].
[11:40:42] Turn 5: Shadowater0
[11:40:44] Shadowater0 plays [Mountain].
[11:40:46] Turn 6: Murpady
[11:41:15] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:41:17] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:41:25] swiftwarkite2 has started watching.
[11:41:29] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:41:43] Murpady casts [Brainstorm].
[11:41:44] Murpady draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[11:41:53] Murpady activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[11:42:00] Murpady plays [Sunken Ruins].
[11:42:08] Murpady casts [Brainstorm].
[11:42:09] Murpady draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[11:42:20] Murpady casts [Ransack the Lab].
[11:42:23] Murpady puts [River of Tears] and [Island] into their graveyard.
[11:42:26] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:42:29] Murpady casts [Cabal Ritual].
[11:42:34] Murpady casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:42:38] Murpady draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[11:42:46] Murpady casts [Treasure Cruise].
[11:42:47] Murpady draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[11:42:51] Murpady casts [Frantic Search].
[11:42:52] Murpady draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[11:42:55] Murpady discards [Sunken Ruins].
[11:42:55] Murpady discards [Sunken Ruins].
[11:43:02] Murpady casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting Shadowater0.
[11:43:03] Murpady puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (10 spells cast before Tendrils of Agony this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for ...).
[11:43:06] [CHAT] Shadowater0: ggs
[11:43:07] Shadowater0 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Murpady
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Murpady: 2–1